The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Hour 2: Craigie Slams Giants for Cutting Slayton Amidst WR Struggles Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac criticize the New York Giants for releasing Darius Slayton, questioning the team's depth and Matt Nagy's influence on the roster. They also examine the return of Aaron Judge, debate the greatest player in Giants history, and share frustrating stories about modern air travel.

(00:01:22) Giants Cut Darius Slayton

(00:05:00) Herbert vs Jaxson Dart

(00:08:15) Aaron Judge Conspiracy Theories

(00:12:00) Rich Defends Coaching Decisions

(00:15:48) Greatest Giant All Time

(00:19:30) Dajon Love Roster Solution

(00:24:15) Aaron Judge Return Lineup

(00:28:00) Baseball Players Are Soft

(00:31:20) Air Travel Etiquette Rant

Hour 3: Michigan's Field Storming & Giants Roster Debate Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

The conversation critiques Michigan fans for storming the field after a close win and discusses the massive financial debt within the Rutgers athletic department. They also evaluate the New York Giants' decision to move on from Darius Slayton and compare the current offensive rosters of the Jets and Giants.

(00:01:20) Michigan Field Storming Controversy

(00:04:40) Rutgers Athletic Department Debt

(00:07:40) College Football Transfer Portal

(00:10:50) Giants Receiver Roster Debate

(00:14:50) Jets vs Giants Offense

(00:19:50) September 11th Memorial Discussion

(00:23:40) Odell Beckham Jr Comparison

(00:27:20) Airport and Airplane Etiquette

Hour 4: Aaron Judge Returns to the Lineup as LIV Golf Faces Bankruptcy Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

They discuss the news of Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees and settle a bet over the exact date of his recovery. The conversation covers LIV Golf's bankruptcy filing and an objective analysis of John Harbaugh's coaching record. They also provide tips for fantasy football drafts and preview the emotional Subway Series on the anniversary of 9/11.

(00:01:33) Appreciating Local Teachers

(00:04:01) High School Athletic Records

(00:06:16) Baker Mayfield Extension News

(00:07:44) Aaron Judge Return Bet

(00:13:02) LIV Golf Filing Bankruptcy

(00:17:14) John Harbaugh Coaching Analysis

(00:19:48) Fantasy Football Draft Strategy

(00:28:12) 9/11 Subway Series Tribute

LSU’s Legal Chess Move Silences Ole Miss and Viral Fan Nostalgia Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and the Big Mac discuss the viral fame of Sarah Smith from the Ole Miss game and reflect on past internet sensations like Catherine Webb and Jenn Sterger. They break down a clever legal maneuver by LSU to challenge player eligibility rules and expose perceived hypocrisy within the SEC. Additionally, they explore the bizarre looksmaxing trend involving Clay Matthews and share frustrations regarding travel logistics and elevator etiquette.

(00:01:27) Viral Ole Miss Fan

(00:03:46) Viral Fan Nostalgia

(00:07:38) Clay Matthews AI

(00:13:48) LSU Legal Strategy

(00:18:23) Travel and Elevators

Michigan's "Embarrassing" Field Storm & Giants vs. Jets Debate Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

The Guys critique Michigan fans for storming the field after a narrow win over Western Michigan and examine the financial struggles of the Rutgers athletic department. The conversation also covers Lane Kiffin's intense coaching style and a roster comparison between the New York Giants and Jets.

(00:01:02) Michigan Replay Controversy

(00:03:14) Rutgers Athletic Debt

(00:06:33) Lane Kiffin Intensity

(00:10:53) Darius Slayton Discussion

(00:16:13) Giants Vs Jets Debate

Craig Carton on OJ Simpson's Disguised 'Juiced' Reality Show Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton examines the unsettling themes in classic comedies like Mrs. Doubtfire before shifting to a discussion about OJ Simpson’s failed prank show. He also critiques the New York Giants' wide receiver roster and shares his excitement for the start of the football season.

(00:01:00) Dark Comedy Theories

(00:03:50) OJ Simpson Reality Show

(00:09:43) Football And Giants Analysis

Craig Skeptical of Aaron Judge Playing Right Field in Return Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac analyze Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees lineup and question the decision to play him in right field after a long injury layoff. They also reflect on a recent flight from Los Angeles, sharing frustrations over airplane Wi-Fi and boarding procedures.

(00:01:04) Aaron Judge Returns

(00:04:00) Half Inning Statistics

(00:07:17) Craig's Travel Story

Craig and Big Mac Tackle the Aaron Judge PED Conspiracy Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' wide receiver depth and the decision to prioritize Darnell Mooney over Darius Slayton. They investigate a social media theory suggesting Aaron Judge’s 84-game absence was a secret suspension rather than an injury, while also breaking down Daniel Jones' preseason preparation and the wild story of an NFL roster imposter.

(00:01:01) Jets and Giants Outlook

(00:02:30) Preseason Playing Time Debate

(00:07:05) Aaron Judge PED Conspiracy

(00:13:28) Giants Roster Move Reactions

(00:21:04) Dajon Love Viral Story

Carton Slams Eli Manning and Derek Jeter Over Gambling Ads Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac criticize Derek Jeter, Eli Manning, and LeBron James for promoting unregulated gambling markets. They also debate the New York Giants' controversial decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton right before the regular season begins.

(00:01:00) Entourage Reunion Review

(00:01:30) Athlete Gambling Endorsements

(00:07:33) Giants Cut Darius Slayton

(00:13:23) Giants Season Outlook

Did the Giants Screw Darius Slayton? Plus Aaron Judge's Return Sep 08, 2026

Show notes

The Carton Show focuses on the New York Giants' surprising decision to release Darius Slayton and the ripple effects on Jaxson Dart's passing options. They also discuss Aaron Judge's anticipated return to the Yankees' batting order for the series against the Rockies.

(00:02:14) Darius Slayton's Giants Departure

(00:06:23) Slayton's Future Landing Spots

(00:08:15) Aaron Judge's Yankees Return

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected