Show notes
If you’ve discovered your husband lies, you’re probably asking, “Is lying emotional abuse?” Is Lying Emotional Abuse? 3 Things 1. If His Lying Makes You Question Reality, It’s Not “Just Lying” If interactions with your husband leave you confused or second-guessing your memory, that’s not normal conflict. That’s your mind trying to make sense of two competing realities: what you see and what he says. If, so keep reading. It’s likely that his lies are a form of emotional abuse. 2. If His Lying Is Ongoing and Tactical, It’s Control It’s important to watch for patterns. If his deception is ongoing and long term, it’s been a way to control you’re perceptions. This form of control is sustained and designed to maintain a double life. Lying in this way is emotional abuse because it manipulates your emotions and decisions. 3. If His Lying Benefits Him and Harms You… If he’s lied to keep you from discovering things that are hurting you, like infidelity, secret money decisions, or anything else, he’s choosing to benefit from your lack of informed consent. At that point, the question “Is lying emotional abuse?” stops being theoretical. It becomes painfully obvious. To see if his lies amount to emotional abuse, take my free emotional abuse test. Many victims blame themselves while trying to understand the chaos. But the truth is simple. He chose to lie. He chose to manipulate. The responsibility is his. Whether He Has a Diagnosis Or Not, Lying Is Emotionally Abusive While some abusers may blame their lying on an addiction or even a mental illness, know that’s not true. He can choose to be honest no matter what his circumstances are.If you’re experiencing this and need support, join our daily support group for betrayal trauma. Transcript: Is Lying Emotional Abuse? Anne: I have Kelly, a victim of emotional abuse on today’s episode. She was a victim of financial abuse and also coercion. She’s going to share her story. And although Kelly and I are both Christian, we know that many listeners to this podcast aren’t. BTR is interfaith and inner paradigm. We welcome everyone. We also invite everyone to share their own personal experience. So as you hear us mention our belief in God, it’s not to offend or to proselytize, but just because we’re sharing from our own experience. And if you’re interested in sharing your experience from whatever faith perspective or paradigm you ascribe to. I would be honored to hear your story. So contact me at podcast@btr.org to set up an interview. Okay, let’s start with your story. Anne: Did you recognize your husband’s abusive behaviors at first? Kelly: I certainly did not. In fact, it was probably about three and a half years into our marriage before someone first told me they could be considered abuse. Up until that point, I had always known that abuse in my mind involved physical violence. And that was not at play in my marriage. I never had any bruises or anything like that. And so while I knew things were not good and it was a difficult relationship, I thought that’s all it was. That you marry for better or worse. And that we went through many of the worst times is what it seemed like. Anne: During that time, where you didn’t recognize the abuse, were you aware of exploitative materials use or any other consent issues related to your relationship? Discovering The Double Life Kelly: A few months after we married, it became evident that I had married someone living a double life. There were huge and extreme lies, and I didn’t know that lying was emotionally abusive. It was about four weeks into our marriage when I first discovered all these. The one day stands out in my mind started out just like any other day. I grabbed my things and went to work. He is in his last semester of undergraduate studies and is graduating in just a few months after we married. And I got to work, and a little later I realized my charger for my laptop is back at the house. https://youtu.be/j8CvkDrWyRc When Is Lying Emotional Abuse? So I finished meeting with a client, and ran home to grab it. I walked in the front door, he was sitting on the couch in the living room, and I was confused. Because I knew he should be in classes at that time. So I had no idea why he was there. And obviously, I jumped a little bit when I opened the door, not thinking anyone would be there. And I said, what are you doing here? He was flustered, and he starts mumbling about how he has a big test coming up for school that he needs to study for. So he skipped classes to focus on that. And I remember in my head thinking, Well, the semester just started a few weeks ago. He should not be at that point yet, of needing to skip things to study for an exam when he’s only had class for a few weeks. But, like I said, it was kind of in the middle of a work day. I needed to get back to work, so I just said, Alright, we’ll talk about it later, and left. Not Knowing: Is Lying Emotional Abuse? Kelly: It took around two months to figure out what was going on. And I knew that he had a history of not doing well in school, so I was immediately concerned and worried about it. And really, every time I tried to talk to him, he never had any straight answers on anything. So eventually, time after time, of trying to ask, okay, well, what time are your classes or which day do you have classes? Or when do you have projects due? Just so I could keep up with it all. He couldn’t figure it out and eventually got to the point where I said, well, why don’t you just log into your portal online so I can look at it with you? And try and sort through all this so that we’re both on the same page and not confused here? He couldn’t do that either. And I told him, well, you know, try and go to the IT department. Maybe you need to get your account reset, all that sort of thing. Eventually, a couple weeks later, he still couldn’t do it. And I eventually sat down with him, and I just said, okay, right here, right now, you need to pull up the site while I’m sitting with you and log in. After an hour or so of arguing, eventually it came out that he was not in school. And in fact, he had dropped out of school for about two years. So that entire time period that we were dating, engaged, and newly married, I have no idea how he spent his time. No one had any idea about this. He had been lying the whole time. Affairs & Exploitative Material Kelly: His parents, everyone in his family, thought he was attending classes. All of his friends did as well, but he was just falsifying information along the way. So after that, I felt like the rug was taken out from underneath me. I started to question other things that seemed confusing or just kind of struck me as something wasn’t quite right. And through that, what I discover is that he had multiple affairs while we were dating. I quickly discovered he had slept with more than one woman multiple times. There was definitely infidelity throughout the time we were together. Anne: This story is consistent with exploitative materials use. The likelihood of him using is extremely high, it is not something discoverable. So even if he used and you never saw it, and he doesn’t own up to it, you would never know. There’s no way to prove it or disprove it. So if I was a betting person, which I am not definitely. I bet he used exploitative materials for sure. He runs you in circles for months. And because you’re caring, compassionate and kind, you’re concerned and trying to help him out. And not once did you think, wait a minute, it’s not that he can’t log in or needs a password. A few months later, you realize it’s because he’s not enrolled. You realize he was lying, but not that lying is emotionally abusive. Lying Is Emotional Abuse & False Graduations Kelly: Yeah, it never crosses my mind that I would need to be a detective with my spouse. I did not grow up in a home like that. My parents have a great marriage and a great relationship where they work as partners together. And so when I entered my own marriage, that’s what I anticipated. But it quickly became evident that that’s not what was going on. That’s just a quick, brief snippet of things. We stayed married for close to five years. And throughout that time, there were three occasions where I believe he was actually graduating from college. He falsified grade reports that he would show me. I threw him a giant graduation party at one point with about 40 of our closest friends there. And after the party, he just blew up at me, and he was so furious that I would go and do something like that. I was confused, and I think it was something that he is just embarrassed about. Knowing that he had had trouble in school. I was trying to have that empathy to understand, wow, maybe I misstepped my bounds here. I shouldn’t have done that. And I thought it was considerate, but it wasn’t something he wants. Really, the only way I discovered he didn’t graduate is because I graduated from my master’s program and went to the same university. When I got the list of graduates, I saw my name there and his was not there. And that was the only way that I had found out. Anne: Wow,that must’ve been shocking. The Extent Of Lies, Education & Work Anne: You caught him several times, but instead of just coming out and telling you the truth, he continued to lie, wow. This is emotional abuse, it doesn’t matter the extent of the lies. So many of them are about having sex with other women, emotional affairs, or their double life. But what I don’t understand is why didn’t he ever just say, Hey, I don’t want to go to school. I’d rather do something else. Like the truth is beyond them. I don’t want to just have sex with you. I want to have sex with a lot of people. Would you still like to be married to me? You know, these are pretty simple things to say. But because of their exploitative privilege, they want to continue to exploit. And they want the entitlements that come along with a happy marriage or college degree. But they don’t want to do the work. Was he employed at all during this time? Kelly: I’m actually not sure. He bounced around a lot on different part time jobs, but it was never very consistent. The number one question I get asked about all of this when I share these details is what was his end game here? You know, someone will find out he doesn’t have a degree. The first job he had after allegedly graduating, he ends up fired from that job. Because he falsified his information and told them he did have a degree when he didn’t. So I think the most difficult part of this is to try and recognize that our brains function differently here. While we all recognize that this will not work in the long run. That just did not connect for him. Forged MCAT Scores Kelly: He was set to attend med school, as shocking as that sounds. Well, we paid for the MCAT, at least I thought we had. I’m not sure what he uses all that money for now. And he actually did not take the exam, I learned months later. But he did forge MCAT scores, and he had those mailed to our house so that I could open them up and see them in the mail. And the tricky part with all this is I think he’s very intelligent. And so I think he felt that not going to school would mean he’s working a job below his potential. Because I remember sitting down and talking about those MCAT scores and asking, Well, why did we spend this money on this if you’re not even in school right now? How could you even take the test if you’re not in school right now? The national program like this checks those sorts of things. So how did that even happen? And eventually through that, I discovered he hadn’t taken it. But the one point that sticks out in my mind is that he is so proud of the detail he had gone to for the forgery. I remember him showing me the paper and talking about how he measures out the margins and all the indentations everywhere, so that there’s no way I could ever guess it was falsified. Anne: Wow, if he had only put that much effort into school. Kelly: That’s exactly what I said. The EMotionally abusive nature of Lying & Consequences Anne: I had a conversation with someone who told me, this abuse stance you take about pornography use is so extreme. They were telling me. It’s so extreme! You know, these guys are really good guys who use. And I’m like, I don’t argue with you that some of them seem like really good guys. But if someone willingly uses without their wife’s knowledge, knowing that if she knew, she would be upset. Knowing that if I tell her that I use, she will be upset. So I’m going to wear my white shirt and tie to church every week. I’m going to participate. I’m going to act like I don’t use for all intents and purposes. And every time pornography comes up, I’m going to be like, yeah, that’s not cool. Like that is serious stuff. Lying is emotionally abusive. This is not just like, Oh, he’s ashamed or embarrassed. Like it’s serious. It’s a serious consent issue. And your husband, people would be like, Whoa, this guy is a psychopath, right? I’m sure many people have said that to you when you tell the story, like Holy Cow, the extent that he went to. But I don’t think people realize that men go to this extent just to cover their use quite a bit. Like, a lot. It’s very, very common, women are going through hell. When you’re married to someone, they’re willing to lie to you like that. About college, or about exploitative material, or about anything else to that extent. Kelly: Absolutely. Personality Disorder Diagnosis Kelly: And you know, it’s not until I finally learn what abuse actually was, that lying is emotionally abusive. This was not just us going through a difficult time. I had it in my head that I was overly controlling. And so he feels pressured and embarrassed, and that’s why he would hide things because I was just too controlling. And putting too much pressure on him. In my case, I was actually the one financially stable. I had the education, I had the career, and he was the one floundering. We eventually reach a crossroads, where I told him you are either moving out of the house now. Or you need to go and have this psych. eval. done. So we can try and figure out what we’re working with here. And when the results came back, they did say he had a personality disorder. And that it was likely an antisocial personality disorder, which is sociopathy. In my case, I did get a bit of that closure there, having that medical explanation and having the doctor turn to me and say, “You need to get out now. And you need to run as fast and as far as possible, because he will never ever change.” And not many women get that. Many of them have this inkling that something is wrong, but they don’t get that official diagnosis. And what I say to them is what you’re talking about, with just the action of covering up pornography or other things. At the end of the day, it doesn’t matter if you have that diagnosis or not. Religious Perspectives On Change: Lying Is Emotional Abuse Kelly: At the end of the day, that is not a healthy relationship. That is manipulative, controlling behavior. And it doesn’t matter what they’re trying to cover up or what sort of diagnosis they may or may not have officially on a paper there. At the end of the day, it’s just not right. Anne: Exactly, most religious people I know believe in change. Especially Christians, they’re like, Christ makes everything possible. With God, all things are possible. Nothing is impossible with Christ, etc. And so to say this person’s never going to change. Most religious people put up a little bit of a, like, well, wait, that’s what, Christ is for. That’s what the atonement was for. And so they get a little bit like, “No, I think people can.” I genuinely do think people can change. And so with that, I want to say like, Okay, can you hold the space for both of these places? That someone can change, but if they have not changed, they haven’t changed. There’s such a difference between someone sayi…
Full show notes at the publisher