The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Todd Zeile on New 9/11 Film and the Healing Power of Baseball Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Todd Zeile joins Craig and Big Mac to discuss his documentary, When America Took the Field, commemorating the 25th anniversary of 9/11. They reflect on the emotional atmosphere at Shea Stadium during the return to baseball and the symbolic significance of Mike Piazza's home run. Zeile also shares personal stories about a meeting with Sandy Koufax and the responsibilities of modern athletes.

(00:01:00) Producing When America Took The Field

(00:04:35) Driving To Shea After 9/11

(00:10:32) Piazza's Iconic Home Run

(00:17:57) Baseball's Healing Impact

(00:24:24) Sandy Koufax Birthday Encounter

Craigie Claims He Drinks the Most Grand Marnier in the Country Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craigie and Big Mac debate the proper way to order a martini and share their distaste for bartenders who ask if the drink should be "on the rocks." They also recount a rough experience with Wild Turkey pickleback shots and explore the world of flavored vodkas and Zyn pouches.

(00:01:00) Grand Marnier and Sponsorships

(00:04:20) Proper Martini Drinking Etiquette

(00:06:58) Picklebacks and Zyn Pouches

Big Mac and Pete Hoffman Set Stakes for NFL Pick Competition Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac, Pete Hoffman, and Anthony Gallo establish the rules for their season-long NFL picking competition, featuring mystery penalties for the last-place finisher. They also evaluate the New York Giants' passing game, debating the deep-ball effectiveness of the offense and the talent level of the current wide receiver room.

(00:01:01) Pick Competition Stakes

(00:04:51) Liquor Sponsor Discussion

(00:06:48) Giants Passing Game Analysis

Reflecting on Piazza's 9/11 Homer & Yankees Parade Mystery Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle discuss Aaron Boone’s case for Manager of the Year following recent tactical decisions for the Yankees. A caller shares a moving story about attending the first Mets game after 9/11, leading to a discussion on the 2001 World Series and the healing power of sports in New York. They also weigh potential roster moves for the Yankees if Jazz Chisholm Jr. misses time with a thumb injury.

(00:01:03) Boone Manager Of The Year

(00:02:54) Emotional 9/11 Mets Story

(00:05:50) Roger Clemens Interview Recap

(00:13:29) Subway Series Pitching Preview

(00:17:23) Yankees Roster Replacement Debate

Craig on 9/11 Reflections & the Elizabeth Holmes Voice Mystery Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The Guys reflect on the emotional weight of the upcoming September 11th anniversary and the significant role sports played in the healing process. The conversation shifts to a captivating documentary about Elizabeth Holmes and the Theranos scandal, including a discussion on her voice and the work of Nathan Fielder.

(00:01:01) Reflecting On 9/11 Anniversary

(00:04:03) Elizabeth Holmes Documentary

(00:10:11) Nathan Fielder Discussion

Daryl Johnston's Giants Outlook & the Jets Must-Win vs. Titans Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The Carton Show analyzes Daryl "Moose" Johnston's expectations for a New York Giants improvement and debate the team's depth at wide receiver. A stark warning is issued for the New York Jets, emphasizing that a loss to the Tennessee Titans could spiral into a winless start through mid-October.

(00:01:00) Daryl Johnston's Giants Outlook

(00:04:16) Office Food Pecking Order

(00:07:40) Jets Week 1 Must-Win

Aaron Boone Benches Aaron Judge in Pivotal Yankees-Rockies Game Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the high ticket prices for the Giants' season opener against the Cowboys and debate the NFL's choice for tonight's Super Bowl rematch on The Carton Show. They also analyze Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge for a pinch-hitter during a narrow Yankees win. Additionally, they compare their home television setups and preview upcoming guest appearances.

(00:01:00) Giants Cowboys Ticket Prices

(00:03:06) NFL Season Opener Preview

(00:04:43) Aaron Boone Benches Judge

(00:09:30) Home TV Setup Debate

(00:12:18) Upcoming Guests Preview

Aaron Judge is BACK as Yankees beat Rockies | 'Go Get 'Em' Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle reacts to Judge's first game back in 99 days, from how he looked in his three at-bats to how the Yankees will ease him back into being an everyday player. Will he be able to knock the rust off in time? Plus, reactions to another Cam Schlittler masterpiece, if Heliot Ramos' big home run can finally get him going, and the concern level for Jazz Chisholm after leaving the game in the ninth inning with a thumb injury.

EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS

Intro - Aaron Judge returns! Breaking down the 5-3 win over the Rockies and the Yankees' current playoff positioning.

4:22 - Reflecting on the 84 games without Judge and why the pitching staff and Aaron Boone deserve credit for keeping the team in the race.

10:12 - Analyzing Judge's first at-bats back, his bat speed, and the team's load management plan for the final 18 games.

18:32 - Cam Schlittler's dominant performance and why he is the undisputed AL Cy Young favorite.

23:59 - Offensive frustrations against a struggling pitcher and the fallout from Jazz jamming his thumb sliding into second base.

27:00 - If Jazz hits the IL, should Anthony Volpe get called up to play second base?

Full Show: Craig Carton Blasts "Clown Show" Giants After Slayton Release Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Carton and Big Mac debate the New York Giants' decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton just before the season opener. They also celebrate the return of Aaron Judge to the Yankees lineup while discussing the ethics of sports figures like Eli Manning and LeBron James promoting unregulated gambling platforms. The conversation extends to the chaos of college football and the bankruptcy filing of Liv Golf.

(00:01:55) Giants Cut Darius Slayton

(00:05:40) Carton Blasts Organizational Moves

(00:11:05) Aaron Judge Returns Tonight

(00:15:55) Slayton Vs Darnell Mooney

(00:26:40) Managing Judge's Yankee Workload

(00:29:35) Evaluating The Giants Depth

(00:35:45) College Football Coaching Drama

(00:41:10) Liv Golf Files Bankruptcy

Hour 1: Craig Rips 'Clown Show' Giants After They Cut Darius Slayton Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac debate the New York Giants' decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton just before the start of the season. They clash over the team's roster depth and the potential impact on offensive continuity while celebrating Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees. They also criticize athletes for endorsing unregulated gambling.

(00:01:25) Giants Release Darius Slayton

(00:05:30) Giants Roster Depth Concerns

(00:10:35) Aaron Judge Yankees Return

(00:15:15) Giants Offensive Continuity Debate

(00:19:25) Darius Slayton Career Production

(00:24:30) Giants Season Victory Predictions