The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Full Show: The Yankees Need to Play George Lombard Jr Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac believes giving George Lombard Jr a day off is only going to make things worse. Is Aaron Glen already on the hot seat before the season even starts? C-Mac says playing Jaxson Dart for a drive against the Jets backups is a waste of time. Instant reaction to the Yankees lineup. Instant reaction to the news that Max Fried will come off the injured list and pitch against the Red Sox. John Madden tried to sue Frank Caliendo?? Someone faked being a 49ers player and scammed her out of over $1 million?? Emmanuel Berbari joins the show to preview this crucial Yankees-Red Sox series. Jaxson not expected to play in preseason finale against the Jets.

Hour 4: No Jaxson Dart in Preseason Finale Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Emmanuel Berbari joins the show to preview this crucial Yankees-Red Sox series. Jaxson not expected to play in preseason finale against the Jets.

Berbari and Big Mac Preview Yankees Pivotal Series Against Red Sox Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle and Emmanuel Berbari analyze the New York Yankees' strategy heading into a crucial series against the Boston Red Sox. They evaluate Anthony Volpe's recent defensive struggles, the thinning bullpen depth, and the high-stakes outlook for Aaron Judge's return to the lineup.

(00:01:07) Intro with Big Mac

(00:05:40) Infield Defensive Issues

(00:10:26) Bullpen Management Talk

(00:17:50) Jazz Chisholm Jr. Impact

(00:24:22) Aaron Judge Return Status

Yankees Lineup Frustrations & a $1.3M NFL Player Imposter Scam Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

The discussion highlights a massive fraud case involving a man posing as a San Francisco 49ers player to scam women out of $1.3 million. They also dive into the New York Yankees' lineup decisions against left-handed pitching and debate the team's reliance on specific veterans over hot hitters. Additionally, the conversation explores bizarre food preferences among the crew, including a controversial stance on chicken cutlets and ketchup on mac and cheese.

(00:01:00) Mannequin Movie Memories

(00:03:46) NFL Player Imposter Scam

(00:08:46) Peculiar Food Takes

(00:12:32) Yankees Lineup Strategy

Madden's Grudge Against Caliendo & Yankees Pitching News Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

McMonigle and Gallo react to the news that John Madden once considered suing Frank Caliendo over his famous impression. They also preview the Yankees' pivotal series against the Red Sox and discuss Max Fried's return to the rotation.

(00:01:00) Sports Impression Debates

(00:03:10) Madden's Feud With Caliendo

(00:07:41) Wrestling Promos And Fads

(00:11:00) Yankees Red Sox Preview

(00:16:27) Max Fried Rotation News

Big Mac Slams Boone's Lineup Decisions and Jaxson Dart Narrative Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac and Gallo evaluate the Yankees' decision to bench Luis García and Spencer Jones in favor of a platoon lineup against the Red Sox. They also challenge the reckless reputation of Jaxson Dart while exploring the learning curve of the new Giants offense under Matt Nagy.

(00:01:04) Yankees Lineup Strategy

(00:07:50) Nostalgia and Dart Narrative

(00:12:08) Giants New Offense

(00:18:37) Lombard's Defensive Woes

Big Mac on Geno Smith's Outlook and Jaxson Dart's Giants Role Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac analyzes the preseason strategies for the Giants and Jets, specifically debating the playing time for Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith. He also examines the Yankees' missed opportunity with Eugenio Suárez and dismisses a caller's theory about an Aaron Judge suspension.

(00:02:14) Jets and Giants QB Plans

(00:06:23) Harbaugh's Tough Training Camp

(00:08:46) Eugenio Suárez Waiver Talk

(00:12:16) Disney and Orlando Vacations

(00:16:11) Debunking Judge Suspension Theory

Woody Johnson's Potential Pursuit of Mike Tomlin for the Jets Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Discussions range from movie nostalgia and Rick Moranis's return to acting to the coaching situation for the New York Jets. Big Mac evaluates Robert Saleh's performance and speculates on Woody Johnson's interest in hiring Mike Tomlin if the team fails to make the playoffs.

(00:01:03) Movie Nostalgia and Rick Moranis

(00:03:44) Football vs High School Musicals

(00:05:13) Giants and Jets Preseason Preview

(00:07:19) Evaluating Robert Saleh's Tenure

(00:10:36) Mike Tomlin Jets Rumors

McMonigle Argues Against Benching George Lombard Jr. Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac explains why George Lombard Jr. should continue playing shortstop despite his recent defensive errors, emphasizing that the rookie needs to play through his struggles. He also analyzes the upcoming series against the Red Sox and expresses concern about the durability of the bullpen heading into the postseason.

(00:01:00) Beatles and Wedding Playlists

(00:02:31) George Lombard Jr. Debate

(00:06:30) Red Sox Series Preview

(00:12:42) Postseason Bullpen Concerns

(00:22:49) Benching For Physical Errors

Big Mac: George Lombard Needs to Play Through Error Slump Aug 28, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac analyzes the high stakes of the Yankees' upcoming series against the Red Sox and its potential impact on their playoff positioning. He also argues against benching George Lombard despite his recent errors, emphasizing the importance of keeping the young shortstop's confidence high.

(00:01:00) Yankees-Red Sox Series Stakes

(00:05:44) George Lombard's Defensive Slump

(00:12:30) Yankees Rotation and NFL News

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected