Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Yankees Catch Massive Break on Pete Alonso Blast Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees survived a massive Pete Alonso scare in Baltimore when his towering shot was ruled foul, a call Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe completely changed the game. They credit the Yankees for taking advantage and finishing off a 5-3 win, but the controversy raises a bigger question about why MLB still cannot definitively judge fair-or-foul home runs with modern technology. Evan and Tiki call for taller foul poles, better camera angles and even new tracking technology to eliminate the guesswork. They also debate whether Alonso still cares about making headlines in New York, while the Orioles broadcast pours gasoline on the rivalry by mocking Mets fans after his earlier home run.

Wednesday Full Show: Mets Under Fire, Giants Trade, Yankees Stay Hot and the Jets Fall Flat Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees keep winning, but almost nothing about it feels comfortable. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down encouraging injury news on Max Fried, the slow road back for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, Jazz Chisholm’s growing struggles, and whether this battered Yankees roster can finally get healthy enough to become dangerous in October. The Mets bring a different kind of frustration after Fernando Tatis Jr. robbed Francisco Lindor, sparking a wild debate over whether fans in the front row have an obligation to help their team. Steve Cohen’s comments on the Mets’ disappointing season ignite another examination of David Stearns, the decision to move on from Pete Alonso and Cohen’s admission that the organization may have taken too much risk. Evan and Tiki also debate the dangers of massive free-agent contracts, Geno Smith’s need for preseason reps and Evan’s grim Jets prediction, plus George Lombard Jr., the Nets’ painful history, NYCFC fandom, Citi Field’s mysterious concession lines and a prediction of a brutal baseball work stoppage.

Hour 1: Yankees Injuries Turn Every Win Into a Grind Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees keep winning, but nothing about it feels comfortable. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into another stressful victory, Aaron Judge’s slow progress toward a return, Giancarlo Stanton’s recovery and why Max Fried’s latest IL stint sounds more precautionary than disastrous. They also debate whether the Yankees deserve credit for surviving an injury-riddled season or criticism for barely playing .500 baseball despite dominant pitching. Jazz Chisholm’s slump and defensive mistakes are becoming harder to defend, while Trent Grisham suddenly delivers the offense New York desperately needs. Plus, Fernando Tatis Jr.’s robbed grand slam sparks a wild debate over whether Mets fans sitting in home run territory failed their team, Evan declares the Mets finished, and the conversation shifts to the Nets, Giants, Cowboys and whether Tiki could survive one more NFL game.

Hour 2: Geno Smith Has to Prove It Right Now Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Geno Smith needs real preseason work, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the Jets cannot afford to ease him into the season. With Smith learning another new offense, they argue he needs reps with the starters, a chance to establish himself as the offensive leader, and enough game action to be ready for Week 1. They also debate whether strong play from Cade Klubnik could eventually create pressure at quarterback. The Yankees could have another bullpen weapon coming in Luis Gil, while George Lombard Jr.’s remarkable defense continues to turn heads. Evan also unloads on the Mets over Jorge Polanco, Ronny Mauricio and the decision to move on from Pete Alonso, while the conversation hits Paul Goldschmidt’s decline, fan interference, and even the New York Red Bulls.

Hour 3: Steve Cohen Backs David Stearns Despite Mets Missteps Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

The Dodgers are under the microscope as Mark Walter faces a federal criminal investigation, raising fresh questions about the franchise’s financial power and the advantages that have allowed Los Angeles to keep spending aggressively. The conversation turns to whether anything could actually threaten the Dodgers, why their biggest free-agent misses barely slow them down, and the fantasy scenario rival fans would love to see if ownership were ever forced to sell. Steve Cohen also addresses the Mets’ trade deadline and makes it clear he remains committed to David Stearns despite questionable offseason decisions. Plus, the Yankees’ biggest American League threats are ranked, with Boston, Tampa Bay and one very familiar enemy looming over October. The Jets get a grim Geno Smith prediction, and Tiki Barber gets an unexpected reminder of just how heavily he was used during his playing career.

Hour 4: Knicks Title Pain Can’t Top Evan’s Celtics Regret Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts admits the Nets helping build a Celtics championship still bothers him more than contributing Mikal Bridges to a Knicks title. Tiki Barber pushes back, arguing the Knicks rivalry should hurt more, while Evan explains why the disastrous Boston trade remains impossible to escape. Evan also owns his Kyle Tucker miss, wonders whether David Stearns should publicly wear an “L” over Pete Alonso, and questions Citi Field’s bizarre concession situation on $5 Tuesday. Plus, the crew debates empty NFL preseason stadiums and Evan makes a brutal prediction for baseball’s next work stoppage: a season that might not begin until Mets-Yankees in mid-July.

David Stearns Should Wear the L for Pete Alonso Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s return puts the Mets’ biggest offseason decision back under the microscope. Evan Roberts says David Stearns should show some humility and literally wear an “L” when Alonso comes back to Citi Field, while Evan and Tiki Barber wonder why Steve Cohen wasn’t directly asked whether letting Alonso go was a mistake. Evan also owns his bad Cody Bellinger and Kyle Tucker take after dismissing Bellinger, while Tiki explains why Bellinger’s defense and ability to handle New York matter so much. Plus, Tiki revisits the Giants’ infamous 2005 loss in Seattle, and a historic 22-0 blowout sparks a debate over whether fans should ever leave a game early.

Steve Cohen Doubles Down on David Stearns Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Steve Cohen is standing firmly behind David Stearns. The Mets owner reiterates his commitment to the president of baseball operations, praises his intelligence and adaptability, and says he was pleased with the club’s trade deadline and the young talent added to the organization. But the support comes with pressure. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Cohen’s comments and question whether Stearns can improve after risky offseason decisions failed to deliver. Cohen also weighs in on the turmoil surrounding the Dodgers, while the conversation turns to Shohei Ohtani’s unusual opt-out clause and why he still seems unlikely to leave Los Angeles.

Geno Smith’s Jets Return Gets a Brutal Prediction Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso becomes the centerpiece of a bigger debate over whether teams are too afraid of the ugly final years of long-term contracts. Evan and Tiki argue that if a star delivers several elite seasons, the deal can still be worth it even if the back end turns bad, with Gerrit Cole serving as a prime Yankees example. The conversation also examines David Stearns’ risk-averse approach with the Mets and whether avoiding long commitments can cost a team championship-caliber talent. Then the focus shifts to the Jets, where Geno Smith’s return inspires a grim prediction about another losing season, an eventual quarterback change and New York once again searching for its long-term answer.

Aaron Glenn Keeps Geno Smith’s Preseason Plan Hidden Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Geno Smith needs to play in the preseason, and the Jets cannot afford to treat him like an established quarterback who can simply show up Week 1 ready to roll. The case is made for giving Smith significant reps with the starters as he learns another new offense, builds chemistry and tries to establish himself as the leader of the team. Aaron Glenn remains vague about his plans, while the strong preseason showing from Cade Klubnik creates another layer of intrigue. The conversation also turns to why the Jets should keep Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall even if the season goes sideways, plus a surprisingly deep New York Red Bulls and NYCFC debate.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected