The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

C-Mac Debates if the Giants Season Opener is a Must-Win Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac reviews Sydney Sweeney's new lingerie collection before diving into New York Giants football. He discusses the high stakes of the Week 1 game against the Dallas Cowboys and takes calls regarding the performance of Jaxson Dart and Dexter Lawrence.

(00:01:48) Sydney Sweeney's Lingerie

(00:05:11) Dick's Logo Discussion

(00:07:17) Giants Opening Game Debate

(00:14:01) Analyzing Jaxson Dart

(00:20:49) Dexter Lawrence's Impact

Big Mac on Giants' Playmakers and Mets' Search for an Ace Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac evaluates the New York Giants' offensive potential and the importance of health for Malik Nabors. The discussion includes a debate on Major League Baseball's blowout games and the possible implementation of a forfeit rule. Finally, they look ahead to the New York Mets' offseason and the potential pursuit of Tarik Skubal.

(00:01:00) The Wheel and The Duke

(00:02:45) Giants Offensive Potential

(00:09:06) Seahawks and Rams Analysis

(00:12:54) MLB Blowout Forfeit Debate

(00:17:02) Mets Offseason and Skubal

McMonigle Rejects Mad Dog's Prediction of an 0-2 Giants Start Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle reacts to Mad Dog Russo's claim that the Giants are guaranteed to start the season 0-2. He emphasizes the critical importance of Malik Nabers being healthy for Week 1 and discusses why the Rams matchup could be a trap game for Los Angeles. They also revisit a bizarre phone call Pete Hoffman received regarding an inheritance scam.

(00:01:09) Hoffman's Bizarre Texas Call

(00:05:40) Smoking Doctors And Beatles

(00:08:03) Malik Nabers Injury Status

(00:10:56) Rams Giants Trap Game

(00:14:08) Giants Slow Start Concerns

McMonigle Analyzes Tony Romo’s Health Statement and CBS Future Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

McMonigle explores Tony Romo's recent statement addressing his health issues and the likelihood of his return to the broadcast booth. They also discuss the value of high-profile announcers compared to pregame studio shows and share anecdotes from the Giants locker room involving Odell Beckham Jr. and Dexter Lawrence. Additionally, callers weigh in on the Jazz Chisholm Jr. controversy and the surprising history of Cookie Puss.

(00:02:37) Tony Romo Health Statement

(00:06:38) Future Of NFL Broadcasting

(00:12:00) Giants Locker Room Stories

(00:17:16) Jazz Chisholm Base Stealing

(00:20:29) Cookie Puss Alien Origins

C-Mac Breaks Down Yankees' Offensive Struggles and Grisham Dilemma Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac discusses the recent legal developments in the Tupac Shakur case and laments the arrival of seasonal items like Oktoberfest beer in early August. He also evaluates the New York Yankees' roster, debating the future of Trent Grisham in the lineup compared to Spencer Jones.

(00:01:31) Tupac Case Update

(00:03:55) Seasonal Items Rant

(00:11:47) Yankees' Offensive Concerns

(00:14:07) Grisham Versus Jones

Stanley Kroenke Buys the Angels; Red Sox Broadcast Controversy Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac discusses the news of Stanley Kroenke and Kroenke Sports and Entertainment purchasing the Los Angeles Angels from Arte Moreno. He explores the franchise's history of expensive contract failures and takes a call regarding the recent Red Sox broadcast controversy involving Will Fleming.

(00:01:12) Kroenke Buys Angels

(00:04:40) Angels Ownership History

(00:08:06) Red Sox-Yankees Debate

Comparing Yankees' Championship DNA to the Knicks' Winning Standard Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

The Carton Show analyzes the New York Yankees' organizational philosophy following a frustrating loss to the Angels. They compare the Yankees' DNA to the New York Knicks' recent success and debate whether 95-win seasons satisfy the franchise's championship expectations. The discussion also touches on Long Island's music scene and the questionable quality of the movie Teen Wolf 2.

(00:01:00) Long Island Bands

(00:03:01) Teen Wolf Discussion

(00:06:55) Yankees Reliever Strategy

(00:13:11) Yankees Versus Knicks

(00:20:31) Winning Standard Debate

Big Mac Slams Yankees' "Disgusting" Performance in Anaheim Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac criticizes the New York Yankees for their lackluster performance against the Los Angeles Angels following a high-energy series against the Red Sox. The discussion covers the team's struggling bullpen, the division race against the Rays, and the return of Aaron Judge.

(00:01:07) Yankees' Disappointing Loss to Angels

(00:05:38) Chasing the Tampa Bay Rays

(00:10:16) Revamping the Yankees' Bullpen

(00:15:00) Mets and NFL News

Yankees platoon POUNDS Boston to take massive series | 'Go Get 'Em' Sep 01, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees made a statement by taking three of four from the Red Sox, including a beatdown in Sunday's series finale. Chris McMonigle celebrates the huge victory, what it means for the postseason, and what it says about how far this Yankee team can go in October. Plus, looking at the Yankees platoon identity moving forward, praising Heliot Ramos for finally coming through with a big hit and Will Warren for his masterful start, while the offense showed encouraging signs across the board.

EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS

3:36 - Breaking down the standings impact: The Yankees move four games up on Boston, which is essentially five games thanks to securing the tiebreaker.

6:14 - Reacting to the Red Sox broadcast calling Jazz Chisholm a "bush league" player for stealing bases while up six runs.

10:04 - Analyzing Aaron Boone's heavily debated platoon strategy. The decision to sit hot left-handed hitters like Luis Garcia and Ben Rice in favor of righties like Paul Goldschmidt and Ramos against left-handed pitching ultimately pays off.

29:23 - Carlos Rodon's start unravels after a poor baserunning decision and terrible send at third base involving Amed Rosario.

39:28 - Concerns over Max Fried's Saturday start, specifically a noticeable drop in his fastball velocity down to 92-93 mph.

45:36 - Praise for Paul Blackburn and the bullpen for escaping late-inning jams to secure the victory.

52:41 - Will Warren delivers the best start of his young career in a massive spot, retiring 13 consecutive Red Sox batters after allowing a leadoff double.

1:04:51 - Ramos crushes a critical three-run home run on a 1-2 breaking ball.

1:12:20 - Tampa Bay Rays update: The Rays sweep the Padres by rallying against Mason Miller in the ninth inning to stay five games ahead of the Yankees.

1:18:52 - Looking ahead to the West Coast road trip against the Angels and Padres. Plus, predictions that Aaron Judge will return to the lineup for the upcoming homestand against the Colorado Rockies.

Full Show: Yankees Dismantle Red Sox as Broadcasters Call for Violence Aug 31, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac analyzes the New York Yankees' dominant series win against the Boston Red Sox and the subsequent fallout from the Boston broadcast booth. He evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, labeling Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt as major busts while discussing the impact of Odell Beckham Jr.'s return. Additionally, they project the long-term outlook for the Knicks following potential contract discounts from Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges.

(00:02:05) Yankees Crush Red Sox

(00:16:59) Red Sox Broadcaster Controversy

(00:22:23) Aaron Boone Management Strategy

(00:30:18) Giants Roster Disappointments

(00:37:44) Rams Roster Construction Envy

(00:45:08) Dramatic MLB Catch Replays

(00:09:27) Knicks Contract Extension Talk