Show notes
Chuck Todd opens with the grim news that the Iran conflict is hot again as both sides resume exchanging strikes — and his blunt assessment is that nothing has actually changed since Trump was begging for a deal a month ago. He argues Trump has mismanaged this war from the very beginning with no clear goal, that he and Israel started it with vastly different objectives, and that he stubbornly refuses to accept a deal that looks like the one Obama got even though that's the only realistic off-ramp available. The brutal truth, Chuck says, is that Trump can't airstrike his way to victory, and if he was never willing to commit ground troops, he never should have started the war in the first place — the Iranians now hold more leverage than the United States, and it's entirely Trump's fault that they do. He delivers one of his sharpest character indictments yet, arguing Trump "failed upwards" to the most powerful job on earth and is now half-assing his way through the presidency the same way he half-assed his way through life, while Vance and Rubio scramble to avoid any ownership of the war.With inflation rising for a third straight month, Chuck sees no path for any of this to improve before the midterms.
But the heart of the episode is a deep, genuinely illuminating dive into a new Pew survey that Chuck calls possibly the best available tool for understanding the actual American electorate — one that shatters the illusion created by social media. The data reveals nine distinct political archetypes (three on the left, three in the middle, three on the right), that the ideological extremes make up only about 15% of the country and are the whitest segments, and that the loud, combative bases dominating online discourse aren't remotely close to a majority. The middle, he notes, is a full 38% of the electorate, with the center-left as the single largest group; the Reagan Republican coalition is measurably gone, reduced to just 11%; the civil war inside the American left is already underway with skeptical progressives who'll never vote Republican but may simply not vote at all; and the MAGA-religious right remains a fortress of reliable voters, with erosion showing up in exactly one place — younger voters. His takeaway is the one that should reshape how both parties think: the persuadable middle is repulsed most by the far left and far right, the party bases are precisely what cause the parties to struggle electorally, and the opportunity for independents has genuinely never been better — because what happens online simply is not reflective of who actually shows up to vote.
Then, cultural critic Chuck Klosterman — author of But What If We're Wrong?, The Nineties, and now a new book simply titled Football — joins the Chuck Toddcast for a fascinating, genre-bending conversation that's part memoir, part sports analysis, and part thought experiment about how a singular American obsession will be remembered centuries from now. Klosterman frames the book as a "living obituary" for football, working from his signature premise that over enough time, almost everything fades until a single simplified narrative is all that survives — and that football, despite being the one true common denominator of the modern American experience (it overtook baseball as the most popular sport by the 1970s, even though people at the time didn't realize it), will almost certainly not remain central to the culture a few decades from now. He and Chuck explore how perception dramatically changes over time , how the internet has fundamentally altered our relationship with time itself, and why arguments against the internet today sound exactly like the arguments people once made against television. Klosterman, who only half-jokingly says his "beat" these days is simply reality, argues that we now consume social media on the working assumption that what we're seeing isn't real — a profound shift in how humans relate to information.
The conversation winds through some genuinely original territory about why football works the way it does and what its eventual decline might look like. Klosterman argues football is a fundamentally cerebral sport with intense but widely dispersed moments of action (the Wall Street Journal famously found only 11 minutes of actual action in a three-hour broadcast), that its sheer complexity and total absence of free-flowing movement is exactly why it's never exported well, and that it nearly became a literal embodiment of American exceptionalism. He and Todd dig into whether the NFL can over-expand into a 12-month product, why football is the one American sport that could plausibly survive on pay-per-view, and how the league walks a razor's edge between the maximum physicality fans crave and the safety changes that are slowly, quietly trying to remove hitting from the game — even as the ever-present risk of injury is precisely what raises the stakes and makes it so engaging. There's a wonderful tangent on COVID and 9/11 as the two great timeline-dividing events of the modern era (one slow and shared globally, one sudden and strange), including Chuck's own reflection that the pandemic was unexpectedly a bonding experience with his kids. Klosterman closes by previewing his next book — an alternate history of rock and roll — and delivering a characteristically provocative argument that rock effectively ended as a meaningful art form in the 1990s, that having access to all the music ever recorded has paradoxically led people to listen to the same 600 songs, and that he genuinely regrets ever getting rid of his CD collection, because the day may come when streaming services are broken up and no longer contain all the music in the world.
Finally, he answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment.
Link in bio or go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.
Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.
Timeline:
(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)
00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction
03:00 The conflict in Iran is active again as sides exchange strikes
04:00 Situation hasn’t changed since Trump begged for deal a month ago
04:45 Trump has mismanaged this war from the beginning, no clear goal
05:30 Trump refuses to accept a deal similar to the one Obama got
06:45 Trump + Israel started the war, but had vastly different objectives
08:45 New report shows inflation is going up for third straight month
09:45 Trump can’t airstrike his way into victory
11:00 If he wasn’t willing to commit ground troops, he shouldn’t have started war
11:45 Trump failed upwards to the most powerful job on earth
12:45 Trump half-assed his way through life, thinks he can do that as president
13:30 Vance & Rubio want no ownership of the Iran war
14:30 The Pentagon is instituting christian nationalist protocols
16:00 Trump is in a quagmire, Iranians know he needs a deal more than them
18:00 The Iranians have more leverage and it’s Trump’s fault that they do
19:30 There’s no way this gets better for the country by the midterms
21:15 New report categorizes Americans political views, most people in the middle
22:00 The extremes are only about 15% of the elecorate & are the whitest
22:45 The loudest parts of the bases aren’t close to the majority
23:30 Democrats have to win more moderate to win than the right
25:00 This Pew survey is possibly the best tool to understand the electorate
26:15 How the survey was conducted
29:15 The Reagan Republican coalition is measurably gone
30:30 There 9 different American political archetypes, 3 on left, middle & right
31:15 Breakdown of American left, which is 30% of the country
33:45 Breakdown of American right, core MAGA voters most likely to vote
35:30 The young right is a bit checked out on politics, don’t always vote
36:30 The middle is 38% of the electorate, center left is largest group
37:45 Remnants of the Reagan coalition is only 11% of the electorate
39:30 The “tuned out middle” is 9% of the electorate, minority of them vote
40:30 The civil war inside the American left is already underway
41:30 Progressives are still skeptical of the Democratic party
43:00 Progressives will never vote Republican, but may not vote
44:15 The MAGA + religious right is a fortress of voters that show up
45:15 Support for Trump amongst younger voters is the one place showing erosion
46:00 The establishment right is politically homeless and persuadable
48:45 The “polite right” demographically best reflects America, but is oldest
50:00 The “checked out middle” isn’t reachable or persuadable
50:30 The far left and right are most repulsive to the persuadable middle
51:15 The bases are what cause the parties to struggle electorally
53:00 The opportunity for independents has never been better
54:15 What happens online is not reflective of the majority of the electorate
1:04:00 Chuck Klosterman joins the Chuck ToddCast
1:05:00 Football is partially memoir, part description of football
1:07:30 The process of writing the book
1:09:00 It was like Chuck was “trying to build his brain in public”
1:11:15 The thought exercise of how football will be remembered in 200 years
1:12:00 Over time, some things stick and others fade away until one thing is left
1:12:45 It’s easier to understand a singular narrative
1:13:30 If something remains in the zeitgeist after 60 years, it has true staying power
1:16:00 Arguments against the internet sound like arguments against TV
1:17:45 What do you consider “your beat” these days? Reality.
1:19:00 Consuming social media with assumption what you’re seeing isn’t real
1:20:15 Book is a living obituary for football. Eventually, it won’t be central to culture
1:21:00 By the 1970’s football was the most popular sport, people thought it was baseball
1:22:15 Football is the one common denominator of the American experience
1:23:15 In a few decades, football will likely no longer be central to our society
1:24:30 The perception of Woodrow Wilson changed well after his death
1:26:00 Perception can dramatically change over time
1:26:45 How much time should pass before writing about a historical event?
1:28:15 The internet has changed our relationship with time
1:29:30 Diving the timeline into pre and post 9/11 and pre/post Covid
1:30:45 The COVID experience was slow, 9/11 happened suddenly
1:32:00 People forget how weird the two weeks after 9/11 were
1:33:30 Covid was a bizarre experience, everyone focused on same thing
1:34:15 Covid truly the first global event, shared by everyone
1:35:30 Covid was actually a bonding experience for Chuck Todd with his kids
1:37:30 History may look back at Covid very differently than we do now
1:42:15 Will football end as the cultural glue when television ends?
1:42:45 Cost of TV advertising is not worth the ROI for many companies
1:43:30 NFL + college football are of the mindset that they can only expand
1:44:30 Football is our only sport that could survive on a PPV basis
1:46:15 The majority of people who love football didn’t play it
1:47:00 Sports show how capitalism operates in a way that’s dangerous
1:49:45 Complexity has made American football hard to export
1:50:45 There’s no freedom of movement in football. It’s all planned
1:52:00 Why hasn’t Rugby caught on in America?
1:52:45 Football almost became an embodiment of American exceptionalism
1:53:45 WSJ studied football and found there’s only 11 mins of action in 3 hours
1:55:45 Football is a mostly cerebral sport with intense, dispersed moments of action
1:56:45 How important is it that football is in fall and winter?
1:57:30 People can now escape nature, but nature is very determinative in football
2:00:30 Most people don’t experience physicality and football demands it
2:01:30 Is it possible for the NFL to overexpand? Could it become a 12 month experience?
2:03:30 Owners want to host a Super Bowl, all stadiums will likely have a roof in 20 years
2:05:45 Football will have value as a distraction, but it needs meaning to stay powerful
2:07:00 Attending football games has gotten increasingly expensive
2:08:30 Safety changes have changed the nature of the game
2:09:00 The dream may be to slowly remove the hitting from the game
2:09:30 Fans used to revel in the hard hits, now they’re turning away
2:10:15 The risk of injury raises the stakes, makes it more engaging
2:12:15 NFL walks the line between max physicality and not turning fans off
2:15:00 What is your next book? Alternate history of Rock n Roll
2:17:45 Rock as a meaningful artform ended in the 90s
2:20:00 People have access to all the music in the world, listen to same 600 songs
2:22:30 Regret getting rid of the CD collection
2:23:15 Eventually streaming services could get broken up, not have all music
2:26:00 Chuck’s thoughts on interview with Chuck Klosterman
2:27:00 Ask Chuck
2:27:15 Thoughts on private equity getting involved in college sports?
2:36:00 Why does ballot counting get overcovered by the media?
2:38:45 Will the incoming shortfall for social security affect the election?
2:42:15 How do you reconcile candidates with character shortfalls & their policies?
2:48:30 Should voters assess media narratives & bias in reporting about Platner?
2:54:00 Does the media need to do a better job explaining how votes come in?
2:59:30 How should presidents approach attending big sports events?
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
