That Aged Well

Latest Episodes:

That Aged Well Interviews: A Date With Dateline Apr 03, 2026

Show notes

It’s a whole bonus WEEK this time around, as Paul and Erika finally get to officially meet their fairy godsisters: Kimberly and Katie from A Date With Dateline! Please enjoy this delightful interview…we sure did!

That Aged Well is brought to you by Quince! Shop in April for 365-day returns and free shipping!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Celebrating Catherine O’Hara Mar 30, 2026

Show notes

It’s a five Monday March this year, and we couldn’t let Screen Legends Month pass without a chance to talk about the dearly departed Catherine O’Hara. The solution? A bonus episode all about her and only her (and, honestly, a bit about her Schitt’s Creek co-stars…but that’s how she’d want it)!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

The Sting (1973) Horse Names, Podcast Buttons & a Carousel/Brothel Mar 23, 2026

Show notes

It’s our last full length episode of Screen Legend March, so we’re going out with a film packed full of legends: The Sting! Sure, we picked it because of Robert Redford, but Paul Newman is here! And Robert Shaw! And Eileen Brennan! And still more! Listen to and enjoy all the legendary content!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

That Aged Well Oscar Recap (2026) Mar 16, 2026

Show notes

Well, hello! Have you ever thought to yourself, "You know, I'm a little Patreon-curious?" We hear you! Paul and Erika stayed up late last night to get this Oscar recap recorded to give you a taste of what we're doing over on the Patreon, where we have bonus episodes that recap current pop culture (which is what we're doing here), but also discuss listener comments and say all the things that we won't say unless there's a paywall! Head to Patreon to find out more!

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Baby Boom (1987) - Spaghetti, Apple Sauce & an Inherited Cow Mar 16, 2026

Show notes

Paul and Erika are celebrating screen legends all month, and this time it’s Diane Keaton’s turn as they talk all about Baby Boom! How much country estate is too much country estate? Does everyone remember the time you could get valium delivered? What is the actual value of a movie “making sense?” All these questions and more are addressed in this episode!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

A Few Good Men (1992) - Confessions, Cameos & a Thinkin’ Bat Mar 09, 2026

Show notes

More March, more screen legends…and this time we’re celebrating Rob Reiner, who doesn’t appear on screen in A Few Good Men, but he definitely directed the hell out of it. How does this military courtroom drama stack up in the pantheon of Rob Reiner films? How does one correctly order a beer in a restaurant? What are the chances of Tom Cruise drinking a Yoo-hoo? Answers to all of these questions and more lie ahead!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Field of Dreams (1989) - Ghosts, Oracles & a Disembodied Voice Mar 02, 2026

Show notes

It’s March! And for all of March, That Aged Well is celebrating some recently departed legends of the silver screen. First up is James Earl Jones in Field of Dreams (and also Ray Liotta and Burt Lancaster…but we chose it for JEJ).

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Hook (1991) - Victorian Parents, Middle Names & a Jolly Roger Feb 23, 2026

Show notes

How can it possibly be the end of Fantasy February already? This month has already given us so much, and it’s not going to let us down now! We are finishing out with Stephen Spielberg’s Hook, aka Peter Pan grows up and has a LOT of memory issues, probably brought on by getting knocked in the head too much without anyone around to run concussion protocols.

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Willow (1988) - Sorceresses, Ex-Boyfriends & a Silent Movie Screen Siren Feb 16, 2026

Show notes

Let’s take at least a week in Fantasy February to truly leave our world behind and enter instead the world of Willow, Ron Howard’s 1988 high fantasy adventure! We’ve often said a movie has everything, but this movie has everything, and then some. Pig extras! Homophobic magic dust! Rituals of indeterminate length! Come join us as we take you through every magical step!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

The NeverEnding Story (1984) - Safe Books, Loose Bones & a Power Ballad Feb 09, 2026

Show notes

Fantasy February gets real this week, as Erika and Paul get all the way into 1984’s classic The NeverEnding Story, which has the three building blocks of any great fantasy story: horses, wolves, and dragons. Once you’ve got those, you’re pretty much 75% of the way to a great fantasy story…but does this one land the last 25%? Listen and find out!

You can follow That Aged Well on Bluesky (@ThatAgedWell.bsky.social), Instagram, Threads, and Letterboxd (@ThatAgedWell)!

SUPPORT US ON PATREON FOR BONUS CONTENT!

VISIT OUR DASHERY STORE FOR THAT AGED WELL MERCH!

Wanna rate and review? HERE YOU GO!

Hosts: Paul Caiola & Erika Villalba

Producer & Editor: Paul Caiola

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.