Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Hour 1: Jets Could Hit Draft Jackpot as Packers Collapse Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

The Jets may be sitting on a draft gold mine. Green Bay’s ugly performance has Evan Roberts dreaming about the Packers’ first-round pick, and with Indianapolis also struggling, the Jets could find themselves armed with multiple premium selections. Evan and Tiki Barber debate just how realistic the draft jackpot could become while still keeping the focus on winning now. The Giants conversation turns to life with Jameis Winston after Jaxson Dart’s injury. Shaun Morash pushes back on the idea that Giants fans should simply move on, while Evan doubles down on his comparison to the 2015 Jets and Ryan Fitzpatrick. They debate what would actually make this season successful, whether winning with Winston would strengthen the Giants’ future around Dart, and why Sunday’s matchup should lean heavily on the running game.

Hour 2: Yankees Face Tough Choices After Sabathia Ceremony Shift Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

CC Sabathia’s long-awaited Yankees ceremony gets thrown into chaos by the weather, forcing the team to move the celebration to Friday afternoon. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber understand why Saturday’s game had to be moved, but they question whether squeezing the ceremony into a difficult time slot is the best way to honor Sabathia and the fans who bought tickets specifically for the occasion. The conversation also turns to the Jets’ difficult matchup with Detroit, where Aidan Hutchinson and the Lions’ pass rush could put major pressure on the offensive line. Plus, what the Jets need to do offensively to bounce back, what Jameis Winston must show for the Giants against Tennessee, and why life without Jaxson Dart has hit Giants fans so hard.

Hour 3: Yankees’ Wild Card Rotation Could Define Their October Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees could make the unconventional call to start Max Fried in Game 1 against Boston and save Cam Schlittler for Game 2. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the second game of a best-of-three may actually be the most important, how the Yankees’ pitching depth gives them flexibility, and whether Aaron Boone should simply embrace Schlittler as his ace. The Giants also face a major test against Tennessee as their pass rush struggles to make an impact and Andrew Thomas works toward a return. Plus, new information emerges about why CC Sabathia’s ceremony stayed on Friday, and Shaun Morash finds a surprising reason to believe the Giants’ season may still have life.

Hour 4: Evan and Tiki Slam Nicolas Cage for His John Madden Impression Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber evaluate the potential for the Giants to move on from Daniel Jones in favor of a trade for Joe Burrow. They also discuss Jordan Love's early-season struggles, the Yankees' mathematical consistency, and the viral trailer for the John Madden biopic starring Nicolas Cage. The conversation shifts to a full slate of Week 3 NFL picks and the weekly Idiots with Idioms blooper reel.

(00:01:50) NFL Game Predictions

(00:05:20) Daniel Jones Trade Discussion

(00:08:45) Jordan Love Analysis

(00:13:40) Pro Football Injury Report

(00:17:00) Yankees Win Total Predictability

(00:23:00) Nicolas Cage Madden Reaction

(00:30:30) Idiots with Idioms Segment

(00:35:55) Week 3 NFL Picks

(00:48:05) Jalen Brunson SNL Appearance

Friday Full Show: The Giants and Jets Prep For Fascinating Week 3's Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

Brutal weather is rolling in, the Giants get set to play with Jameis, the Jets get set for the Lions, and the Yankees and the CC Ceremony get moved

Shaun Morash Finds New Hope for Giants Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

A major twist emerges in the controversy surrounding CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony. The Yankees told the show they offered Sabathia and his family the opportunity to move the celebration to next season, but CC requested that it remain Friday. That changes where the blame falls, although frustrated fans who bought Saturday tickets still want answers about refunds. Then Shaun Morash talks himself into a new sliver of hope for the Giants, comparing their current situation to the unlikely 2022 playoff team. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the comparison as the debate turns into whether Jameis Winston, a strong running game and improved coaching could somehow keep the season alive.

Giants’ Pass Rush Has Become a Massive Problem Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

The Giants’ defensive front has been shockingly ineffective, and Tiki Barber can’t understand why a unit loaded with pass-rushing talent is near the bottom of the league at generating pressure. With Brian Burns potentially unavailable and Kayvon Thibodeaux among the players who need to produce more, Sunday against Tennessee could reveal what kind of Giants season this will become. The conversation also turns to John Harbaugh bringing longtime Baltimore assistant Jerry Rosburg onto the practice field after questionable game-management decisions. Plus, the Yankees’ limited Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway creates another headache for fans after the schedule change.

Yankees Should Save Cam Schlittler for Game 2 Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

Cam Schlittler may be the Yankees’ ace, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe that could be exactly why he belongs in Game 2 against Boston. They debate why the second game of a best-of-three can carry the most weight, how Max Fried fits into the Game 1 plan, and why the Yankees’ three-ace rotation gives them options most teams simply do not have. Plus, Garrett Crochet could become a dangerous weapon out of the Red Sox bullpen, and the Yankees take heat over the handling of CC Sabathia’s ceremony and frustrated ticket holders.

CC Sabathia Honor Gets an Awkward Reschedule Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony is moved to Friday afternoon because of the weekend weather, leaving many fans frustrated after buying Saturday tickets specifically to see him honored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the game itself had to be rescheduled, but wonder whether the ceremony should have been moved to a future date instead. They also get into the confusion surrounding the Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway and ticket refunds, while emphasizing that Sabathia’s career deserves a proper celebration with fans able to be there.

Yankees Reschedule Complicates CC Sabathia’s Big Honor Sep 25, 2026

Show notes

CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony is suddenly moved to Friday afternoon because of the weekend weather, creating frustration for fans who bought Saturday tickets specifically to see him honored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the game needed to be rescheduled, but question whether the ceremony should have been pushed to a future date instead of squeezed into a difficult time slot. They also break down the complications surrounding the Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway, ticket refunds and the challenge of properly honoring Sabathia on short notice. Evan and Tiki understand the Yankees were forced into a tough situation, but believe CC and the fans deserved a smoother solution.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected