Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Jameis Winston Must Bring the Giants Back to Life Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury has crushed the optimism surrounding the Giants, and some fans are already waving the white flag. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that the season is over, arguing that Jameis Winston still has enough around him to keep the Giants competitive if he can deliver. The bigger loss may be the excitement Dart created. Giants fans finally thought they were getting answers about their young quarterback, and now that development is frozen for the rest of the season. With Winston taking over, the Giants face a very different season and a fan base desperate for any reason to believe again.

Karl-Anthony Towns Could Be Entering His Final Knicks Season Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Karl-Anthony Towns and the Knicks have hit an impasse in extension talks, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying the idea that it creates a cloud over their championship defense. The real question comes after this season: will Towns take a major discount to help the Knicks stay under the second apron, or could this ultimately be his final year in New York? Then the focus shifts to Jameis Winston and the massive opportunity created by Jaxson Dart’s injury. Tiki Barber lays out what the Giants must change offensively to help Winston succeed, while Evan argues this may be Jameis’ last legitimate chance to fulfill his dream of becoming a Super Bowl starting quarterback.

Yankees Face a Brutal Aaron Judge Decision Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge belongs in the Yankees’ postseason lineup if he’s healthy enough to play, regardless of how well the team performed without him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that the Yankees should simply stick with the players who carried them during Judge’s absence, pointing to the impact their captain still brings and the central question of whether his return makes them better. Meanwhile, Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham are nearing potential postseason returns, but neither should automatically reclaim a starting job. Evan and Tiki see Stanton as a dangerous right-handed power bat off the bench, while Spencer Jones has done enough to keep his place in the lineup.

Aaron Judge Refuses to Sit Out October Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge isn’t backing away from the risk of returning for the Yankees’ postseason run. Judge says the future isn’t guaranteed and he’ll do whatever he can to get back, sparking a debate over why this October opportunity is too important to pass up. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber also consider whether the possibility of a lengthy MLB lockout could factor into Judge’s willingness to push through his calf injury. The conversation then shifts to the Giants’ quarterback situation behind Jameis Winston. Callers float potential lottery tickets, including Jalen Milroe and Zach Wilson, while Evan argues that losing a starting quarterback doesn’t automatically mean the season is over.

Aaron Judge Is Calling His Own Shots Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge is determined to return for the Yankees’ Wild Card series, but playing through a calf strain could come with a frightening risk. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge should push to play, how concerned the Yankees should be about a potential Achilles injury, and whether another week of recovery could make a difference.

Giants Quarterback Search Could Take a Wild Turn Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

The Giants need another quarterback after losing Jaxson Dart, but how aggressive should they get? A caller proposes trading for J.J. McCarthy, launching a debate over whether New York should sacrifice draft capital for a young quarterback with upside or simply add an available veteran behind Jameis Winston. Jimmy Garoppolo emerges as a logical possibility, while names like Anthony Richardson, Joe Milton and Pittsburgh’s young quarterbacks enter the conversation as potential lottery tickets. Aaron Rodgers even gets floated if Pittsburgh’s season falls apart, but that idea is quickly rejected as the Giants weigh the difference between finding immediate insurance and taking a chance on someone who could have a future in New York.

John Harbaugh Is Already Talking Giants Playoffs Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh isn’t ready to surrender the Giants’ season. His decision to say Jaxson Dart is out for the “regular season” sparks a debate over whether Harbaugh was deliberately sending a message that he still expects his team to be playing in January. With Jameis Winston taking over, Tiki Barber explains why the Giants must reshape their offense and lean into a physical downhill running game instead of trying to replicate what worked with Dart. The conversation also turns toward Dart’s long-term recovery, the concern surrounding his meniscus injury and why the Giants need to spend this season proving their young core can become the foundation of a contender.

Giants Must Prove They Can Win Without Dart Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart is done for the regular season, but the Giants’ season doesn’t have to die with him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what New York should expect with Jameis Winston taking over, including whether a veteran quarterback can still lead this team to eight, nine or even more wins. Evan points to the 2015 Jets and Ryan Fitzpatrick as proof that losing a young quarterback doesn’t automatically destroy a season. The conversation gets heated over whether wins and losses should remain the Giants’ ultimate measuring stick or whether the focus should shift toward the development of young building blocks like Abdul Carter and Malik Nabers.

Player and Fan Reactions on Hiring of Andy Green | 'Rico Brogna' Sep 24, 2026

Show notes

The Andy Green hiring has been a mix reaction. Evan weighs in on player reactions along with emailer reactions.

Wednesday Full Show: The One where Jaxson Dart's Season is Over Sep 23, 2026

Show notes

On an emotional episode Evan and Tiki discuss why the Giants' season isn't over despite the worst case news surrounding Jaxson Dart, while Morash can't buy in. Oh and the Mets have a manager.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected