Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Hour 3: Jets Could Become a Coveted Coaching Destination Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

The Jets were right to keep Aaron Glenn, but another bad season could completely change their coaching outlook. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why firing Glenn midseason would make little sense, why Frank Reich should not be viewed as an automatic replacement, and how three first-round picks could make the Jets a far more attractive destination if they conduct a coaching search after the season. Aaron Judge’s 2018 injury return offers a fascinating comparison for his current comeback, including what it could mean for his postseason readiness and defensive role. Plus, Keith Hernandez goes out of his way to encourage A.J. Ewing, Tiki recalls giving Tyrone Tracy advice, the worst New York sports jerseys get ranked, and the Nets’ sale of Julius Erving is revisited as one of the franchise’s defining mistakes.

Hour 4: Did the Yankees Get Lucky on Wednesday Night? Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

Evan and Tiki break down Pete Alonso crucial foul ball hit in the 7th inning of last night's Yankees-Orioles game. Geno Smith will start for the Jets in preseason week two against the Steelers.

Thursday Full Show: The Yankees Escaped Pete Alonso Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the controversial call on Pete Alonso's fly ball down the left field line against the Yankees. What is the Giants running back room going to look like following the signing of Najee Harris. The 5 worst jerseys in NY sports since 2000. What is Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets?

Shaun Morash Gets Blasted as a Raging Hypocrite Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts calls out Shaun Morash for a glaring double standard after Shaun criticized Evan for doing Mets content during WFAN programming, only to go live with Talkin' Giants while Evan & Tiki were on the air. Tiki backs Evan’s argument that specialized YouTube shows are not really competing with WFAN’s broader radio coverage. The conversation also digs into MLB replay after Pete Alonso’s disputed foul ball, why Hawkeye cannot settle every call, and a wild idea to extend foul poles with lasers. Plus, Aaron Glenn will ultimately be judged on wins, while George Lombard Jr. draws comparisons to Jeremy Peña and a young Miguel Cabrera.

Jets Need David Bailey to Become a Superstar Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

The Jets drafted David Bailey second overall, and the expectation is enormous: he needs to become the kind of defensive superstar the franchise has rarely had. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Bailey can develop into a true game-wrecker, why even strong Jets defenses have lacked that dominant presence, and how the shadow of Darrelle Revis still hangs over highly drafted defensive stars. The final stretch also features a Giants playoff disagreement, with Evan believing they can get in while Tiki sees an eight or nine-win team falling short. Plus, Pete Alonso’s absence gets measured against the Mets’ disastrous first-base production, MLB’s replay controversy comes under fire, and New York’s ugliest jerseys spark a debate over whether winning changes how fans remember uniforms.

Tiki Barber Reveals His Advice to Tyrone Tracy Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

Odell Beckham Jr. says the NFL never identified a specific banned substance, only that his testosterone levels were too high, shedding new light on the suspension that helped keep him unsigned last season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down how Beckham’s appeal delayed the punishment and why his timing made finding a team even tougher. Keith Hernandez then surprises Evan by revealing he went out of his way to speak with struggling Mets youngster A.J. Ewing. That sparks Tiki to share the ball-security advice he gave Tyrone Tracy during his rookie year and what he learned from Giants legend Frank Gifford. Plus, a Nets fan relives the franchise-altering sale of Julius Erving, and the possibility of Frank Reich replacing Aaron Glenn midseason gets an early reality check.

Odell Beckham Jr. Could Actually Make the Giants Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

The Giants’ roster battles take center stage from there, with questions about Najee Harris, Tyrone Tracy Jr., Jalin Hyatt and a crowded receiver room. Odell Beckham Jr.’s chances of making the team are suddenly looking real, while George Lombard Jr. sparks another Yankees prospect debate and a reminder of just how impossible Derek Jeter comparisons can become.

Jaxson Dart Must Prove the Injury Concerns Wrong Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s trips to the blue medical tent have inspired a nickname Giants fans absolutely hate. Evan Roberts defends calling Dart “Big Blue Tent,” arguing the frequency is impossible to ignore, while Tiki Barber pushes back on taking the nickname too far. The debate turns into a bigger question about how quickly fans attach expectations and narratives to young players. George Lombard Jr. becomes the next test case as Evan and Tiki debate comparisons to Derek Jeter, Jose Reyes, Alex Rodriguez and other shortstops. They argue that prospect expectations can become ridiculous before a player has even established himself, while also revisiting how perceptions changed around Anthony Volpe, Michael Conforto and other highly touted young players.

George Lombard Jr Is Igniting a Yankee Pennant Run Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

George Lombard Jr is giving the Yankees exactly the kind of spark a top prospect can provide in a pennant race. His clutch contact, aggressive baserunning and brilliant defense have Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering just how high his ceiling can go, leading to comparisons ranging from Andrelton Simmons and Jose Reyes to Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez. The conversation turns to the Giants and what Evan sees as an unfair rush to bury Tyrone Tracy. One missed preseason block and the excitement surrounding Cam Skattebo have changed the narrative quickly, but Evan argues Tracy has already proven he can be a dynamic NFL back and still views him as the Giants’ RB1.

Orioles Broadcast Pushes Yankees Conspiracy After Alonso Call Aug 20, 2026

Show notes

The Pete Alonso controversy gets even louder as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare the stunned reactions from Yankees and Orioles broadcasters after Alonso’s apparent home run remained a foul ball. Even Yankees voices admit they caught a break, while Baltimore’s broadcasts are left furious over a decision that looked impossible to explain from the angles shown on television. Then the frustration turns into conspiracy talk, with Orioles radio questioning whether the New York-based replay center somehow favored the Yankees. Evan and Tiki dismiss that theory while explaining why the original call on the field was so difficult to overturn. Aaron Boone also weighs in with the one opinion almost nobody else seemed to share: he thought the ball was foul.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected