Riddle Me That! True Crime

Latest Episodes:

Conversations w/ Murder She Told: Danielle Bertolini and the Humboldt Five Dec 18, 2021

Show notes

In part two of my discussion with Kristen Seavy from the Murder She Told Podcast we talk the disappearance and eventual discovery of the remains of her childhood friend Danielle Bertolini, as well as the Humboldt Five. Detailed description below.
Description of original episode on Murder She Told:
My childhood friend’s disappearance
The story that I have for you this week is the story of my childhood friend, Danielle Bertolini. She and I grew up together in my small hometown of Newport, Maine (population 3,200). We were friends and classmates in elementary and junior high, and I fondly remember her unapologetic and spunky personality.
At 23 years old, in 2014, she went missing in Fortuna, California in Humboldt County.
Today, she is known as one of the Humboldt County Missing Five.
Danielle’s mother’s heartrending interview
For years I followed her case on Facebook through the family’s updates, seeing and sharing their pain.
This is a story that’s been in my heart for a long time, but I just didn’t know how to tell right. But when I reached out to Danielle’s mother, to talk to me, on the record, about her daughter’s tragic disappearance and death, she agreed.
We sat down at my dining room table, and we had a surprisingly intimate and tough conversation about Danielle’s life, and her death.
The majesty of the redwoods and the darkness that lurks within
Danielle moved across the country to a beautiful area called Humboldt county, home of some of the tallest trees in the world, the giant redwoods. The beauty of the trees is juxtaposed by the ugliness of the crime and the proliferation of drugs in the area.
Alder Point, California, a small town in Humboldt County, is flanked by a famous peak dubbed “Murder Mountain” where many have gone missing and many have died. Murder Mountain initially got it’s nickname after serial killer couple Michael Bear Carson and Suzan Carson hid out there after murdering 26-year-old Clark Stephens in 1982, seeking refuge in the trees while police tried to nab the perpetrator of their crimes. But it stuck because of the sheer number of people who disappear and are found murdered in Humboldt County.
Drugs, lies, murder, and a search for justice
Danielle’s life was transformed by the loss of her son Xavier. She left behind her life in Maine, where she had constant reminders of her trauma, and went to find a fresh start in California amidst the redwoods.
But California wasn’t the answer she was looking for, and Danielle fell into the wrong crowd and was using heavily. Before her disappearance, she trapped and trying to find a way out.
One year later, a human skull is found washed up on the bank of the Eel River, and is ultimately identified as Danielle’s.
Join the fight! A petition to prioritize this case
I have started a petition on change.org to dial up the pressure on this case. Danielle isn’t the only person to go missing under the same circumstances. There is a person of interest and there is evidence. Justice is so close. Help the family get the closure that they deserve.
SIGN THE PETITION
https://www.change.org/p/humboldt-county-district-attorney-justice-for-danielle-bertolini-and-sheila-franks?utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=custom_url&recruited_by_id=5b2baae0-2626-11e6-b7a5-3be3a030e21a
A very special thanks to Billie Jo Dick for sharing her daughter’s life story and memories with me.
If you’re holding onto any information or think you might know something about the murders of Danielle Bertolini and Sheila Franks, I urge you to submit a tip to the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office Anonymous Tip Line at (707) 268-2539.
Connect on Instagram (@MurderSheToldPodcast) for photos from this episode and more.
Murder She Told Danielle Bertolini Pt One:
https://www.murdershetold.com/episodes/danielle-bertolini
Danielle Bertolini Part Two ft. Billy Jensen:
https://www.murdershetold.com/episodes/danielle-bertolini-billy-jensen

Conversations w/ Murder She Told: Serial Killer James Rodney Hicks Dec 11, 2021

Show notes

Today I am talking with Maine native Kristen Seavy, who is an actress and a True Crime podcaster, the host of Murder She Told about her hometown Serial Killer James Rodney Hicks. Kristen covered this story on the first two episodes of her podcast, which I will link below.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/Julesandashley
Here is Kristen's original episode description from murdershetold.com
She entered The Gateway looking for love, and instead, she found him…
It’s October 16th, 1982, in my hometown of Newport, Maine. But this is before my time. Jerilyn Towers goes to a local bar, The Gateway Lounge, for a drink... and never comes back.
The bartender who was working that night said she remembered seeing Jerilyn there. And she wasn’t alone. She was approached by a man named James Hicks who flattered her and bought her drinks all night. They seemed to be laughing and having a great time. Around 1am, they left together.
Newport Police Chief Jim Ricker goes to question Hicks, and he quickly realizes that Jerilyn may not be the only person who was last seen with this man, and that they both might not actually be missing...
He learns that in 1977, Jennie Cyr, the former wife of James Hicks just... disappeared. She “ran off with a lover,” claimed Hicks. Ricker calls up the Cyr family, and they all have the same story: Jennie didn’t run off. Jennie was dead. And they knew exactly who was responsible...
This is the story of James Hicks, the serial killer next door that you've never heard of, and the most sensational trial in Maine State history.
Part One of The Deadly Web of James Hicks is available now on Murder, She Told wherever you get your favorite podcasts.
Special thanks to Police Chief Jim Ricker for sharing his first-hand account.
Connect with Murder, She Told on instagram @MurderSheToldPodcast for more key photos from this episode and more.
Episode one link:
https://www.murdershetold.com/episodes/1-james-hicks
Episode two link:
https://www.murdershetold.com/episodes/2-james-hicks

BONUS Twisted & Uncorked: Where is William Bradford Bishop ft. Riddle Me That! Dec 08, 2021

Show notes

For a bonus episode this month as a big thank you to our listeners, we got the chance to sit down with Dr Jules from Riddle Me That & Path Went Chilly podcasts. We discuss a very controversial and mysterious family homicide and the patriarch, William Bradford Bishop's potential involvement and disappearance.
What do you think could have happened and where is William now?
Remember to rate, review, and subscribe, it is the best way to spread the word!
Patreon = patreon.com/twistedanduncorked
Website = twistedanduncorked.wixsite.com/podcast
Instagram, Facebook and Tiktok = @twistedandcorked
Twitter = @twisted_pod

Conversations w/ Maggie Freleng fr. Murder In Alliance Dec 04, 2021

Show notes

Join Maggie and I as we go through some of the cases she covered on season one of Unjust & Unsolved: Temujin Kensu, Andre Brown & JJ Velasquez. We also speak about Maggie's emotional journey investigating the murder of Yvonne Layne & what was thought to be the potential wrongful conviction of David Thorne on Murder In Alliance. Maggie also speaks candidly about the loss of one of her best friends through suicide. If this is a sensitive subject for you, please ff to the 3:30 mark of the show. I will link suicide prevention hotlines below, as well as the corresponding episodes for the cases we speak about on the show.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Suicide Prevention hotlines/websites that will link you up with a number wherever you are in the world:
suicidepreventionhotlines.com
findahelpline.com
opencounceling.com
suicidepreventionlifeline.org
Murder In Alliance:
https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/murder-in-alliance/id1566463218
Unjust & Unsolved: Andre Brown:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/andre-brown/id1527777879?i=1000505288681
Unjust & Unsolved: JJ Velazquez
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/unjust-unsolved/id1527777879?i=1000493208580
Unjust & Unsolved: Temujin Kensu
https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/temujin-kensu/id1527777879?i=1000501202834
The Prosecutors: Temujin Kensu Pt. One
https://prosecutorspodcast.com/2021/03/30/66-temujin-kensu-fred-freeman-part-1-kung-fu-fighting/
Part Two:
https://prosecutorspodcast.com/2021/04/06/68-temujin-kensu-part-2/

Introducing: Haunting History: The Disappearance of Debra Lynn Tidwell & sons Joshua & Jackson Dec 02, 2021

Show notes

Check out this podcast that focuses on the creepy, morbid histories and true crime cases. If you like my show, I know you will love this. This is part one of a series so be sure to subscribe to Haunting History to hear the rest of the episodes.
Subscribe:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/haunting-history-podcast/id1435733836
The podcast that reaches back into the past for the events that shocked us all, tales of true crime, mystery and the macabre. Join us as we travel back in time and revisit the people and the stories behind the headlines and when we are lucky, the stories where events and the paranormal collide.
Debra Lynn and her 3 year old twins Joshua and Jackson disappeared without a trace on May 4, 1979. Please like and share the Facebook page, Find Debra Lynn Kidwell and Sons.
https://www.facebook.com/findingdebralynnkidwellandsons/
http://www.doenetwork.org/cases/870dfca.html
https://www.namus.gov/MissingPersons/Case#/24298

Conversations w/ Lauren Bright Pacheco fr. Murder In Illinois: Christopher Vaughn Nov 27, 2021

Show notes

In this episode we discuss Lauren's podcast 'Murder in Illinois' and the highly polarizing case of Christopher Vaughn. We attempt to unravel exactly what Lauren did in her podcast....did Christopher kill his wife Kimberly and his three children? or was Kimberly a better suspect based on forensic (ballistics, blood evidence, crime scene recreation etc) and circumstantial evidence w/ regards to Kimberly's behavior leading up to the crime as witnessed by her daughter, as well as the medication she was taking and how she herself had seen a shift in her personality. Please, please go and listen to Murder In Illinois and draw your own conclusions, these opinions are my own and the opinions of Lauren on the case and they may be far removed from the conclusions you draw based on the evidence.
We will also dive into how Lauren managed to cope with the social media attacks due to the delicate nature and fixed narrative surrounding this case. Lauren will also share her television producer background where she has worked for two of the most famous t.v. Doctors Dr. Phil and Dr. Oz.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Lauren's Podcasts she has hosted and/or produced:
Murder in Illinois:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/murder-in-illinois/id1573417225
Murder in Oregon:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/murder-in-oregon/id1478138996
Happy Face:
https://www.happyfacepodcasts.com/
The Murders at Whitehouse Farm:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-murders-at-white-house-farm-the-podcast/id1532057296
Wholly Human w/ Leanne Rimes:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/wholly-human-with-leann-rimes/id1540357529
Next Question With Katie Couric:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/next-question-with-katie-couric/id1134154895

INTRODUCING We're All Screwed: The New Mexico State Penitentiary Riot Nov 24, 2021

Show notes

We’re All Screwed is a true crime podcast with a goal of bringing awareness to lesser known cases and victim advocacy! We try to focus on less sensationalized cases to shine light on cases that may not be as glamorous as others. We would love your input and love to hear your personal stories if you have any!! If we can help one case get the attention it deserves, we’re doing our jobs! Stick around a while, we might just grow on ya! Please rate and review and follow us on social media for updates and fun conversations!! Much Love, Lacy, Anika & Krystle
The New Mexico State Penitentiary riot, which took place on February 2 and 3, 1980, at the Penitentiary of New Mexico south of Santa Fe, was the most violent prison riot in U.S. history. Inmates took complete control of the prison and twelve officers were taken hostage. Several prisoners were taken hostage, mutilated, and tortured by the other inmates. It took 36 hours to regain control of the prison. Join us in this episode to hear all of the events that took place and why!
Sources:
Santafenewmexican.com
lcsunnews.com

Conversations w/ Mike Morford: The Zodiac Killer & Murdaugh Murder Saga Nov 20, 2021

Show notes

In this episode I talk to Mike Morford from The Zodiac Speaking, Criminology, The Murder in My Family, Missing Person's and Abjack Entertainment. We talk Zodiac Killer & Mike attempts to unravel the ball of yarn that is the confusing case of the Murdaugh family and all of the murders and strange deaths connected to this legacy of legal minds. We also talk about Gabby Petito, I will the corresponding Criminology episodes below.
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/criminology/id1264424015?i=1000535882429
If you want to dive even deeper, check out Murdaugh Murders:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/murdaugh-murders-podcast/id1573560247
Criminology's episode on Gabby Petito:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/gabby-petito/id1264424015?i=1000536617513
Zodiac Speaking Podcast:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/zodiac-speaking/id1554911287
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Art: @fleshwadYT fleshwadyt@gmail.com
Music: Jobbers

INTRODUCING Homicide Highway: Billy Milligan Nov 19, 2021

Show notes

Homicide Highway is a True Crime podcast hosted by Harley Newell and Lacy Wilkinson. We are two friends who met because of our love for true crime. We cover and analyze cases down to the last gory detail. No case is off limits for us to discuss, no matter how much we may disagree on the circumstances or the outcome.
Billy Milligan was 5 years old when he was sodomized and buried alive by his step father. This trauma, along with his father completing suicide was the trauma that led to his personalities to splinter into others. What happens when one of your personalities decides to be a violent rapist? Well not good things. The victims in this story were also pushed to the side with the media frenzy that took over once the diagnoses came out that this man had 24 personalities living in his head.

Conversations w/ Robin Warder: The West Memphis Three Nov 13, 2021

Show notes

In this episode Robin tells me all about one of his pet cases, the West Memphis Three. We explore the suspects, the documentaries, the legal issues up until present day.
Support the show:
Patreon.com/julesandashley
Art: @fleshwadYT fleshwadyt@gmail.com
Music: Jobbers

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Riddle Me That! True Crime

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected