Evan & Tiki

Latest Episodes:

Tiki Rips Reporter Over TreVeyon Henderson Criticism Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Aaron Judge’s potential return becomes a major Yankees debate as Evan and Tiki weigh whether even a diminished Judge still makes the lineup better and what a World Series run without him could mean for the conversation around his legacy. The Yankees also have one narrow path left to steal the AL East, requiring a perfect finish and help from Tampa Bay. Tiki also goes carry by carry through TreVeyon Henderson’s rushing performance after an awkward exchange with a reporter, arguing Henderson had every reason to be frustrated by questions about his consistency.

Jaxson Dart Injury News Gives Giants Real Hope Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s injury may not keep him out as long as Giants fans feared. Shaun Morash says he’s hearing an encouraging outlook, while Tiki Barber and Shaun both predict Dart returns October 11 against Washington. Evan Roberts is slightly more cautious, picking October 18 against the Saints as the quarterback’s comeback date. The crew also examines what Jameis Winston’s performance could mean for Dart’s timeline, reacts to the Jets signing Will Levis to the practice squad, and pushes back on complaints that the Rams played dirty. After a brutal Giants loss, the bigger truth is impossible to ignore: Los Angeles was simply the far better team.

Jaxson Dart Injury Leaves Giants Season Hanging Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s injury instantly changes the Giants’ outlook, putting Jameis Winston in charge of keeping the season afloat. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine Winston’s brutal first appearance, why a full week of preparation should help and whether the Giants can survive until Dart returns. John Harbaugh’s 6-11 record when starting backup quarterbacks during the Lamar Jackson era adds another concerning layer. Shaun Morash also counts down the five worst parts of the Giants’ loss, from the offensive line collapse to injuries and questionable coaching. Plus, Aaron Judge is expected to miss the AL Wild Card series, Jazz Chisholm is set to return and a Mets fan takes Yankees trolling to another level.

Joe Benigno Rips Aaron Glenn’s Jets Game Management Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Joe Benigno unloads on Aaron Glenn after another “same old Jets” loss, hammering his fourth-down decisions, overtime strategy, and late-game management. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the coaching mistakes, Frank Reich’s brutal play calling, costly penalties, special teams breakdowns, and a Jets offense that disappeared when the game was there to be won. Despite the frustration, Joe isn’t ready to bury the season. He believes the defense has taken a major step forward, Geno Smith gives the Jets competent quarterback play, and the roster is dramatically better than last year. The conversation also turns to Jaxson Dart’s injury, the Giants’ opportunity in the NFC East, and why Joe desperately wants Glenn to prove he can become the Jets’ long-term answer.

Shaun Gets Roasted for His Giants Meltdown Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Shaun Morash becomes the target of “Posted and Toasted” after an emotional night of Giants tweets, including panic over Jaxson Dart, frustration with Abdul Carter and a brutal comparison to the Brian Daboll era. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber pile on as Morash defends his reactions and gets dragged back into his long-running feud with Jets fans over the infamous Aaron Rodgers chicken-wing video. Then the show gets hit with major Yankees news: Aaron Judge is expected to miss the Wild Card Series against Boston because of a calf strain. Evan and Tiki react to the severity of the update and what it means for the Yankees’ postseason hopes.

Harbaugh’s Red-Zone Decisions Cost the Giants Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh’s red-zone decisions come under scrutiny after the Giants failed to capitalize on Javon Holland’s huge forced turnover. Evan Roberts questions why New York leaned on Najee Harris and settled for a field goal, while Tiki Barber explains how losing Jaxson Dart forced the Giants to run plays designed for a completely different quarterback. That raises a bigger question about Jameis Winston’s fit behind Dart. The offense is built around Dart’s mobility and zone-read ability, something Winston simply cannot replicate when thrown into the game without a tailored plan. Evan and Tiki also push back on the idea that Harbaugh should be immune from criticism, arguing that even great coaches deserve heat when their in-game decisions fall short.

Giants Pass Rush Has Become an Early Disaster Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s knee injury hangs over everything after the Giants were thoroughly outclassed by the Rams. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how differently the game might have looked with Dart, whether concerns about his durability are fair, and why losing the quarterback makes this Giants team nearly impossible to evaluate. The bigger on-field alarm is a pass rush that was supposed to be the strength of the defense. Brian Burns, Kayvon Thibodeaux and company have produced one of the NFL’s worst pressure rates through two games, leaving an already vulnerable secondary exposed. The Giants may be 1-1, but the circumstances surrounding that record have changed the conversation completely.

John Harbaugh’s Giants Honeymoon Is Over! Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

John Harbaugh takes his first real wave of Giants criticism after a night filled with questionable decisions. Evan Roberts blasts the Giants for snapping a field goal attempt with five seconds still on the play clock, then kicking into the end zone instead of burning more time before halftime. He calls the sequence coaching malpractice after the Rams nearly turned those extra seconds into points. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber also debate whether Harbaugh should have pulled key starters once the game was slipping away, especially after Brian Burns and Andrew Thomas were hurt late. Tiki then zooms out on the bigger picture, arguing the Giants may have climbed out of the NFL’s bottom tier, but they still are not ready to compete with teams like the Rams, Bills, and Chiefs.

Jaxson Dart’s Injury History Is Becoming a Giant Problem Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s latest injury sparks an uncomfortable Giants debate: can they rely on their franchise quarterback to stay on the field? Evan Roberts makes clear he is not questioning Dart’s toughness or blaming him for getting hurt, but missing time in consecutive seasons is becoming impossible to ignore. The focus then shifts to Jameis Winston after his brutal relief appearance. Tiki Barber explains why an offense designed around Dart’s mobility and quick decision-making does not fit Winston’s game, meaning the Giants may need major changes if Dart misses time. Evan also compares Winston’s performance to other backup quarterbacks forced into action and finds his effort far worse, setting the stage for the first criticism of John Harbaugh.

Jameis Winston Implodes After Jaxson Dart Goes Down Sep 22, 2026

Show notes

Jaxson Dart’s knee injury immediately overshadows everything for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the frightening hit, the uncertainty surrounding Dart’s status, and the growing concern about whether their young quarterback can consistently stay on the field. Tiki explains why this injury looked more like terrible luck than something Dart could have prevented. Jameis Winston’s performance only made the night worse. Evan and Tiki rip the veteran backup for missed throws, poor decisions, and failing to give the Giants a chance after Dart went down. Shaun Morash joins the conversation with a more optimistic view of Dart’s injury, while the Giants are left facing major questions at quarterback.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Evan & Tiki

Related Podcasts

1

2

3

4

5

6