The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Craig Carton Says Wendy's Stole His $80 Million Mint Frosty Idea Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig shares the story of how he pitched a 'Mint Frosty' concept to Wendy's, only for the company to allegedly implement the idea and reward him with just a $10 gift card. He also debates the national perception of Daniel Jones and describes a grueling commute spent watching Yellowstone.

(00:01:00) Burgers and Al Leiter

(00:02:25) Giants Quarterback Debate

(00:06:08) Cowboys Defense vs Giants

(00:08:20) Commute and TV Talk

(00:12:43) Wendy's Mint Frosty Fiasco

Anthony Volpe’s Return and the Yankees Playoff Lineup Dilemma Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

The discussion weighs the excitement of the Knicks' ring ceremony against the high stakes of a Yankees playoff game. Focus then shifts to Anthony Volpe's return from the minors and how he might platoon with Jazz Chisholm Jr. during the postseason.

(00:01:00) Knicks Ring Ceremony Dilemma

(00:05:03) Anthony Volpe Returns

(00:07:26) Yankees Playoff Roster Decisions

Carton Calls Drake Maye's Performance Inexplicable After Patriots Loss Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the New England Patriots' disappointing loss and Drake Maye's costly interceptions. They also preview the Rams-Niners matchup and recap a wild night of New York baseball including the Yankees' blowout and the Mets' high-scoring thriller.

(00:01:46) Drake Maye's Struggles

(00:08:53) Rams Niners Preview

(00:09:52) New York Baseball Recap

Full Show: Carton and Big Mac Talk Volpe's Return and Zeile's 9/11 Doc Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

They analyze the start of the NFL season and a crucial Yankees-Rockies series while discussing Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge. Former Met Todd Zeile discusses his 9/11 documentary "When America Took the Field," and comedian Aaron Berg shares insights into his new special. The conversation also details Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees lineup following an injury to Jazz Chisholm Jr.

(00:01:50) NFL Season Kickoff

(00:05:35) Boone Benches Judge

(00:14:30) Zeile 9/11 Documentary

(00:16:45) Theranos Fraud Discussion

(00:26:45) Comedian Aaron Berg

(00:18:35) Anthony Volpe Recalled

(00:12:35) NFL Week 1 Picks

Hour 1: Craig Warns of 0-4 Start if Jets Falter Against Titans Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac dive into the return of football on The Carton Show with Big Mac, debating the New York Giants' outlook and the high stakes for the New York Jets' season opener. They analyze Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge and reflect on the upcoming 25th anniversary of September 11th. Finally, they share their thoughts on a new documentary about Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes.

(00:01:54) Giants Cowboys Ticket Prices

(00:05:14) Boone Benches Aaron Judge

(00:09:31) Craig's Television Setup

(00:14:25) Giants Defensive Weapons

(00:20:34) Jets Critical Titans Matchup

(00:11:43) September 11th Anniversary Reflections

(00:16:45) Elizabeth Holmes Documentary Discussion

(00:19:46) Voice Of Elizabeth Holmes

Hour 2: Craig and Big Mac on Boone's Benchings and a 9/11 Tribute Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac discuss Aaron Boone's accountability with the Yankees and share an emotional 9/11 story from a listener regarding Mike Piazza. They debate the merits of calling up Jasson Domínguez and Anthony Volpe while establishing the stakes for an NFL picking contest and sharing opinions on martinis.

(00:01:20) Boone's Managerial Accountability

(00:02:54) Tom's Emotional 9/11 Story

(00:05:39) Piazza's Home Run Impact

(00:09:42) 2001 World Series Parade

(00:12:10) Mets Pitching and Replay

(00:15:46) Volpe and Domínguez Debate

(00:20:47) NFL Picks Punishment Stakes

(00:24:33) Martini and Liquor Talk

(00:27:40) Daniel Jones Offense Discussion

Hour 3: Todd Zeile on the Healing Power of Mike Piazza's 9/11 Home Run Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac evaluate the Giants and Jets' rosters while critiquing the U.S. Open's decision to schedule a signature match at midnight. They later welcome former Met Todd Zeile to discuss his documentary, 'When America Took the Field,' which chronicles baseball's role in the healing process after 9/11. Zeile also shares a humorous story about a 'Man Dinner' with John Franco and a credit card roulette prank.

(00:01:35) Debating Relationship Television Shows

(00:07:42) Jets and Giants Season Outlook

(00:13:15) U.S. Open Scheduling Controversy

(00:17:45) Fans Dressing for the Open

(00:22:50) Yankees Lineup and Injury News

(00:10:10) Todd Zeile on 9/11 Documentary

(00:14:40) Emotional Return to Shea Stadium

(00:21:20) Mike Piazza's Iconic Home Run

(00:32:10) Athletes Impacting the Community

(00:38:25) John Franco's Man Dinner Prank

Hour 4: Late Night U.S. Open Rant and Fat Dom's Eagles Investigation Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The discussion begins with a critique of upcoming movie sequels and a dive into classic cinema before shifting to the U.S. Open's controversial late-night match scheduling. They analyze the recent NFL investigation involving Eagles' security head Fat Dom and the online drama surrounding Emmanuel Acho. Comedian Aaron Berg joins to share stories about his new stand-up special and his dedication to fitness.

(00:01:20) Movie News and NASCAR Debates

(00:06:11) Stanley Kubrick Conspiracy Theories

(00:10:51) U.S. Open Late Start Criticism

(00:14:52) Fat Dom Eagles Security Investigation

(00:19:32) Broncos Defense and Mahomes Matchup

(00:24:09) Aaron Berg Discusses Comedy Special

(00:30:30) Marriage Vows and Key West

Hour 5: Big Mac's Super Bowl Predictions & Anthony Volpe's Yankees Return Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

McMonigle forecasts a Baltimore Ravens versus Los Angeles Rams Super Bowl and names Caleb Williams as a dark horse MVP candidate for the upcoming NFL season. He also discusses the New York Yankees recalling Anthony Volpe to replace the injured Jazz Chisholm, weighing the shortstop's potential impact against his recent minor league success. The segment concludes with official against-the-spread picks for the Seahawks and Patriots season opener.

(00:01:27) NFL Season Preview

(00:06:58) Super Bowl Predictions

(00:10:30) Defensive Star Analysis

(00:13:56) Giants Offensive Outlook

(00:18:02) Anthony Volpe Recalled

(00:23:37) Volpe's Hitting Approach

Aaron Berg Joins The Carton Show to Talk Fitness, New Special & the Jets Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Berg joins The Carton Show in studio to discuss his physical transformation and his new YouTube special, 30 Minutes with Aaron Berg. He shares humorous stories about gym etiquette at Jersey Barbell and his experiences officiating a wedding through the Church of Humanism. The conversation wraps up with Berg's take on the New Jersey Devils and his prediction for a Jets Super Bowl run.

(00:01:12) Aaron Berg In Studio

(00:05:55) Fitness And New Special

(00:10:25) Weddings And Sports Talk

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected