Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Evan Fires Back at Jets Crowd Criticism Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Jets fans take heat for the atmosphere at MetLife, and Evan Roberts wants none of it. After hours in miserable rain and another crushing loss, Evan defends the crowd, argues the stadium was louder than critics claim and explains why the frustration felt so familiar for a fan base accustomed to painful endings. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh in on the whiteout, the weather and just how miserable the entire experience became. The conversation then circles back to NFL overtime strategy after Evan realizes he had one detail wrong about the Colts-Chiefs finish. That correction leads to a deeper debate over why teams choosing to defend first may need to stay aggressive on fourth down, and why Aaron Glenn’s bigger problem was failing to adjust his overtime plan to what the Jets were actually doing on the field.

Aaron Rodgers Already Sounds Fed Up With McCarthy Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Rodgers struggles against New England, looks noticeably slower and then gives a postgame answer that sounds a lot like criticism of Mike McCarthy. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Rodgers’ performance and the not-so-subtle message he sent about Pittsburgh’s play calling. The NFL injury news gets ugly as Jayden Daniels suffers another concerning setback and Caleb Williams goes down with a hamstring injury that could impact the Jets in two weeks. Plus, Tom Brady analyzes Daniels’ injury, the Bears offense crashes back to earth, and an innocent Fox sideline report about preparing wet footballs produces one of the funniest lines of the day.

Jets Waste Dominant Defense With Brutal Game Management Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Glenn’s overtime decision leaves Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber questioning whether the Jets coach understood what was happening in front of him. With the offense sputtering and the defense dominating Green Bay, Glenn chose to take the football first, then defended the move by pointing to what the Jets had done in a completely different game. Evan and Tiki explain why that reasoning made the decision even more frustrating. The criticism goes far beyond overtime. They break down questionable fourth-down choices, a disastrous short-yardage play, poor clock management and special teams mistakes that helped waste a tremendous defensive performance. After another collection of costly in-game decisions, the biggest concern is becoming impossible to ignore: coaching played a major role in the Jets letting this one get away.

Jets’ Fourth-and-One Disaster Exposes Frank Reich’s Play Call Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

The Jets’ failed fourth-and-one becomes the next flashpoint in their crushing loss to Green Bay. Evan Roberts liked Aaron Glenn’s decision to be aggressive, but Tiki Barber argues the Jets’ struggles blocking all day made going for it far more questionable. The biggest problem was the play itself, with Braelon Allen taking a shotgun handoff and getting hit before he had any chance to generate momentum. Tiki breaks down the blocking failures from the tight ends and offensive line, while Evan points out that the Jets attacked the exact area Aaron Glenn said they wanted to avoid. After looking like the team’s identity a week earlier, the run game and offensive line failed when the Jets needed one yard most.

Aaron Glenn’s Explanation Makes Jets Collapse Even Worse Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Glenn’s explanation for the Jets’ disastrous end-of-regulation clock management only fuels more frustration. Evan Roberts blasts Glenn for admitting he never considered using a timeout, while Tiki Barber argues that Glenn’s defensive responsibilities may have kept him from thinking like a head coach in the moment. The bigger concern is whether anyone on the staff was helping him manage the situation. The Jets’ problems extended to the offense, where Geno Smith missed chances to extend plays with his legs and the entire unit collapsed after a late miscommunication with Braelon Allen. Five straight drives went nowhere as the offensive line struggled, Geno took sacks, and the Jets failed to finish another game they had under control.

Aaron Glenn’s Clock Disaster Leaves Jets Fans Furious Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Glenn’s late-game clock management becomes the biggest target after the Jets blow a 10-point fourth-quarter lead in a crushing overtime loss to Green Bay. Evan Roberts is furious that Glenn let nearly a minute disappear instead of calling timeout and giving the offense another chance to win, while Tiki Barber points to the difficulty of balancing defensive play-calling with head-coaching responsibilities. The frustration runs much deeper. Geno Smith and the offense regressed, the offensive line struggled, penalties piled up, and the Jets repeatedly failed in critical moments. Even Packers coach Matt LaFleur admitted he was confused by New York’s handling of the final minute, adding another layer to a loss that felt painfully familiar.

Best of the NFL on WFAN: Could Giants and Jets start 2-0? Sep 19, 2026

Show notes

Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to give his take on Jaxson Dart making the leap in year two after a promising Week 1 performance. Plus, Evan Roberts says fans should embrace the optimism from Week 1 and believe that both New York teams could be on the rise. The Evan and Tiki crew wonder if Tyrone Tracy's job is at risk if he struggles again in Week 2, while Gio believes both the Giants and Jets are catching their Week 2 opponents at just the right time.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Pete Alonso returns Sep 19, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso returned to Queens this week, and it brought about PLENTY of debates. Gio says Alonso hitting his 300th career home run to tie the game in the ninth for the Orioles, and getting a curtain call as a visiting player afterward, cemented 2026 as the most embarrassing season in Mets history. Plus, KFC Barstool called in to Boomer and Gio to rip Sean Manaea for criticizing Mets fans for calling for that curtain call. Tiki Barber called out Manaea as well, while Evan sounded off on Alonso for taking the curtain call. On The Carton Show, Craig and C-Mac debate how David Stearns must feel about Alonso's return, and how it might impact Steve Cohen's thought process about the future.

Friday Full Show: The Jets Have Expectations Sunday, NFL Picks, and More Sep 18, 2026

Show notes

It is two days before Packers-Jets. a White Out is in effect, NFL Picks, and all the Football Friday trimmings.

Hour 1: Jets Fans Just Got a BRUTAL Reality Check Sep 18, 2026

Show notes

Josh Allen and the Bills open their new stadium by overwhelming Detroit, giving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber a sobering reminder of what the Jets are chasing in the AFC East. They marvel at Allen’s rare combination of passing, rushing, durability and regular-season dominance, while debating whether his legacy ultimately depends on finally winning a Super Bowl. The Jets may never find a quarterback better than Allen, but Evan argues they can still build a roster capable of beating Buffalo. The conversation shifts to why the Jets have a real opportunity against Green Bay, especially if they can control the game on the ground. Plus, the Giants’ fast start sparks optimism that John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart can create lasting stability, while a frightening Jared Young collision leads to criticism of the Mets’ national broadcast for discussing his future while he was being treated.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Evan & Tiki

Related Podcasts

1

2

3

4

5

6