Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Hour 1: Cam Schlittler Owns Boston as Boone Lets Him Cook Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Cam Schlittler overwhelmed the Red Sox again, and Aaron Boone finally managed like he had a horse worth riding. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Schlittler’s dominant postseason performance, Boone’s decision to push him deep despite a rising pitch count, and why the Yankees’ starting rotation may have become the identity that can carry them through October. They also contrast Boone’s aggressive approach with Boston pulling Peyton Tolle after just 83 pitches. Aaron Judge also created an unexpected pregame mystery by not taking part in the Yankees’ on-field introductions despite being in the dugout supporting his teammates. The crew debates whether Judge was simply keeping the spotlight on the active roster or whether his absence reflected frustration with how the Yankees handled his injury and playoff status.

Hour 2: Cam Schlittler Dominates as Yankees’ Youth Takes Over Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice have turned the Yankees’ postseason into a showcase for the organization’s young core. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Schlittler’s dominant performance against Boston, Rice’s huge night, and how a lineup filled with inexpensive, homegrown talent has changed the feel of this Yankees team. The conversation turns to Brian Cashman’s role in building a group that could define the next era in the Bronx. The crew also defends Yankees fans over the controversial mound-visit boos, praises NBC’s playoff broadcast approach, and debates how Aaron Boone should manage every run in a tight postseason game. Plus, Tiki explains why moving Arvell Reese to the edge too soon could hurt both the Giants and the young linebacker’s development.

Hour 3: Giants Suddenly Have a Real Shot at the NFC East Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

The Giants suddenly have a path to stealing the NFC East. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash look at a wide-open division, why Philadelphia and Dallas suddenly feel vulnerable, and how Jameis Winston now becomes the biggest variable in keeping the Giants in the race. They also break down the team’s ugly red-zone offense, Najee Harris moving up the running back hierarchy, and Kayvon Thibodeaux fooling everyone with his reaction to Odell Beckham Jr.’s release. Then the focus shifts to October baseball, where Shaun declares the Red Sox the Yankees’ new Twins after another dominant playoff showing. The guys also react to the Astros getting called out by one of their own players over empty playoff seats, Susan Waldman delivering an accidental insult to Big Mac, and the unforgettable Yankee Stadium scene after Ben Rice’s grand slam.

Hour 4: Evan and Tiki Debate Brian Cashman's Faith in Austin Wells Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Evan and Tiki analyze the Yankees' postseason matchup against former pitcher Sonny Gray and the Red Sox. They argue over Brian Cashman's roster management and whether the decision to stick with Austin Wells over other catching options will haunt the team. The conversation also explores potential lineup changes and Max Fried's inconsistent postseason history.

(00:01:50) Sonny Gray's Yankee Return

(00:06:30) Yankees Postseason History Trivia

(00:10:20) Jameis Winston Leadership Debate

(00:14:45) Evaluating Brian Cashman's Deadline

(00:18:45) Austin Wells Catcher Debate

(00:25:00) Boone's Aggressive Bullpen Use

(00:32:20) WFAN Fan Focus

(00:36:40) Comparing Boone and Cora

(00:43:00) Max Fried Postseason History

Yankees Are Turning Boston Into an October Bye Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Shaun Morash declares the Red Sox the Yankees’ new Twins, arguing Boston has become an October punching bag as the Yankees keep shutting down their offense. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on just how far that comparison can go, but Shaun sees a matchup the Yankees should dominate for years. Then Susan Waldman delivers what might be the ultimate insult to Big Mac by suggesting he hasn’t watched every Yankees game. The guys debate whether the shot was really aimed at Craig Carton, revisit Big Mac’s Yankee Stadium habits, and celebrate the incredible scene after Ben Rice’s grand slam sent drinks flying through the bleachers.

Astros Players Turn on Their Own Fans Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

The Astros are unraveling, and now one of their own players is calling out the fans. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to thousands of empty seats in Houston, Bennett Sousa criticizing the atmosphere, and why the Astros suddenly feel nothing like the powerhouse Yankee fans once despised. The conversation then turns back to the Giants and their continued red-zone failures. Tiki explains why the coaching staff may be overthinking things with Jameis Winston, especially after abandoning a rushing attack that was working against Tennessee. Plus, the guys debate the difference between TV and radio play-by-play and why postseason broadcasts can frustrate fans used to their local announcers.

Giants Suddenly Have a Clear Path in the NFC East Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

The Giants suddenly have a real opening in the NFC East. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down a division with no dominant team, why Philadelphia and Dallas look vulnerable, and how Jameis Winston could keep the Giants firmly in the race. They also react to Kayvon Thibodeaux pretending he had just learned about Odell Beckham Jr.’s release, a performance convincing enough to fool Tiki. Plus, Najee Harris appears to be moving ahead in the Giants’ backfield, Tyrone Tracy’s role is shrinking, and special teams could become a major factor in how this team wins close games.

Aaron Boone’s Volpe Decision Sparks a Postseason Debate Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

NBC’s Yankees-Red Sox broadcast earns strong praise for using analysts who actually know both teams. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Joe Girardi and Lou Merloni added valuable detail, why national broadcasts often frustrate local fans, and why this formula may be the best alternative when Michael Kay and the YES crew are unavailable. The Yankees’ in-game decisions also come under the microscope, including whether Anthony Volpe should have bunted with a one-run lead and Cam Schlittler dominating. Evan and Tiki highlight two successful Yankees challenges that helped manage Schlittler’s pitch count and create a scoring opportunity. Tiki also explains why moving Arvell Reese to the edge too quickly could hurt his development with the Giants.

Yankees Fans Get Blasted Over Cam Schlittler Scare Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

Yankees fans got crushed for booing when pitching coach Matt Blake visited Cam Schlittler, but Evan Roberts comes to their defense. He explains why the emotional playoff atmosphere, limited sightlines and fear of Schlittler being removed made the reaction understandable, while pushing back on the idea that the crowd simply didn’t know baseball. The conversation shifts to just how quickly the Yankees have moved from the Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole era toward a young core led by Schlittler and Ben Rice. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash credit Brian Cashman for building that group without a painful transition, revisit the Michael King trade, and explain why Boston already has plenty of reason to despise the Yankees’ newest young stars.

Brian Cashman’s Cheap Young Core Is Carrying the Yankees Sep 30, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees are winning with a lineup that looks nothing like the expensive powerhouse fans are used to seeing. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash marvel at a starting group loaded with homegrown players making less than $1 million, with Ben Rice, Spencer Jones, George Lombard Jr. and Austin Wells helping fuel the October run. They also look ahead to Max Fried’s chance to finish off Boston, debate which National League opponent Yankees fans should want in a potential World Series, and rip the decision not to show postseason player introductions on television. The crew argues those introductions are part of what makes playoff baseball feel special and should be available for fans watching at home.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected