Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

David Stearns Should Wear the L for Pete Alonso Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s return puts the Mets’ biggest offseason decision back under the microscope. Evan Roberts says David Stearns should show some humility and literally wear an “L” when Alonso comes back to Citi Field, while Evan and Tiki Barber wonder why Steve Cohen wasn’t directly asked whether letting Alonso go was a mistake. Evan also owns his bad Cody Bellinger and Kyle Tucker take after dismissing Bellinger, while Tiki explains why Bellinger’s defense and ability to handle New York matter so much. Plus, Tiki revisits the Giants’ infamous 2005 loss in Seattle, and a historic 22-0 blowout sparks a debate over whether fans should ever leave a game early.

Steve Cohen Doubles Down on David Stearns Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Steve Cohen is standing firmly behind David Stearns. The Mets owner reiterates his commitment to the president of baseball operations, praises his intelligence and adaptability, and says he was pleased with the club’s trade deadline and the young talent added to the organization. But the support comes with pressure. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Cohen’s comments and question whether Stearns can improve after risky offseason decisions failed to deliver. Cohen also weighs in on the turmoil surrounding the Dodgers, while the conversation turns to Shohei Ohtani’s unusual opt-out clause and why he still seems unlikely to leave Los Angeles.

Geno Smith’s Jets Return Gets a Brutal Prediction Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso becomes the centerpiece of a bigger debate over whether teams are too afraid of the ugly final years of long-term contracts. Evan and Tiki argue that if a star delivers several elite seasons, the deal can still be worth it even if the back end turns bad, with Gerrit Cole serving as a prime Yankees example. The conversation also examines David Stearns’ risk-averse approach with the Mets and whether avoiding long commitments can cost a team championship-caliber talent. Then the focus shifts to the Jets, where Geno Smith’s return inspires a grim prediction about another losing season, an eventual quarterback change and New York once again searching for its long-term answer.

Aaron Glenn Keeps Geno Smith’s Preseason Plan Hidden Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Geno Smith needs to play in the preseason, and the Jets cannot afford to treat him like an established quarterback who can simply show up Week 1 ready to roll. The case is made for giving Smith significant reps with the starters as he learns another new offense, builds chemistry and tries to establish himself as the leader of the team. Aaron Glenn remains vague about his plans, while the strong preseason showing from Cade Klubnik creates another layer of intrigue. The conversation also turns to why the Jets should keep Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall even if the season goes sideways, plus a surprisingly deep New York Red Bulls and NYCFC debate.

Pete Alonso Haunts Mets as Polanco Hits the IL Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s absence is becoming impossible for the Mets to ignore. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber unload on the disastrous production replacing Alonso, with Jorge Polanco heading back to the injured list and Ronny Mauricio still stuck in the minors. Evan argues that any long-term benefit from avoiding Alonso’s contract eventually has to make up for how badly the decision has hurt this season. The conversation also turns to the Yankees, where Luis Gil could emerge as a high-leverage bullpen weapon, George Lombard Jr.’s defense is already making a massive impact, and Paul Goldschmidt’s fading production has pushed him toward a bench role.

Tiki Barber Says He Could Play One More NFL Game Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Tiki Barber gets hit with the ultimate hypothetical: for $100 million, could he suit up for one more NFL game? Tiki says he could probably make it work, but admits the recovery would be brutal and the thought of taking NFL contact again is far from appealing. The football talk also turns to the Giants adding Najee Harris, with Tiki viewing the move as protection against injuries in the backfield rather than a sign of panic. Evan Roberts and Tiki also weigh in on Dallas signing 37-year-old Von Miller and why a limited pass-rush role could still make him valuable. Plus, the conversation dives into the NFL’s oldest active players and a Yankees fan shares the painful story of giving up the exact seat where a home run later landed.

Mets Fans Blew Their Chance to Save Lindor Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Francisco Lindor was robbed of a grand slam by Fernando Tatis Jr., but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber can’t stop thinking about the Mets fans sitting right behind the play. Should they have attacked the ball and made Tatis’ catch more difficult, or is it unfair to expect fans to react like players when a baseball is flying toward them? Evan argues that fans sitting in the front row of home run territory need a game plan because they can legitimately impact the outcome. The debate turns into a hilarious breakdown of fight, flight and freezing in the moment, along with memories of infamous fan interference. Plus, Evan admits his own sports teams have given him very little reason to experience meaningful-game stress.

Yankees Injuries Have Turned Every Game Into Survival Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees keep surviving, but every game feels like a struggle. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether New York deserves credit for staying afloat through a brutal run of injuries or criticism for barely playing .500 baseball despite outstanding pitching. Aaron Judge is making slow progress, Giancarlo Stanton is moving closer to a return, and Aaron Boone’s comments make Max Fried’s injured-list stint sound more precautionary than catastrophic. Jazz Chisholm is becoming another source of frustration. His bat has disappeared, the strikeouts are piling up, and a defensive mistake has Evan questioning whether Chisholm should still be guaranteed everyday at-bats. The Yankees may be headed for October, but getting Judge, Stanton and Fried healthy at the right time could determine how far they actually go.

Carson Benge & the Bazooka Arm | 'Rico Brogna' Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

The Padres saw first hand how good Carson Benge has been as he prevented not one but TWO runners from scoring in the first inning. This is now becoming a daily occurrence from the rookie right fielder. 11 base runners on and one scores, The Mets defense is alive and well. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Tuesday Full Show: Max Fried's Elbow Injury; Jaxson Dart's Blue Tent Issues; Jets QB Future; Indispensable Yankees; Jose Igelsias Returns Aug 18, 2026

Show notes

Evan and Tiki discuss the Max Fried injury and the implications it has for the future of the Bronx Bombers. They also continue the discussion on Jaxson Dart's health, Breece Hall's injury update, the Jets QB situation, Indispensable Yankees rule the Cinco and the boys react to the news of Jose Iglesias throwing out the first pitch tonight at CitiField.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Evan & Tiki

Related Podcasts

1

2

3

4

5

6