Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Thursday Full Show: Yankees Bullpen Crisis, Jets Wanted Nabers, Alonso Returns Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

The Yankees’ trade deadline is already producing wildly different results. Luis Garcia Jr. looks like a massive addition and Austin Wells has quieted the catcher concerns, but Fernando Cruz’s injury exposes the bullpen hole Brian Cashman failed to fill. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash also debate whether Eugenio Suárez could still help the Yankees in October. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as Connor Hughes reveals the Jets tried to trade up for Malik Nabers and weighs whether the Jets have a legitimate path to eight wins. Plus, the Jets and Giants roster debate heats up, and Evan predicts Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field with Baltimore could turn the ballpark into an Orioles home game.

Hour 1: Cashman’s Deadline Gamble Leaves Yankees Bullpen Exposed Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Brian Cashman’s trade deadline is looking better offensively, but the Yankees’ bullpen could become the decision that defines their postseason. Luis Garcia Jr. has been a massive addition, Austin Wells is finally producing like a functioning major league catcher, and the lineup is clicking. But Fernando Cruz’s devastating injury exposes the risk of Cashman failing to add a reliever, leaving major questions about how the Yankees will get the final nine outs in October. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate whether Eugenio Suarez should be added off waivers, George Lombard Jr.’s alarming error streak, and whether Anthony Volpe could actually become part of the conversation again. Plus, Mike Breen tells an incredible story about celebrating the Mets’ famous 1986 World Series comeback from inside the Red Sox radio booth.

Hour 2: Malik Nabers Trade Attempt Could Have Reshaped Jets Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

The Jets wanted Malik Nabers badly enough to explore trading up with the Giants, and Connor Hughes reveals New York had Nabers ranked as the best receiver in his draft class. Hughes explains why the Giants quickly shut the door, why the Jets believed Nabers had best-in-the-NFL upside, and whether missing out ultimately worked in their favor. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as Hughes also lays out a path to a surprising Jets season, raises major concerns about their defense, and explains why Jaxson Dart still looks uncomfortable and needs more preseason work. Plus, the Giants’ growing tension with Cam Skattebo, Odell Beckham Jr.’s roster outlook, and a heated debate over why an MLB mercy rule may eventually become inevitable.

Hour 3: Pete Alonso’s Citi Field Return Could Hijack the Crowd Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field could turn into an unforgettable scene, with Evan Roberts predicting Mets fans may treat the former franchise star like the home-team hero. Evan compares Alonso’s looming reception to Eddie Giacomin’s legendary Rangers return and debates whether the Mets should even raise the home run apple if Alonso reaches a milestone. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the Geno Smith versus Jaxson Dart argument heats up again, including whether the Jets have any realistic path to eight wins. Plus, the NFL officially kills the Pro Bowl games, the guys dream up a wild Yankees-Mets tripleheader, and a ridiculous Babe Ruth conspiracy takes over Cinco de Five.

Hour 4: Jaxson Dart Preseason Debate Splits Evan and Shaun Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts sees a massive gap between the Giants and Jets, even after admitting the Jets may have more talent at several offensive positions. His biggest reasons are coaching and a Giants pass rush he believes could become the team’s identity. Meanwhile, Shaun Morash pushes back on the Giants hype as the Jets prepare for another season surrounded by low expectations. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. They also debate whether Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith should play in the preseason finale, rip the NFL for forcing season-ticket holders to buy preseason games, revisit painful New York sports memories, and look ahead to Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field.

Giants Pass Rush Could Make Them a Playoff Team Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Evan Roberts explains why he believes the Giants can dramatically outperform the Jets despite giving the Jets the edge at several offensive positions. John Harbaugh is the biggest difference, while Evan believes the Giants’ pass rush could become the identity of a surprisingly successful season. Shaun Morash pushes back on some of the Giants optimism and questions the offensive line comparison. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. They also debate whether Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith should play against the Jets, revisit the Nets’ dramatic 2002 playoff win over Indiana, compare Pete Alonso’s return to Tom Seaver’s 1977 homecoming, and reveal Evan’s perfect prediction of the Jaxson Dart interview question count.

Pete Alonso’s Citi Field Return Could Embarrass the Mets Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field could become an uncomfortable night for the Mets, with Evan Roberts predicting fans may treat Alonso like the home-team star. Plus, Evan and Shaun Morash battle over Jaxson Dart versus Geno Smith, debate a new extra-innings idea, and get pulled into the absurd Babe Ruth conspiracy.

Jets Eight-Win Debate Erupts Over Geno Smith Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

The NFL officially ends the Pro Bowl games, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree the format had become meaningless while debating whether the honor can finally regain value. Then the Jets argument explodes again. Evan insists an eight-win season is at least possible if Geno Smith rebounds, while Shaun says the season is basically doomed before it starts.

MLB Mercy Rule Is Coming Whether Fans Like It Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

A mercy rule is coming to Major League Baseball, and Evan Roberts believes the way managers now surrender blowouts makes it inevitable. After the Mets essentially waved the white flag against Milwaukee, Evan and Shaun Morash debate how a run rule could work, why teams would embrace it, and whether fans would accept games ending early.

Connor Hughes Reveals Jets’ Malik Nabers Pursuit Aug 27, 2026

Show notes

Connor Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash with revealing details on how close the Jets came to pursuing Malik Nabers in the draft. Hughes explains why the Jets had Nabers ranked ahead of Marvin Harrison Jr., why the Giants shut down trade talks, and why Nabers was viewed as a potential best-in-the-NFL receiver.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Evan & Tiki

Related Podcasts

1

2

3

4

5

6