The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Hour 1: McMonigle Rips "Bitter" Red Sox Radio Call After Jazz Chisholm Steals Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

McMonigle recaps the New York Yankees' series win over the Boston Red Sox, focusing on the mental edge established during their 16-1 blowout. On The Carton Show, he critiques the WEEI radio broadcast that labeled Jazz Chisholm "Bush League" for stealing bases. The discussion also evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, including the status of Jalin Hyatt and Evan Neal.

(00:01:31) Giants Roster Moves

(00:05:03) Yankees Statement Series

(00:08:51) Will Warren's Dominance

(00:15:32) Red Sox Radio Outrage

(00:20:06) Jazz Chisholm Controversy

(00:24:46) Platoon Lineup Debate

(00:33:56) Yankees Series Edge

Hour 2: Orioles Claim Luis Robert Jr. & The Great Stan Lee Debate Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman break down the Baltimore Orioles claiming Luis Robert Jr. off waivers and what it means for the New York Mets' financial future. They also debate the postseason impact of Jazz Chisholm Jr., analyze Carlos Beltran’s legacy, and argue over whether Stan Lee or Steven Spielberg has a greater cultural footprint.

(00:01:20) Luis Robert Jr. Claimed

(00:05:15) Pete Alonso Performance Debate

(00:10:00) Jazz Chisholm Playoff Expectations

(00:14:00) Pedro Martinez Dominance

(00:17:15) Carlos Beltran Legacy Documentary

(00:21:00) Yankees Red Sox Series Recap

(00:26:00) Yankees Playoff Bullpen Strategy

(00:30:00) Al Pacino Classic Movies

(00:38:20) Stan Lee Versus Spielberg

(00:43:30) Bear Encounter In Warwick

Hour 3: Big Mac Rips Giants Draft Busts as Odell Beckham Jr. Returns Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Giants' decision to bring back Odell Beckham Jr. while moving on from major draft disappointments like Evan Neal. The Carton Show explores the New York Yankees' current lineup strategy and debates the best movie sequels and old-school candy. They also weigh in on the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the challenges of watching every NFL game on Sundays.

(00:02:21) Beckham Jr. Rejoins Giants

(00:05:54) Giants Recent Draft Busts

(00:12:11) New York Sports Update

(00:15:27) Yankees Lineup Debate

(00:19:46) Legacy of Odell Beckham

(00:24:08) 80s Movies and Candy

(00:30:02) Jets Quarterback Options

(00:37:44) Giants Defensive Expectations

(00:45:05) NFL Sunday Ticket Debate

Hour 4: Red Sox 'Embarrassed' Themselves by Giving Up to Yankees Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

McMonigle recaps a dominant series win for the New York Yankees over the Boston Red Sox on The Carton Show, highlighting Aaron Boone's role in Jazz Chisholm Jr. stealing bases. He analyzes the Los Angeles Rams' unique approach to roster management and the NFL's 'fungible' salary cap. The conversation also explores the New York Giants' draft struggles under general manager Joe Shane.

(00:01:21) Jalen Brunson Birthday Song

(00:04:45) Heussler's Yankee Hate

(00:12:11) Rams Salary Cap Magic

(00:16:59) Giants Draft History Analysis

(00:25:16) Yankees Crush Red Sox

(00:41:27) Boone Defends Jazz Chisholm

(00:46:29) Savannah Bananas Entertainment

Hour 5: Yankees Bludgeon Red Sox as World Series Hopes Reach New Heights Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Anthony Gallo analyzes the Yankees' recent dominance over the Red Sox and argues why they are the primary World Series contender in a weak American League. He and DJ Hoff also discuss the Mets' pitching struggles and evaluate David Stearns' roster management.

(00:01:35) Yankees Dominance Over Boston

(00:07:24) American League Playoff Field

(00:09:15) Mets Pitching Rotation Struggles

(00:15:30) Cubs World Series Hopes

(00:21:43) Aaron Judge Return Update

Big Mac Slams the Rams’ Impossible Salary Cap Moves Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle expresses frustration over the Los Angeles Rams' ability to consistently manipulate the salary cap to retain superstars like Aaron Donald. He also recounts legendary stories of Bob Heussler's disdain for the Yankees and discusses the hit-or-miss draft record of Giants GM Joe Schoen.

(00:01:01) Celebrating Jalen Brunson

(00:04:06) Bob Heussler Yankee Hate

(00:10:15) Rams Cap Management Issues

(00:15:21) Joe Schoen Draft Critique

(00:23:11) On-Air Parenting Banter

Big Mac Mocks Craig's Candy Tastes and the Jets QB Situation Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac ridicules Craig Carton's questionable movie takes and his preference for "old person" candies like bottle caps and spice drops. They transition into a debate regarding the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the necessity of a multi-TV setup for the upcoming NFL season.

(00:01:00) Debating 80s Movie Sequels

(00:04:26) Craig's Bizarre Candy Tastes

(00:06:40) Jets Quarterback Room Concerns

(00:16:21) Giants Defensive Matchup Analysis

(00:19:41) The Ultimate Sunday Setup

Big Mac Breaks Down Giants Roster Cuts and OBJ's Return Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Giants' final roster decisions, specifically highlighting the return of Odell Beckham Jr. and the release of high draft picks Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt. He reflects on the organization's repeated failures to stabilize the offensive line and receiving corps over recent years. They also take calls regarding Aaron Boone's management of the New York Yankees' batting order during a key rivalry series.

(00:02:49) OBJ Makes Giants Roster

(00:04:00) Evan Neal Labelled Bust

(00:11:09) Giants Personnel Failures

(00:15:52) Yankees Lineup Decisions

(00:19:43) OBJ Return Reactions

Pete & Big Mac Debate Stan Lee vs. Spielberg and a Warwick Bear Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Pete McMonigle and Big Mac debate the cultural impact of Stan Lee compared to Steven Spielberg while revisiting classic movie scenes. They also recount a listener's encounter with a bear during an ice cream bet and look ahead to the Giants' regular-season roster.

(00:01:33) Iconic Graduation Songs

(00:03:45) Al Pacino Movie Classics

(00:10:36) Stan Lee Versus Spielberg

(00:15:01) Bear Interrupts Ice Cream Bet

(00:17:47) Giants Roster Moves Update

C-Mac Evaluates Beltran’s Legacy and Aaron Boone's Lineup Decisions Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac analyzes the Orioles' waiver claim of Luis Robert Jr. and reflects on Pete Alonso's late-season surge. They examine Carlos Beltran's complicated history with the Mets and evaluate Aaron Boone’s tactical decisions during the Yankees' series against the Red Sox.

(00:01:14) Luis Robert Jr. Claimed

(00:05:13) Pete Alonso’s Hot Streak

(00:15:36) Carlos Beltran’s Mets Tenure

(00:20:36) Yankees Red Sox Recap

(00:25:34) Yankees Bullpen Strategy