Show notes
About this episodeDoes money need to be just? Or is it just a tool of man? Yan Pritzker joins this episode with host Samuel McCulloch to discuss growing up in the Soviet Union, Bitcoin as freedom, and how it can be used as a get out of "troubled" country hedge.Yan Pritzker is the co-founder and CTO of Swan Bitcoin, the best place to buy Bitcoin with your bank account using automated daily, weekly, and monthly savings plan. Yan is the former co-founder and CTO at Reverb, which was sold to Etsy for $275M.Yan's LinksHomepage | Linkedin | CrunchbaseSwan BitcoinWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy Yan’s experiences of growing up in the Soviet Union influenced his thinking around Bitcoin and how he came into the space.Why we need a society where people have freedom with their money and without capital controls.Why there are always tradeoffs between freedom and surveillance in any society.What the difference is between people who prefer safety over freedom and people who prefer freedom over safety; and why this matters now more than ever.Why we need to look beyond the US narrative around ‘Axis of Evil’ countries and our empire perspective to understand the causes of terrorism.Why money and US financial systems are at the root of most of the conflicts in the world.Why the US dollar system may be broken and why Bitcoin is a hedge against this future outcome.Why the lack of short-term volatility is a tradeoff with systemic instability and why volatility always comes back in the long-term.Why centralized systems create more opportunities for criminals to steal your data because the information is fully public and easily hacked.Why Yan thinks perfect privacy does not exist and is impossible to achieve if you interact with any centralized system.Why everyone should be saving a little Bitcoin every month nd how SwanBitcoin helps you do this.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show TranscriptionSamuel: Hello, and welcome to the end of the chain. I’m your host, Samuel McCullough. And I want to welcome you to this very special episode where I am joined by Yan Pritzker from Swan Bitcoin. Now, I think it’s very important to speak with people who are Bitcoin maximalists and who have a different point of view than I do when it comes to the development of cryptocurrencies and how they’re used in the wider world. This turned out to be a lively debate. I want to thank Yan for coming on. I think we talked about some really great points and really got into some deeper aspects of using cryptocurrencies that I don’t think Yan may have explored before. So I want to thank him for coming on to the episode. As always make sure to subscribe to this podcast, share it with your mothers, brothers, sisters, mothers, and anyone else who you think would enjoy listening to the end of the chain. All right. That wraps it up. Let’s hop into the episode.Welcome to the podcast. Yan, I’m actually really excited to have you on because, two months ago, my wife and I, we just moved from Russia back in February actually. And yeah, so I had been living there for six years. I moved there in 2013. my wife is from Tuman in Siberia. And, but we met in Moscow and we had lived, we got married a couple years back, three years back and, then just moved here to Florida, for a new job just a while back. In my research, you’re also Russian as well too, and you, like my wife, lived in the Soviet Union as well. When exactly did you immigrate to the United States?Yan: Yeah, so I came over in 1989. I was seven years old at the time and came over with my parents and my sister. But yeah, I grew up in Russia, in Soviet Russia, which was a very interesting experience for sure.Samuel: I think a lot of people in the West, it’s really lost on them. Even people that grew up in the United States, the views that they were getting were not really t actual life of living over there. The more time that I’ve spent there, and more so even getting out of Moscow as well too, like living in more rural places, you start to see the differences and kind of cultured people, and it’s a great place. I love Russian culture. I love Russian food.Yan: Oh yeah.Yan: We still eat lots of Russian food all the time now.Samuel: Yeah, I know. It’s great. And, but at the same time, I think I still see a lot of problems there.Yan: Yeah. Plus or minus.Samuel: Out of communism. And, I think reading about it and listening to a lot of stories from that time, the growing pains of moving from a completely centrally controlled economy to a less centrally controlled economy has been difficult, and I know that’s one of the reasons that kind of brought you into Bitcoin as well too.Yan: Yeah. I mean, it’s interesting because I had got into Bitcoin, unrelated to being from the Soviet Union, but then after I sort of studied it for a while, I circled back and started understanding what the actual purpose of Bitcoin was. Because, you know, as somebody who grew up doing technology stuff, I’ve been doing startups for 20 years.So when I first heard about Bitcoin, I really thought about it as a technology. Is it really interesting distributed systems problem that had been solved? How to get a whole bunch of computers to coordinate that didn’t trust each other, and there was a lot of brilliance there. When I first got into Bitcoin, I spent a lot of time studying decentralised and distributed networks in general, kind of the whole blockchain space, you know, theory and all these other kinds of distributed projects, and then probably six or eight months after doing that, and I circled back to Bitcoin.Just trying to understand the underlying, like where did this all come from? And I almost, by accident stumbled upon this talk by Andreas Antonopoulos called Currency Wars, where he started talking about why Bitcoin was important and how he had misread it, right? He said that he originally thought of it as a remittance technology that it would maybe compete with Western Union and then over time, he started seeing this pattern in the world where all these governments were essentially playing games with their currencies, and we see that today, right? We see Trump tweeting at Jay Powell, like, we need to lower interest rates to be competitive with the rest of the world.We need to stimulate our economy and so what they’re really talking about there is currency debasements and capital controls, which is something that’s happening all over the world. Andrea spoke a lot about that and saying how people weren’t able to access money out of their HTMS, and there were bank runs, people weren’t allowed to leave the country with a certain amount of money. When I understood all of that, I started understanding Bitcoin as a money for freedom for defeating capital controls and for allowing people to have real ownership over their money. That’s when I started asking my parents because you know I’d never thought about what the Soviet life was like. I was seven years old when I came over here. We grew up very poor in America. We quickly got back on our feet because my parents were thankfully well-educated. They were engineers and teachers. It took them a while to get back on their feet, but we did. Initially, we were very poor, and I never thought about like why is that the case?You know, I kind of assumed we just left, the Soviet Union with what we had. But as it turns out, when we left, our parents were able to exchange only $100 per person to leave the country with. So we left the country with $400 in our pocket and the reason for that was capital controls because the Soviet Union did not want; they had a fake exchange rate, just like most countries do when they have broken currency or when they have a centrally planned economy. The government has one exchange rate. It might be, say, 10 rubles, so dollar, and then on the street it’s really like a hundred rubles. Nobody actually wants that currency. Because of that, they have capital controls where they will only exchange a certain amount when you’re leaving the country. That’s when I finally started tying together why Bitcoin was really important for the world. It wasn’t because it was this really interesting technology or payment system. It was because it was a new type of money that you could actually carry out with you from a country like the Soviet Union and that’s kind of when it all came together for me.Samuel: It acts as like a digital Swiss bank account that can’t be seized.Yan: Yeah, I think of it that way. Or digital gold, right? It’s something, unlike those things. I mean Swiss bank account, only can’t be seized in quotes, right? Given enough government intervention, all kinds of things are possible, and same thing with gold. If you’re in the Soviet Union or something, you try to walk out of the country with gold in your pockets while you’re not going to leave very far. Bitcoin is interesting in the way that it’s scarce. You know, it’s digital, and it’s portable. You can put it in your head, and you can just memorise, say 24 words, which represent your private keys. And you can just walk out of a country like that. And, you know, you have your money, you have your wealth, and that’s very compelling for people living in those kinds of regimes.Samuel: One thing that happened in Russia and probably in the rest of the outer Soviet union countries is that from the time of the collapse in like 1991, up until maybe the mid-2010s, there had been a huge process of offshorisation of capital fleeing the country. There were all the dark markets who would use their positions of power, essentially acting as a mafia, right? Changing from essentially a mafia boss legitimately by the government standards, at least like a legitimate business owner who would control vast sums of capital and assets that were legally through the government structure, but like in real life, illegally seized and then use to enrich themselves, beyond the scope of what anybody could think of.Yan: Yeah, and I think a lot of these people had ties to the prior government, right? Like when people were in the PO in communist Russia, when everybody was supposed to be equal. I mean, that really wasn’t the case. People had special access to capital, to business, and there were bribes everywhere that were obviously in any tightly controlled economy, there’s a thriving black market because the reality is things still have to happen. I think a lot of these folks had access to these markets when everyday people didn’t and were able to rise upSamuel: Over this time period, you know, it’s estimated that 50% of all of Russia’s wealth has gone offshore and is now in different jurisdictions outside of the scope of the Russian government. This is one thing that led to their big push in the middle of 2000 tens for the offshorisation to try to limit the amount of money that could flee offshore outside of the country. Do you think that the Russian government should be able to go if it wants to and seize these offshore funds?Yan: It’s a tricky thing, right? Because it’s like a double-edged sword, right? You either have freedom, or you don’t have freedom. So you know, if you have the freedom you have cash and cash is to some degree anonymous, you know, and you’re free to move it around while you’re going to have criminals doing that, right? You’re also going to have everyday people doing that. Now if we say there are two possible futures from this point on. One is that all money is going digital. I don’t think that’s probably not a contentious point. Money is becoming digital very rapidly, and whether that happens, tomorrow or in two generations, it’s going to happen at some point. The vast majority of payments over, you know, in the world are starting to become digital anyway. When money goes fully digital, what kind of world do we want? One answer to that is we want to have a world where every payment is tracked, traced, surveillance, right? That’s what banks and governments want. They push for that. We have papers coming out of the IMF and other baking entities that say when we get to digital money, and especially central bank digital money where we have no intermediaries we can trace everything and that’s really great. We can stop terrorism and drugs and child porn and all that kind of stuff.Offshoring of oligarch money, right? But what does that mean for the average person? Because we have to remember that criminals are a very small proportion of the general population. So what we’re saying is in order to stop these ten guys who have offshored millions of dollars, we’re going to check and surveil everybody’s payments, and that really leads to very totalitarian regimes. We already see examples of that. Look at China, where they have a social credit system where they’re monitoring what people are doing. Then they can push them out of the system and say, okay, now you can’t buy train tickets cause you smoked on a train.Is that really the society we want, or do we want a society where people have freedom with their money? It does mean that there will be criminals that are also free of that money, but criminals are also free with the internet. There have always been criminals throughout history.We’ve always stopped some of them, not all of them. It’s just a question of tradeoffs. For me saying that all money should be surveilled and tracked and we should have the option to press a button and cut a person out of the system or cut an entire country out of the system, that is a bad tradeoff to make because we’re really just saying we’re going to take everybody’s freedom away.Just look at the Soviet Union, people were just not able to leave because they couldn’t take their money with them and that’s what that means. When you have capital controls, and you have surveillance, and you give the state so much power, you’re really saying people should be stuck in wherever country, whatever country they’re stuck in, and they can’t leave cause they can’t take their money and they can’t buy the things that they need to because those things are illegal because their government has decided that I don’t like that society at all, and that’s not the tradeoff that I would make.Yan: I’m actually from Ukraine. I am from Kyiv, but I have not followed modern Ukrainian history, really, other than what I’ve heard on the news with, you know, things going down. I don’t really have any ties to the country anymore. There’s nobody, no family there for me.Samuel: Covich, that’s the guy.Yan: Putin’s guy, right?Samuel: I mean, all these things are a very grey area, right? Because to say that somebody is pro-European, pro-Russian, it really comes down to the geopolitics of how the natural gas and oil is passing through Ukraine and who’s benefiting from that because it really doesn’t matter. It really didn’t matter who was in place. It just matters more about who is on top to be able to reap the profits.From the industry and benefit their friends, in these types of governments, it’s wrong for Americans to think that the Russian government, or maybe not the Russian government, but that the Ukrainian government or the Russian government or any of these former Soviet States work in the same way that the American government does, and that it has the same trend level of transparency and the same level of, ability to protest.There was this really amazing scene where people from Kyiv walked over to his residence. And this was his dacha that was outside of the city. And nobody actual…
Full show notes at the publisher