Claire Fallon and Emma Gray obsessively analyze our cultural obsessions, from fashion trends to books to the buzziest TV shows.
patreon.com/claireandemma
php/*
Claire Fallon and Emma Gray obsessively analyze our cultural obsessions, from fashion trends to books to the buzziest TV shows.
patreon.com/claireandemma
Copyright: © CLAIRE AND EMMA LLC
Pedro Pascal + Dakota Johnson + Chris Evans + love triangle + New York City + an exploration of modern dating should = pure joy. Unfortunately, the math behind Celine Song’s sophomore feature, “Materialists,” simply doesn’t add up.
You know things aren’t going great when you watch a movie and can’t stop mentally cataloguing each item of clothing the protagonist is wearing. That ruffled Doên dress? $398. The work bag that looks like a dupe of the Khaite one? $650. A floral Reformation dress? $278. Knee-high Paris Texas boots? $766. Sexy Simkhai top? $375. A cerulean Proenza cocktail dress? Originally $1190, but now on sale for $365.
Alas, the minute Dakota Johnson’s Lucy — an immaculately-dressed, 30-something star matchmaker living in a modest but beautiful Brooklyn Heights apartment — declares that she makes $80k/year (before taxes!!!), I knew we were doomed to do the mental tally. Song has said that including this specific number was an intentional choice; she wanted the audience to linger over the financial realities of the not-uber-wealthy. But in a movie thin on character development, it served more as a distraction.
“Materialists” follows Lucy (Dakota Johnson), a 30-something star matchmaker and self-described expert on the romantic marketplace who says she’s looking to marry rich. At the wedding of one of her former clients, she meets the groom’s brother, Harry (Pedro Pascal), a private equity multi-millionaire (billionaire?) who believes that love is about transaction and sees intrinsic value in Lucy. She also runs into her broke actor ex-boyfriend John (Chris Evans), the former love of her life who is now working as a cater waiter and living in an apartment where his roommates leave used condoms around their shared kitchen. Thus the movie sets up its central questions: Will Lucy choose Money or Love? And if being loved is about being viewed as valuable — a thesis that Lucy states plainly early in “Materialists” — where is that value derived and who gets to decide what it is?
The movie is at its sharpest when examining the cold realities of a dating marketplace — a marketplace where buyers are also commodities — devoid of human intimacy. The app-ification of courtship is laid bare in Lucy’s intake meetings with new potential clients. (Song herself previously worked as a matchmaker, and it shows.) A 48-year-old man expresses a desire to finally settle down with a mature woman, by which he means a 27-year-old. Another man tells Lucy that “39 is 40,” and then requests “nothing over a 20 BMI.” Lucy’s services are luxury goods, acquired by people of means in order to guarantee the acquisition of luxury spouses. But as Lucy tells one client later in the movie, “this is not a car or a house. We’re talking about people. People are people are people are people. They come as they are.”
But who are Lucy and Harry and John? They are less people, and more paper dolls, gesturing around at vague, potentially fascinating ideas. And even all the money in the world can’t buy substance.
“The Materialists Trailer Is A Liar,” Andrew Gruttadaro, The Ringer
“Materialists Is an Inert Misreading of Modern Romance,” Angelica Jade Bastién, Vulture
“How a Salary Figure Changes Everything in ‘Materialists,’” Alissa Wilkinson, NYTimes
“'materialists' is a romcom for the money diaries generation,” Viv Chen, The Molehill
“Rich Suitor/Poor Suitor,” Heather Schwedel, Slate
“Is Materialists Actually a Horror Movie?,” Jesse Hassenger, GQ
Share Rich TextIf you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
Let’s talk reunions, y’all! We’re back from our summer vacations, rested and ready to reunite for all the reunion specials we missed during our OOO week: “The Ultimatum: Queer Love” and “Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” Hosts Joanna Garcia Swisher and Nick Viall took their best swings at the Andy Cohen crown, with varying results, but each reunion offered at least a few juicy moments.
In “The Ultimatum: Queer Love,” there were more happy updates than usual. And we love to see our queens thriving! But the reunion drama was somewhat dampened by all the couples who showed up ready to protect their relationships. Only the single cast members came out throwing elbows. Ashley and Marita shared a particularly bruising exchange, while Marie seeped poorly suppressed rage throughout the special. In a surprise twist, Mels’s Brussels sprout recipe played a key role in the conflict. Joanna was present and warm as ever, but ineffectual, leaving many intriguing questions and follow-ups unasked. We get into all the updates from the couples and former couples, assess the hosting, and try to make sense of the hot-button topics that weren’t even broached. (Like… what do Magan and Dayna have on Joanna??)
Next, the “Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” reunion! The questions were sharper and the follow-ups were on point, but the absence of season villain Demi took the thrill out of most of the conversations. (She was, she alleges, unable to cancel a family vacation to Disney.) Instead, the women have to respond to clips from a pre-taped interview with Nick, in which Demi talks shit with the confidence of a woman who does not have to actually face her targets. Meanwhile, Jessi has a lot to say about how she can’t say anything at all regarding Marciano’s allegations that they had an affair after meeting on “Vanderpump Villa” (to learn more, we’ll have to watch season 3). But there are some explosive moments — notably, Jen and Zac producing an audio recording of Demi instructing Jen to positively spin Demi’s own rumored dalliance with Marciano during “VPV” — as well as some poignant ones. We get into it all in the second half of this episode.
Hope you enjoy! xo
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
“The Ultimatum: Queer Love” finale had it all: Proposals! Confrontations! A dramatic breakup! This season was a true emotional rollercoaster, in all of the best ways.
We got to see some real growth from both couples — Pilar & Haley and Magan & Dayna faced potentially relationship-ending challenges during their trial marriages — as well as individuals — Ashley seems to find her voice and reckon with the potential incompatibilities that she and her longterm girlfriend Marita have. Other couples are resistant to untangling hard truths right up to the end. (Yes, we ARE talking about you, Mel and Marie.)
We taped this episode ahead because of our insane schedules, so this podcast will only include discussion of episodes 8 and 9 of “Queer Love” S2. A separate podcast about the (honestly quite juicy) reunion will be coming soon.
Hope you enjoy! Xo
Special thanks to Jonathan Behar for editing today’s episode.
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
Just in time for the end of Pride Month, “The Ultimatum: Queer Love” has returned to our screens. And after watching the first seven episodes of season 2, we couldn’t help but wonder… why does the straight version even exist when “Queer Love” is so far superior?
The new season follows six couples who have reached a crossroads in their longterm relationship. One partner wants to get married, and the other has reservations. For some couples, the hesitancy has to do with familial rejection or disapproval; for others it’s a more run-of-the-mill uncertainty about fundamental compatibility. (Looking at you, Marita and Ashley!)
So, shepherded through the process by host Joanna Garcia Swisher (who remains an inexplicable choice for a show about queer love), the couples break up, date everyone else on the cast, and choose a new partner for a three-week trial marriage. And oh boy do these people take their trial marriages SERIOUSLY. Some become each other’s therapists/besties (Marita and Britney), and others fall into full-on new relationships (Haley and Magan, Mel and Dayna). After those three weeks are up, they return to their original partners and figure out if they still can (and want to!) make it work.
It’s transcendent reality television — a true window into the human experience, full of love, sex, betrayal and emotional messiness. We talk about everything from the first seven episodes we could fit into one taping, and we had an absolute blast doing it. Hope you enjoy! Xo
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
If one can say anything uplifting about season 2 of “The Valley,” it’s probably that the show is, at least, providing video documentation of Jax Taylor’s misdeeds — and his slimy attempts to throw blame for his horrific behavior on everyone around him, his ex-wife Brittany Cartwright in particular.
In this latest batch of episodes, Jax steps up his harassment of Britt. He continues to rage-text her, reaches out to their mutual friends and family to try to convince them he’s truly changed and needs Britt’s sympathy and care, watches her from the family home’s interior surveillance cameras, apparently fakes (or at least exaggerates) a medical emergency, dumps his disastrous financial problems on her, and continues to imply (under the guise of taking full accountability) that Britt is responsible for his bad behavior. After all, she should have held him accountable before! She should have left him! He wishes she had! Oh, if only someone had forced him to be less of a piece of shit!
Meanwhile, the side-plots continue to play out. Jesse continues to fixate on Michelle having cheated on him, and Michelle airs her own grievances in front of the group. (At least Jesse has the backing of their former relationship coach, now his solo coach, who seems particularly gifted at feeding into the aggrieved mindset of the recently divorced male.) Nia draws fire from her friends when she doesn’t openly trash her husband Danny for getting drunk at a wine-tasting in Santa Barbara. Jasmine realizes she may not be over Danny groping her and Melissa last Halloween. Defending Danny and Nia, Kristen spreads a rumor about Jason taking off his wedding ring at bars, which somehow leads to a blowup between Jason, Janet… and Jasmine.
In this episode, we catch up on these central plot points and try not to let Jax raise our blood pressure. Hope you enjoy! xo
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
Carrie Bradshaw is swanning about in tulle in her massive Gramercy Park townhouse. Her boyfriend is in Virginia, her jewelry designer millennial neighbor is now living in her old uptown apartment, and her friends are busy fucking nuns and stalking elite college counselors.
Naturally, that means it’s time for her to sit down and write a novel. About women. Women who “toss and turn” due to their “insecurities,” and obsess over the past. But it’s not the past, it’s the present: May, 1846. Or is it 2012? When you’re talking about “And Just Like That…”, one can never be sure.
The show may be set in the year of our lord 2025, but the cultural discussions are straight out of the early 20-teens. Reality dating shows — did you know smart women can enjoy them? Hate-watching, baby! Everything happens on our phones now — even dating! Have you heard???
Not only does the cultural zeitgeist of “And Just Like That…” season 3 feel woefully dated, but our heroines are now ensconsed in such absurd levels of wealth that it feels as if there are no real stakes to… well… anything. As David Mack put it in a fantastic piece for Slate: “If SATC was once a revolutionary show about sex and dating, AJLT is now too often a series about money and the carefree lifestyle that wealth provides the leisure class. … In its third season, AJLT is more content than ever plodding along (albeit in Manolos) as little more than a pedestrian fantasy that’s lost most of the spunk and spark of the original series. Like its characters’ lives, AJLT is just… comfortable.”
And yet, there’s still so much to laugh about when discussing this show. And we don’t just mean Carrie’s historical romance novel! We had so much fun (and secondhand embarrassment) talking about that Aidan masturbation scene, Seema’s showdown with matchmaker Cheri Oteri, the character development we are actually *enjoying* from Miranda, and what we hope to get from Carrie and Charlotte as the season progresses. Hope you enjoy! Xo
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
What would Jesse Solomon do (if you were a hot model in his proximity)? Evidence from the lanky “Summer House” star, during his sophomore season on the show, suggests that he would shower you with flattery and over-the-top declarations of romantic feelings, press forward with a committed relationship, get his toe sucked during a 37-minute off-camera hang with two women, and all the while vent to your shared friend group about all the “red flags” you’ve displayed. And if you have a problem with any of it? Well, he was only joking. Baddies beware, because this was the fate of Lexi Wood, the latest ingenue on season 9 of the Bravo show.
We have watched model and Instagram star Lexi’s arrival — and the couple’s PDA-heavy, turbulent insta-relationship — at first with exhausted irritation, then undiluted annoyance, and ultimately fascination. Lexi’s baby-voiced flirtation and eagerness to jump into things with Jesse before she had solidified social connections with the rest of the house didn’t endear her to the audience. And Jesse, after a low-key first season, seemed transparently determined to make his mark with a splashy relationship. It all came off as a little too calculated and, simultaneously, a little too foolish, to get invested in. But the wreckage left by their short-lived relationship has, against our will, riveted us. We are ready to rubberneck at the flaming trail of destruction. Among the casualties: Ciara’s chill summer, Lexi’s friendships with the other summer house guests, and Jesse’s nice-guy halo.
In this episode, we discuss everything that unsettled us about Jesse’s courtship of Lexi and how he has handled the fallout of their relationship, as well as how Lexi approached her first season and her fling with Jesse. We also dig into Ciara’s reluctant role in the Jesse-Lexi drama (please leave this woman in peace!!). Plus, we discuss breast milk flavor profiles and Paige’s sparse revelations about the Craig breakup at the end of the finale. Hope you enjoy! xo
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
What is MomTok? A business? A friend group? A sisterhood? A vehicle for TV drama? A tool for dismantling the patriarchal forces undergirding the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints? In season 2 of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” the ladies of MomTok are back — and they have very different answers to that big question.
For Demi and Whitney, MomTok is a buttoned-up business where cosplays friendship — or at least practices loyalty — which means that there’s no room for chaotic colleagues like Taylor Frankie Paul. For Taylor, Mayci, Mikayla, Layla, Jen and newcomer Miranda, it’s more of a group of friends who also happen to make very lucrative content together. For all of them, it’s a way to push back (in a limited and often personally convenient way) on the oppressive boundaries of their conservative upbringings.
If season 1 of SLOMW was an Intro to MomTok course, season 2 throws us right into an advanced seminar, full of carefully performed rituals of femininity (a Mormon bake-off!) and compulsory fertility (pregnancy roulette!). The women are excavating past traumas, wading into Hulu crossover drama, and having incredibly meta conversations about the nature of being on reality television.
In this podcast episode, we get into as much of the season’s drama as we can, including Taylor and Demi’s showdown, Zac’s attempts at redemption, and the final bombshell accusations that are thrown Jessi’s way. We also dig into some of the post-show drama. (Will MomTok survive this???)
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
The technofuturists want it. The evangelicals want it. The creepy manosphere dudes want it. The current iteration of the American right wing may be an odd and sometimes contradictory coalition, but there’s at least one thing they all unite around: More babies.
President Trump has dubbed himself “the fertilization president,” while his vice president, J.D. Vance, notoriously has bemoaned “childless cat ladies” as a social ill and suggested that people with children should get more votes. Elon Musk has fathered at least 14 children as part of an ideologically driven quest to save civilization with his “legion” of offspring. The Trump White House has considered a number of proposals for boosting the birth rate, including a motherhood medal for women who have six or more children.
Meanwhile, pronatalist influencers like the noxious Simone and Malcolm Collins are flocking to the predominantly white, male, and conservative Natal Conference to advance the cause and draw attention to what they deem a population crisis.
What exactly is going on here? Why has the right suddenly become obsessed with birth rates, and what policies will they push to achieve their fertility goals? Why are these so-called pro-family advocates utterly uninterested in policies that would both improve the lives of parents and children and potentially raise birth rates, like universal free childcare? And how has the left responded to this renewed breeding obsession? After months of reading and raging about these questions, we decided we needed to talk it out. In this podcast, we try to follow all of these threads — and, to be transparent, we also vented a lot of sputtering fury.
Below, we’ve compiled a list of articles we read prior to this conversation, many of which are cited in the podcast. Gently poach your brain in a pronatalism soup, if you will! Sarah Jones’s essays for New York Mag are particularly illuminating on the historical context and dark undercurrents of the right wing’s fertility fever.
Hope you enjoy! xo
“America’s premier pronatalists on having ‘tons of kids’ to save the world: ‘There are going to be countries of old people starving to death,’” by Jenny Kleeman, The Guardian
“Pronatalism explained: Why tech titans like Elon Musk want to have tons of kids to save the world,” by Julia Black, Business Insider
“Meet the ‘elite’ couples breeding to save mankind,” by Io Dodds, The Telegraph
“The Women Who Think the World Needs More Babies,” by Emma Goldberg, The New York Times
“The Pro-Baby Coalition of the Far Right,” by Elizabeth Bruenig, The Atlantic
“They say they want Americans to have more babies. What's beneath the surface?” by Lisa Hagen, NPR
“What's behind the 'pronatalist' movement to boost the birth rate?” by Tonya Mosley, NPR’s Fresh Air
“White House Assesses Ways to Persuade Women to Have More Children,” by Caroline Kitchener, The New York Times
“So you want to increase your country’s birth rate? Experts say it’s tough,” by Vivian Hoang and Hannah Graberstein, PBS News
“A Nobel Prize winner decodes why people aren’t having kids,” by Heather Long, The Washington Post
“The rise of pronatalism: why Musk, Vance and the right want women to have more babies,” Carter Sherman, The Guardian
“There’s Nothing New About Pronatalism,” by Sarah Jones, New York Magazine
“Why the Left Should Embrace Pronatalism,” by Elizabeth Bruenig, The Atlantic
“Don’t Have Children,” by Kate Manne, More to Hate
“Pronatalism Isn’t a Solution, It’s a Problem,” by Sarah Jones, New York Magazine
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
We’re back with another chat about “The Valley,” one of the darkest and most compelling reality shows on TV. And our main takeaway from episodes 2-4? Ban the boys chat.
A whole lot happens during this stretch of episodes, all of which we get into on this week’s subscriber podcast.
Jax, still playing the victim even as he verbally assaults his soon-to-be ex-wife Brittany, heads off to a mental health treatment center. And once he’s there, does he put his head down and focus on getting the help he needs? Of course not! Instead he focuses on rage-texting Brittany around the clock.
Janet and and Zack seem to reach a detente, as do Janet and Kristen. And we learn one of the most endearing facts about Janet to date: She absolutely fucking loves Dave & Busters.
Jesse starts a rumor on an extremely rancid “boys chat” thread — truly anyone who would participate in a group chat started by Jax Taylor, straight to jail — that his soon-to-be ex-wife Michelle is a sex worker who is sleeping with a billionaire for $1500 a night. This is relayed to camera by Danny to Luke, and obviously it gets back to Michelle in the middle of Janet’s Dave & Busters birthday bash. No one in the group seems to give the rumor any credence, but it (understandably) deeply hurts Michelle.
We learn that a few months before filming Danny got blacked out and got deeply inappropriately handsy with Melissa, Jasmine’s girlfriend. (Yikes!)
The gang heads off to a weird vibes trip to Santa Barbara, spearheaded by Jesse and co-planned by Kristen. (A truly dark-sided alliance, these two.) It’s filled with races, New Age spiritual ceremonies, and, of course, man-baby meltdowns.
Let us know how you’re liking our coverage of “The Valley”! Are there other Bravo shows you’d like us to dip our toes into?
If you liked reading this, click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Patreon!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription