The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Full Show: Drake Maye’s “Inexplicable” Loss and Anthony Volpe's Yankee Recall Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

They critique Drake Maye's performance in the Patriots' loss to the Seahawks before debating Anthony Volpe's return to the Yankees. The conversation also explores Brian Daboll's tense media interaction regarding Malik Nabors' injury status and dives into the public feuds surrounding Aaron Rodgers' past relationships. A caller's claim to the success of Vitamin Water and personal anecdotes about business ideas are also shared.

(00:02:13) Drake Maye’s Interception Meltdown

(00:10:21) Yankees and Mets Updates

(00:15:56) ALCS vs. Knicks Plans

(00:19:15) Anthony Volpe Returns

(00:31:15) Vitamin Water Ownership Claim

(00:26:37) Aaron Rodgers Relationship Drama

(00:21:31) Tense Giants Media Clash

(00:16:36) NFL Thursday Night Picks

Hour 1: Carton Blasts Drake Maye's Three-Interception Meltdown in Patriots Loss Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Carton and Big Mac analyze the New England Patriots' frustrating loss to the Seahawks, highlighting Drake Maye's fourth-quarter interceptions. They also discuss the New York Yankees' dominant win, Anthony Volpe's return to the lineup, and a humorous story about a missed business opportunity with Wendy's.

(00:01:43) Patriots Loss Analysis

(00:06:23) Drake Maye Comparison

(00:09:51) Yankees Blowout Victory

(00:15:26) Knicks Ring Ceremony

(00:18:27) Anthony Volpe's Return

(00:14:45) Jackson Dart Narrative

(00:22:01) Wendy's Frosty Story

Hour 2: Aaron Rodgers Relationship Drama and Anthony Volpe's Return Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

They analyze the latest public feuds involving Aaron Rodgers and his past relationships with Danica Patrick and Shailene Woodley. The conversation also covers the Yankees' decision to recall Anthony Volpe from the minors following an injury to Jazz Chisholm Jr.

(00:01:20) NFL Betting Advice

(00:05:55) Aaron Boone Texting

(00:07:27) Call With Annabelle

(00:10:55) Radio ID Rules

(00:13:05) Vitamin Water Origin

(00:19:08) Pop-Up Bagels Investment

(00:22:06) Aaron Rodgers Drama

(00:35:08) Halloween Candy Snubs

(00:37:45) John Harbaugh Presser

(00:41:12) Anthony Volpe Returns

Hour 3: Volpe’s Return, LeBron’s Betting Deal & Harbaugh’s Giants Media Feud Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Evan Roberts react to Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees and debate the team's playoff positioning. They discuss Robinson Cano's legacy as a second baseman and criticize LeBron James for his gambling endorsements. The segment also covers a tense media interaction regarding Malik Nabors and the New York Giants' outlook.

(00:01:25) Anthony Volpe Returns

(00:05:00) Live Show Planning

(00:08:30) Robinson Cano's Legacy

(00:12:00) LeBron's Polymarket Deal

(00:15:30) Riddles And Jokes

(00:21:45) Larry In Las Vegas

(00:27:15) Mickey Mantle Memories

(00:34:15) Tommy Lugauer Copying Controversy

(00:39:15) John Harbaugh Media Tension

Hour 4: Carton and C-Mac on Malik Nabors’ Caution Ahead of Sunday's Opener Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss Malik Nabors' cautious approach to his injury recovery and the mental pressure of returning to the Giants' lineup. They analyze the impact of high-profile injuries on the league, compare recovery timelines for Patrick Mahomes and Daniel Jones, and share their official NFL Game of the Week predictions.

(00:01:11) Player To Watch Picks

(00:03:54) Malik Nabors Injury Mindset

(00:11:23) Mahomes And Jones Recovery

(00:13:08) Silvox Game Of Week

(00:20:19) Aaron Judge Rest Day

Big Mac and Gallo Pranked by 86-Year-Old Yankee Fan Larry Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Larry from Las Vegas joins Big Mac to argue against Anthony Volpe's return to the lineup before participating in a prank on producer Anthony Gallo. They also reflect on the legacy of Barry Melrose and share stories about the golden era of the New York Yankees.

(00:02:10) Barry Melrose and Lane Kiffin

(00:03:16) Volpe Debate and Gallo Game

(00:10:08) New York Yankee Nostalgia

Division Title Stakes and Volpe's Move to Second Base Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

They analyze the Yankees' critical series against the Rockies, emphasizing that a loss could signal the end of their division title aspirations. The conversation shifts to Anthony Volpe's defensive transition and where he fits into the roster alongside Jazz Chisholm Jr. They also evaluate Robinson Canó's place in franchise history and criticize LeBron James for his recent sports betting endorsements.

(00:01:02) Volpe Returns to Lineup

(00:02:13) Yankees Division Title Stakes

(00:07:43) Volpe and Chisholm Debate

(00:10:01) Robinson Cano Legacy Comparison

(00:12:35) LeBron James Betting Criticism

Big Mac Reacts to Anthony Volpe's Return to the Yankees Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

After Jazz Chisholm's injury, the Yankees recalled Anthony Volpe to play second base. Big Mac discusses if the demotion helped Volpe find his stroke and if he deserves another shot in the Bronx.

(00:01:01) Anthony Volpe's Return

(00:04:16) Analyzing Volpe's Stats

(00:07:32) Invention of the Microwave

(00:08:46) Yankees Fan Reactions

Aaron Rodgers' Messy Dating Life and Halloween Candy Snubs Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig explores the public feuds between Aaron Rodgers and exes Danica Patrick and Shailene Woodley, critiquing Rodgers' recent comments about his past relationships. They also discuss his reputation for being stingy with Halloween candy compared to other NFL legends like John Elway and Boomer Esiason.

(00:01:08) Aaron Rodgers Relationship Feuds

(00:05:21) Rich Couple Counseling Debate

(00:09:03) Analyzing Rodgers' Dating History

(00:13:11) NFL Stars' Halloween Snubs

(00:16:41) Yankees and Harbaugh Updates

Caller Claims She Orchestrated Coca-Cola's Vitamin Water Acquisition Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Margaret calls in to recount her time at Coca-Cola where she suggested the company buy Vitamin Water, earning her only a small bonus for a billion-dollar idea. Craig Carton promises to put her in touch with Mike Repole and later reflects on his own missed chance to invest in Pop-Up Bagels.

(00:01:00) Betting Results and Advice

(00:05:42) Anthony Volpe News

(00:07:30) Trucker Stories with Annabelle

(00:11:59) Radio Station ID Debate

(00:14:06) Vitamin Water Acquisition Claim