Payoff Pitch

Latest Episodes:

The Fresh Prop of L.A. | Fri MLB Best Bets Apr 24, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Mike Calabrese teams up with Derek Carty to break down the Friday's MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, F5 plays, player props, and a HR bet on a player who may or may not have a name that rhymes with Bill Sith. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

8 - 60-GRADE BETS

12 - 40-GRADE BETS

Check out the Action Network app and sign up for Action Pro for instant notifications from our top experts. Right now get $20 off an annual subscription with promo code POD20. Just follow this link to get started.

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

No, I Don't Want to 'Meet the Mets' | Tue Apr 21 Apr 21, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Collin Whitchurch and Tanner McGrath team up with Grant Neiffer to break down the Tuesday MLB slate. The crew dives into HR props, totals, and some ML plays including Collin's faith in a New York team who is better off forgotten. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

11 - 60-GRADE BETS

18 - GRANT'S HR BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

High Hits in The Rockies | Mon Apr 20 Apr 20, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Tanner McGrath to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into team totals, pitche props, overs in Dodgers-Rockies that hit different. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

12 - 60-GRADE BETS

17 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Three True Outcomes (All of Them Profitable) | Fri Apr 17 Apr 17, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Tanner McGrath & Derek Carty to break down the Friday's MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, F5 plays, player props, and bet on a player with three true outcomes that they hope will have a profitable return. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

15 - 60-GRADE BETS

24 - 40-GRADE BETS

30 - KALSHI PREDICTION OF THE DAY

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Checking the Doppler for Dingers | Tue MLB Best Bets Apr 14, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Sean Zerillo and host Mike Calabrese team up with Grant Neiffer to break down the Tuesday MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, totals, and some HR props that may be going yard with some nice weather scheduled for today according to MLB meteorologist Sean Zerillo. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

11 - 60-GRADE BETS

18 - GRANT'S HR BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Overs & (No) Outs | Mon MLB Best Bets Apr 13, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Sean Zerillo teams up with Mike Calabrese to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into a LOT of team totals & overs for today's slate. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

16 - 60-GRADE BETS

26 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Fading Dustin May's Flow | Fri MLB Best Bets Apr 10, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Tanner McGrath to break down the Friday's MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, F5 plays, player props, and Dustin May aesthetic. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

18 - 60-GRADE BETS

30 - 40-GRADE BETS

38 - POLYMARKET PREDICTION OF THE DAY

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Two Lefties Don't Make a Righty | Tue MLB Best Bets Apr 07, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Sean Zerillo and Collin Whitchurch team up with Grant Neiffer to break down the Tuesday MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, F5 plays, player props, and some HR props in a lefty vs lefty pitching matchup. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

14 - 60-GRADE BETS

41 - 40-GRADE BETS

44 - POLYMARKET PREDICTION OF THE DAY

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Late Night Bravery | Mon MLB Best Bets Apr 06, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Sean Zerillo and Collin Whitchurch team up to break down the Monday MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, F5 plays, player props, and more, including Collin remembering some guys like he's prone to do. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

23 - 60-GRADE BETS

44 - 40-GRADE BETS

48 - POLYMARKET PREDICTION OF THE DAY

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Betting on the Next Kyle Lohse | Fri MLB Best Bets Apr 03, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Sean Zerillo and Collin Whitchurch team up with Derek Carty to break down the Friday MLB slate. The crew dives into sides, totals, first five inning plays, player props, and more, while also mixing in some fun 2000s player comps tied to their favorite bets. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

2 - 80-GRADE BETS

18 - 60-GRADE BETS

47 - 40-GRADE BETS

51 - POLYMARKET PREDICTION OF THE DAY

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.