Show notes
TTPD is Christy and Rachel’s GOAT albums of TS, and we’re so excited to explain the lore in an incredibly in-depth, nearly two hour episode! Taylor Swift and Matty Healy were publicly together for only a few weeks in 2023—but their story was nearly a decade in the making (real Swiftiesk now). We trace their history from a backstage meeting in 2014 to their whirlwind reunion, then revisit Midnights and The Tortured Poets Department for clues about Joe Alwyn, Matty Healy and her long-awaited, anticipated romance, the backlash, and its implosion.
Thank you to our sponsors!
Find pieces made for real life with Wayfair. Join Wayfair Rewards to get five percent back on every purchase.
Make your bed your favorite place to be this season with Quince. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers. Get free shipping and 365-day returns.
Head to Cure Hydration and use code SNARK for 20% off your order. Subscribe and save; you can pause or cancel anytime.
Explore your style without commitment — get $28 OFF your first month of Nuuly by using code SNARK at Nuuly.com!
3 Million Butts Love TUSHY. For a limited time Get 10% off TUSHY with the code SNARK at hellotushy.com
That scratched up pair has done its job. Upgrade today with Zenni! Go to zenni.com/podcast and use code PODCAST15 for 15% off your first order, plus free shipping on all US orders over $65.
Wrap yourself in luxury with Lola Blankets! Use our code SNARK for 40% off LolaBlankets.com for a limited time
Get ad-free and bonus episodes weekly on our Patreon — and don’t forget to sign up for our weekly newsletter! Shop our merch!
Make sure to follow us on Instagram and watch full episodes on YouTube!
@snarkbaitpod
@christynoel__
@soph_ross
FULL LINKS:
Approximate Timestamps:
Part 1: The Addendum
00:00 Intro: Recording an Addendum After Taylor's Surprise News
01:20 Patient Zero & the Encore Dropped Mid-Recording: Initial Reactions
03:20 Patient Zero's "Sterile Asylum" Aesthetic vs. the Encore's Flashy Reveal
07:25 Album Release Theories & the Summer I Turned Pretty Comparison
11:30 Debating the Encore & Favorite Eras Aesthetically
16:25 The Lavender Haze/Mad Men Connection Deep Dive
18:00 Closing Thoughts, the Truman Black/Joe Alwyn Connection & Outro
Part 2: The Main Episode
23:40 Intro: Rachel Returns & Setting the Stage on Taylor & Maddie
27:30 Current Album Speculation: Debut Re-Release & November 10th Theories
32:50 Joe Alwyn's Truman Show Picture & the Gaylor Theories Tangent
37:00 Favorite Taylor Relationship Debate & "The Life of a Showgirl" Critique
41:45 Joe Alwyn as a Muse & Christy's "Maddie as OTP" Hot Take
47:30 The Origin Story: Meeting at a 1975 Concert & Early Courtship
53:45 A Friend's Insider Perspective & Disclaimer on Being a Critical Swiftie
57:00 The Quiet Reputation Era Through the 2023 Breakup & Eras Setlist Swap
1:00:10 April 8th: The Official Joe Breakup, Timed to Maddie's Birthday
1:03:00 The Public Proclamation Timeline & the Sudden June 2023 Breakup
1:05:45 Color Symbolism, the Romantic Gesture Theory & Midnights as a Breakup Album
1:09:15 "You're Losing Me," "Midnight Rain" & "The Great War"
1:14:30 "Question...?" & "Maroon": The Foxborough Surprise Song Tied to Maddie
1:16:55 TTPD as a "Postmortem": "So Long London" & Debating "loml"
1:21:25 "Guilty as Sin?," "Fresh Out the Slammer" & "But Daddy I Love Him"
1:26:00 Defending Her Choices & Questioning Taylor's Real Value System
1:31:00 "I Can Fix Him" & the Title Track's Direct Jack/Lucy References
1:35:00 Marriage Imagery, "Fortnite" & the Album's Downward Spiral
1:42:30 Voice Memo Alternate Lyrics They Wish She'd Kept
1:45:10 "I Can Get You Back" & the Wine-Name Coding
1:53:00 "The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived," "The Prophecy" & "The Manuscript"
2:01:10 Final Thoughts, Lighthearted Closer & Outro
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
