Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Hour 3: Jaxson Dart Faces a Make-or-Break Giants Season Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart holds the key to how far the Giants can climb in 2026, but Connor Hughes has serious reservations about whether Matt Nagy’s offense will bring out his best. Hughes explains why Dart may need to become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a massive leap, and why the new system could put far more pressure on him than last year’s offense. The conversation also turns to Odell Beckham Jr.’s surprising resurgence, why Darius Slayton was cut and the Giants’ defensive concerns entering the opener against Dallas. On the Jets, Hughes predicts an opening-week loss, explains why Aaron Glenn appears secure entering the season and weighs Breece Hall’s expected workload. Plus, the crew sets the stakes for another season of NFL picks.

Hour 4: Evan and Tiki Reveal Bold Super Bowl Picks as NFL Season Kicks Off Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash announce their Super Bowl predictions, selecting teams like the Bears, Broncos, and 49ers to reach the big game. They also discuss the breaking news regarding Rutgers coach Steve Pikiell and reflect on Tiki's past NFL openers. (00:01:50) Super Bowl Predictions (00:06:28) Reviewing Past Picks (00:11:15) Title Game Logistics (00:17:07) Steve Pikiell Diagnosis (00:19:39) Tiki Career Trivia (00:31:10) Giants Roster Outlook (00:33:45) Jalen Brunson Hosting SNL (00:39:30) NFL Week 1 Picks

Our Official Super Bowl Predictions Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The Super Bowl predictions are officially on the record, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash go in three very different directions. The crew also revisits their wildly different February predictions, debates strength of schedule.

Shaun Morash’s NFL Reality Check Gets Weird Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The NFL is back, but the opening-night Super Bowl rematch brings up one problem: Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash can barely remember anything that happened in last year’s championship game. They revisit just how dull the Patriots-Seahawks Super Bowl was and why that lack of memorable moments has taken some shine off the rematch. Shaun also runs through five things fans need to remember as the new season begins, from the Bills’ new stadium and coaching change to Aaron Rodgers reuniting with Mike McCarthy, Mike Evans changing teams and Jaxson Dart’s record against Dallas. Plus, a diehard Jets caller explains his anxiety over Geno Smith and the team’s quarterback situation.

Evan, Tiki and Shaun Set a Brutal NFL Bet Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The NFL picks competition is back, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree on a punishment designed to make the losers miserable. The two who fail to finish first will have to attend a sporting event wearing a shirt promoting an opinion they absolutely hate, sparking ideas involving Jalen Brunson, Malik Nabers, Joel Embiid and Evan’s baseball takes. The crew also revisits the Giants’ decision to move on from Darius Slayton, rejecting the idea that the veteran receiver was somehow disrespected. With a new coaching staff setting its own priorities, they argue the Giants simply made the roster decision they believed was best.

Connor Hughes: Jaxson Dart Could Be Held Back by Matt Nagy Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart can change the Giants’ entire outlook, but Connor Hughes has major concerns about whether Matt Nagy’s offense is built to maximize the young quarterback. Hughes explains why Dart must become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a Patriots-like leap and why Nagy’s system could make that development much harder. Hughes also breaks down why Odell Beckham Jr. earned his way onto the roster and helped make Darius Slayton expendable. The conversation then shifts to the Jets, where Breece Hall’s workload remains a question entering Week 1, Hughes predicts an opening loss and explains why Aaron Glenn enters the season with significant job security.

Yankees’ 34-Year Winning Streak Demands More Respect Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees’ streak of 34 consecutive winning seasons gets put into stunning perspective against every other major New York sports franchise. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much credit the organization deserves, why Yankee fans may take sustained success for granted, and whether the Dodgers have any realistic chance of eventually challenging the streak.

Garrett Wilson’s Captain Snub Raises Jets Eyebrows Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Garrett Wilson being left off the Jets’ season-long captain list sparks questions about what the decision really means. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber listen to Wilson’s reaction, debate whether he sounds disappointed, and explain why the snub should not become a lingering issue inside the Jets locker room.

John Harbaugh Critics Get Ripped Over Giants Doubts Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh’s critics come under fire as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber reject the idea that the Giants should pump the brakes on their new coach. Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments are compared to the résumés of Andy Reid, Mike Tomlin, Sean Payton and other top coaches, with the argument that players have too often failed to execute in his biggest losses. The Yankees are also running out of room in the AL East race as Tampa Bay keeps winning and a four-game series with the Rays starts to look like a must-sweep. Aaron Judge’s return sparks another debate over his postseason struggles, whether a fresher Judge can finally change the October narrative, and why this Yankees roster may not need him to carry the entire offense.

Aaron Judge’s Yankees Return Was a Letdown Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge returned to the Yankees lineup, but the storybook moment never came. Evan Roberts admits he was disappointed by Judge’s hitless night after comparing it to the unforgettable comeback homers from Alex Rodriguez and David Wright, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Judge’s first game back mattered much at all. The Yankees also face a tricky reality as Judge works his way back and may not finish every game, creating late-inning lineup decisions like the one that put Heliot Ramos in a huge spot. Plus, the Subway Series pitching matchups take shape, and a caller sparks a bigger debate over whether the Mets could ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected