Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Jets Guarantee Their Interception Drought Ends Sunday Sep 11, 2026

Show notes

The Jets may have the better chance than the Giants to start 1-0, but everything could come down to Geno Smith. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate which version of Geno will show up against Tennessee and whether the Jets can trust a quarterback coming off a rough season to reinvent himself once again. The Titans don’t scare Evan nearly as much as the possibility of the Jets beating themselves. Plus, the crew makes a bold prediction that the Jets will finally end their interception drought, while Malik Nabers’ uncertain status adds another major question heading into the Giants’ opener against Dallas.

New York Sports Helped a City Heal After 9/11 Sep 11, 2026

Show notes

Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, honoring the firefighters, police officers and other heroes who risked and lost their lives trying to save others. Tiki recalls returning to New York after the Giants played in Denver the night before the attacks, while Evan shares what it felt like experiencing that terrifying day from Washington, D.C. They also remember how sports helped New York begin to feel normal again, from Mike Piazza’s unforgettable home run to the Giants returning to the field. Twenty-five years later, the memories remain vivid, even as a younger generation now knows September 11 only as history.

Mets Get Revenge on the Marlins | 'Rico Brogna' Sep 11, 2026

Show notes

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets are trying to put their stamp on the Miami Marlins season by sweeping them. Hopefully this will be revenge for knocking the Mets out of the playoffs at the end of the season last year.

Thursday Full Show: Patriots Look like Frauds, Yankees Bring Volpe Back Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

The Patriots and Drake Maye imploded, Tiki looks back at Week 1's in his career, and a failed Yankee prospect won't go away.

Hour 1:Drake Maye Meltdown Gives Jets New Hope Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Drake Maye’s brutal fourth quarter has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering if the Patriots are far more vulnerable than expected, and whether that suddenly gives the Jets a clearer path to surprise people in the AFC East. Evan also admits Sam Darnold’s injury immediately made him think about Seattle potentially trading for Geno Smith, sparking a debate over Geno, Russell Wilson and how aggressive the Seahawks should be at quarterback. The Giants’ opening stretch also comes under the microscope, with Evan more confident about beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in Week 1. Tiki pushes back on that logic as they debate Dak Prescott, Matthew Stafford, the Rams’ travel and the Giants’ offense. Plus, the Yankees take care of business, the Mets keep winning, and the John Sterling home run call machine makes an unexpected return.

Hour 2: John Harbaugh Picks a Fight With New York Media Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh showed a much sharper side with the Giants media, pushing back on questions about Darius Slayton and refusing to reveal Malik Nabers’ status. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Harbaugh was simply having fun or trying to intimidate reporters, and why that strategy will not stop the New York media from pressing him for answers. The Yankees also lose Jazz Chisholm to the injured list, opening the door for Anthony Volpe’s return after a dominant Triple-A stretch. Evan and Tiki debate Volpe’s proper role, whether Aaron Boone can manage the situation correctly, and how his return could affect George Lombard Jr. Plus, skepticism about Matthew Stafford and the Rams, the Giants cornerback competition, and Mike Tomlin’s debut at the desk.

Hour 3: Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts’ FULL attention Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts’ attention before the Jets even play a game. Evan admits his “wandering eye” is still fixed on Tomlin and believes the former Steelers coach already sounds like he misses coaching enough to return next year. Tiki Barber pushes back on how soon that comeback could happen, while both agree Tomlin’s blunt style and credibility make him a natural on television. Evan also delivers a confident prediction that the Mets will smoke the Yankees, while the crew debates Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and the dangerous Rays. Plus, Sam Darnold’s hip injury raises questions about Seattle’s season, Shaun Morash unveils his Giants rooting guide, NFL fan traditions get ripped apart, and Robert Saleh gets a harsh assessment as he tries to prove himself again as a head coach.

Hour 4: Tiki Barber Recalls Fixing Fumble Issues Under Tom Coughlin Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber discuss Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees on WFAN and revisit past predictions about his career longevity. Tiki reflects on the specific coaching adjustments that solved his NFL fumbling issues and joins the crew in analyzing the upcoming Rams-49ers game in Australia. They also examine the massive hype and record-breaking ticket prices surrounding the Giants' opener against the Cowboys.

(00:01:50) Subway Series Doubleheader

(00:04:13) Anthony Volpe Archive Callouts

(00:07:48) MLB Playoff Format Criticisms

(00:12:45) Mets Player Assessment Discussion

(00:17:15) Rams Versus 49ers Strategy

(00:22:30) Tiki Career Trivia Segment

(00:27:00) Fixing Tiki's Fumbling Issues

(00:32:04) NFL Week 1 Injury Report

(00:39:00) Patriots Versus Seahawks Analysis

(00:44:40) Rams Versus 49ers Picks

Shaun Morash Rips the NFL’s Most Annoying Fans Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Shaun Morash unloads on the NFL traditions he cannot stand, blasting the Seahawks’ “12,” Bills Mafia, the Vikings’ Skol chant, Eagles fans and Detroit’s third-down signs. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber jump into the chaos as the Jets’ simple stadium chant gets rare praise.

Giants Fans Get a Brand-New Rooting Guide Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Sam Darnold’s hip injury immediately has the crew wondering how long Seattle can survive without its starting quarterback and whether Drew Lock is enough to keep the Seahawks afloat. The uncertainty also catches Shaun Morash’s attention as a Giants fan watching potential NFC wild-card competition. That sets up the debut of Shaun’s new weekly Giants rooting guide, where every NFL matchup gets broken down based on what outcome helps Big Blue most. Evan Roberts goes from mocking the idea to embracing it, while Tiki Barber joins the debate over how the guide could eventually shift from playoff positioning to draft positioning if the Giants’ season goes south.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected