Oral Arguments of the Florida Supreme Court and Florida’s District Courts of Appeal
Brought to you by the Florida Sixth District Court of Appeal
php/* */ ?>
Oral Arguments of the Florida Supreme Court and Florida’s District Courts of Appeal
Brought to you by the Florida Sixth District Court of Appeal
Copyright: © Sixth District Court of Appeal
6th DCA - 6/19/25 - Grand Vista of Orlando Condo. Assoc., Inc. v. Singh - Case No. 23-3618
4th DCA - 6/17/25 - Goldstone, et al. v. Auston, et al. - Case No. 23-2426
4th DCA - 6/17/25 - SFR Services, LLC v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London - Case No. 24-0362
4th DCA - 6/17/25 - Aviation Performance Solutions, LLC v. Hinshaw & Culbertson, LLP, et al. - Case No. 24-0504
4th DCA - 6/17/25 - Loren v. State - Case No. 23-3154
4th DCA - 6/17/25 - Lawson v. State - Case No. 24-2477
3d DCA - 6/17/25 - T & G Locksmith Corp., et al. v. Granada Ins. Co. - Case No. 24-0916
3d DCA - 6/17/25 - Gomes v. Maniglia, et al. - Case No. 24-1719
3d DCA - 6/17/25 - Malek v. Malek, et al. - Case No. 24-0084
1st DCA - 6/13/25 - Shands Jacksonville Med. Center, Inc., et al. v. Chavez, et al. - Case No. 20-3605
4th DCA - 6/10/25 - Bembry v. State - Case No. 24-2173
3d DCA - 6/11/25 - Fuller v. The City of Miami, et al. - Case No. 24-1694
3d DCA - 6/11/25 - Warren v. State - Case No. 22-2022
5th DCA - 6/10/25 - Lewis v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co. - Case No. 24-1567
3d DCA - 6/10/25 - De Soleil South Beach Assoc. v. Perrin, et al. - Case No. 24-0707
3d DCA - 6/10/25 - Morejon-Blagoev v. State - Case No. 24-2051
3d DCA - 6/10/25 - Brock v. State - Case No. 24-393
2d DCA - 6/10/25 - Knowlton v. State - Case No. 24-0658
2d DCA - 6/10/25 - Coburn v. Davis, et al. - Case No. 24-0840
2d DCA - 6/10/25 - Stoudt v. Hildebrand - Case No. 24-1281
2d DCA - 6/10/25 - Wiggins v. Cates - Case No. 24-0859
2d DCA - 6/10/25 - Godwin v. Michelini - Case No. 24-2810
1st DCA - 6/10/25 - Rooms to Go Warehouse , et al. v. King - Case No. 24-1087
1st DCA - 6/10/25 - AK Land Title, LLC v. Hurd - Case No. 24-1319
1st DCA - 6/10/25 - Cuarezma Carmona v. Stocking Mgmt, LLC - Case No. 24-0028
2d DCA - 6/4/25 - ARC Global Invs., II, LLC, et al. v. Digital World Acquisition, et al. - Case No. 24-2364
2d DCA - 6/4/25 - State v. Fleur - Case No. 24-1292
2d DCA - 6/4/25 - Shaikh, et al. v. Waite - Case No. 24-0868
2d DCA - 6/4/25 - Bright v. Thomas - Case No. 24-2593
2d DCA - 6/3/25 - Thifault v. State - Case No. 24-1348
2d DCA - 6/3/25 - Schmidt, et al. v. Thobe, et al. - Case No. 24-0994
2d DCA - 6/3/25 - Paylan v. Times Publishing Co. - Case No. 23-0400
5th DCA - 6/3/25 - Mulero v. State - Case No. 23-3735
3d DCA - 6/3/25 - German Corp., et al. v. Rinella, et al. - Case No. 24-1075
4th DCA - 5/29/25 - Limousin v. State - Case No. 22-2914
4th DCA - 5/29/25 - Gorham v. State - Case No. 23-2436
6th DCA - 5/29/25 - Phlster, LLC, et al. v. The Bernstein Firm, LLC, et al. - Case No. 23-3806
4th DCA - 5/27/25 - Southern Waste Systems, LLC v. Waste Mgmt. Inc. of Fla. - Case No. 23-1865
4th DCA - 5/27/25 - Florida Custom Guns, LLC v. City of Dania Beach, FL - Case No. 24-1089
4th DCA - 5/27/25 - Thayer, et al. v. Hawthorn, et al. - Case No. 24-1273
4th DCA - 5/27/25 - Shah, et al. v. Patel, et al. - Case No. 24-1321
4th DCA - 5/27/25 - Wojtowicz v. State - Case No. 24-1492
6th DCA - 5/22/25 - Florida Assoc. of Realtors, et al. v. Orange County, Florida, et al. - Case No. 24-0548
6th DCA - 5/22/25 - Calderon v. State - Case No. 23-4158
5th DCA - 5/22/25 - Gabor v. Remington Lodging and Hospitality, LLC., et al. - Case No. 23-3183
5th DCA - 5/22/25 - Brent M. Huber, Inc. v. Allstate Inc. Co., et al. - Case No. 24-2589
5th DCA - 5/22/25 - Latone, et al. v. De Arce - Case No.24-2919
6th DCA - 5/13/25 - Brugal v. City of Naples - Case No. 24-4088
6th DCA - 5/13/25 - Folsom v. State - Case No. 24-0320
6th DCA - 5/13/25 - Buckley v. Geico Indemnity Co. - Case No. 24-0088
5th DCA - 5/20/25 - Kirby v. Kirby - Case No. 24-1024
2d DCA - 5/21/25 - Vogt, et al. v. Vogt, et. al. - Case No. 24-1318
2d DCA - 5/21/25 - Wendel v. Trustees of Mease Hospital, Inc. - Case No. 23-2182
2d DCA - 5/20/25 - Quay 1 and 9, LLC, et al. v. Block Condo. Assoc., Inc., et al. - Case No. 23-2631
2d DCA - 5/20/25 - Benjamin-Anderson v. U.S. Bank Trust Nat. Assoc. - Case No. 23-1530
2d DCA - 5/20/25 - Beck v. State - Case No. 24-1953
3d DCA - 5/20/25 - Ramon Int. Ins. Brokers, Inc., et al. v. Chaucer Syndicates Ltd, et al. - Case No. 24-971
3d DCA - 5/20/25 - Capozzi v. State - Case No. 23-1336
3d DCA - 5/20/25 - Holmes v. State - Case No. 24-174
2d DCA - 5/14/25 - Mid-America Apartments, Ltd., et al. v. Tracz - Case No. 24-1849
2d DCA - 5/14/25 - Simeonov, et al. v. Delgado - Case No. 24-0800
2d DCA - 5/13/25 - Koziak v. State - Case No. 24-0531
3d DCA - 5/14/25 - Diakiwski v. Craft Constr. Co. LLC, et al. - Case No. 24-0450
5th DCA - 5/13/25 - Schramm v. Adams Homes of Northwest Fla., Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-0445
5th DCA - 5/13/25 - Coon v. Walmart Stores East, LP - Case No. 23-3663
4th DCA - 5/13/25 - Columna, Inc. v. Cowart - Case No. 23-2861
3d DCA - 5/13/25 - Boca Aircraft Maintenance, LLC v. Fifteen Group Capital, LLC - Case Nos. 24-670 & 24-1296
3d DCA - 5/13/25 - Gibbs v. State - Case No. 23-1676
3d DCA - 5/13/25 - Barnes v. State - Case No. 23-2155
6th DCA - 5/1/25 - Lentz v. The School Board of Orange County, FL - Case No. 24-1281
2d DCA - 5/7/25 - Hourglass Entertainment, LLC v. NRG Invs., Inc. - Case No. 24-1251
2d DCA - 5/7/25 - Palm Garden of Sun City Center, LLC v. Estate of Julia D. Pavis - Case No. 24-1445
2d DCA - 5/7/25 - Engelin v. Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC - Case No. 24-0640
5th DCA - 5/6/25 - Neal v. State - Case No. 23-3589
5th DCA - 5/6/25 - West Volusia Hospital Auth. v. Volusia County, FL - Case No. 24-1670
5th DCA - 5/6/25 - Rodrigues v. Anderson, et al. - Case No. 24-0180
3d DCA - 5/6/2025 - Silva v. Tower Hill Signature Ins. Co. - Case No. 23-2082
3d DCA - 5/6/2025 - Abner v. Lyft Florida, Inc. - Case No. 24-479
3d DCA - 5/6/2025 - State v. Adams - Case No. 23-2305
2d DCA - 5/6/25 - Dove Inv. Corp. v. Bank of Am., N.A., et al. - Case No. 24-1882
2d DCA - 5/6/25 - Critical Intervention Services, Inc. v. Tampa Electric Co. - Case No. 24-1338
5th DCA - 4/24/25 - Bear Warriors United, Inc., et al. v. Fla. Dep't of Transportation, et al. - Case No. 24-0958
4th DCA - 4/29/25 - Isbell, et al. v. Bohrer - Case No. 23-3114
6th DCA - 4/23/25 - Randall Mechanical, Inc. v. The PHM Group, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-1249
2d DCA - 4/23/25 - Gorman v. Clearwater Beach Hotel, LLC - Case No. 24-0345
2d DCA - 4/23/25 - Tulsi v. Ramlagan - Case No. 24-0902
2d DCA - 4/22/25 - Simon v. Anheuser-Busch Companies, LLC, et al. - Case No. 23-2775
2d DCA - 4/22/25 - Blackshear v. Haynes - Case No. 24-0011
2d DCA - 4/23/25 - Florida Forever Roofing and Restoration, LLC v. Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp.- Case No. 24-1014
2d DCA - 4/22/25 - Krocka v. Public Storage, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-1022
4th DCA - 4/22/25 - Mastriana v. Brown Brothers Harriman Trust Co. - Case No. 24-0950
4th DCA - 4/22/25 - Mendelsohn, et al. v. Ecclestone, et al. - Case No. 23-2425
6th DCA - 4/17/25 - SFR Services, LLC v. Fla. Dep't of Financial Services - Case No, 23-1050
6th DCA - 4/17/25 - Winter Haven Hospital, Inc. v. Howland, et al. - Case No. 24-1015
6th DCA - 4/15/25 - Battaglia v. Battalia - Case No. 23-1658
6th DCA - 4/15/25 - Gipson v. State - Case No. 23-4087
2d DCA - 4/16/25 - Otis v. Thoratec, LLC, et al. - Case No. 24-0779
2d DCA - 4/16/25 - First Acceptance Ins. Co. v. Same Day Windshields, LLC - Case No. 24-2036
2d DCA - 4/16/25 - Rainone v. Organ, et al. - Case No. 23-2648
5th DCA - 4/15/25 - Scott v. Publix Super Markets, Inc. - Case No. 24-0949
4th DCA - 4/15/25 - Park Crossing Homeowners Assoc. Inc., et al. v. Suarez, et al. - Case No. 23-3116
4th DCA - 4/15/25 - Progressive Select Inc. Co. v. Gonzalez - Case No. 24-0677
4th DCA - 4/15/25 - Jackson v. Dupuis, et al. - Case No. 24-0558
4th DCA - 4/15/25 - Adar v. Carricarte - Case No. 24-1383
3d DCA - 4/15/25 - Garden State Holdings, LLC v. Shazbop, LLC, et al.- Case Nos. 23-2014 & 24-1113
3d DCA - 4/15/25 - Shaw, et al. v. Calles, et al. - Case No. 23-2133
3d DCA - 4/15/25 - Kalinina v. State - Case No. 23-2302
3d DCA - 4/15/25 - Suarez, et al. v. Alexander, et al. - Case No. 24-1850
3d DCA - 4/15/25 - 569 NW 54th Street, LLC v. City of Miami - Case No. 24-1473
2d DCA - 4/15/25 - Florida Forever Roofing and Restoration, LLC v. Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp. - Case No. 24-0971
2d DCA - 4/15/25 - Yoksich v. Tally, et al. - Case No. 23-2678
2d DCA - 4/15/25 - Souders v. Suarez Trucking FL Corp. - Case No. 23-2211
2d DCA - 4/15/25 - Manhattan Avenue, LLC v. The City of Tampa - Case No. 24-2631
1st DCA - 4/10/25 - Nolan v. Orange County Public Schools/USIS - Case No. 23-1555
2d DCA - 4/9/25 - Nationwide Ins. Co. of Am. v. Auto S America, LLC - Case No. 24-1635
2d DCA - 4/9/25 - Kapila v. EFO Laser Spine Institute, Ltd. - Case No. 24-0234
2d DCA - 4/8/25 - Wick v. A-Action Mortgage Co., et al. - Case No. 24-0889
2d DCA - 4/8/25 - Lutheran Services Florida, Inc. v. Davis - Case No. 24-0912
2d DCA - 4/8/25 - Carroll v. State - Case No. 24-2719
2d DCA - 4/8/25 - Maldonado v. State - Case No. 23-2052
5th DCA - 4/8/25 - Surin v. English - Case No. 23-2944
5th DCA - 4/8/25 - Ramos-Figueroa v. State - Case No. 24-0770
3d DCA - 4/8/25 - Gomez v. State - Case No. 23-951
3d DCA - 4/8/25 - Dorta, et al. v. Perez, et al. - Case No. 24-1365
3d DCA - 4/2/25 - Edelstein v. Sulzberger, et al. - Case No. 23-2262
3d DCA - 4/2/25 - Husarek v. State - Case No. 23-1645
3d DCA - 4/2/25 - Steinmetz v. Pickholtz, et al. - Case No. 24-417
1st DCA - 4/2/25 - Kennedy, et al. v. Peardon, et al. - Case No. 24-0574
1st DCA - 4/2/25 - Johnson v. Johnson, et al. - Case No. 24-1139
6th DCA - 3/25/25 - Fleck, et al. v. First Amer. Title Ins. Co. - Case No. 24-1175
6th DCA - 3/25/25 - Geico Indemn. Co. v. Innovative Open MRI of Pensacola, LLC - Case No. 23-3421
2d DCA - 3/26/25 - Mayer v. State - Case No. 23-2071
2d DCA - 3/26/25 - Schmidgt Invs. of South Fla, LLC, et al. v. A.G. Development Group, Inc. - Case No. 24-0988
2d DCA - 3/25/25 - Clarke v. J.F. Sink & Sons, Inc. - Case No. 24-0446
2d DCA - 3/25/25 - Stergis v. Woodbridge at Carrollwood Condo. Assoc., Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-1448
2d DCA - 3/19/25 - ARC Global Invs., II, LLC, et al. v. Digital World Acquisition, et al. - Case No. 24-1780
2d DCA - 3/19/25 - Vazquez, et al. v. Safepoint Ins. Co. - Case No. 23-2567
2d DCA - 3/19/25 - Zoble v. Kensington Estates Homeowners - Case No. 23-2625
4th DCA - 3/25/25 - Condo. Assoc. of Golf Villas II, Inc. v. Fla. Ins. Guar. Assoc., Inc. - Case No. 24-1058
4th DCA - 3/25/25 - Castro v. State - Case No. 24-2358
6th DCA - 3/27/25 - Lipsey v. Francis - Case Nos. 23-4292 & 23-4293
4th DCA - 3/18/25 - Kuehne + Nagel, Inc. v. OJ Commerce LLC - Case No. 23-2744
4th DCA - 3/18/25 - Fleming v. State - Case No. 24-0623
6th DCA - 3/18/25 - Thakkar, et al. v. Good Gateway, LLC, et al. - Case Nos. 23-1545 & 23-1546
6th DCA - 3/18/25 - Marin v. Nemours Children's Hospital - Case No. 24-1080
6th DCA - 3/18/25 - Walgreen Co. v. Pappalardo, et al. - Case No. 23-3091
3d DCA - 3/18/25 - Kaster Linch Farrar & Ball LLP v. Clyde & Co U S LLP - Case No. 23-1747
3d DCA - 3/18/25 - Robinson v. State - Case No. 23-1254
6th DCA - 3/13/25 - Penton v. State - Case No. 23-3992
6th DCA - 3/13/25 - Melrose Ventures, LLC, et al. v. Uptempo Marketing Corp., et al. - Case No. 23-3824
2d DCA - 3/12/25 - Vasilakou-Emmenegger v. The Bank of New York Melton, et al. - Case No. 23-2606
2d DCA - 3/12/25 - Stalley v. Garisto - Case No. 24-2232
2d DCA - 3/12/25 - Johnson, et al. v. One Blood, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-1682
2d DCA - 3/11/25 - Deutsche Bank Nat. Trust Co. v. Del Callego, et al. - Case No. 24-1696
2d DCA - 3/11/25 - MHC Cortez Village, LLC v. Cortez Road Invs. and Finance, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-1834
2d DCA - 3/11/25 - Custom Homes by Triumph, LLC v. Sverdlow, et al. - Case No. 24-0148
4th DCA - 3/6/25 - Reaves v. State - Case No. 24-1306
4th DCA - 3/6/25 - Martinez v. City of Lantana, Florida - Case No. 24-1187
4th DCA - 3/6/25 - Paul v. State - Case No. 23-2680
4th DCA - 3/6/25 - State v. Sierra - Case No. 23-2736
3d DCA - 3/5/25 - 84 Shopping Plaza Corp., et al. v. Bru's Room Bird Road LLC - Case No. 23-1205
5th DCA - 3/4/25 - Ryan v. State - Case No. 23-1479
3d DCA - 3/4/25 - Mascato Corp. v. Mutchnik Constr. Group, Inc., et al. - Case Nos. 24-91, 24-787 & 24-851
3d DCA - 3/4/25 - Anderson v. Florida Power & Light, et al. - Case No. 23-1471
2d DCA - 2/25/25 - Stevens, et al. v. Fla. Peninsula Ins. Co. - Case No. 24-0253
2d DCA - 2/25/25 - Golub v. Neff-Golubo - Case No. 24-0813
2d DCA - 2/25/25 - Smith v. The School Board of Hillsborough County, Florida - Case No. 23-2315
2d DCA - 2/25/25 - Kirkpatrick Price, Inc. v. Clone Systems, Inc. - Case No. 24-1170
2d DCA - 2/25/25 - Florida Homeowner Equity, et al. v. Fairchild - Case No. 24-1332
2d DCA - 2/19/25 - Tillman Nature Preserve, LLC v. Babush, et al. - Case No. 24-1264
2d DCA - 2/19/25 - Belcher v. State - Case No. 23-0972
2d DCA - 2/19/25 - McGee v. McGee - Case No. 24-1447
2d DCA - 2/19/25 - Scheller v. Hall, et al. - Case No. 24-0266
5th DCA - 2/18/25 - Washington v. State - Case No. 24-0765
5th DCA - 2/18/25 - Brevard Constr. Co. v. Mallory - Case No. 24-0536
5th DCA - 2/18/25 - Waters v. State - Case No. 23-3675
4th DCA - 2/18/25 - Stein v. Langer, et al. - Case No. 24-1682
4th DCA - 2/18/25 - Antezana, et al. v. Kimley-Horn Associates, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-0486
2d DCA - 2/18/25 - Northrop, et al. v. Sig Sauer, Inc., et al. - Case No. 24-0869
2d DCA - 2/18/25 - Hamelin v. Hamelin - Case No. 24-1156
2d DCA - 2/18/25 - Cisneros v. Havens, et al. - Case No. 24-2173
2d DCA - 2/18/25 - BE-! Concepts Holdings, LLC v. CCKG, LLC - Case No. 23-1802
3d DCA - 2/19/25 - BRP-Rotax GMBH & CO KG v. Ciccolini - Case No. 23-1215
3d DCA - 2/18/25 - Ferguson v. The Republic of Trinidad and Tobago, et al. - Case No. 23-880
3d DCA - 2/18/25 - Fontainebleau Florida Hotel LLC, et al. v. Westchester Surplus Lines Insurance Company, et al. - Case No. 23-1264
3d DCA - 2/18/25 - Tung, et al. v. The Republic of Trinidad and Tobago, et al. - Case No. 23-887
3d DCA - 2/18/25 - Progressive Am. Inc. Co. v. Gonzalez, et al. - Case No. 23-2247
1st DCA - 2/14/25 - Allstate Fire and Cas. Inc. Co. v. Rosenbloom, et al. - Case No. 23-3363
SC2024-0883 In Re: Amendments to Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.132SC2023-1184 Marcus Roland Maye v. State of FloridaSC2024-0232 Michael Lawrence Woodbury v. State of Florida & SC2024-1127 Michael Lawrence Woodbury v. Secretary, Dept. of CorrectionsSC2023-1498 Darious Wilcox v. State of Florida & SC2024-0785 Darious Wilcox v. Secretary, Department of Corrections
SC2024-0317 In Re: Amendments to Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure
This case concerns proposed changes to the Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, as submitted to the Court in a report from The Florida Bars Appellate Court Rules Committee. In part, the proposed amendments would provide civil or criminal defendants with a right to bring an interlocutory appeal from an order denying a claim of Stand Your Ground immunity.
SC2023-0915 JJJTB, Inc. v. Stephen V. Schmidt, et al.
JJJTB seeks review of a Second District Court of Appeal decision in a foreclosure case. Other courts of appeal decisions conflict on the issue of whether certain jurisdictional issues can be waived.
SC2024-0096 Michael H. Hunt v. State of Florida
Hunt was convicted and sentenced to death in the 2019 murder of Alexandra Peck in Panama City. He raises six issues here in a direct appeal of his conviction and sentence.
SC2023-1298 Michael James Jackson v. State of Florida
Jackson was originally sentenced to death for the 2005 murders of James and Carol Sumner that began with robbery and kidnapping in their Jacksonville home. Jackson’s death sentences were later vacated. At his 2023 resentencing, Jackson was again sentenced to death for the murders. Jackson now raises 14 issues challenging his 2023 resentencing.
SC2023-0593 Christopher Allen Pryor v. State of Florida
Pryor appeals his life sentence as a violent career criminal in possession of a firearm, seeking resolution of the district court’s ruling in conflict with other appellate decisions. Also at issue is whether escape from a juvenile detention facility counts as a qualifying offense under the violent career criminal statute.
SC2023-0807 Juan Javier Oquendo v. State of Florida
Oquendo appeals his manslaughter conviction on the basis of conflicting opinions from the district courts of appeal concerning the admissibility of evidence of post-traumatic stress disorder in a self-defense claim and the related jury instructions.
SC2023-1662 Scottie D. Allen v. State of Florida & SC2024-0543 Scottie D. Allen v. Secretary, Dept. of Corrections
Allen was convicted of and sentenced to death for the 2017 first-degree murder of his cellmate at the Wakulla Correctional Institution. This Court upheld Allen’s conviction and death sentence on direct appeal. Allen then filed a postconviction motion seeking to vacate his conviction and sentence. The trial court denied that motion. Allen now appeals the trial court’s denial. Allen also petitions this Court for a writ of habeas corpus.
SC2023-1476 Mesac Damas v. State of Florida
Damas was convicted and sentenced to death for murdering his wife and five minor children in 2009. This Court affirmed Damas’s conviction and sentences in 2018. Damas moved to vacate his conviction and sentences in postconviction proceedings, raising four claims. The postconviction court denied Damas’s motion. This is his appeal.
SC2023-0988 Citizens of the State of Florida, etc. v. Florida Public Service Commission
The Office of Public Counsel (OPC) appeals the final order and the clarifying final order of the Public Service Commission (PSC) in a rate case filed by Florida City Gas, a subsidiary of Florida Power & Light Company. OPC challenges the PSC’s approval regarding reserve requirements, depreciation, and the continued acquisition adjustment.
SC2023-0320 Mark H. Wilson v. State of Florida
Wilson challenges his death sentences in the 2020 Putnam County murders of two boys, brothers of his girlfriend’s sister with whom they were living. He raises 11 issues in this appeal.
SC2023-1000 Donald Otis Williams v. State of Florida
Williams was convicted of first-degree murder in the 2010 Lake County murder of Janet Patrick. The trial court sentenced Williams to death after the jury recommended the death penalty by a 9-3 vote. In 2017, this Court affirmed Williams’s convictions but reversed his death sentence and ordered a new penalty phase. After being resentenced to death in 2023, Williams now appeals his death sentence and raises four issues