Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Blue Jays Radio Guarantees Yankees Will Choke Again Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

Toronto is talking trash about the Yankees again, with Blue Jays radio hosts calling New York a “dumb” baseball team and guaranteeing they would beat the Yankees in the playoffs. Evan pushes back on the shot, arguing Toronto is judging this Yankees team through last year’s failures while ignoring how much has changed. The debate turns to which AL East teams should actually scare the Yankees most in October and why Toronto still feels like a house of horrors. The conversation then shifts to the Jets and Giants, as Shaun Morash argues some Jets fans are jealous of the excitement surrounding the Giants. Evan explains why there is still a path to Jets optimism, even after Aaron Glenn’s disastrous first season.

Posted and Toasted Exposes Shaun Morash’s Brutal Old Tweet Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

Posted and Toasted delivers another round of old social-media receipts, including a self-deprecating Shaun Morash post and a freezing-cold take about Jaxson Dart and the Giants. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the show digs through some painfully funny history.

Malik Nabers vs. Garrett Wilson Turns Personal Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

The Jets have five games to prove Shaun Morash wrong. Shaun says a 3-2 start would force him to reconsider his bleak outlook, while Evan Roberts calls Week 1 against Tennessee a “do we have a season” game and argues the Jets still have a path to surprise people. The debate then erupts again over Malik Nabers and Garrett Wilson, with Shaun insisting Nabers has the higher ceiling while Evan points to Wilson’s production despite constant quarterback turnover. The Giants-Jets divide ultimately comes down to two words: coach and quarterback. Evan believes John Harbaugh can elevate the Giants into the playoffs, while he has far less faith in Aaron Glenn doing the same for the Jets.

Shaun Morash Rips the Jets’ Offensive Talent Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, and he isn’t buying the Giants as a playoff team. Shaun still sees roughly an eight-win roster, pointing to major concerns on the defensive line and at cornerback even as optimism grows around other parts of the team. Then the Jets-Giants comparisons get heated. Callers push back on Shaun’s pessimism about the Jets, sparking arguments over Malik Nabers versus Garrett Wilson, the two teams’ skill-position talent, and whether the Jets’ young tight ends deserve the hype. Shaun keeps coming back to the same conclusion: the Jets still stink, no matter how much potential their offense may have.

Evan Battles Back Against Shaun’s Jets Pessimism Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

The Jets’ talent becomes the center of a heated argument as Evan Roberts pushes back on Shaun Morash’s insistence that Geno Smith makes all of it irrelevant. Evan lays out potential wins on the schedule and argues that dismissing an eight-win season as impossible goes too far, while Shaun keeps coming back to the same conclusion: without the quarterback, none of the surrounding talent matters. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as callers jump into the debate, including comparisons between the Jets and Giants skill-position groups. That sparks another argument over Garrett Wilson, Malik Nabers, A.D. Mitchell and whether Jaxson Dart is already better than Geno Smith, before the conversation turns toward Nabers potentially being ready for Week 1.

Geno Smith Has Shaun Writing Off the Jets Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

Geno Smith turns the Jets’ season into a heated argument over whether they have any realistic chance to surprise people. Evan Roberts expects a bad year but refuses to dismiss them completely, pointing to the offensive line, Garrett Wilson, the running game and Smith’s past success as reasons a competitive season is at least possible. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts and takes the much harsher position, arguing Smith will ultimately sink the offense and that the Jets have virtually no path to being good. Evan fires back with a 20 percent chance of eight wins, setting off a fierce debate over hope, quarterback play and just how bad the Jets really are.

Mets Get Walked Off in Two of Three Games | 'Rico Brogna' Aug 25, 2026

Show notes

In what looked like a well played series, the Mets lost two of three on the final at bats of the game. The bullpen let down the team for the first time since the trade deadline. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Monday Full Show: Stanton’s Yankees End, Lombard’s Cooperstown Hype, Dart’s Blue Tent Aug 24, 2026

Show notes

Giancarlo Stanton’s latest calf injury could end both his season and his Yankees career. The debate turns to whether New York should finally move on from Stanton, how his remarkable October availability shapes his legacy, and why injuries to Ryan Weathers and Max Fried reinforce the idea that the Yankees can never have enough pitching. George Lombard Jr. then becomes one of the day’s hottest arguments after a shaky defensive weekend. Shaun Morash doubles down on his belief that Lombard should eventually be among baseball’s elite shortstops and reach the Hall of Fame conversation, setting off callers and plenty of pushback. The Giants also take center stage as Jaxson Dart’s repeated trips to the blue medical tent become both a running joke and a legitimate concern heading toward the regular season. The show also hits Tarik Skubal’s Dodgers future, the Jets’ preseason flashes, Deshaun Watson and Cleveland’s dysfunction, and the tightening AL East race.

Hour 1: Giancarlo Stanton’s Yankees Career May Be Over Aug 24, 2026

Show notes

Giancarlo Stanton may have played his final game for the Yankees. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to Stanton’s latest calf injury, why his remarkable October history makes this setback different, and whether New York should finally move on this offseason. Ryan Weathers’ elbow injury also reignites the debate over the Yankees’ pitching depth and proves why Evan believes a contender can never have enough starting pitching. Then George Lombard Jr.’s rough defensive weekend turns into a heated argument over expectations for the Yankees’ young shortstop. Shaun puts Lombard on a path toward becoming one of baseball’s elite at the position, callers push back hard on the early Hall of Fame talk, and the debate quickly goes off the rails.

Hour 2: Dodgers Are Driving Tarik Skubal Into the Ground Aug 24, 2026

Show notes

The Dodgers’ handling of Tarik Skubal has Evan Roberts convinced they have no intention of keeping the ace long term. After back-to-back starts featuring two of the highest pitch counts of Skubal’s career, Evan argues Los Angeles is riding him hard because they expect him to leave, opening the door for the Mets to become the obvious landing spot. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts and pushes back on just how certain that conclusion really is. The hour also turns into a heated Deshaun Watson debate after the Browns quarterback fires back at Cleveland fans for booing him. Evan calls the Browns more dysfunctional than the Jets, while Shaun argues the reaction is partly fueled by the fan obsession with Sanders. Plus, George Lombard Jr.’s Yankees future, Anthony Volpe’s role, Francisco Alvarez frustration, and a birthday-text feud with Tommy Lugauer.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected