Payoff Pitch

Latest Episodes:

Over the Total and Under the Influence | Mon MLB Best Bets May 18, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Sean Zerillo to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, Totals, and a play on our host Collin after a standout drinking performance against the famed BBOC host Stuckey. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

11 - 60-GRADE BETS

25 - ACTION PRO TOP PROP PROJECTIONS

Check out the Action Network app and sign up for Action Pro for instant notifications from our top experts. Right now get $20 off an annual subscription with promo code POD20. Just follow this link to get started.

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Hoping for a Chappy Ending | Fri MLB Best Bets May 15, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Derek Carty to break down Friday’s MLB slate. The crew dives into home run plays, player props, and a HR prop on Matt Chapman we hope ends with a massive payout. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident picks and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in for their top plays, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

8 - 60-GRADE BETS

15 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Home Runs Are Illegal in Texas | Tue MLB Best Bets May 12, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Collin Whitchurch and Sean Zerillo team up with Grant Neiffer to break down the Tuesday MLB slate. The crew dives into their plays on the slate from totals to a HR props except for ones in Globe Life Field. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

15 - 60-GRADE BETS

19 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ryan Weathers Weathering The Weather | Mon MLB Best Bets May 11, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Sean Zerillo to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, Totals, and an under bet on Yankees/Orioles with Yankees pitcher Ryan Weathers coming back from feeling under the weather to pitch tonight. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

19 - 60-GRADE BETS

29 - ACTION PRO TOP PROP PROJECTIONS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The Unluckiest Hitter in Baseball | Fri MLB Best Bets May 08, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Collin Whitchurch and Sean Zerillo team up with Derek Carty to break down Friday’s MLB slate. The crew dives into home run plays, player props, and a HR prop on a player they have granted the title as the unluckiext hitter in the MLB. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident picks and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in for their top plays, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

14 - 60-GRADE BETS

20 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Always Bet Pete to Go Deep | Tue MLB Best Bets May 05, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting experts Collin Whitchurch and Sean Zerillo team up with Grant Neiffer to break down the Tuesday MLB slate. The crew dives into about 30+ plays they have on the slate from totals to a HR prop on the shows favorite hitter "Big Meat" Pete Alonso. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

15 - 60-GRADE BETS

28 - 40-GRADE BETS

35 - TOP PROJECTIONS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

A Bronx Tail | Mon MLB Best Bets May 04, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Sean Zerillo to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, strikeout props, and a bet from each of the guys on Yankees/Orioles that is too good to refuse. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

17 - 60-GRADE BETS

34 - 40-GRADE BETS

41 - ACTION PRO TOP PROP PROJECTIONS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Great Minds Fade Alike | Fri MLB Best Bets May 01, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Derek Carty to break down Friday’s MLB slate. The crew dives into home run plays, player props, and a shared bet they both landed on in Phillies vs. Marlins. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident picks and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in for their top plays, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

12 - 60-GRADE BETS

23 - 40-GRADE BETS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The 40-Year-Old Prop Virgin | Tue MLB Best Bets Apr 28, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Sean Zerillo to break down the Tuesday's MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, strikeout props, and Sean's first ever HR prop given out on the show you do NOT wanna miss. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

18 - 60-GRADE BETS

41 - 40-GRADE BETS

46 - ACTION PRO TOP PROP PROJECTIONS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The Kids Don't Know How Good Mark Prior Was | Mon MLB Best Bets Apr 27, 2026

Show notes

Payoff Pitch is back as Action Network betting expert Collin Whitchurch teams up with Sean Zerillo to break down the Monday's MLB slate. The crew dives into ML plays, strikeout props, and reminiscing on 2000's pitchers their producer wasn't even alive for. Using the MLB 20–80 scouting scale, they grade their most confident plays and highlight where they’re finding the most value across the board. Tune in to hear their top picks, insights, and how they’re attacking today’s slate. Subscribe to the Action Network YouTube page so you don't miss our live shows every Monday, Tuesday and Friday during the regular season!

1 - 80-GRADE BETS

24 - 60-GRADE BETS

38 - 40-GRADE BETS

41 - ACTION PRO TOP PROP PROJECTIONS

Click here to instantly tail some of the bets from today's episode with quick slips!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.