TopPodcast.com
Menu
  • Home
  • Top Charts
  • Top Networks
  • Top Apps
  • Top Independents
  • Top Podfluencers
  • Top Picks
    • Top Business Podcasts
    • Top True Crime Podcasts
    • Top Finance Podcasts
    • Top Comedy Podcasts
    • Top Music Podcasts
    • Top Womens Podcasts
    • Top Kids Podcasts
    • Top Sports Podcasts
    • Top News Podcasts
    • Top Tech Podcasts
    • Top Crypto Podcasts
    • Top Entrepreneurial Podcasts
    • Top Fantasy Sports Podcasts
    • Top Political Podcasts
    • Top Science Podcasts
    • Top Self Help Podcasts
    • Top Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Top Stocks Podcasts
  • Podcast News
  • About Us
  • Podcast Advertising
  • Contact
Not in our directory?
Add Show Here
Podcast Equipment
Center

toppodcastlogoOur TOPPODCAST Picks

  • Comedy
  • Crypto
  • Sports
  • News
  • Politics
  • True Crime
  • Business
  • Finance

Follow Us

toppodcastlogoStay Connected

    View Top 200 Chart
    Back to Rankings Page
    Government

    Public Procurement Podcast –

    Podcast bringing public procurement issues to a lay audience. Interviews by Dr. Pedro Telles

    Advertise
    • Apple Podcasts
    • Google Play
    • Spotify

    Latest Episodes:
    #3 - Frank Brunetta (Canadian Procurement Ombudsman) Jun 11, 2015
    Show notes

    What can we learn from Canada's experience with a Procurement Ombudsman? Interview with Frank Brunetta, Procurement Ombudsman for Canada. The remit of the Ombudsman is to promote fairness, openness and transparency in federal public procurement. Before joining the office of the procurement ombudsman Frank was Assistant Deputy Minister of the departmental oversight branch, public works and government services in Canada, where his responsibilities included provided independent assurance and oversight on the prudent, probity and transparency of departmental operations. iTunesTranscriptI would like to start our interview by discussing the role of the office, namely how it came about and what are the powers that are contained in the Office of the Procurement Ombudsman.The creation of the office primarily came through a procurement scandal that we’ve referred to as the sponsorship scandal, and this is a procurement issue that was conducted under the former government, the Liberal government where procurement rules were severely breached. The Conservatives seized on that opportunity, the Liberal government fell, the Conservatives came into power with part of their platform being to clean up public procurement, they passed, one of their first tasks after being in power was to pass the Federal Accountability Act, within the Federal Accountability Act there was a provision for the creation of a procurement ombudsman who would in some form oversee public procurement.As I understand it the original concept was for a procurement auditor and as the bill passed through the two houses of parliament the decision was made to make the office not a procurement auditor but a procurement ombudsman. So primary impetus for creating the office really was a very severe scandal where public funds were misdirected, if you do any research on it you’ll see that there were charges laid, people went to jail for it, etc, so the Conservative government created the office and it was through an amendment to the Department of Public Works and Services Act, so they amended the Act to make provisions for this office and then regulations were generated which essentially give the office four primary mandates, one is to review complaints with respect to the award of a contract for the acquisition of goods below 25,000 Canadian dollars, and services below 100,000 Canadian dollars including taxes.The second is to review complaints with respect to the administration of a contract, regardless of dollar value, the third element of our mandate is to review the practices of departments for acquiring goods or services to assess their fairness, openness and transparency and make necessary recommendations to improve those practices. This element is a bit of a holdover from the procurement auditor role that I alluded to earlier and then finally the fourth element of our mandate is to ensure that an alternative dispute resolution process is provided if requested and agreed to by both parties to a federal contract. There is a fifth that is contained but has yet to be invoked with the minister or the governing council can ask the Procurement Ombudsman to undertake a review as they see fit, so for example if there’s another procurement scandal I am, or this office is one of the options for them to review how that procurement was conducted. So those are the five elements, but the four primary ones are the ones that I referred to, if you have complaints for the award of a contract between certain dollar thresholds or under certain dollar thresholds, review of complaints on the administration of a contract and that has no dollar thresholds, the procurement practice of departments and I can get into that a little bit, how that’s done, and then ensure the ADR, Alternative Dispute Resolution process is in place. So in terms of the review of government procurement practices, we do a couple of things to determine what areas we might want to review there Pedro, our office operates very much like a complaints office that you’d have in any major corporation, so we have a 1-800 line, we have a website, where suppliers can contact us to tell us about issues that they may be having regarding a department, a particular process or a procurement vehicle. We track those calls and the nature of the calls, we do different types of analysis, we try to determine whether a particular department is a constant source of irritation for suppliers, whether a particular process has been a particular problem, or whether there’s some sort of a pattern that can be established with a particular procurement vehicle. We do that because the regulations require me to have reasonable grounds to undertake a procurement practice review, if I can establish reasonable grounds then I can go into a department or to several departments to review that practice, to see whether there is in fact compliance with the appropriate rules and regulations and to ensure that whatever is being done in terms of procurement is fair, open and transparent. That’s essentially my mandate.Could you describe a little bit more what economic operators that take part on the contracts that are covered by your mandate, what can they expect from your intervention for a contract that has been awarded.That’s the first element of my mandate which is reviewing the award of a contract below 25,000 Canadian dollars for goods, and below 100,000 dollars including taxes for services, so if I can give you an example, a supplier may be responding to a request for a proposal by a department, he or she submits a proposal and sometime after that submission is notified by the department that the proposal has not been accepted, typically in Canada departments provide a reason for the proposal not to be accepted. If the supplier is unclear or does not agree with that reason or alternatively if he feels that there’s been some sort of inappropriate approach used to award the contract to the winning bidder, or to exclude his or her bid, they can call my office and the first thing we do, because we are after all an ombudsman’s office, we try to understand the issue, get some sense as to what happened, how it happened and then to be quite honest with you Pedro, and I would say 90% of the times when we explain the process to the supplier the supplier has a better understanding of why the department did what they did, and we were able to... we call it dispose of the matter, what we find Pedro, since the office opened is in the vast majority of cases a supplier will call our office with the intent of complaining but the issue is based on a misunderstanding of how the federal procurement process works. A lot of suppliers believe that doing business with the Canadian government is like doing business amongst themselves, they don’t understand it, certain rules that have to be followed, doing business with the Canadian government isn’t as simple as my father used to when he was a contractor, it was a handshake, some suppliers still believe that’s the case, so when we explain the process a lot of these complaints are dealt with through information exchange.One thing that I pointed out in one of my annual reports to parliament, I think it was last years was that what I found is that it’s often not the information in itself that is satisfying the supplier, it’s who it is coming from, because in a lot of cases the supplier will have called the department and received a very reasonable explanation from the department, but they don’t accept it, the supplier does not accept it. On the other hand they call our office, we give them essentially the same information but because it’s coming from an independent neutral third party, an office that has no vested interest in the procurement process, they seem to accept it much more openly, and that’s perhaps a point I should have made when it came to my mandate, my office is an independent office, we’re not beholden to any government department, any agency, while I report to the Minister of Public Works, the Minister has no influence and no say in the work that I do, the areas that I review, or how I review them, so we really are independent and arm’s length from the government operation. That seems to be a big bonus and attraction for suppliers, to know that they’re coming to an office that isn’t attached to any government operation.Do you have any idea about the figures of complaints you get every year or have you gotten since the start of the office?I'm in the process of preparing my annual report to parliament, so those numbers are pretty fresh. Last year we received 577 contacts, now I have to stress the word contact, because we often get calls that have nothing to do with procurement, so we track every call that we receive, any contact that we receive, last year was 577, and since my appointment four years ago that number has steadily increased, I believe it’s roughly 70% higher, 577 is 70% higher than it was the first year I took office, and a large reason for that is one of my primary objectives when I took office was to ensure that the suppliers knew this office existed, keep in mind that we’ve only been operational since 2008, so one of the big challenges for the office was to promote our services, so the increase, the 70% increase in the four years isn’t because procurement is somehow getting worse, it’s because more suppliers know we exist. Now of the 577 if I can boil it down to how many we actually investigated, so reviewing of complaints as per the first element of our mandate, reviewing complaints for the award of a contract below 25,000 for goods and 100,000 for services, last year we investigated three and that’s a startling contrast given the number of contacts we have, but let me explain to you that we are after all an ombudsman office and our primary objective is to de-escalate issues, I once said to a parliamentary committee that my objective is to do no investigations. I mean that’s ludicrous, but really our objective is to try to deal with things informally, that’s the role of an ombudsman’s office, so when you look at the contrasting numbers of 577 and three investigations, while a lot of those numbers, a lot of the 577 have to do with suppliers simply calling us to find out how things are supposed to work and whether in their particular circumstances it worked the way it should have. I believe that the number is about 170 of the 577 were suppliers calling with what they felt should be a complaint and that was through the process of information exchange, facilitation that my office provides between the supplier and the department, that we were able to de-escalate those numbers and only have to deal with three actual reviews or investigations, so while the mandate sounds like I have pretty strong powers to investigate, I keep in mind that the role of an ombudsman is to deal with things informally, and try to facilitate informal resolution issues and that’s really the principle that dictates our approach as an office.And regarding any disputes on the administration or performance of the contracts, what is your role on those, what can you provide to the parties?Well again there are two elements to that nature of complaint, if there is a complaint with respect to the administration of a contract, as I said initially there is no dollar value on the administration, the truth of the matter is most complaints with regards to the administration of a contract are because the holder of the contracts, or supplier who is engaged in a contractual arrangement with a department is having some sort of a disagreement with the department, so in the vast majority of cases we do not investigate that complaint, what we offer is alternative dispute resolution which is the fourth element of my mandate, so a supplier will come in and say, “Well I don’t agree with the way the department is administering this contract, or their interpretation of the terms and conditions of this contract, can you help?” once that request is made the regulations require me, I have no discretion, the regulations require me if that request is made to approach the other party to the contract which is the department, and offer alternative dispute resolution and in these cases we would essentially mediate the dispute. And on that business line or that element of our mandate the office has a sparkling record of 100% of the cases being resolved, what we find and it’s not any different than any other type of alternative dispute resolution, by the time one of the parties of the contract contacts our office, the lines of communications have broken down to the point where the two parties aren’t talking, so our task is, I hate to minimise it, but it’s fairly easy. We get the parties to sit across from a table again, and try to reinvigorate that dialogue, that should never have broken down, once they start talking and they start understanding each other’s position and we orchestrate the session so that it allows both sides to outline their views and their position, what we find without exception of people start to understand the other party’s perspective, and inevitably must be human nature, they try to find a mutually acceptable solution, and once that happens that agreement they arrive at becomes legally binding, so we have them sign a legally binding agreement and that’s how that issue is resolved.How many ADR cases have you had since 2008?Well that’s... I mentioned earlier one of the challenges was to ensure that suppliers knew we existed, that seems to be working with an increase of 74%, the ADR continues to be a challenge, we have had 13 cases since 2008 and we have done a considerable amount of outreach advertising, I can’t conclude on why the uptake on that service isn’t what we expected it to be but it could be that a lot of these disputes are being resolved through dialogue without our assistance, we know that in some cases some departments have their own ADR processes, we know that in some cases some departments include litigation clauses in the contracts that preclude a supplier from coming to see us.Is that legal?Yeah, the contract... every department has the discretion to include what they feel is appropriate for their operational requirements and their contracts. Now we were successful last year in having the vast majority of departments include clauses in the contracts that make suppliers aware that if there’s a dispute they can come to our office and we have started to see this year a number of suppliers that have contacted us who have become aware of the office through that clause, when I started in the office in 2008 I realised one of the biggest challenges was letting the suppliers know we existed and one of the things that I did last year was to ask department so put that clause in contracts, and in tracking the calls that we get from suppliers, one of the questions that asked is how did you hear about us and we’re starting to see a number of suppliers saying they heard about us through the clause in the contract.That’s very interesting. Could you give us an idea about what is the cost of running an office like the Procurement Ombudsman?Okay, depending on our workload and the typical transition that you have with staff, it fluctuates between 25 and 30 staff and we run on a budget of 2.8 million Canadian dollars, so it’s a fairly lean operation, now the Treasury Board submission that created our office has a provision that allows the ombudsman to return to the Treasury for additional resources if the original forecasted number of complaints increases, that threshold hasn’t been crossed yet so we haven’t gone back to the Treasury for additional resources, 2.5 to 2.8 seems to be a good number given the volume that we currently have.Is that a yearly figure or a monthly figure?No, that’s an annual.I have a couple of questions to finish the interview. In the EU last year we introduced new substantive regulations, so the…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    #2 - Claire Methven O'Brien (Danish Institute of Human Rights) Jun 05, 2015
    Show notes

    How can public procurement ensure that Human Rights are complied with? Dr. Claire Methven O’Brien from the Danish Institute for Human Rights is the second interviewee of the PPP. Claire is an expert in human rights law, particularly human rights and business. Claire has a long experience both across Europe, and in developing countries, dealing with multi-national enterprises, governmental and human rights bodies, and civil society. She is also a Research Fellow at the University of Groningen Department of International Law and a member of the International Law Association Working Group on Business and Human Rights.The topic of our talk today was the intersection of human rights and public procurement and how the first should influence the second. Links for papers/research discussed in the podcast available after the transcript. iTunesTranscriptIt’s great to have you here with us today and I would like to start the conversation by getting you to talk about your big idea or argument in a nutshell.Thank you. Well human rights are of course a big idea, you might say the big idea of the 20th century and what we have seen over the course of the 20th century and…21st is the gradual extension of the application of human rights, not just to the state but now also increasingly with a view to securing the accountability of non-state actors and in particular the private sector to human rights standards. Of course globalisation and the rise of multinational enterprises, and increasing liberalisation, which has made that possible, have brought with it changes in the nature of production and the way in which production affects human individuals and communities.Unfortunately, a lot of the time those impacts have not all been positive, and what has been very well publicised in recent decades are negative environmental effects of multinational activity but also negative impacts on labour conditions, working conditions, particularly in developing countries, in a variety of ways. The United Nations have sought for quite a number of years to generate standards which would be able to express the application of human rights norms to the private sector. Eventually in 2011, the [UN] Human Rights Council endorsed a set of Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights which affirm that states have got a responsibility to regulate the private sector in order that negative impacts on human rights are avoided, that private companies themselves have got a responsibility to respect human rights, and that also thereby, whoever’s a victim of human rights impacts or abuses perpetrated by or associated with businesses have a right to mediation and remedy for those.And a part of those Guiding Principles focuses on public procurement. Guiding Principles 5 and 6, in particular, highlight the need for the state, as part of its general duty of protecting and promoting human rights, to make sure that, in relation to the delivery of public services by the private sector human rights are protected, and also in any commercial transactions that the state engages in. And this obviously entails the extension to the private sector [with whom the government contracts], to ensure that human rights are also protected…[which] you could expect… in line with the general push towards ensuring that private companies in their global supply chains ensure that human rights are protected.So we can see if you like that the time appears to have come for public procurement laws and regulations - which have historically often been perceived, and sometimes in practice have also been applied, to restrict the state’s possibilities for introducing terms which are designed to protect human rights, we’ve seen that you know in terms of the general issue of sustainability in public procurement and also initiatives around fairer trade - the time has come for that interpretation of public procurement law to be scrutinised to a much greater extent than has been true previously, and to be aligned now with the requirements of human rights norms, [as]…fundamental norms which ought to define the rule of law for any state…[and which in] many countries are also part of the constitutional order.I would start with the end, as you said correctly, in many states human rights are a part of the constitutional order but a part of the constitutional order up to a certain extent. Now the interesting point, as you mentioned literally at the start, is that there has been a gradual expansion and extension of the concept of human rights over the last 50 or 70 years and one of the queries I have is how can we match for example the importance or relevance, let’s say, of the first generation kind of human rights, right to life, right to privacy, rights to private property and so on, which more recently the evolutions of the concept of human rights because I mean public procurement law has nothing to say that you cannot respect human life for example in terms of, or the conception as a human right, but what is now sometimes conceived as human rights on a more modern or contemporaneous interpretation those ideas.I suppose in answer to that I would say that there is less and less support within human rights law and human rights circles for the view according to which you can distinguish “waves” or “generations” of human rights which have different weight, which have a different place in the normative order…[H]istorically, according to peoples’ political preferences, civil and political or economic and social rights were emphasised, and there are still jurisdictions in which distinctions are made between those and they are given effect to in different ways through constitutional law.On the other hand, in newer constitutions you can see, and in some countries with older constitutions in different ways, you can see the significance of that distinction between civil, political, economic, social and of course including labour rights in the economic and social, that distinction beginning to be dissolved. And, you know, you can look towards for instance, I mean not to digress too much, but you can see in the area of human rights impact assessment which is a discipline being increasingly applied to evaluate laws and policies at the regional level in the EU, in national jurisdictions, those kinds of exercises will include economic and social along with civil and political rights. In the area of human rights based budgeting or participatory budgeting exercises… to focus in on those, will be all human rights and certainly in the jurisprudence of bodies at the UN and… the general output of the UN human rights system you will see, increasingly, less distinction between those categories that you’ve mentioned, so that it’s a more holistic approach that is being applied and adopted by I think most bodies today so it becomes harder to maintain in the public procurement context that as, you know, a distinction.I think that is the crux of the problem, when you say that there is a more modern holistic approach to the interpretation of the, or the concept of should constitute human rights and that we should not distinguish between different kinds of human rights or waves the fact is, the examples that you’ve given other than the ones that are received directly in the constitutions, for example, in the European Charter of Human Rights, all those other human rights are based in soft law. So the example that you use at the start, for example, of the guiding principles that were put out by the Human Rights Council of the UN they constitute an example of soft law.That’s correct but that’s another binary, the hard and soft law distinction, of course is a binary one which quite a lot of scholars, political scientists, have questioned the utility of, in understanding what actually has the effect of producing changes in society. The Guiding Principles [on Business and Human Rights], albeit technically a soft law standard, have been remarkable, in a short space of time, in what they have achieved, in terms of triggering action at the international level but also at the national level. So the European Commission, in its 2011 Communication on Corporate Social Responsibility called on EU Member States to develop national action plans on business and human rights with reference to the UN Guiding Principles [on Business and Human Rights], and subsequently already a number of Member States have produced national action plans on business and human rights, all of which, I should say, [of those] that have been published mention public procurement and the need at the national level to either undertake reviews of the extent to which existing measures ensure respect for human rights in the course of public contracting or similar measures.At the international level, the OECD has aligned its Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises with the UN Guiding Principles [on Business and Human Rights] so that the OECD Guidelines now include reference to human rights and when, at the national level again, National Contact Points under the OECD Guidelines receive complaints about the conduct of businesses based in the OECD abroad, again those National Contact Points are now called on to determine those complaints or to facilitate the mediation of those kinds of complaints with reference to the UN Guiding Principles essentially. Just in terms of the practices that we see evolving and emerging amongst public authorities and central government, you can see that notwithstanding their status as a soft law standard, the Guiding Principles have actually had a lot of significant effects already.Going back to the fact that EU Commission put out a CSR policy or communication document in 2011 and some member states have created national action plans, again we are in the realm of soft law. It is not a decision by the European Commission, nor a Regulation, or a Directive and certainly not a part of the Treaties, so again, this is an idea that tries to help to nudge member states in a certain direction but the litmus test here is that if Member States do not comply with that communication, nothing will happen to them.Well, I completely agree with you on that, the litmus test is of course whether at national level, or indeed at the regional of the EU, the policy commitments made to human rights are internalised, through the adoption of specific laws on whatever subject which are aligned to the ambitions and commitments contained in human right standards. And in that respect, certainly the recent procurement Directives have been disappointing. While the Commission maintains that the new Directives provide ample scope to allow public authorities in the EU to undertake procurement practice which does comply with the [UN] Guiding Principles, my assessment is that, in technical terms, the changes that have been made are narrow, they’re narrow in as much as they refer actually only to Core Labour Standards… so the rights protected by the ILO’s Core Labour Standards, forced labour, child labour, discrimination and some trade union rights, but in practical terms the [European] Commission has not done anything to suggest they’re going to follow through in promoting awareness of the commitments of the EU to the Guiding Principles and to ensuring respect for human rights… in procurement, in relation to the transposition of the Directives or really in any way, [such as] undertaking activities to support public authorities within EU member states to understand what the significance of human rights might be in the procurement context.And there’s a lot of things that the Commission or public authorities, procurement authorities at the national level, can do to help purchasing authorities begin to get on the human rights train if you like or to begin that journey, because none of us on the human rights side who’ve been looking at public procurement would say that it’s a simple or straightforward matter to advance human rights in procurement while also, at the same time, respecting the other legal obligations on public authorities flowing from public procurement law and in other areas. It’s not going to be easy because, as I said at the beginning, historically there has been a both real and perceived conflict between public authorities obligations to ensure that they take action to ensure that procurement respects human rights, that companies they contract with respect human rights while meeting their other obligations.Could you provide us an example of how member states and contracting authorities should work together to develop more human rights friendly or human rights compliance policies in procurement.Maybe I can start by illustrating a couple [of examples], since we haven’t touched on it already, just some of the human rights issues that are arising in the context of public procurement in case [your listeners] are not familiar with those. Just to give a few examples, focusing on the more egregious examples, these are in fact some cases… taken from a report by the International Corporate Accountability Round Table, ICAR, on public procurement and human rights called ‘Turning a Blind Eye, Respecting Human Rights in Government Purchasing’, which of course is [available to listeners] on the internet:The insignia, for instance, of US military services were found in the rubble of a factory fire that recently killed workers in Bangladesh. The Danish government has also been reported to order military uniforms from an Export Processing Zone, in fact also in Bangladesh, where trade unions are prohibited. Plastic gloves, procured by the public…healthcare sector in Denmark have also been documented to contain rubber from plantations which rely on forced labour, and a US government contractor transported Nepalese construction workers from their home country into Iraq, which was at that time a combat zone, and while on route their convey was attacked by insurgents who executed them and posted their deaths on the internet. So you can see…just in relation to procurement of goods, there is quite a wide range of serious human rights abuses that can be associated with procurement. And also in the area of public services, particularly I have familiarity with the UK, there have been various reports produced by the National Human Rights Institutions in the UK, by the Parliamentary Human Rights Committee, and of course by NGOs, on the lack of respect for human rights and dignity in the private delivery of health and social care for the elderly or other people, persons with disabilities or other people who need personalised care.So in that context there’s all kinds of ways in which elderly, vulnerable people who are dependent on the state taking due action to look after them and ensure their human rights are respected have actually been totally let down and either…the framework terms of contracts, or the monitoring provided for, or indeed the price paid for those kinds of services has been inadequate to ensure that an appropriate standard of care is delivered.This final example is more of an issue not with the procurement processing itself but the actual outcome, the actual service that is being procured that does not respect the human rights of the users or beneficiaries.It’s not always clear cut that that’s the case, and in fact the Scottish Human Rights Commission collaborated in recent years with the Scottish government in relation to the review of the whole contracting process in relation to those kinds of services that we’ve just been discussing, to look at in what ways the process of commissioning of care can be changed in order that human rights are integrated right from the beginning of that process. So we don’t want to be in a position where we’re trying to close the door after the horse has bolted, it’s really a question of ensuring right “from the get go”, from the design of the terms of tenders, of framework contracts, that human rights are being adequately considered.Similarly…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    #1 - Albert Sanchez-Graells (Leicester University) May 18, 2015
    Show notes

    How did England, Wales and Northern Ireland transpose Directive 2014/24/EU? We are starting the series with a conversation with Dr. Albert Sanchez Graells, Senior Lecturer at the University of Leicester and who undertook his Ph.D at Universidad Autonoma de Madrid. His excellent Ph.D thesis was adapted to the Public Procurement and the EU Competition Rules, published by Hart in 2011 and with a second edition just launched. It is fair to say that Albert almost singlehandedly put the importance of competition as a procurement principle squarely in the agenda. He blogs daily about procurement at howtocrackanut.blogspot.com. iTunesTranscript Thank you for having you on the show. So we’re going to be talking about directives 2014/24. It has been transposed already into the UK or at least to England and Wales and in fact this is the first transposition of the directive. What is your view, in general terms, about the transposition?Well I think that the UK government, particularly the one with responsibility for English and Welsh procurement was very keen on starting taking advantage of certain provisions or derivations that they negotiated for. My impression is that the reform of the provision of public services and the special regime in Article 74-77, in particular 77 which supports the mutualisation of the NHS or education institutions is probably the main driver for such a big transposition.What are the advantages and disadvantages that you see so far in this quick transposition?Well I guess that the main advantage of the quick transposition is that, as I was saying, all contracting authorities can immediately take advantage of the more flexible approach, the negotiations to life-cycle costing when it comes to award of contracts and other advantages, as well as probably pre-empting having to transpose as well certain policies that the European Commission may be willing to develop on the back of the directives and I think that in that way the UK probably is pre-empting in this sort of gold-plating in the transposition there is always a very big political issue in the UK.When it comes to disadvantages I think that the biggest problem is that obviously there has not been much time to think about what needed to be changed and what the legislator basically did is adapt the whole of the directives as they are without probably strategically thinking about what parts to leave out, what parts to regulate in more detail or also without waiting for some clarification as to what the new requirements exactly mean or imply, so in that regard the disadvantage is that the poor quality of the directives and I think it’s a common understanding that the directives are poorly drafted and sometimes poorly thought through, has been immediately accepted and transposed into English and Welsh procurement rules which probably will have to change in the future just to make them a bit more sensible.Are you effectively saying that, okay, we’re getting the rules quite quickly, the transposition quite quickly but the trade-off is A, most of the mistakes or the kinks that needed to be ironed out from the directive have not been ironed out and B, we may have to actually have a new transposition or at least have a new set of regulations in the future that solves those small problems?Yes, I think you’re totally right, I think that the biggest problem, for instance, is when it comes to the new procedures that we have been commenting and think about the innovation partnership or the competitive dialogue, we have very bare minimum rules in the directives as to how this procedure’s going to be conducted by the member states and I think that in that regard there is a gap and I would not like to be in the feet of contracting authority in the UK that tries to implement a competitive dialogue or an innovation partnership solely on the basis of the rules they have right now in the Public Contracts Regulations 2015 because there’s more uncertainty than clarity.I would think that for the regulations to be actually useful, either you need additional layers of directions or guidelines from the current commercial service or you need effectively a second wave of reform which brings detail to the very generic rules that the transposition has reached so far.But the fact is the transposition style is fairly similar to the one that was adopted about ten years ago when the UK transposed the directive 2004/18. In fact if you look at the Public Contracts Regulations 2015 and 2006 side-by-side, they pretty much follow the same structure in relationship with the original directives. Contracting authorities were still able to use those Public Contract Regulations over the last ten years so how can we actually argue that more detailed regulations were needed instead of just the copy out approach that was taken?Well I think that back in 2004 we had the office for Government Contracts and when the new directives were adopted in 2004 and the transposition took place in the UK in 2006, it was very active in providing guidance. The second point which probably is a bit less clear, it may just be my personal opinion but the fact that in the UK, at least in England, the procurement profession is highly regulated and we have institutions like CIPS imparting mandatory training for people taking on procurement roles, they also cover some of those gaps and I think that that triggers all sorts of issues about the difficulty of imposing rules that are not written anywhere but just come from some common training or understanding of the profession. I think also it may result in many situations being sorted out outside of strong legal process or enforcement and this may be linked to the UK culture of litigation but I think that the transposition technique and the limited scope of the rules also have to do with the limited number of procurement challenges that reach the courts, simply because these appointed bidders, they’re not exactly what the contracting authorities have applied beyond what’s on the regulation and the rules and the regulation are sufficiently abstract or lack in detail that probably courts may tend to side with the contracting authorities, so overall I’m not sure whether it’s positive or negative, what I would say is that it’s a very different game from the one we would expect in Latin countries or in civil law based countries, well when it comes to transportation which basically take an approach that is different and they just regulate to the most minute detail and sometimes with strict formalities and so I guess it’s an interesting case of comparative approach to transposition. Speaking about the transposition as it is, what do you think are the biggest mistakes that the central government in UK has actually introduced with transposition? Well I think that the biggest mistakes come from taking directives as they are and not restricting procedures that they may have wanted to restrict. In terms of procedures I think that just assuming and critically the openness, the negotiations and hoping three procedures that effectively allow for initiations as the competitive procedure with negotiations, the competitive dialogue and innovation partnership is not necessarily advantageous, particularly when at least the innovation partnership is, I would think, optional.So I think that that multiplies legal uncertainty and it probably gives the false impression that negotiations are free for all, which I’m not sure is the medium term interpretation of the directive, at least when the UK Commission starts talking about what the member states have done. The other thing is think about frameworks and how intensive frameworks have been used in the UK, I think that not having reviewed some of the options within the directive or at least not having set out fully a default framework agreement and the procedure for its award and now the restricted procedure rules, it’s a bit difficult to implement so I think that some of the contracting authorities on the ground will have difficulty trying to decide whether they can carry on doing things as they used to or whether they actually need to implement changes and I don’t think that the regulations will give them lots of guidance and I think that’s a mistake.Another mistake obviously from my perspective and I know you said we didn’t speak about competition but I cannot avoid it! Not having thought through how to implement Article 18 of the directive, which is now Regulation 18 on general principles and I think that it’s quite foreign to the common law to have general principles, particularly when it comes to public law, without having a policy that backs them up and I think that probably now having adopted this very open-ended and lacking detail regulations can make life difficult in practice so I guess it would just be a transitory period but for a while maybe contracting authorities would refrain from implementing new things, just waiting and seeing how others do it or what they can learn from.Let me stop you there on the negotiation and frameworks before I go back to the competition. The fact is the UK has always been very pro negotiations employer procurement, if you think about the practice in the country over the last decade of the 20th Century, in the 1990s and also before the creation of Directive 2018 and the competitive dialogue inside it, the UK was using effectively negotiated procedure almost as a standard procedure for PFI contracts. Mm.That’s one example, so the country has always been very pro negotiations, I’m not saying that I agree with this, I’m just saying that actually there’s a lot of experience in at least a few contracting authorities in doing public procurement with negotiations. The same thing with frameworks, the UK is actually the country in the EU that has used frameworks more often over the last ten years or so, in fact I was looking at the numbers a few months ago and I think they’ve used it more than a thousand times, which is a lot more than anyone else.On the issue of frameworks, I think it’s true the UK has probably been leading on the adoption of frameworks but what I struggle to understand is why there’s this such strong preference for frameworks over dynamic purchasing systems and one of the explanations could be that dynamic purchasing systems used to come with the not so nice add-on that they had to tendered through the open procedure but none of this has changed, I would have expected switched or almost an immediate substitution between frameworks and dynamic purchasing systems because it’s true that in the UK value for money, as a domestic issue at least, is always quite highly ranking in the set of goals that contracting authorities need to achieve and I would expect that a dynamic purchasing system that is always open, always allows for the maverick, for the innovator to show up and offer something new or at a better price, would be a much more desirable system so I struggle to see why they didn’t think about this more strategically in trying to push for dynamic purchasing systems further than they have as far as I can see.Do you think that may happen?I think it will happen for some reasons but one of the reasons is that if we look at the provision on the catalogues and the auctions, it is true that they work for both frameworks and dynamic purchasing systems but they work much better for dynamic purchasing systems because it makes no sense to have a catalogue that only includes the products of the suppliers you selected three years ago. I think that once you have the technology in place to actually be harvesting information from these catalogues automatically you would like these catalogues to be as broad as possible, also because the cost of putting one more catalogue into the system is relatively low I would expect, so I think that they will soon realise that dynamic purchasing systems maximise the electronic procurement related tools much more than frameworks so I would expect the substitution to take place say in the next three years, once the transition to eProcurement is further consolidated and in fact the rule. To go back to your point on negotiations, I think that all the examples you mentioned about negotiations basically are for large scale project. Uh huh, I agree. And I think it’s linked to the fact that for large scale projects in the UK contracting authorities have no problem engaging external consultants and experts, including lawyers and economists and they’re happy to pay those extra fees for the services that come with the PFI or with the bigger projects just because they know that in the long-run, hopefully with the aid of the experts, they will get a better deal than if they were doing things differently. I think that the problem now with negotiations is that now you can negotiate basically for anything and I think we have both discussed this at length, I really like your paper with Luke Butler from last year and it’s very clear that the grounds for resorting to negotiations are way too broad, basically contracting authority would simply say it was not possible to award without negotiating and hence they negotiate which is a circular test and this completely changes the game because it’s not trying to talk one-to-one to big suppliers or big players in the market using knowledge and expertise that we either have or we acquire as contracting authorities, now it’s going to be any contracting authority with or without any knowledge negotiating with any supplier of any size and I think that once the issues of oversight appear and unfortunately at some point they will appear, the negotiated procedure will be demonised and that’s...I know it’s maybe a gloomy forecast but I think that at some point, as we have seen in many other jurisdictions, there’s going to be some issue of corruption or favouritism into negotiation and this can actually kill the tool for everyone so again I think that precisely protecting the developments that procedures with negotiation have made in the UK it would have been wise to limit them beyond what the directive does and I think that would be perfectly possible because the grounds in Article 26 are basically to resort to a procedure that is exceptional so further reducing them would be in compliance with EU law, in my view.I would argue that those three procedures, competitive dialogue, competitive procedures negotiation and innovation partnership, those three Ls say that they’re special in nature and not exceptional because they can be used as almost standard procedures for specific grounds but not all the time but you’re making a very good point about negotiations and the excess of negotiations in public procurement. Going back to the regulations, what do they think is the problem that people are not paying enough attention to?If I have to pin one down I would think that the problem people are not paying attention to is that the bad wording of the directive and the badly organised information in the articles or directive have been altered in the regulations and the English and Welsh legislator has basically restructured the content and most of them, they don’t alter the legal content of the provisions but altering the order puts emphasis in different places and I think that the problem of doing that is that if contracting authorities don’t spend the time learning the whole of the regulations they make mistakes just because they apply partial rules because the second half of the rule you should be applying is elsewhere, particularly today thinking about Regulation 42, which I’m starting to read about technical specifications for our comments, I realise that one of the caveats that I love about the technical specifications article directive is that the technical specifications should not be drafted in a way that hinders or distorts competition or excludes any potential provider. Correct. This is something that naturally should appear in number, l…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Previous 1 2 3 4

    Related Podcasts

    Inside Strategic Coach: Connecting Entrepreneurs With What Really Matters

    1

    Inside Strategic Coach: Connecting Entrepreneurs With What Really Matters Business
    WSJ Your Money Briefing

    2

    WSJ Your Money Briefing Business
    FORTUNE Unfiltered with Aaron Task

    3

    FORTUNE Unfiltered with Aaron Task Business
    FORTUNE OnStage Presents: The Most Powerful Women

    4

    FORTUNE OnStage Presents: The Most Powerful Women Business
    Slate Money

    5

    Slate Money Business
    In The Dark – The New Yorker

    6

    In The Dark – The New Yorker Business News
    footer-logo

    Contact Us

    Toll Free: 844-670-7747

    Links

    • Home
    • Top Charts
    • Networks
    • Apps
    • Independents Podcasts
    • Podcast Advertising
    • Podcast News
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Analytics & Insights

    Stay Connected

      Privacy, Terms of Use & Our Code of Ethics Protecting Content Creators Copyrights