After Shows

Only Show Fans

Join comedians and sisters-in-LAW Amanda Austin and Maggie Rieth Austin as they binge and then brief you on the best shows on streaming. Currently watching: THE WEST WING

Latest Episodes:

Ep 130: The Pitt-Season 1 Feb 13, 2026

Show notes

Recapping Season of The Pitt!

Amanda and Maggie are together again! Maggie makes a guest apperance in the Dallas studio and they have the most fun talking about the best show, The Pitt. They loved this "ER meets 24" medical drama. Very real. Very intense. Very exicted for Season 2. They talk about their favorite doctors and who they would and would NOT want to treat them from the cast of The Pitt. They even introduce a new character to the show: Aunti Chianti. (Brought to you by 1/2 priced bottles of wine at Cane Rosso on Wednesdays).

The Pitt is a must watch and you must watch it so you can follow along when they recap Season 2!

EP 129: All's Fair, Season 1-Part 2 Feb 03, 2026

Show notes

Reapping Season 1, Part 2 of All's Fair

There's nothing fair about the fact this show is actually on TV but it's 2026 and here we are. Amanda and Maggie discuss this show in detail, much to Amanda's dismay. Maggie tries to convince her of all the redeemding qualities of this show while the only thing Amanda can get on board with is a nice, monochromatic dress code that really pulls an outfit together. Amanda is still floored there will be a season 2, but she's committed to this podcast, and more importantly, her wonderful sister-in-law, so she will through. Turns out, All is not Fair when recapping tv shows for a famous podcast.

Ep 128: The Chair Company, Season 1-Part 2 Jan 23, 2026

Show notes

Recapping Season 1 of The Chair Company-Part 2. Back on their same bullshit for 2026 and here to recap the last half of this Tim Robinson tv treat. They talk about both the predictability and unpredictabilty of Season 1. They discuss who would be "banter" and who would be "bits" if they changed their name to "Banter and Bits." Amanda finally tells the story of the time she was wrongfully arrested. Maggie introduces her pitch for a new British Band: Sharing Dairy! They discuss the brilliance that is James (Jim) Downey, how why Maggie decided not to go to art school, and how they are both prepping for this big, winter snowmageddon!

If you're loving this content, please like, subscribe, and leave a review. It really helps them and they know you love to help!

EP 127: The Golden Globes Jan 18, 2026

Show notes

Recapping the 83rd annual Golden Globes

While Amanda and Maggie must have both missed their invites in the mail, they were still delighted to recap some of their favorite moments from this year's ceremony. They talk about Nikki Glaser and what a rock star she is, their favorite Globes looks, the shows that won, and all the new TV they have to add to their list. It's fair to say they're going to be very busy playing catch up with all the incredible shows out there. Join them in their campaign to #getthemtotheglobes next year. They've got sequin tops and soft pants ready to go!

Ep 126: When Harry Met Sally Dec 30, 2025

Show notes

Reviewing When Harry Met Sally

They may not remember where they where the first time they met this movie, but the girls do know they haven't met another film quite like it. One of the best films of our generation that culminates on New Years Eve, Nora Ephron's writing and Rob Reiner's directing couldn't be a better match. Amanda and Maggie talk about all the wonderful quotes and moments that come from this film, whether or not tiny finger tap shoes are the next billion dollar idea of theirs, and what it's like to be snowed in with over 2 feet of snow while recording! This was a movie for the ages and the best one to wrap up the year.

The recent and tragic loss of Rob Reiner and his wife Michelle is devastating. Thank you, Rob and Michelle, for all the wonderful moments you brought the silver screen. We are so grateful for you and your work and are thinking about your family during this time.

Ep 125: My Secret Santa Dec 17, 2025

Show notes

Reviewing My Secret Santa. It's no secret that the girls kinda liked this holiday film. Was it giving Mrs. Doubtfire meets problematic HR issues? Yes. Was it somewhat unbelievalbe and still charming? Yes. Does Amanda think the male lead is the Travis Tanner of Hallmark films? Obviously, yes. Amanda ad Maggie dish about their favorite moments from this holiday film that was ranked #1 on Netflix (on the day they watched it) and also gab about what it's like to have boring hair, how easy it would be for Amanda to date Glen Powell, and how the math isn't mathing on their listener to reviewer ratio. So, hey! If you like this podcast, don't forget to subscribe and PLEASE leave a review. It helps them soooo much, and it's the helping holiday season so help some girls out!

Up next week: A Very Merry Ex-mas

Ep 124: Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story Dec 09, 2025

Show notes

Reviewing Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story

Amanda and Maggie really nose their stuff in this epsiode. They talk about what it's like to get "work done", what it's like to be a Bills and/or a Cowboys fan. They also talk about what it's like to live in a helluva lot of snow and how not-so-acurate the clothing for negative wind chill temps. They even discuss where they'd set the scene for next year's version of the same film (or the same title!)

What did you think of this football festive film? Let them know!

Ep 123: The Beast in Me Dec 01, 2025

Show notes

Reviewing The Beast In Me.

Well if it isn't another psychological thriller that requires at least one hand basket, if not two, for viewing! Maggie and Amanda give their hot takes on this show with a star-studded cast. They discuss when it is and is not appropraite to go to the bathroom while on the phone, how to properly pronounce the name Lauren, and why everyone needs a show psychologist. They talk about how much creme brulee is truly enough and they pitch new Jennifer Garner and Patrick J. Adams to be the new stars of this now-rumored anthology. What did you think of The Beast in Me? DM them or send them an email, they wanna hear from you! Make sure to follow them on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube for all things TV and don't forget to like, subscribe, and leave a review on the podcast!

Ep 122: All's Fair, Season 1-Part 1 Nov 24, 2025

Show notes

Reviewing the epsiodes 1-4 of All's Fair...

Amanda gave in to Maggie's request to watch this "law procedural" starring none other than Kim Kardashian. As someone who barely keeps up with any of the Kardashians, this one was a stretch for Amanda. Maggie talks about all the redeemding qualities of this show while Amanda sides with most critics who genuinely can't stand it. It's truly a show unlike any other law procedural and they still have four more episodes to review very soon. What are your thoughts on this new (hopefully) limited series?

Ep 121: Nobody Wants This-Season 2 Nov 17, 2025

Show notes

Recapping Season 2 of Nobody Wants This

Nobody Wants This? Or does everybody want this? Amanda and Maggie want it. In fact, it's a show so nice they recorded it twice! They recap the entire second season of this "warm blanket rom com" and talk about the everything relatable and unreleatable about this show. They talk about how nobody on LinkedIn has any business talking about TV. They also have a very healthy debate about Talbots vs Casual Corner, whether or not they'd tell each other if their spanx were showing, and how dumb wedding dress sizes are. It's safe to say that when it comes to season 3, Amanda and Maggie totally want this.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Only Show Fans

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected