Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Aaron Judge’s Pregame Absence Sparks Yankees Controversy Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge was noticeably absent from the Yankees’ pregame player introductions despite being in the dugout supporting his teammates, creating an unexpected controversy after their dominant win. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate why Judge stayed off the field and whether he was simply trying to keep the attention on the active roster or sending a message about his playoff status. The crew also wonders if Judge’s decision actually created more attention than an introduction would have. Plus, callers react to Cam Schlittler’s intense demeanor, and the conversation returns to Aaron Boone’s willingness to push his ace beyond the pitch-count limits Yankees fans have become accustomed to.

Cam Schlittler Owns Boston as Boone Lets Him Roll Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Cam Schlittler dominated the Red Sox again, and Aaron Boone made the kind of old-school decision Yankees fans have been begging to see. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Boone pushing Schlittler past 110 pitches, why Boston’s early hook of Peyton Tolle backfired, and how trusting the starter helped set the tone for a convincing Yankees win. The bigger takeaway may be the Yankees’ postseason identity. Instead of living and dying with Aaron Judge and home runs, this team can lean on a dominant rotation. After Schlittler’s latest performance against Boston, the crew argues Boone has to keep riding his starting pitching if the Yankees are going to make a deep October run.

Tuesday Full Show: The Yankees get Read for a Red Sox War, Odell Released Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees get ready of another October, though this is in September. Judge is off the roster, apparently Odell is too.

Hour 1: Yankees Shut Down Aaron Judge, Turn to Stanton Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge is officially off the Yankees’ Wild Card roster, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the organization finally overruled its superstar. Judge wanted to play, but the Yankees appear unwilling to risk their long-term investment with the season hanging on a best-of-three series against Boston. Evan argues there can be no Judge excuse if the Yankees lose. Meanwhile, Giancarlo Stanton is somehow back after not playing since April 24. Evan praises Stanton’s postseason toughness and believes he could still deliver a memorable October moment as a dangerous bat off the bench. The conversation turns to Stanton’s complicated Yankees legacy, his remarkable playoff availability despite years of regular-season injuries, Trent Grisham’s return, and how the Yankees should build their roster around a rotation expected to carry a heavy postseason workload.

Hour 2: Giants’ J.J. McCarthy Trade Puts Jaxson Dart on Notice Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

The Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy sparks a major debate about what comes next for Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston and New York’s quarterback room. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why Minnesota giving up on McCarthy does not guarantee he will fail, how John Harbaugh could unlock him, and why a fifth-round pick is a worthwhile gamble for a former first-round quarterback. They also examine the uncomfortable possibility of McCarthy pushing Dart or Winston if he takes advantage of his opportunity. The Yankees unveil an unconventional Wild Card roster loaded with position players, opening the door for Aaron Boone to aggressively deploy Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe and Giancarlo Stanton. Plus, Case Keenum’s huge performance gets attention, and Posted and Toasted digs up old J.J. McCarthy takes from around WFAN.

Hour 3: Aaron Boone Could Be Gone If Yankees Collapse Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees finally open their Wild Card showdown with the Red Sox, and Evan Roberts argues Boston’s season was built on one historic hot streak surrounded by long stretches of mediocre baseball. That puts even more pressure on the Yankees to take care of business at Yankee Stadium, with Cam Schlittler on the mound and Gerrit Cole potentially waiting for a winner-take-all Game 3. The bigger consequence could come for Aaron Boone. Evan believes a series loss to Boston could end Boone’s Yankees tenure, while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh how much Aaron Judge’s situation and the short-series format could factor into that decision. Plus, the Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy, John Harbaugh’s plans at quarterback, and an early Rangers season prediction.

Hour 4: Joe Musgrove's Surprise Activation & Yankees Postseason Roster Debate Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber analyze the San Diego Padres' stunning choice to activate Joe Musgrove for the Wild Card series despite his long-term injury absence. They also break down the New York Yankees' postseason roster decisions and the New York Giants' release of Odell Beckham Jr. following his brief return.

(00:01:25) Joey Porter Jr. Rumors

(00:07:55) WBC Impact On Injuries

(00:11:14) Joe Musgrove's Padres Return

(00:14:16) Odell Beckham Jr. Released

(00:17:48) Giants Defense And Boone

(00:25:43) MLB Salary Cap Battle

(00:30:23) Coughlin's J-Fund Push-Up Challenge

(00:36:18) Yankees-Red Sox Series Predictions

Giants Cut Odell After a Forgettable Comeback Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

Odell Beckham Jr.’s return to the Giants ends without a single catch as Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber react to his release and debate whether his brief comeback will even be remembered. They also examine the Giants’ aggressive approach, the J.J. McCarthy move and whether Joey Porter Jr. is worth the draft capital and massive contract that could come with a trade. The conversation shifts to Aaron Judge missing the Yankees’ postseason roster, whether playing in the World Baseball Classic deserves any blame, and the bizarre wave of stars returning just in time for October. Joe Musgrove’s comeback after nearly two years away sparks a heated debate over whether players who miss the entire regular season should be eligible for the playoffs.

Brian Cashman’s Clock Is Ticking on Boone Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Boone’s future could hinge on this Wild Card series against Boston. Evan Roberts believes a loss to the Red Sox may be enough for the Yankees to move on, arguing that Brian Cashman has historically reached a breaking point with managers after long runs without a championship. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Aaron Judge’s situation, the short-series format, or even an upcoming lockout could influence that decision. The conversation also turns to what Evan actually wants from the Yankees this postseason, including a potential ALCS matchup with Houston. Then Shaun closes the hour with his Cinco de Lunch, unloading five reasons Boston sucks ahead of Yankees-Red Sox and Rangers-Bruins.

J.J. McCarthy Gets His Giants Career Lifeline Sep 29, 2026

Show notes

J.J. McCarthy gets a fresh start with the Giants, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate whether John Harbaugh can help revive the former first-round pick’s career. With expectations dramatically different after New York acquired him for a fifth-round pick, McCarthy now has a chance to prove he can become a reliable NFL backup or potentially something more. The conversation turns to whether McCarthy could already be the Giants’ No. 2 quarterback this week behind Jameis Winston and what Harbaugh needs to see before trusting him. Plus, the surprising early success of backup quarterbacks across the NFL, the Mets watching Freddy Peralta thrive elsewhere, and a baseball lawsuit sparked by a dangerous stadium wall.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected