Show notes
Chuck Todd opens with an uncomfortable truth Republicans are doing everything possible to avoid acknowledging: Trump turns 80 next week, his physical and mental decline is increasingly visible to anyone paying attention, and the GOP is now repeating exactly the same mistake Democrats made by ignoring Joe Biden's obvious deterioration. The cruelest irony: Trump literally built his entire 2024 campaign on the premise that his opponent was too old and too sleepy to do the job, but Biden's catastrophic debate finally broke the Democratic silence in a way the GOP shows no signs of replicating. Chuck argues Trump's behavior isn't unusual for an 80-year-old — it's deeply unusual for an American president. He warns that Senate Republicans made an enormous mistake by not killing the weaponization fund, that every GOP incumbent up for reelection is now vulnerable to extremely effective attack ads, and that acting DNI Bill Pulte is almost certainly holding that position illegally — the courts will probably step in to declare him ineligible.
He previews Tuesday's primaries in Maine and South Carolina, where Lindsey Graham looks genuinely vulnerable, and notes that if Graham gets forced into a runoff, history says he's in real trouble. He's watching how much protest vote Janet Mills picks up in Maine, and on Graham Platner — who has been saying that the war "messed him up" — Chuck offers a pointed observation: just because behavior is explainable doesn't always make it excusable.He closes with a sharp analysis of the Scott Pelley firing at 60 Minutes, arguing the real story isn't Pelley at all — it's the Ellisons, who are using 60 Minutes as a bargaining chip with Trump to get their Paramount merger approved. He believes 60 Minutes is a symbol with massive brand equity, and Trump wants to bring it to heel or topple it altogether.
Then, David French — New York Times columnist, veteran constitutional attorney, and one of the sharpest legal thinkers writing today — joins the Chuck Toddcast for a riveting conversation about how the legal system is straining to handle a world being remade by AI, an out-of-control executive branch, and the slow erosion of America's basic constitutional architecture. French opens with the chilling case the Florida Attorney General has now brought against OpenAI in connection with the Florida State University shooter, who asked ChatGPT how to disengage his weapon's safety just three minutes before opening fire. French argues that if ChatGPT had been a human person, it would unquestionably have been charged as a co-conspirator — humans get prosecuted for encouraging suicide all the time — and that when ChatGPT is speaking, OpenAI is legally speaking, full stop. He walks through the murky liability questions the law is now scrambling to answer: Google Search has never been held to the same standard as ChatGPT, but ChatGPT actively generates new speech rather than just pointing users to existing content, and French argues that litigation needs to function as a meaningful deterrent rather than mere compensation — though ultimately Congress is going to have to actually legislate AI regulation rather than leave the entire field to civil lawsuits.
The conversation turns to what French sees as a more immediate constitutional crisis: Trump's blanket immunity for tax violations and the "anti-weaponization" slush fund scheme, both of which French argues are flatly indefensible on legal grounds. He explains the deeper problem — Trump suing his own government creates a fiction of an adversarial proceeding when there isn't actually one, and Trump cares far more about the liability shield than the slush fund itself, because he's trying to remove himself from the operation of the law in essentially the same way a king would. The pardon power only covers federal crimes, not civil offenses, and Congress has clear authority to stop this if it had the will. French offers several concrete reforms: require congressional approval for legal settlements above a certain dollar threshold, force members of Congress to obtain a certification in the Constitution itself, and that political parties should perform comprehensive background checks for their candidates, On the question of whether the Founders intended a Christian nation, French is unequivocal: they didn't, and Madison rebuked Christian nationalism explicitly. The deeper structural problem behind the DOJ's loss of credibility is the unitary executive theory itself — Article II of the Constitution is dangerously vague, the executive was never meant to be a co-equal branch (Congress was supposed to be most powerful), and the only durable fix may require constitutional reform to formally remove the DOJ from executive control. French closes on a hopeful note: after every dark period in American history, the country has entered a major era of reform — and he believes one is coming again.
Finally, Chuck hops into the ToddCast Time Machine to revisit the infamous quote “Have you no sense of decency” from the Army/McCarthy hearings, why McCarthy was one of the first American politicians to master the attention economy, and why that famous quote precipitated the decline of McCarthy’s influence. He also answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment.
Predict the action all the way through the finals. Sign up now for your twenty-five dollar bonus on https://fanduel.com/predicts
Link in bio or go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.
Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.
Timeline:
(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)
00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction
05:30 Trump turns 80 in a week. Plans on celebrating himself with UFC fight
06:30 You can tell that Trump is not doing well physically/mentally
07:30 Republicans ignoring Trump’s decline like Dems did with Biden
10:00 Trump won’t do events where he has to stand, he sits now
11:30 Trump’s staff has been padding his schedule with private meetings
12:30 Trump built his campaign on premise his opponent was too old & sleepy
13:15 Biden’s debate broke the Dems silence, GOP hasn’t done same with Trump
14:30 Trump has influence and pull over his party that Biden didn’t
15:15 Trump’s behavior isn’t unusual for an 80 year, is unusual for a POTUS
16:00 Reinforces public perception that parties will say/defend anything for power
19:00 This will add to the credibility problems for the Republican party
19:30 Senate Republicans made huge mistake not killing the weaponization fund
20:15 Every Republican up for reelection is now vulnerable to easy attack ads
21:15 It’s probably illegal for Bill Pulte to hold the acting DNI position
23:00 Courts will likely step in to declare Pulte ineligible for position
25:30 Major primaries coming up on Tuesday including ME & SC
26:45 Lindsey Graham is vulnerable in South Carolina
27:45 Christian conservative right has always been skeptical of Graham
28:45 Outsiders have been ousting incumbents across the country
30:15 Since the Tea Party, GOP base has gone against the establishment
32:30 The anti-war vote will have qualms with Trump & Graham
33:15 Graham’s career is defined by being a political weathervane
35:00 If Graham is forced into a runoff, history says he’s in trouble
35:30 Will be interesting to see how much protest vote Janet Mills gets in ME
36:15 Platner says war messed him up… does he have the temperament for the job?
37:45 Just because behavior is explainable, doesn’t always make it excusable
38:15 Platner is in “save his campaign” mode
39:30 Bad actors will exploit California’s slow ballot counting process
40:30 Counting process requires people have faith in it, slowness hurts credibility
42:00 California has a duty to make citizens confident in the election
44:00 Thoughts on changes at 60 Minutes and Scott Pelley’s firing
44:30 Too much focus on Pelley and not enough on the Ellisons
45:00 Publicly traded media companies have all folded to & appeased Trump
47:30 Companies have a responsibility to shareholders, bad for news integrity
48:30 60 Minutes is a symbol, and Trump wants to bring it to heel/topple it
49:30 We don’t know the politics of the Ellisons, but they want their merger approved
50:30 Ellison’s know one 60 Minutes piece Trump dislikes could blow up merger
51:45 Bari Weiss is being used… is she comfortable being used?
53:00 Scott Pelley has the money to speak out and fight back
54:00 Journalists that stayed hoping to weather the storm & wait for new management
55:15 60 Minutes has incredible brand equity and is being gutted for the merger
56:45 The story is the Ellisons using 60 Minutes as a bargaining chip
1:04:00 David French joins the Chuck ToddCast
1:05:30 Insurance companies & gambling companies have opposite incentives
1:08:00 States liberalized sports gambling and the public hasn’t liked it
1:09:45 Trying to regulate after the fact can be difficult
1:11:00 Common law concepts are starting to come into regulating AI
1:11:30 Florida AG has brought criminal case against OpenAI over FSU shooter
1:13:00 There has to always be human liability in AI cases
1:15:00 If ChatGPT was a human in FSU case, it would have be charged as co-conspirator
1:16:00 Shooter asked ChatGPT how to disengage the safety 3 mins before shooting
1:18:00 In Canadian school shooting, ChatGPT’s participation was overt
1:20:30 Determining liability is murky. Google search isn’t held to same standard as ChatGPT
1:22:00 Humans can be prosecuted for encouraging someone to commit suicide
1:23:15 There are circumstances where criminal liability could apply to AI
1:23:45 When ChatGPT is speaking, OpenAI is speaking
1:25:00 Litigation needs to be a deterrent, not just compensation for victims
1:27:30 We need to pass laws regulating AI, not just pressure via civil lawsuits
1:28:45 How is blanket immunity for Trump tax violations remotely legal?
1:29:45 Congress’s job to stop weaponization fund & Trump IRS immunity
1:30:45 Legal system rests on an adversarial relationship in court cases
1:31:45 There’s no adversarial proceeding when Trump sues his own government
1:32:30 Trump cares more about liability shield than the slush fund
1:33:30 Pardon power only applies to federal crimes, not civil offenses. Can be sued
1:34:15 Trump is trying to remove himself from the operation of the law like a king
1:35:00 How can congress stop Trump’s DOJ from issuing these settlements?
1:36:45 Congress should have to approve settlements above a certain amount of $
1:38:30 Member of congress should have to get a certification in the constitution
1:39:45 Parties should force candidates to pass a comprehensive background check
1:41:00 Why aren’t state funded partisan primaries a violation of equal protection?
1:44:15 Partisan primaries are killing the political system
1:45:00 States can say that they’ll only fund open primaries
1:46:15 Campaign finance reforms and PACs have weakened party control
1:48:00 Did the founders intend for America to be a christian nation?
1:49:00 Founders were biblically literate, but not particularly devout
1:49:30 Founders intentionally did not create a christian nation
1:50:30 Madison argued against paying clergy with tax dollars
1:51:15 Madison rebuked christian nationalism and immigration restriction
1:53:45 DOJ has lost credibility, how can we separate the DOJ from the executive?
1:54:30 Problems with DOJ are downstream from the unitary executive theory
1:55:30 Article II of the constitution is vague and inexplicit
1:56:45 After dark period, America enters periods of reform, which we badly need
1:58:45 Never supposed to be co-equal branches. Congress should have most power
1:59:30 Have to remove executive’s ability to claw power to the top
2:00:30 Would likely need constitutional reform to pull DOJ out of executive branch
2:03:00 Past congressional leaders wouldn’t voluntarily cede power
2:04:45 In late 80’s - early 90’s, congress was incentivized to compromise
2:05:30 Changes to college basketball in one-and-done and NIL era
2:07:00 Transfer portal has created a new form of one-and-done
2:08:45 NBA can only improve regular season by reducing the 82 games
2:10:15 Regular season NBA games are more intense than 30 years ago
2:13:45 ToddCast Time Machine - June 9th, 1954
2:14:15 “Have you no sense of decency?” quote becomes famous
2:15:00 Quote came during the Army/McCarthy hearings
2:15:30 The famous line didn’t end McCarthyism
2:16:15 The myth is that McCarthy created the Red Scare… he did not
2:17:00 The Cold War was not a distant abstraction, people were worried
2:17:30 McCarthy didn’t create the wave… he was surfing it
2:18:45 Mass media was growing in America and sped up the information wars
2:19:30 McCarthy understood media and how to create anticipation
2:21:00 McCarthy mastered the politics of attention, his and Trump’s mentor was Roy Cohn
2:23:00 The fear of communism still existed, but public confidence in McCarthy eroded
2:24:00 Television exposed McCarthy in a way quotes and newspapers couldn’t
2:25:30 Army/McCarthy hearings started as a personnel dispute for Roy Cohn ally
2:27:00 There were multiple institutions moving against McCarthy
2:28:00 Army chief counsel Joseph Welch spoke the infamous line
2:28:30 Welch gave words to a conclusion Americans were reaching on their own
2:31:15 Ask Chuck
2:31:30 When will congress actually hold cabinet members accountable?
2:38:15 Thoughts on DHS pulling CBP from sanctuary city airports?
2:42:15 Navigating the tension between voting for and against a candidate?
2:48:15 Thoughts on Democrats proposing a national gerrymandering ban?
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
