Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Mike Tomlin Already Has Evan Dreaming About the Jets Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Mike Tomlin’s television debut has Evan Roberts convinced the former Steelers coach already misses the NFL. Evan admits his “wandering eye” remains fixed on Tomlin as a potential Jets option and believes a coaching comeback could come quickly, while Tiki Barber argues Tomlin may need more time away before returning. The Yankees debate heats up as Jose Caballero gets praised over Anthony Volpe, while the Rays’ ability to put the ball in play makes them a legitimate threat. Evan then delivers his strongest prediction of the hour, declaring the Mets are going to smoke the Yankees this weekend. Plus, Evan fires back at a caller who insists he secretly hates the Giants.

Harbaugh’s Media Battles Could Get Ugly Fast Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh’s combative approach with the media becomes the center of another Giants debate. Evan Roberts makes clear he enjoys Harbaugh pushing back, but warns that trying to intimidate New York reporters will only make them press harder. Tiki Barber agrees that Harbaugh can handle the media however he wants, but the questions are not going away. The conversation also touches on Anthony Volpe’s return and Evan’s concern about how Aaron Boone will use him before turning to the physical future of football. Tiki explains why he does not expect the sport to fundamentally change despite growing concern about head injuries, emphasizing the inherent violence players accept when they choose to keep playing.

Anthony Volpe Returns With the Yankees Under Pressure Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Anthony Volpe is back with the Yankees after tearing up Triple-A, but his return comes with Jazz Chisholm headed to the injured list and major questions about how Aaron Boone will use him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Volpe should play second base, compete with Jose Caballero for at-bats, and finally settle into the utility role they believe fits him best. There is also concern about how Volpe’s return could affect George Lombard Jr., who replaced him at shortstop and gave an awkward answer when told Volpe was coming back. Plus, Evan explains why he remains skeptical of Matthew Stafford and the Rams despite Stafford’s massive previous season.

John Harbaugh Suddenly Drops His Folksy Giants Act Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh’s relationship with the New York media suddenly turned combative. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Harbaugh’s sharp responses to questions about Darius Slayton and Malik Nabers, including whether he was simply pushing back or trying to intimidate reporters into backing off. Evan warns that tactic will not work in New York, where Giants reporters will keep pressing no matter how uncomfortable Harbaugh makes it. They also examine why Slayton was cut, how Deonte Banks has earned a fresh opportunity under the new coaching staff, and whether Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history should create real concern despite his huge previous season.

Giants-Rams Debate Gets Heated Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts refuses to buy the Rams hype, arguing that Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history make Los Angeles far less intimidating than everyone assumes. He even feels better about the Giants beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in the opener, sparking a heated debate with Tiki Barber over Stafford, the Rams’ talent and whether their unusual travel schedule could leave them vulnerable. The conversation shifts to the Yankees after George Lombard Jr.’s grand slam, including a listener’s push to revive the John Sterling home run call simulator. Plus, a Jets fan unloads on Bill Belichick amid problems at North Carolina, while Evan and Tiki explain why Belichick’s college tenure does nothing to change how they view his NFL legacy.

Giants Face a Brutal Opening Test Against Dallas Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

The Giants’ season opens with a daunting matchup against Dak Prescott and the Cowboys, and Evan Roberts is already more confident about their chances in Week 2 against the Rams. The Giants’ ugly history against Dallas, their limited preseason work with Jaxson Dart and questions surrounding Malik Nabers all fuel the concern, while Tiki Barber pushes back on Evan’s surprising confidence in a road upset over Los Angeles. The debate centers on whether the Cowboys or Rams present the bigger early-season challenge, with Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history becoming a major point of contention. Plus, the Seahawks’ quarterback situation after Sam Darnold’s injury keeps Geno Smith and Russell Wilson in the conversation, and the Mets somehow provide one of the night’s most compelling games.

Patriots Regression Could Open Door for Jets Sep 10, 2026

Show notes

Drake Maye’s disastrous fourth quarter has Evan Roberts wondering if the Patriots are already showing signs of a major regression, and whether that could give the Jets a real opening in the AFC East. After watching Maye throw three fourth-quarter interceptions, Evan sees a possible roadmap for the Jets to surprise people this season. Sam Darnold’s injury creates a completely different Jets thought: could Seattle become desperate enough to trade for Geno Smith? Evan floats the possibility while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash immediately point to Russell Wilson as the more logical Seahawks option. The debate turns into a heated argument over whether Geno or Wilson is closer to playing winning football right now.

Wednesday Full Show: The Giants are Chasing Patriot Dreams, Brunson will Host SNL Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The NFL Season will kickoff tonight, and the Giants can look to the Patriots playing tonight as inspiration. We give our Super Bowl picks, and much more.

Hour 1: Giants Can Follow the Patriots’ Super Bowl Blueprint Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

The Giants have a blueprint for a massive turnaround, and it looks a lot like last year’s Patriots. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare Jaxson Dart’s rookie numbers to Drake Maye’s, John Harbaugh’s arrival to Mike Vrabel’s impact, and explain why Big Blue could be positioned for one of the NFL’s biggest jumps. The biggest obstacle is clear: a run defense that finished near the bottom of the league must dramatically improve. Plus, Aaron Judge returns to the Yankees lineup without the storybook moment Evan wanted, while the crew looks ahead to intriguing Subway Series pitching matchups and debates whether the Mets can ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.

Hour 2: John Harbaugh Critics Get Blasted Over Giants Doubts Sep 09, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh’s critics get called out as the Giants’ new coach becomes the center of a heated debate. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments diminish his coaching résumé, comparing his career to Sean Payton, Mike Tomlin and other respected NFL coaches. They also debate what success should actually look like for Harbaugh in New York and whether matching Tom Coughlin’s two Super Bowls is an unrealistic standard. The Yankees’ division hopes are fading as Tampa Bay keeps winning, Aaron Judge’s postseason struggles return to the spotlight, and the Yankees’ incredible streak of 34 straight winning seasons gets some perspective. Plus, Garrett Wilson is left off the Jets’ captain list, MLB expansion could reshape the leagues, and Montreal, Nashville, Portland and Salt Lake City emerge as possible destinations.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Evan & Tiki

Related Podcasts

1

2

3

4

5

6