Show notes
What Would You Pack to Build a Civilization?
We have talked about empires before, from the ancient ones to the British, but nothing prepares you for the vastness of the Pacific Ocean. This was Polynesia, and we are looking at how people built a civilization and what they packed for it.
Someone, somewhere on one of those islands, decided to take a canoe out and explore. Finding another island, or two, or three. Later, someone said,
“Hey, our island is getting crowded; we need to make a new colony somewhere else."
You may have heard ancient stories about “an island” passed on as stories are. Perhaps someone was there before and returned with stories of another island that could be the future home. Complete with freshwater and fresh tropical drinks like a daiquiri.
Looking at those distances, even by today's standards, all I can think about is a long flight across the Pacific. The seats are uncomfortable, and the food isn’t particularly good. I’d hope for an upgrade that might give a little more legroom, and perhaps a meal that doesn’t come wrapped in plastic. Of course, I would hope the Wi-Fi works. Because someone on X is wrong.
The ancient Polynesians crossed this same ocean in canoes. Navigation before GPS (seriously, no Google Maps). Probably larger seats, and their Wi-Fi was the stars, the currents, and finding seabirds meant land and home.
Over centuries, voyagers reached those islands and settled them.
It is hard to imagine how extraordinary this is. My Western mind is blown to think that this is before Europeans crossed the pond.
The Polynesians didn’t just carry provisions for the voyage. They transported what they needed to settle an island. And the food was the constant.
They were bringing the means to make those places habitable. And that makes me think of another enormous frontier that humans are only beginning to explore. Space. The final frontier (where is Captain Kirk).
Their Pacific, Our Universe
“Space, the final frontier,” I was about ten when that TV show came out, and it was one of my favorites. “Boldly going where no man had gone before.”
For us to go to space, we either need to be a billionaire or a government. But for the people of the Pacific, they needed a few friends to build a boat. We have to have thousands of pounds of rocket fuel, lots of thrust just to escape Earth’s gravity and get into orbit. They needed a push from the beach, and they were on the ocean in their vessel.
Now comes the important question. What do we eat when we get there? This is a question NASA is still trying to answer. If you read The Martian, potatoes were the answer, and some of that came from the folks who used them.
Right now, the International Space Station receives regular deliveries of food from Earth; it was the first Instacart. I’ve had the pleasure of trying some of this food, and I must say I prefer it to American Airlines' fare.
If you are in a canoe, you can bring food along for a journey. If you inhabit a new island, you need to bring the plants to grow, the pigs, and whatever else to establish a colony. Same with Mars. On Star Trek, they had a machine that looked like a fancy vending machine, turn a button, and out came clam chowder. They avoided the messy background of how this got assembled, was it pre-made, or magically put together and transported like the transporter room that Bones McCoy hated to get in.
NASA has already experimented with growing lettuce, peppers, and other plants in space, using relatively little water and without conventional soil. Biosphere was an experiment done in the desert to see how people did in a version of space, just as barren, but still a windshield away from the real Earth. In that and many other experiments, NASA, as well as many of Earth’s engineers and farmers, work with plants to see what might work. Our friends in Polynesia had done those same experiments.
They didn’t have to create life-support systems on an uninhabitable planet. They were moving familiar food-producing organisms into unfamiliar environments.
You could eat a coconut and plant one. The time to plant a tree is 100 years ago; the next best time is now. Same with a yam and breadfruit. Bring some to eat, some to plant.
We think of space, and we don’t rely on just NASA. Biosphere was privately funded like SpaceX. In fact, I am writing this with help from those satellites now. We have lots of private financing, not specifically looking to go to space, but consider this: we are making artificial meat in a lab. Why? Some want the taste without the cow. Bringing a cow to Mars might make a carnivore happy, but it isn’t practical. We have water engineers saving water and trying to grow crops in the most inhospitable places on earth. They aren’t thinking of Mars or beyond; they are thinking of feeding a hungry planet.
Each of our ingredients, breadfruit, yams, and coconuts, was not part of a grand experiment to find a new island. But something that had worked for centuries, feeding a people, and some learned to grow them to make it easier. Like all of our civilizations. They learn to grow something, then they can grow it elsewhere, and civilization spreads.
Breadfruit: What Do You Do With It?
Breadfruit, it isn’t bread, and it doesn’t look like the fruit most of us know. It is a bumpy green ball about the size of a grapefruit. Cut it open, and you’ll find pale, starchy flesh.
Roast breadfruit, and the aroma and texture are a bit like freshly baked bread. I think that is more imagination than I have; perhaps it was so long at sea. To me, it is more like a roasted potato than a loaf of sourdough.
In our series, we have seen that early farmers take a wild plant and learn how to grow it for the village. They plant some wheat in the spring and harvest it in the fall. But every year it needs to be planted again. The soil for wheat or rice was often rich soil with water nearby.
The soil on most islands is not great for growing rice or wheat. It is often volcanic, or sandy, or a mix. But these Breadfruit trees can be planted in volcanic soil, or even sandy soil, and in five to seven years, the tree is producing fruit. It thrives on that volcanic soil with good drainage and lots of rain that the South Pacific has.
Chopped is one of the Food Network's game shows where chefs are given a surprise basket of ingredients to make a meal in a short period of time. On occasion, breadfruit shows up. If the breadfruit is firm, it is mature and mostly starch, like a potato. Something you can cut, deep fry, mash, or boil and add some olive oil to (the Polynesians didn’t have olive oil, or even Popeye).
If the breadfruit is fully ripe, the flesh is. soft, creamy, sweeter, and almost custard-like. This would be a custard, or maybe throw it in the ice-cream machine. The ice cream machine on Chopped is a trap; it almost always goes on the brink, like McDonald’s.
But that mature breadfruit tree can produce hundreds of pounds of fruit during a season. And unlike an annual grain crop, a breadfruit tree can continue producing for decades. Just like wheat and rice provided a dependable source of carbohydrates, or the potato, the breadfruit was the source for these islanders.
You could go to an island, plant some trees, come back later, and start to colonize it. You could start with a small number of people, and as the trees' harvest grew, as well as the harvest from the ocean, you could gradually sustain a larger population.
Taro, Yams, and the South American–New Zealand Express
Taro is one of those vegetables you might have seen in an Asian market. It looks like a hairy, unattractive potato. Cut it open, and there is a starchy interior, creamy white, sometimes flecked with purple.
Taro is the foundation of poi. And since it seems every strip mall in California has some poi, you probably had one of the essential foods of Polynesia. Yes, poki and poi, coming to a mall near you.
You cannot eat Taro raw because it contains calcium oxalate crystals (if your body makes these, they are called kidney stones). Those crystals will irritate your throat and esophagus.
Yams were another useful crop. And before someone sends me an angry message from the sweet potato industry, a true yam is not a sweet potato. This is one of those facts you will see someone talk about at Thanksgiving. Yes, we know. And I am assured that the Polynesians did not have marshmallows.
Some yams grow into enormous underground tubers. They can be stored for considerable periods, much like you can store potatoes, making them valuable when fresh food is scarce.
A South American Passenger
Sweet potatoes used by the Polynesians originated in the Americas. And that means that there was a trade route between those civilizations. In fact, the Polynesians were growing yams before Europeans reached the Pacific.
The precise movements of people and plants, and the dates and routes involved, we can only guess. Who knows who reached whom first? The result of that trade was that the sweet potato became part of the food system of the Pacific, all the way to New Zealand.
The South American–New Zealand Express. Enter the Māori
The Polynesian ancestors , the Māori ,reached New Zealand around the late thirteenth century.
New Zealand was much colder than the tropical islands. Breadfruit trees and coconuts didn’t grow well in New Zealand. But the sweet potato, called kūmara in Māori, did.
They developed storage pits to preserve the harvest through colder seasons. Much like your root cellar.
Coconuts: Food, Water, and a Hardware Store
My first view of the coconut was a television program based on James Michener’s Tales of the South Pacific. Otherwise, coconut was something mom used to bake some food. Speaking of which, I make an amazing almond tort (click here).
Maybe you saw the silly TikTok video where Paul Saladino brings coconuts through airport security to serve as his liquid. He says he doesn’t want the microplastics from the bottled water they sell after security, and I agree. But most of us bring a steel refillable water bottle, but Paul brings a sack of coconuts. Where does he have room for that, and how on earth do you open them? Not with a machete, good luck bringing that through security.
The Polynesians, however, had a far more practical reason to carry coconuts. They serve as food, where the young coconut provides liquid and soft flesh. The older mature coconut provides more fat and calories — oh, that just hit me. Yes, we gain a bit of fat as we age.
Coconuts have more uses than food. The shell makes a cup or clothing. The leaves can be woven into baskets and roofing. And the fibrous husk can be made into rope.
And what did they use that rope for? Well, ask any man who has a garage, and we have rope. Men have collected ropes long before we had drawers full of cords that provided electricity to a used electronic device no longer made. But for the Polynesians, ropes are needed for canoes.
Imagine crossing thousands of miles of ocean in a vessel whose wooden components are held together with rope made from coconuts. No Home Depot, but you had the makings of a rope. And when the tropical rains came, there was work to be done. No internet, so you had to do something, and they would sit under a shelter and braid coconut fibers into rope.
Here in America, when it rains, we tend to stay inside and Netflix and chill. At my age, that means watching a movie and relaxing on the couch. I understand the younger generation has given that phrase an entirely different meaning. Ah, to be young again.
But let’s not dwell on life after sixty.
We look at coconuts and think of a tropical drink. They looked at coconuts and saw food, drink, building materials, and a hardware store. All growing on a tree, no hook in a garage or drawer.
Pigs, Chickens, and the Noah’s Ark of the Pacific
The islands the people went to were not small, little desert islands. There are plenty of those in the South Pacific. But those don’t have the water, soil, or area to be anything more than a camping site for young lovers. Think of the Hawaiian Islands, all large, able to support not only the breadfruit, taro, and coconuts. They are also large enough to have ranches for another source of food, as well as their hides, hooves, etc.
But those islands didn’t come equipped with the plants or the animals to support a new colony. Those creatures, along with the plants, had to be brought.
Polynesians were not vegetarians. There is plenty of evidence that they brought with them pigs, chickens, and maybe a few other creatures. In Alaska, among my people, the Athabascan, vegetarians are given another name: bad hunters.
Polynesians also had pets. When we move, we take our pets. I have moved several times with my Golden Doodle, Lucky. The golden doodle goes through the same phases as humans. Until age five, they are a whackadoodle, endless energy. Then, Doodles, at the age of five, discovers they can lie down, and one day they transform from an energetic dog into the Great American Sloth. Dogs have been faithful companions for almost all of human existence. In fact, we probably evolved to simply serve the dog.
Now, anyone who has traveled with a dog knows it requires food and water. You also have to share your sleeping quarters with them. And you have to clean up after them.
For food, there were pigs and chickens. There may have been others, and probably were, but let us think about taking a canoe ride with some pigs and chickens. Imagine the larger, and sometimes cantankerous, pig. Or several pigs. Chickens would be easier; they take up less space. But they can still be a pain. I suppose they would have taken the smaller pigs on the boat and have the larger ones for the going-away party.
Why go to all this trouble? Because one pig is dinner. A breeding pair of pigs could eventually mean pork for an entire village. Chickens reproduce a little faster than pigs. If you have ever been to the island of Kauai, chickens roam freely, and have been here for longer than Europeans. I see them running around and think of Coq au vin.
The Pacific rat traveled with people across much of Polynesia. Some were probably deliberately transported as food, while others may have simply helped themselves to passage. Others went to New York, where they still dominate the city and are well served by the politicians.
Every civilization started with a farm, something to grow that could sustain people, allow them to settle down, form villages, towns, governments, and, of course, taxes. Different parts of the world provided ingredients that fostered those civilizations.
We went from hunter-gatherers to civilizations because food allowed us to do that. Civilization is more than just planting enough to get by. These are the lessons we have learned from our previous episodes of coffee, salt, tea, and spices.
If you ever thought about Mars, think about the planning of the Polynesian people and what was done here on Earth. Take a look at the size of the water they had to cross. In our next section, what it might take to inhabit another planet.
What Would You Pack to Colonize Mars?
This is more than a thought experiment; it is an active area of research as we consider outposts in our solar system and beyond. Who wouldn’t want to snowboard on Uranus? But what do you bring, and how do you start that process? Well, I have a few ideas.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
