Claire Fallon and Emma Gray obsessively analyze our cultural obsessions, from fashion trends to books to the buzziest TV shows.
patreon.com/claireandemma
php/*
Claire Fallon and Emma Gray obsessively analyze our cultural obsessions, from fashion trends to books to the buzziest TV shows.
patreon.com/claireandemma
Copyright: © CLAIRE AND EMMA LLC
Happy Halloween, beloveds! Gather round the campfire, because we sure have a spooky story for you: a tale of a sweet, naive college freshman who stumbles into an entanglement with the wrong man. A man with a dark past and a penchant for seduction. A man so addicted to fucking around, he’s driving his life straight into a ditch.
In short, we both ripped through Hulu’s sordid series “Tell Me Lies,” based on the 2018 novel by Carola Lovering, which wrapped up this week with a shocking finale that already has us clamoring for a second season. As a TV show, it’s far from perfect; as a period piece set in 2007 (our own college days!) it sadly leaves much to be desired. As a creepy, steamy binge, it fits the bill, as long as you don’t worry too much about the details.
The series follows Lucy (Grace Van Patten), a freshman at an upstate NY liberal arts college in 2007, who falls hard and fast for Stephen (Jackson White), a junior with “bad boy” oozing from his pores. Stephen pursues Lucy diligently, but he also withholds commitment and seems to be hiding things from her, which only makes her work harder to keep him interested. Meanwhile, her roommate Macy dies in a tragic car accident before classes even begin, and it soon emerges that some people on campus know more about the circumstances of her death than it initially seemed. Is Stephen a wounded but worthy soul, or a fuckboy beyond redemption? Will their relationship bring out Lucy’s best, or drag her down to the depths?
On this episode, we discuss the aesthetic of 2007 (side parts and flat-irons, dark eyeliner and tunics) and what appears to be the show’s choice not to embrace it. We also unpack the show’s exploration of emotional abuse both in families and between romantic partners, and its lurid depiction of the evils of hook-up culture. We hope you enjoy, and remember: stay safe out there. Fuckboys are everywhere.
P.S. Remember to vote!! Look up your early voting polling place and get out there. Even scarier than an FBoy is a racist, xenophobic, misogynist nutjob running your state and local government.
Share Rich TextToto, we’re not in Malibu anymore!
That’s right y’all, it’s time for our 5 (moderately) happy, newly-engaged couples to head back to Dallas, move into their show-appointed neutrally-decorated apartments, and commence the grueling labor of coupledom.
This week’s batch of episodes was so meaty that we found it difficult to discuss them in a concise and coherent manner. Some scenes felt like they needed entire podcast episodes, like the knotty conversation that Bartise and Nancy have about abortion rights, or the massive blow-up fight that Matt and Colleen have and then quickly try to paper over. Plus, predictably, both Bartise and Cole continued to act a fool after realizing that the other women they had pursued in the pods, were in fact, also hot.
Luckily for our cold dead hearts, which have been beaten down even further by this season of Bachelor In Paradise, we also got some sweetness in these episodes. Alexa and Brennon continue their reign as the golden couple, even as their differences become more pronounced, and SK and Raven’s slow burn has turned into a moderately hot flame.
Who are our top 3 enemies? Who rose up the ranks in our should-they-get-married ratings? Listen and enjoy! xo
ShareWe’ve been reading…
After a break, I went back to Gabrielle Zevin’s “Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow” and read the last two-thirds of it on one rainy Sunday afternoon. I couldn’t put it down, and I spent the last 100-ish pages weeping. It’s so very beautiful. Don’t let the gaming premise turn you off, this is a must-read. -Emma
I’m still reading “Nevada” by Imogen Binnie, though I’ve been on something of an enforced break. Max has had a bad cold, so not only was our weekend more chaotic than usual (postnasal drip does not put toddlers in a good mood any more than it does adults, and they can’t use decongestants) but he missed a couple days of daycare. My fun reading is the first thing to drop off the agenda, but I’m hoping to get back to it soon!
I also read Lila Shapiro on the lawsuit Moira Donegan is facing over the Shitty Media Men list, which disturbingly appears poised to go to trial. -Claire
We’ve been listening to…
Taylor Swift’s “Midnights.” Duh. I’ve been especially obsessed with the 3am tracks, specifically in “Could’ve Would’ve Should’ve,” her musical excoriation of John Mayer, who she dated at 19 when he was 32. “Give me my back my girlhood / It was mine first.” Devastating. -Emma
We’ve all been listening to “Midnights,” which for some reason has emerged as the Taylor album I am least likely to skip tracks on. Maybe I’m just becoming more patient in my old age and letting her quieter tracks have a chance to creep up on me, or maybe I love the blend of indie rock influences and synthy pop — somehow I even enjoy the cringe tracks like “Vigilante Shit.” (It’s because I, like Taylor, am cringe.) -Claire
We’ve been watching…
Honestly haven’t had time to watch anything this week other than BIP, Love Is Blind and a little bit of Tell Me Lies. Pretty cool that I got to do all of that for work. -Emma
The upside of Max’s cold is that we’ve all had a chance to get into “Encanto.” The first couple times we tried it, he found it pretty overstimulating, but now he is obsessed. And so am I. He gets to watch chunks of it while he does his many inhaler sessions, or when he’s too miserable to play with toys, and I think I enjoy it as much as he does. The plot holes are starting to get to me a bit (why does Tia Pepa affect the weather easily enough to summon a whole hurricane on her wedding day, but in the actual movie we only see tiny little clouds directly over her? Mostly I have a lot of questions about Tia Pepa) but it’s just so fun and packed with earworms. -Claire
We’ve been buying…
It will come to absolutely no one’s surprise that I indulged in a little Hill House holiday-wear. I love this soft blackwatch tartan pattern, and got the Louisa dress and the Evelyn, both perfect for taking a fall stroll / grabbing a meal out / podcasting from your bedroom. All the versatility I need for my current lifestyle. (LOL.) -Emma
Ugh, same. I wear my tartan Ellies around the house constantly in the winter, so it was easy to convince myself that I needed more. I got a Caroline, and it’s like being swaddled in a soft, light blanket. For those who need to look nice outside of their homes, perhaps at parties or even a fashion-forward office, I recommend the mod Araminta — I’ve never felt more beautiful in a statement sleeve or a shift dress. (I never need to dress up, so mine is going back, but not without a pang!)
I also saw that Rifle Paper Co. was having a sale on 2023 planners, so I went ahead and got the 2023 version of my current planner, which I love. The promotion appears to be over, but a few individual planners are still discounted. I’m more an organizational aspirant than a rigorous organizer, but this planner has just the right balance of calendar space, general note-taking space, and to-do list space for my fairly basic needs. -Claire
Share Rich TextWe love a pod love pod here at Rich Text, so we were ready as hell for season 3 of “Love Is Blind” to kick off this week and we’re already back on our bullshit (making pods about pods).
Season 3: Dallas edition, which is dropping just a month after the season 2 “Love Is Blind: After the Altar” special and associated divorce announcements proved the Chicago experiment a bust, hopes to restore our faith in blind speed dating. Can Vanessa Lachey and her statement sleeves (and, less importantly, her husband Nick) help these lonely hearts find love sight unseen?
The first four episodes introduce us to our main daters (e.g. the ones who end up getting engaged and participating in the rest of the show), follow a few love triangle clusters, and see our newly betrothed couples head off to Malibu for a luxury getaway.
At this stage, season 3 might be the least dramatic season yet, with no apparent second-choice engagements, love triangles that linger past the pod stage, or interpersonal drama. That doesn’t mean people don’t find ways to act foolish (doing a loud set of jumping jacks while a potential fiancé shares a painful family story, for example) or say gross things (“I’m gonna pump a couple kids in you,” FOR EXAMPLE), but the season feels a bit gentler and more mature.
One thing was a particularly refreshing change after a season 2 fraught with fatphobia, negative body talk, and weight loss backstories: not only are the contestants presented as less fixated on thinness, we actually see a plus-size woman, Alexa Alfia, who embraces her own body and its beauty and who has a blissful love story in the pods.
If you’ve watched already or if you just want to hear the breakdown, here’s our full recap. Hope you enjoy! xo
ShareWe’ve been reading…
“Nevada,” by Imogen Binnie. I’ve been listening to the Missing Pages podcast Emma mentioned a few newsletters ago, and while it hasn’t necessarily been my favorite podcast ever (for one thing, I’m already pretty familiar with all the big literary scandals and mysteries from covering the book world for half a decade and writing innumerable listicles about the industry), I enjoyed Binnie’s interview on an episode about J.T. Leroy. It got me curious about Binnie’s own cult classic, which was recently reissued by FSG. The novel follows Maria, an almost-30 trans woman who has a miserable job at a Very Famous Indie Bookstore in New York, a rapidly imploding relationship with a long-term girlfriend she used to love, and a brewing internal crisis over her inability to connect with her own feelings and needs. It’s provocative, scathing, and deeply jaded — Maria is even bored with her own traumas and vulnerable places. It’s often uncomfortable reading, in the best possible way. -Claire
Jamelle Bouie’s NYTimes op-ed, “Jim Crow Should Have Made One Thing Clear,” about lessons we all need to take on board from our own nation’s history as we head closer and closer towards terrifying authoritarianism. The whole column is a must read, but this paragraph stopped me in my tracks:
As we look to a November in which a number of vocal election deniers are poised to win powerful positions in key swing states, I think that the great degree to which authoritarianism is tied up in the American experience — and the extent to which we’ve been trained not to see it, in accordance with our national myths and sense of exceptionalism — makes it difficult for many Americans to really believe that democracy as we know it could be in serious danger. In other words, too many Americans still think it can’t happen here, when the truth is that it already has and may well again.
Please please please make sure you are registered to vote, and get yourself and your communities to the polls in November. Our lives and our democracy depends on it. -Emma
We’ve been watching…
I finished “Partner Track” this week. It was a treasure trove of memes for me, given that the villain has exactly the same name as my brother (who is not villainous at all) and the script is littered with gems like “I just want to punch Dan Fallon in his smug, pretentious face,” so I had to see it through. But genuinely, to me, “Partner Track” is an “Emily in Paris”-level binge: so much is going badly (the acting, the writing, the corny plot twists, the often clunky if well-meaning treatment of social justice issues) that it’s impossible to look away. Honestly, get me another season of “Partner Track” to watch alongside Emily’s Parisian adventures — but also, maybe some more actually good shows with quirky female leads. -Claire
The first episode of the new season of “The Vow.” Did this NXIVM docu-series need a season 2? Probably not. Does it lack interrogation of things like the money that went in and out of the self-help cult? Yes. Will I still be watching it all? Also a yes. -Emma
We’ve been listening to…
“Normal Gossip,” because I always save the new episodes to have as a little treat later and then forget I have them stashed away. This week my absent-mindedness paid off because I got to binge, like, six episodes of “Normal Gossip” and I was LIVING, my friends. Boy band fandom gossip! Family Secret Santa gossip! Gay kickball league gossip! This week I was just swimming around in it, letting it sink into my pores. The Telephone Game episode, a time-lapse compilation of the weekly guests playing an extended game of telephone with an anonymized piece of gossip, was perhaps my favorite, just because it is SO INSTRUCTIVE about not just the fact that gossip DOES get twisted with each retelling, but how and why those changes happen. -Claire
The first episode of a new pod series about the rise and fall of pop famous church Hillsong. “Hillsong: A Megachurch Shattered” is an investigative seven-part series which is a companion piece to a discovery+ docu-series. So far, it’s gripping. -Emma
We’ve been buying…
The Emilia velvet rose platform heels from the recent Antonio Melani X Nicola Bathie Dillard’s drop. I am planning to wear a certain lilac tulle dress to an upcoming wedding, and they seemed to call for some striking platform heels. I went with the cabernet color to darken my look up for fall, and I love them. However, I am slightly terrified of falling over and/or injuring myself?? Women who wear high high heels are so brave. -Claire
These brown leather knee-high Vince Camuto boots. They have been having a major fall sale, so I got them at a discount and I am so excited to enter my flowy dress / tall boots era! As someone with ~shapely~ calves I thought I simply couldn’t wear knee-high and over-the-knee boots, but it turns out that some brands (like Vince Camuto!) make a ton of their taller boots in wide-calf sizes too. #Bless. -Emma
Share Rich TextIf you are a geriatric or middle-aged millennial woman who loved Scholastic book fairs, you probably have core memories of “Catherine Called Birdy.” The 1994 historical fiction Y.A. novel by Karen Cushman was certainly formative for both of us.
The book follows spirited 14-year-old Birdy, the daughter of a country knight in 1290 England. Her father has decided that it is time to marry her off to the highest bidder, and the novel takes us into Birdy’s diary as she quietly and overtly rages against the gender-based strictures of her time. It is a story that feels both incredibly of the moment that it was published, and simultaneously a timeless tale of transition from girlhood into young adulthood.
On Oct. 7, Lena Dunham’s adaptation of the beloved novel, which stars Bella Ramsey, Billie Piper, Andrew Scott and Joe Alwyn (aka Mr. Taylor Swift), hit Amazon Prime. On this week’s subscribers pod, we dive into the film and the ways in which it stays true to the book and has been updated, with mixed results, as well as why the magic of the story endures, even for readers like us, who are now the age of Birdy’s mother rather than the protagonist herself.
Hope you enjoy! xo
ShareWe’ve been reading…
Sloane Crosley’s latest novel, “Cult Classic.” This book is like Emma catnip: a woman in her late 30s, satire about dating culture, and New York City. I love it so much. -Emma
This strangely lovely New Yorker story by Ted Geltner about the real, terrifying car crash that inspired a classic short story. Every turn of the article is unexpected. -Claire
We’ve been listening to…
More “Heavyweights.” This week’s episode is a beautiful story about estranged family relationships, the beauty of strangers, and healing generational trauma. -Emma
I finally got into “Missing Pages,” the literary scandal pod Emma recommended a few weeks ago, and it’s already inspired me to buy at least one book. That’s the kind of podcast I can get behind: a podcast that reminds me to shop support my local independent bookstore. -Claire
We’ve been watching…
“Love Is Blind” screeners, which is great because I love having more men I don’t know as low-grade nemeses. Get ready for some wild Friends to Enemies ratings in the weeks to come. -Emma
Netflix’s “Partner Track,” which is pretty terrible, and screeners of “Love Is Blind” season 3, which are exactly what they ought to be. Stay tuned for pods! The season starts dropping soon. -Claire
We’ve been buying…
A classic black belt with a bit of embellishment. I have been trying to buy more neutral pieces lately that can be worn with each other for years to come. In that vein, I purchased this & Other Stories black belt with a gold heart buckle — a much more affordable version of this Saint Laurent one. I’ve already worn it cinched at the waist over dresses and with trousers, and it’s perfect. -Emma
A long quilted liner jacket from Everlane for the cold, wet fall park days we’ve been having. Somehow I never bothered to get myself a really warm, capacious, practical transition jacket, so for the last few springs and falls I’ve resorted to piling on layers of sweaters and light jackets for cold, damp playground days. I read that this jacket runs big, so I sized down one size, and it’s still perfectly oversized and cozy. Also, the weather is now suddenly warm again. But I have no regrets. -Claire
Share Rich TextWe’re back with more answers to more questions! Last week, we published a free episode with our responses to some of the wonderful questions you all sent us about work and work-adjacent topics. Today, in our usual subscribers-only episode, we’re answering some of the more personal and personal-adjacent questions.
How do you make friends in your thirties? How do you stay friends when some of you are having kids, and some of you aren’t? What does feminist parenting look like when you have a son? How did we know our partners were “the ones”? And honestly, how can we continue to wear pants and feel stylish as 30-somethings? We discuss all this and more.
Thank you all so much for asking us so many delightful questions! We hope to do this again sometime. As we continue to figure out what this newsletter/podcast is and should be, we’re always trying to figure out the best mix of TV/movie coverage, cultural trend discussions, and personal conversations about our lifestyles, so let us know in the comments or our inbox what you’d like to see more frequently.
ShareWe’ve been reading…
Still working on “Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow,” because I read at a snail’s pace when I’m not on vacation. Too much TV to consume for the pods! -Emma
“I Never Promised You a Rose Garden,” the 1964 Joanne Greenberg novel I mentioned previously, which I finished over the last week. It fulfilled all the promises of Esmé Weijun Wang’s glowing foreword; I found myself constantly wanting to underline and annotate it because its observations about human experience are so sharp and well-formulated. The book follows a teenage girl battling schizophrenia through years of grueling treatments and psychoanalysis at a mental institution, emerging to a hard-fought recovery toward the end, and it is a deeply specific, revelatory book about those experiences. And like any very good, deeply specific book about a certain experience, it captures certain universal feelings all the more vividly. I highly recommend it. -Claire
We’ve been watching…
The new season of “Sister Wives,” after our fave Aubrey Gordon recommended it. True to her review, this season, which shows the slow dissolution of the polygamist Brown family, is a fascinating anthropological document, which explores relationship power dynamics, patriarchy, collective parenting and divorce. -Emma
In addition to the new season of “Sister Wives” (during which I have been reveling in everyone finally turning on Kody), “Reboot,” Hulu’s charming new show about a popular early aughts multi-camera sitcom that gets rebooted by an up-and-coming, edgy filmmaker (Rachel Bloom), who turns out to be harboring a very personal reason to reimagine the comfort-food TV staple as a more complex, daring show. The cast is exceptional (Keegan-Michael Key, Judy Greer, the list goes on), and I’m honestly just glad that we’re finally reckoning with Hollywood’s reboot addiction through the most vital medium of our time: streaming TV comedy. -Claire
We’ve been listening to…
The new season of Gimlet’s Heavyweight podcast. Host Jonathan Goldstein is just so smart and thoughtful, and manages to find the most beautiful and intimate stories to tell. Also, his voice is soothing AF. -Emma
Good Cult, a podcast about the personal development cult Lifespring (not yet mentioned in the podcast but an unfun fact: Ginni Thomas was in the group as a young woman and became an anti-cult activist after leaving… until, you know, she got into QAnon). Reported and hosted by River Donaghey, a journalist who grew up in a sort of unlicensed branch of Lifespring. His parents met in an offbrand version of the famous Lifespring organization called Wings and raised him attending its seminars — the podcast touches on his own family’s experiences and delves into the backstory of Lifespring, its leader, and the string of deaths and other disturbing outcomes linked to the intense, confrontational seminars the group offered. Need I say more? -Claire
We’ve been buying…
The most perfect slouchy trousers from Reformation. (I sized up for extra slouchiness, and got the pants in Stone Stripe, but they come in a bunch of colors and petites!) These are the pants that can do it all: go to the office, out for a nice dinner, or paired with chunky sneakers for a daytime fall stroll. -Emma
My Hill House fall order finally arrived, and I’m loving the botanical green crepe Ellie for fall — I do find it hard to layer cotton dresses for the colder months because of how the skirts cling to my tights. (Wait, is this why people wear slips? I’m going to look into this.) Also the Grandpa cardigan in navy. I know it’s pretty boxy for some people, but somehow I find it to be slouchy perfection, and I vastly prefer the pearl buttons to the usual gem-encrusted buttons they use. -Claire
Share Rich TextThis is the free edition of Rich Text, a newsletter about cultural obsessions from your Internet BFFs Emma and Claire. If you like what you see and hear, consider becoming a paid subscriber. Part 2 of this series will be released for paid subscribers on Monday. Rich Text is a reader-supported project — no ads or sponsors!
We asked you, our beloved audience, for questions a few days ago thinking that *maybe* we’d get enough to cobble together one podcast episode. But, as always, our community went above and beyond.
We got so many thoughtful, interesting, probing questions that we decided to break this Q&A into two episodes: One public episode (this one!!) released today, on work and career, podcasting, our favorite books, The Bachelor and other culture. The second part will go out on Monday for paying subscribers only, and will get a bit more personal, as we dig into questions about love and marriage, parenting, 30-something style, and friendship.
Thank you for your questions, and we hope you enjoy!
Give us feedback or suggest a topic for the pod • Subscribe • Request a free subscription
Planning a family reunion can be stressful, because there are so many ways it can go wrong. Someone gets too drunk. Someone gossips loudly about something they shouldn’t. A few key family members simply opt out altogether which gives everyone even more to gossip about! You know the kind of family we’re talking about… the one where everyone dates everyone else, and then some of them get engaged sight unseen, and then eventually all of them break up?
That kind of family. A reality television family.
That’s right, babies, we’re talking about the cast of the second season of Netflix’s ~experimental~ dating show, “Love Is Blind.” And because any family reunion is bound to be full of chaos, that’s exactly what the second 3-episode “After The Altar” special delivered.
In some ways, the whole thing was kind of a bummer. After all, weeks before the special dropped, both married couples — Iyanna and Jarrette, and Nick and Danielle — announced in quick succession that they would be divorcing. “After The Altar” provides some insight into why Iyanna and Jarrette may not have been fundamentally compatible, but Nick and Danielle’s split remains a mystery. We also see the ways in which on-screen conflicts and the audience reaction to season 2 can work to create festering resentment, which we see play out between Sal and Mallory (and Sal’s extremely-hot-theater-kid-energy new gf!), as well as Natalie and Shayne.
But it’s not all cringey sadness. There is always something comforting about checking in with characters (humans?) who you have grown to feel an affinity to. And we get some heartening updates from Deeps and Kyle… the semi-convincing will-they-or-won’t-they couple.
Either way, we knew what the task was for this viewing. We ranked these characters during the season, so we simply had a duty to check in with our feelings. Some people held steady in our BFF rankings, and others precipitously dropped. Plus, we have a new minor nemesis. Hope you enjoy the episode! xo
ShareWe’ve been watching…
I am officially obsessed with “Bad Sisters,” the new Apple TV series from Sharon Horgan (of “Catastrophe” brilliance). It’s an adaptation of a Swedish show about five sisters and their nightmare of a brother-in-law. After watching their sister become diminished in an emotionally abusive relationship — and after he enacts his own unique brand of torture upon each of his four sisters-in-law — the sisters decide to take matters into their own hands. Like John Tucker and Earl… John Paul has to die. The show is dark and comedic and full of raw insights on what it looks like to be a woman backed into a corner. -Emma
Season 2 of “Rutherford Falls,” the Peacock comedy about a Native museum curator (Jana Schmieding) who is passionate about preserving her people’s cultural heritage — but whose best friend (Ed Helms) happens to be a clueless scion of the white family that colonized the land generations ago. In season 1, their friendship, and the balance of power in the town, was turned upside-down after a podcaster comes to town and unearths secrets about the history between the town and the (fictional) Minishonka nation. Schmieding is fantastic as Reagan, the self-deprecating but ambitious curator, and it’s wonderful to see a fat, Native woman not only in a starring role, but at the center of an extremely charming love triangle. I didn’t realize it had been picked back up for a second season, but it’s a delightful, easy watch — “Parks and Rec” energy — and I’m glad to have it back in the rotation. -Claire
We’ve been reading…
Finally started Gabrielle Zevin’s “Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow,” and it turns out that the debut novel about two friends who meet as children and go on to become video game designers is just as good as everyone says it is. (Also… the gaming elements should not deter anyone who, like me, has zero interest in gaming.) -Emma
Friend of the pod Esmé Weijun Wang wrote the foreword to a new Penguin Classics edition of Joanne Greenberg’s “I Never Promised You a Rose Garden,” so I had to get it. The title was familiar, but I never knew anything else about the book until I heard about it from Esmé, and it’s absolutely fascinating. An autobiographical novel about a teenage girl, Deborah Blau, who is sent to a mental institution by her desperate parents, the book takes us deep into Deborah’s inner world of Yr, the fantasy realm she first retreated into and then felt trapped within. -Claire
We’ve been listening to…
The Mindy Kaling episode of Meghan Markle’s new Spotify podcast, “Archetypes.” She speaks openly about being an unmarried woman in her 40s, professional success, and more. It’s a really beautiful episode, and I have to shout out my BFF (and our OG Here To Make Friends producer!!!) Katelyn Bogucki who is the Executive Producer on the project. I recommend listening with a glass of wine and a good cry. -Emma
I’m just on my usual rotation this week! I think I might be running out of room in my listening schedule for new shows… -Claire
We’ve been buying…
I mean… is it any surprise? There was a new Hill House drop for the beginning of fall, and I snagged a few pieces I am super excited about, including this cozy Grandpa Cardigan in cream (the pearl buttons!!), this wrap skirt in pink (I have this in another pattern/fabric and I really love it), and this “Nap Top,” which I hope will be a good, slightly elevated layering piece, in the artists’ edition print. -Emma
A safety hair-cutting razor and Jayne Matthews’ DIY shag classes! Remember that early part of the pandemic, when everything was locked down and people were getting really into cutting their own hair and baking their own bread? I was a bit busy doing my own childcare and working at my own job and cooking my own meals and breastfeeding my own baby, so I just watched enviously on Instagram as people learned, from the hairstylist whose famous retro shags inspired my 2019 bangs revival, how to cut their own hair. And now, bitches, it’s my time. I watched, I hyperventilated, I awkwardly used a straight razor to “carve petals” into my hair. It is definitely edging closer and closer to mullet territory (because I CAN’T STOP) but I love how capable I feel and how proud (on good hair days at least) of what I have made. -Claire
Share Rich TextAs Netflix has turned its hand to mass-producing romantic comedies, there have been some truly delightful successes — movies that capture the sweetness, humor, brightness and sizzle of a ‘90s or ‘00s classic (“Always Be My Maybe,” “Set It Up,” and “Wedding Season” are among our favorites). But many of the platform’s romcoms are aiming more for the Hallmark Channel audience than the cinematic release one, and of those, the movies tend to fall into two categories: oddly melancholy, and intensely zany. It’s “A California Christmas” (mopey, muted colors, plot points revolve around someone dying of cancer) or “Love Hard” (pratfall-heavy, bright colors, plot points revolve around a kiwi allergy making someone’s face look puffy).
This week, entirely by accident, we ended up watching one of each. We chose to pair “Love in the Villa” with “That’s Amor” because they both featured sad American women healing from rejection by exploring a new culture and finding love with hot European men. As it turned out, “Love in the Villa” is the epitome of a zany romcom, with over-the-top comic escapades that should have ended with mutual restraining orders rather than true love, and “That’s Amor” is such a sadrom it’s almost mumblecore.
But the movies share a great deal of DNA: lonely, unlikable heroines who don’t know much about life outside their particular corners of the U.S., handsome heroes who spar with them and then fall in love with them, lessons in appreciating foreign cuisines, and, of course, everyone’s exes showing up to ruin things right when it seemed like true love was about to blossom.
On this episode, we recap every unsettling beat of “Love in the Villa,” followed by “That’s Amor.” We unpack the movies’ romcom tropes, analyze their romantic leads, and discuss the most jawdroppingly awful moments in each (no spoilers, but they involve potential police brutality and bad graphic design, respectively). Uncork a nice Barolo, slice your Spanish tortilla, and enjoy! xo
Share Rich TextWe’ve been reading…
Romcoms! I read and loved Elissa Sussman’s “Funny You Should Ask” after seeing Emma recommended it, and then tried Mia Sosa’s “The Wedding Crasher” and “The Worst Best Man,” which are the ultimate candy fluff reading (with some steamy scenes as the cherry on top). I also took a little break from my “Persuasion” reread to plow through “The Rabbit Hutch,” and now I’m savoring the last few chapters of Anne Elliot’s dramatic journey to find love — which, by the way, pair perfectly with the slight nip of fall we’ve had in the air lately. -Claire
I finally discovered the brilliance of Elin Hilderbrand’s Nantucket books? (I know, I know… I’m VERY late to the party.) I read “The Perfect Couple,” and then went right into “The Hotel Nantucket,” and wow do I love the breezy fun of these perfect summer novels. -Emma
We’ve been watching…
“Frozen”! Y’all, it happened! I’ve spent my adulthood saying I would watch each hot new kids movie with my own children, and my toddler is now old enough to sit and watch an entire movie. We resorted to this a couple times over the course of an end-of-summer daycare break that extended from the Wednesday before to the Tuesday after Labor Day (a week during which, funnily enough, we still had to work). I never caught a whole sitting, but finally I have managed to piece together what happens in “Frozen.” And not to be, like, so controversial but also so brave, but there are only two good songs in it? I was led to expect more. “Let It Go” does slap though — even more so with your two-year-old trying to sing along. -Claire
My boyfriend and I have gotten really into “Delhi Crime,” a Netflix India series in a mix of Hindi and English, which follows the Delhi police department’s attempts to solve inspired-by-real-life cases. Each season follows a different major case, and the show wisely does not idealize the police detectives at its center, and even dives headfirst into the ways policing can easily become a corrupting force. -Emma
We’ve been listening to…
The 1986 season of Slate’s history podcast One Year, which recently kicked off. Each episode takes on one event from that year, but it’s a smart mix of the most well-remembered events and the ones that have totally dropped out of the collective consciousness. This season has featured episodes about two things I had never really heard of: then-Pistons star Isiah Thomas’s quixotic “No Crime Day” campaign in Detroit, and a misbegotten TV special in which Geraldo Rivera promised to show audiences the hidden vault of Al Capone live on air. It also tells the story of the Challenger explosion through the eyes of the finalists who competed with Christa McAuliffe to be the first teacher in space, a perspective that made a more familiar story completely new (and still utterly horrifying). -Claire
Podglomerate’s new investigative podcast about literary scandals, Missing Pages! Hosted by literary critic Bethanne Patrick, Missing Pages re-explores stories about the publishing industry that you probably remember seeing headlines about, but may not recall all of the details. With the benefit of time, Patrick revisits scandals such as Caroline Calloway’s rise and fall, Kaavya Viswanathan’s alleged plagiarism, and the larger implications of Dan Mallory’s lies. It’s fascinating stuff, and very well-reported. Highly recommend. (Claire note: WHAT HOW HAVE I NOT HEARD OF THIS?? NEED!) -Emma
We’ve been buying…
Jeans. The glorious season of floaty dresses is coming to an end, and that means I’m re-entering the hell of finding a pair of jeans that I actually want to wear all day, every day. (Tights just aren’t a satisfying daily wfh option, given that I live with a cat who sheds white hair and refuses to let me trim her claws.) I tried a couple pairs of washed black jeans from Madewell, which has been driving me crazy with inconsistent sizing and fit for the past couple of years but will occasionally serve me up the perfect pant, and hit the jackpot with the curvy perfect vintage jean in lunar wash. (Sadly, the amazing promo discount I got seems to be over.) I’ve tried this same cut in a different wash that didn’t fit in the waist properly, but these? Perfect. Just hoping I can find an equally good everyday jean in a classic blue before spring comes again! -Claire
Skincare products! A handful of my very sweet friends gifted me a fancy facial for my birthday, which I went to this week. I hadn’t had anyone properly evaluate my skin in awhile, and I ended up buying a few of the products my esthetician recommended, including the Biologique Recherche Lotion P50 1970, which so many people swear by. It’s an exfoliating toner which also hydrates, and so far I am loving it. It’s a little pricey, but you only need to use a few drops at a time so I think it will end up lasting me a long time. I also had been looking for a cleanser which my sensitive, breakout-prone skin didn’t react poorly to, so I grabbed a bottle of the iS Clinical Cleansing Complex as well. -Emma
Share Rich Text“Selling the O.C.” almost has it all. It has the Oppenheim twins. Brittany Snow’s hot husband. Double-digit listings with infinity pools. Acres of cleavage sheathed in bandage dresses.
But it does lack a few key things — a protagonist, for example. Deliriously fun fashion. Any overt mention of the MAGA energy dripping from several of its main cast members. A clear and compelling narrative arc behind the chaotic and superficial drama that drives the season.
Naturally, as soon as we could get our grubby little hands on the first season of Netflix’s “Selling the O.C.,” baby sister to reality soap smash “Selling Sunset,” we watched every episode. And yes, there was some joy to be found in there, in ogling the garish, soulless modern palaces being flogged by the O Group and trying to unspool the threads of conflict behind each confrontation.
But so much of the show was lackluster compared to its big sister. The cast is mostly quite bland and, frankly, unlikable; it was actually surprising to realize how appealing many of the “Selling Sunset” agents actually are, despite the constant drama. Mary, Chrishell, Amanza, Maya, and even Heather look grounded and pleasant compared to their counterparts in Newport Beach, who are constantly in a competition to be more two-faced and nasty than their colleagues. The drama that ensues seems ginned up and shallow, perhaps in part because it is such a new office — most of these agents barely know each other. And yet the show didn’t manage to capture what conflict did happen onscreen; there’s always vague, poorly explained off-screen beef that translates into confusing, unsatisfying fights.
We discuss how the show’s characters and storylines disappointed us, as well as the show’s fashion (sexy conservative, á la Fox News host), real estate aesthetic (inside of a cruise ship) and much more in this week’s episode. Hope you enjoy! xo
ShareWe’ve been reading…
I’m nearing the end of Tess Gunty’s “The Rabbit Hutch,” which, as it unfolds, is digging more into some familiar sociopolitical questions: The #MeToo era and exploitative sexual relationships; life under the shadow of Trump; late capitalism and the distortions created by massive wealth and fame; and the void that once was, or could be, filled by religious faith and community. Two of her characters, in particular — the ethereal, anguished teenager Blandine Watkins and the troubled grown son of a famous TV star — give voice to aching screeds about the brokenness of the lives they’ve been given. Her pain involves loneliness, heartbreak; his also involves Morgellons disease, a controversial syndrome in which those afflicted claim to find fibers emerging from their skin. With increasing urgency, they try to find a religious, or at least quasi-religious, meaning to transmute their suffering into transcendence. This may sound plodding, but it’s actually a page-turner! -Claire
I have been ripping through some perfect beach reads during my vacay. I finished “The Arc,” which I loved, and then moved onto Elisa Sussman’s “Funny You Should Ask,” Jean Meltzer’s “The Matzah Ball,” and Lizzy Dent’s “The Setup.” Rom-coms in novel form? Inject them right into my veins. -Emma
We’ve been watching…
I just started Nathan Fielder’s new show, “The Rehearsal,” and I think I need a full week to recover from the first episode. Fielder is the creator and star of “Nathan For You,” a comedy reality show in which he would use his very slight business expertise to dream up unhinged strategies for struggling businesses. In “The Rehearsal,” he spends each episode guiding an ordinary person through an elaborate rehearsal process for a task they’ve been dreading; episode one featured a man who wanted to come clean to his bar trivia friends about his lack of a graduate degree after years of misleading them. The show builds an exact replica of the space in which the event will take place on a giant soundstage and casts actors to play anyone else who might be present. Fielder drills the guest star over and over again, intentionally introducing interruptions and unpleasant reactions so that there’s an effective script in place should that actually happen on the day in question. It’s social anxiety made manifest, an attempt to ward off one’s worst fears by making them concrete. I cried at the end of the first episode. That’s a recommendation, I think! -Claire
Honestly… nothing? Taking a little bit of a break from TV while I’m traveling. -Emma
We’ve been listening to…
Nothing new lately! -Claire
The “Scarsdale Diet Murder” episode of Maintenance Phase, featuring Sarah Marshall! I love this perfect Maintenance Phase / You’re Wrong About crossover event. -Emma
We’ve been buying…
The Tradlands Paloma pants in black! I love these pants, and am excited to transition them into fall — so imagine my excitement when they were marked down in the end-of-season sale! Now I’m just trying to resist getting them in olive as well. -Claire
Do hotel rooms count? I’ve been traveling these couple weeks, and just had the most wonderful stay at Waya Narbonne, on the Mediterranean coast of France. An absolutely sweet Dutch couple runs this low-key but elegant “domaine,” and it was a complete delight to stay there. Also… I did get an emerald gingham nap dress because I have an illness and the simple pattern is divine. -Emma
Share Rich TextNothing scratches that romcom itch for us better than a slightly absurd but well-executed comedy about two hotties who are just pretending to date… or are they? And while “Marry Me” fell completely flat, and “I Want You Back” was delightful but sizzle-free, Netflix has a new movie that truly delivers on the promise of a fake relationship romance: “Wedding Season.”
The premise, in brief: microfinancier Asha and startup guy Ravi are set up by their pushy parents, who long for each of their children to finally marry. To avoid matchmaking pressure during a summer of weddings, they agree to pretend that they’re an item… only to slowly fall for each other. There are yearning eyes, misunderstandings, secrets that come out at the most inopportune times, and above all, a happy ending.
What is it that makes Fake Dating the ideal romcom trope of our time? Why do we crave it? There are obvious advantages to the construction: It requires the leads to spend a lot of time onscreen together, enabling plenty of flirtation and doe-eyed wistful looks. It seamlessly transitions from a way to enforce togetherness between people with no other reason to hang out into a psychological barrier to starting a real romantic relationship (e.g. “we already agreed this is just pretend”). It’s also perfectly ludicrous, the kind of thing that pretty much never happens in real life and yet constantly happens in this specific genre. Like a superhero leaping over a skyscraper with a single bound, it assures us that the humdrum disappointments of every day life won’t be holding us back in this fictional escape.
But maybe it’s also a trope well-suited to a time when courtship seems more confusing than ever before and the process of dating to find a relationship is Sisyphean and baffling — swiping endlessly on the apps, going on promising first dates that go nowhere, getting ghosted, getting funneled into situationships. The Fake Relationship echoes another form of courtship, one that “Wedding Season” also considers: arranged marriage. Asha’s parents had one, and in a heart-to-heart late in the movie, Asha’s mother admits that she was heartbroken to be married to a man who wasn’t her choice. At first, she says, she pretended to love him. But then she realized it had become real. Asha’s mother wanted her daughters to choose their loves, but in the end, Asha also finds love by, at first, pretending to love someone. Overburdened by freedom, we have to imagine ourselves into romantic prisons in order to find our way to a person worth choosing freely.
In this episode, we talk about those parallels, break down all the absurd plot details, and revel in our favorite swoony details. Hope you enjoy! xo
ShareWe’ve been reading…
“The Rabbit Hutch” by Tess Gunty, a buzzy debut novel poised to meet a moment when the Catholic aesthetic and the slow decline of a capitalism-ravaged country are in the zeitgeist. It unfolds over a week in the fictional Indiana city of Vacca Vale, which is decades into a long decline after the bankruptcy and closure of the automobile company that made the town prosperous. Our heroine Blandine Watkins, an eccentric teenager obsessed with female Catholic mystics, has been spat out by the foster care system and left to cope with the end of an emotionally consuming affair with her high school theater director. The alienated, abandoned characters inhabit an alienated, abandoned city. Everyone is seeking an escape.
I actually picked up this book because of a personal connection: Gunty’s mom was my (wonderful) art teacher, and her brother was my elementary school classmate. The book is deeply informed by the pervasive Catholicism and post-Studebaker travails of our shared hometown, South Bend, and it’s fascinating to see how she grapples with them in her work. Also noted: a fair amount of jabs at the plans to revitalize Vacca Vale as a tech industry hub (*cough* Mayor Pete). Putting aside my indisputable hometown bias, “The Rabbit Hutch” sometimes strains a bit harder for showy prose than it needs to, but it’s an ambitious, imaginative, compelling meditation on the search for meaning in the wake of despoliation and decline. -Claire
I’m still making my way through “The Arc” (I am not on vacation, so I’m reading at a much slower clip) and I’m still really enjoying it. Excited to see if this thoroughly modern/app-dating-centric romantic novel sticks the landing. -Emma
We’ve been watching…
The upcoming Netflix reality show “Dated & Related,” which sounds more incestuous than it is. A modern mash-up of family-matchmaking cable reality shows like “Parental Control” and the new generation of villa-based, IG-model-populated, teeny-bikini-clad dating competitions like “Love Island,” this show features sibling pairs who are challenged to wingman and wingwoman (wingperson?) each other to true love. We’ve often advocated for more reality daters to come in paired with preexisting BFFs or confidants, and so it’s interesting to see this play out in the ensemble format! While it actually seems to help tamp down drama (hardly a reality TV producer’s goal), the relationships between the siblings (both same and mixed-gender duos, all pursuing hetero relationships) are genuinely sweet to watch. Please let me know if I should make Emma watch this for a pod! I’m ready!! -Claire
“Look Both Ways,” Netflix’s updated, much more rosy spin on “Sliding Doors,” starring Lili Reinhart as a young woman graduating college. In one life path, she has a one-night stand with her friend and gets pregnant. In the other, she doesn’t. It isn’t anything revelatory, but it’s a sweet movie and Reinhart shines. The lack of exploration of abortion as a viable option to an unplanned pregnancy feels really weird given where we are post-Roe, but otherwise it’s a lovely watch. -Emma
We’ve been listening to…
I’ve been in catchup mode lately. For a while, I wasn’t in the mood to listen to “Know Your Enemy,” Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell’s podcast on the intellectuals of the right, and I’m getting back in the groove with their most recent episodes on the terrifying Arizona Senate candidate Blake Masters and the historian Christopher Lasch and his cooptation by the new right.
Also, my favorite short-lived indie band of the aughts, Voxtrot, is reuniting for a small tour and putting out some new songs, so I’ve been reconnecting a bit with my angsty 20-year-old self. -Claire
The Kardashians episode of our bud Amanda Montell’s podcast “Sounds Like A Cult.” I love a sharp, smart conversation about traditionally low-brow fare, and this really delivers. -Emma
We’ve been buying…
This swingy prairie-girl minidress in the Madewell pre-fall sale. I essentially quit above-the-knee dresses cold turkey after my toddler was born, but now that he is a nimble walker and I’m rarely called on to bend all the way over in public anymore, I hear the siren song of the short skirt again — especially with the approach of fall and cozy tights. -Claire
This versatile black midi skirt from Pixie Market that a fashion influencer I follow who specializes in showing you how to remix classic pieces in your wardrobe #influenced me to buy. (I know, I know, I’m weak.) At least it was on sale? -Emma
Share Rich Text