TopPodcast.com
Menu
  • Home
  • Top Charts
  • Top Networks
  • Top Apps
  • Top Independents
  • Top Podfluencers
  • Top Picks
    • Top Business Podcasts
    • Top True Crime Podcasts
    • Top Finance Podcasts
    • Top Comedy Podcasts
    • Top Music Podcasts
    • Top Womens Podcasts
    • Top Kids Podcasts
    • Top Sports Podcasts
    • Top News Podcasts
    • Top Tech Podcasts
    • Top Crypto Podcasts
    • Top Entrepreneurial Podcasts
    • Top Fantasy Sports Podcasts
    • Top Political Podcasts
    • Top Science Podcasts
    • Top Self Help Podcasts
    • Top Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Top Stocks Podcasts
  • Podcast News
  • About Us
  • Podcast Advertising
  • Contact
Not in our directory?
Add Show Here
Podcast Equipment
Center

toppodcastlogoOur TOPPODCAST Picks

  • Comedy
  • Crypto
  • Sports
  • News
  • Politics
  • True Crime
  • Business
  • Finance

Follow Us

toppodcastlogoStay Connected

    View Top 200 Chart
    Back to Rankings Page
    Technology

    End of the Chain

    Future focused podcast and articles shaping the end of history, AI, Blockchain, VR…

    Advertise

    Copyright: © End of the Chain Copyright 2021

    • Apple Podcasts
    • Google Play
    • Spotify

    Latest Episodes:
    Freedom Money - Yan Pritzker - Swan Bitcoin May 21, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeDoes money need to be just? Or is it just a tool of man? Yan Pritzker joins this episode with host Samuel McCulloch to discuss growing up in the Soviet Union, Bitcoin as freedom, and how it can be used as a get out of "troubled" country hedge.Yan Pritzker is the co-founder and CTO of Swan Bitcoin, the best place to buy Bitcoin with your bank account using automated daily, weekly, and monthly savings plan. Yan is the former co-founder and CTO at Reverb, which was sold to Etsy for $275M.Yan's LinksHomepage | Linkedin | CrunchbaseSwan BitcoinWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy Yan’s experiences of growing up in the Soviet Union influenced his thinking around Bitcoin and how he came into the space.Why we need a society where people have freedom with their money and without capital controls.Why there are always tradeoffs between freedom and surveillance in any society.What the difference is between people who prefer safety over freedom and people who prefer freedom over safety; and why this matters now more than ever.Why we need to look beyond the US narrative around ‘Axis of Evil’ countries and our empire perspective to understand the causes of terrorism.Why money and US financial systems are at the root of most of the conflicts in the world.Why the US dollar system may be broken and why Bitcoin is a hedge against this future outcome.Why the lack of short-term volatility is a tradeoff with systemic instability and why volatility always comes back in the long-term.Why centralized systems create more opportunities for criminals to steal your data because the information is fully public and easily hacked.Why Yan thinks perfect privacy does not exist and is impossible to achieve if you interact with any centralized system.Why everyone should be saving a little Bitcoin every month nd how SwanBitcoin helps you do this.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show TranscriptionSamuel: Hello, and welcome to the end of the chain. I’m your host, Samuel McCullough. And I want to welcome you to this very special episode where I am joined by Yan Pritzker from Swan Bitcoin. Now, I think it’s very important to speak with people who are Bitcoin maximalists and who have a different point of view than I do when it comes to the development of cryptocurrencies and how they’re used in the wider world. This turned out to be a lively debate. I want to thank Yan for coming on. I think we talked about some really great points and really got into some deeper aspects of using cryptocurrencies that I don’t think Yan may have explored before. So I want to thank him for coming on to the episode. As always make sure to subscribe to this podcast, share it with your mothers, brothers, sisters, mothers, and anyone else who you think would enjoy listening to the end of the chain. All right. That wraps it up. Let’s hop into the episode.Welcome to the podcast. Yan, I’m actually really excited to have you on because, two months ago, my wife and I, we just moved from Russia back in February actually. And yeah, so I had been living there for six years. I moved there in 2013. my wife is from Tuman in Siberia. And, but we met in Moscow and we had lived, we got married a couple years back, three years back and, then just moved here to Florida, for a new job just a while back. In my research, you’re also Russian as well too, and you, like my wife, lived in the Soviet Union as well. When exactly did you immigrate to the United States?Yan: Yeah, so I came over in 1989. I was seven years old at the time and came over with my parents and my sister. But yeah, I grew up in Russia, in Soviet Russia, which was a very interesting experience for sure.Samuel: I think a lot of people in the West, it’s really lost on them. Even people that grew up in the United States, the views that they were getting were not really t actual life of living over there. The more time that I’ve spent there, and more so even getting out of Moscow as well too, like living in more rural places, you start to see the differences and kind of cultured people, and it’s a great place. I love Russian culture. I love Russian food.Yan: Oh yeah.Yan: We still eat lots of Russian food all the time now.Samuel: Yeah, I know. It’s great. And, but at the same time, I think I still see a lot of problems there.Yan: Yeah. Plus or minus.Samuel: Out of communism. And, I think reading about it and listening to a lot of stories from that time, the growing pains of moving from a completely centrally controlled economy to a less centrally controlled economy has been difficult, and I know that’s one of the reasons that kind of brought you into Bitcoin as well too.Yan: Yeah. I mean, it’s interesting because I had got into Bitcoin, unrelated to being from the Soviet Union, but then after I sort of studied it for a while, I circled back and started understanding what the actual purpose of Bitcoin was. Because, you know, as somebody who grew up doing technology stuff, I’ve been doing startups for 20 years.So when I first heard about Bitcoin, I really thought about it as a technology. Is it really interesting distributed systems problem that had been solved? How to get a whole bunch of computers to coordinate that didn’t trust each other, and there was a lot of brilliance there. When I first got into Bitcoin, I spent a lot of time studying decentralised and distributed networks in general, kind of the whole blockchain space, you know, theory and all these other kinds of distributed projects, and then probably six or eight months after doing that, and I circled back to Bitcoin.Just trying to understand the underlying, like where did this all come from? And I almost, by accident stumbled upon this talk by Andreas Antonopoulos called Currency Wars, where he started talking about why Bitcoin was important and how he had misread it, right? He said that he originally thought of it as a remittance technology that it would maybe compete with Western Union and then over time, he started seeing this pattern in the world where all these governments were essentially playing games with their currencies, and we see that today, right? We see Trump tweeting at Jay Powell, like, we need to lower interest rates to be competitive with the rest of the world.We need to stimulate our economy and so what they’re really talking about there is currency debasements and capital controls, which is something that’s happening all over the world. Andrea spoke a lot about that and saying how people weren’t able to access money out of their HTMS, and there were bank runs, people weren’t allowed to leave the country with a certain amount of money. When I understood all of that, I started understanding Bitcoin as a money for freedom for defeating capital controls and for allowing people to have real ownership over their money. That’s when I started asking my parents because you know I’d never thought about what the Soviet life was like. I was seven years old when I came over here. We grew up very poor in America. We quickly got back on our feet because my parents were thankfully well-educated. They were engineers and teachers. It took them a while to get back on their feet, but we did. Initially, we were very poor, and I never thought about like why is that the case?You know, I kind of assumed we just left, the Soviet Union with what we had. But as it turns out, when we left, our parents were able to exchange only $100 per person to leave the country with. So we left the country with $400 in our pocket and the reason for that was capital controls because the Soviet Union did not want; they had a fake exchange rate, just like most countries do when they have broken currency or when they have a centrally planned economy. The government has one exchange rate. It might be, say, 10 rubles, so dollar, and then on the street it’s really like a hundred rubles. Nobody actually wants that currency. Because of that, they have capital controls where they will only exchange a certain amount when you’re leaving the country. That’s when I finally started tying together why Bitcoin was really important for the world. It wasn’t because it was this really interesting technology or payment system. It was because it was a new type of money that you could actually carry out with you from a country like the Soviet Union and that’s kind of when it all came together for me.Samuel: It acts as like a digital Swiss bank account that can’t be seized.Yan: Yeah, I think of it that way. Or digital gold, right? It’s something, unlike those things. I mean Swiss bank account, only can’t be seized in quotes, right? Given enough government intervention, all kinds of things are possible, and same thing with gold. If you’re in the Soviet Union or something, you try to walk out of the country with gold in your pockets while you’re not going to leave very far. Bitcoin is interesting in the way that it’s scarce. You know, it’s digital, and it’s portable. You can put it in your head, and you can just memorise, say 24 words, which represent your private keys. And you can just walk out of a country like that. And, you know, you have your money, you have your wealth, and that’s very compelling for people living in those kinds of regimes.Samuel: One thing that happened in Russia and probably in the rest of the outer Soviet union countries is that from the time of the collapse in like 1991, up until maybe the mid-2010s, there had been a huge process of offshorisation of capital fleeing the country. There were all the dark markets who would use their positions of power, essentially acting as a mafia, right? Changing from essentially a mafia boss legitimately by the government standards, at least like a legitimate business owner who would control vast sums of capital and assets that were legally through the government structure, but like in real life, illegally seized and then use to enrich themselves, beyond the scope of what anybody could think of.Yan: Yeah, and I think a lot of these people had ties to the prior government, right? Like when people were in the PO in communist Russia, when everybody was supposed to be equal. I mean, that really wasn’t the case. People had special access to capital, to business, and there were bribes everywhere that were obviously in any tightly controlled economy, there’s a thriving black market because the reality is things still have to happen. I think a lot of these folks had access to these markets when everyday people didn’t and were able to rise upSamuel: Over this time period, you know, it’s estimated that 50% of all of Russia’s wealth has gone offshore and is now in different jurisdictions outside of the scope of the Russian government. This is one thing that led to their big push in the middle of 2000 tens for the offshorisation to try to limit the amount of money that could flee offshore outside of the country. Do you think that the Russian government should be able to go if it wants to and seize these offshore funds?Yan: It’s a tricky thing, right? Because it’s like a double-edged sword, right? You either have freedom, or you don’t have freedom. So you know, if you have the freedom you have cash and cash is to some degree anonymous, you know, and you’re free to move it around while you’re going to have criminals doing that, right? You’re also going to have everyday people doing that. Now if we say there are two possible futures from this point on. One is that all money is going digital. I don’t think that’s probably not a contentious point. Money is becoming digital very rapidly, and whether that happens, tomorrow or in two generations, it’s going to happen at some point. The vast majority of payments over, you know, in the world are starting to become digital anyway. When money goes fully digital, what kind of world do we want? One answer to that is we want to have a world where every payment is tracked, traced, surveillance, right? That’s what banks and governments want. They push for that. We have papers coming out of the IMF and other baking entities that say when we get to digital money, and especially central bank digital money where we have no intermediaries we can trace everything and that’s really great. We can stop terrorism and drugs and child porn and all that kind of stuff.Offshoring of oligarch money, right? But what does that mean for the average person? Because we have to remember that criminals are a very small proportion of the general population. So what we’re saying is in order to stop these ten guys who have offshored millions of dollars, we’re going to check and surveil everybody’s payments, and that really leads to very totalitarian regimes. We already see examples of that. Look at China, where they have a social credit system where they’re monitoring what people are doing. Then they can push them out of the system and say, okay, now you can’t buy train tickets cause you smoked on a train.Is that really the society we want, or do we want a society where people have freedom with their money? It does mean that there will be criminals that are also free of that money, but criminals are also free with the internet. There have always been criminals throughout history.We’ve always stopped some of them, not all of them. It’s just a question of tradeoffs. For me saying that all money should be surveilled and tracked and we should have the option to press a button and cut a person out of the system or cut an entire country out of the system, that is a bad tradeoff to make because we’re really just saying we’re going to take everybody’s freedom away.Just look at the Soviet Union, people were just not able to leave because they couldn’t take their money with them and that’s what that means. When you have capital controls, and you have surveillance, and you give the state so much power, you’re really saying people should be stuck in wherever country, whatever country they’re stuck in, and they can’t leave cause they can’t take their money and they can’t buy the things that they need to because those things are illegal because their government has decided that I don’t like that society at all, and that’s not the tradeoff that I would make.Yan: I’m actually from Ukraine. I am from Kyiv, but I have not followed modern Ukrainian history, really, other than what I’ve heard on the news with, you know, things going down. I don’t really have any ties to the country anymore. There’s nobody, no family there for me.Samuel: Covich, that’s the guy.Yan: Putin’s guy, right?Samuel: I mean, all these things are a very grey area, right? Because to say that somebody is pro-European, pro-Russian, it really comes down to the geopolitics of how the natural gas and oil is passing through Ukraine and who’s benefiting from that because it really doesn’t matter. It really didn’t matter who was in place. It just matters more about who is on top to be able to reap the profits.From the industry and benefit their friends, in these types of governments, it’s wrong for Americans to think that the Russian government, or maybe not the Russian government, but that the Ukrainian government or the Russian government or any of these former Soviet States work in the same way that the American government does, and that it has the same trend level of transparency and the same level of, ability to protest.There was this really amazing scene where people from Kyiv walked over to his residence. And this was his dacha that was outside of the city. And nobody actual…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    New Economic Systems - Jesse Proudman - Strix Leviathan May 18, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeWhat does it mean to be agnostic about blockchain? Jesse Proudman joins the episode to discuss his time at IBM, Tether flows, gap finance and how his hedge fund is navigating the volatility of crypto markets. Jesse is the CEO and Founder of Strix Leviathan and a member of the Strix Leviathan Investment Committee. Jesse has over 20 years of experience as a technical entrepreneur. Prior to Strix Leviathan, Jesse founded Blue Box, a cloud computing startup. Jesse raised $22M in venture capital for Blue Box and subsequently sold the company to IBM where Jesse was named as an IBM Distinguished Engineer. At IBM, Jesse spent time researching blockchain and cryptocurrency. Jesse is an active member of the Seattle startup community. He was awarded the 2014 GeekWire Young Entrepreneur of the Year award, was named to the 2013 PSBJ 40 under 40 class and serves on the board for the Buerk Center for Entrepreneurship at the University of Washington. Jesse holds a bachelor’s degree from the University of Puget Sound.Jesse's LinksLinkedin | WikipediaStrix Leviathan's WebsiteWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy Jesse’s time at IBM and working in Hyperledger, helped him develop his approach to blockchain investment.How IBM’s marketing machine is doing a great job of getting people talking about blockchain and asking why?Why public blockchains solve three/four problems well and why most business models do not need one.How Jesse’s research demonstrated that prices are entirely driven by behaviour, speculation and liquidity in the crypto space.Why Tether is a privatised Eurodollar network and how this is used to evade capital controls and sanctions.Why the next halving is different than the previous two because of the number of leveraged loans.Why miners are betting on speculation and leveraging their businesses to pay their bills rather than selling their Bitcoin.Why the Stablecoin business model falls apart when you have negative rates, which are coming sooner than you think.Why the painful user experience problem still exists in the crypto/DeFi space and how this needs to be fixed to allow for wider adoption.Why Jesse is a big fan of Silvergate Bank’s exchange transfer network and why infrastructure development still has a long way to go in the space.Why Jesse believes price is a function of the narrative that people choose to believe in: if you think it will happen, it will happen.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show TranscriptionJesse Proudman Show NotesSamuel: Today, I am joined by Jesse, who is the CEO at Strix Leviathan, an algorithmic crypto-focused quantitative hedge fund. Jesse, welcome to the End of the Chain.Jesse: Thrilled to be here. Thanks for having us.Samuel: I wanted really to dive into your opinions on some of the things that you were doing in your past. I know that you had started a company called Bluebox, and then they were acquired by IBM back in 2015, and you bounced around between different divisions. Once they determined you can figure out what you want to do with IBM. You came to the VC side of things and their accelerator, specifically at IBM. But one of the things that IBM has done in terms of blockchain since like 2016/17, is developing Hyperledger which is a private blockchain developed for companies and other small enterprises or small/medium enterprises, or even large ones, that would need some sort of private ledger that they could use in relation to what is being done on the public side with say, Ethereum. I’ve never really been a huge proponent of private blockchains. I mean, they’re a read-only database that’s connected between a lot of actors. With the development of the rules and regulations that we have, for data privacy, especially in the EU with GDPR, it takes a lot of the trust factor out of the equation when developing these sorts of databases. I want to start by getting your feeling on since it has been three years almost since you left. What have you seen at IBM really since then, and how do you think that the Hyperledger system can develop, or is it even necessary with today’s network systems that are being built out for companies?Jesse: Yeah, it’s a great question. IBM acquired Blueblocks, June of 2015. I spent the first year and a half after the acquisition working with the IBM cloud group to integrate the broader Bluebox products in IBM clouds, their private cloud initiatives, and then began to look for other opportunities there. The blockchain space and the blockchain initiative at IBM, in particular, were really interesting to me. From my side, I’m most interested in blockchain due to the financial aspects of it, and the sort of blockchain as a distributed database is not super interesting to me. When I was making that transition, my pitch was to effectively become the subject matter expert on the cryptocurrency component of blockchain.At that point in time, IBM didn’t have a focus or an interest on that side. They’d wanted to stay out of sort of the cryptocurrency component, and they wanted to focus on more of the supply chain style implementations. That original sort of pitch that I made was denied. I was offered a role as a product manager working on the Hyperledger project, and I think my challenge or concern is very much like yours. In the midst of the summer of 2017, the word blockchain or distributed ledger was being used really as a marketing initiative to be able to gain sort of excitement from folks, without really thinking through the rationale for why to use these sets of technologies.I think by far and large, it doesn’t make sense to add the complexity and overhead that private blockchains create for the use cases that they’re being used for or being used for at the time. I think there can be certain use cases where this technology does make sense in a private sense, but for the most part, when you have a bunch of parties that trust each other, which most of the implementations that were being done at the time were for, you don’t need this kind of overhead. That role wasn’t particularly interesting to me, and I ended up settling on the accelerator role, trying to develop a blockchain-focused accelerator for startups and wrote the prospectus for that and then ultimately my job was to continue to research the space over the summer of 2017. At the conclusion of 2017, IBM came back, and it was determined that there wasn’t capital to fund the accelerator.So I made the decision to leave and to launch strikes. Kind of over the last couple of years I’ve been watching the IBM blockchain group, sort of from my periphery, I think that organization is led by one of IBM’s better managers, Marie Weeks. She ran IBM cloud when we were there for a period of time, so I interacted with her in that domain, and she seems to be sort of in IBM, there are two casts of characters. There’s like the lifelong IBM folks that have kind of moved from role to role and have kind of worked their way up in the company and it in my eyes, IBM has this culture where you don’t really fail out of IBM. You fail up to some extent, so a lot of folks were in positions where they, in my eyes, didn’t necessarily have the technical or leadership capability to effectively run that organization. Then there were other folks in the organization that that really seem to get it. They understood what the technology landscape IBM was operating in looked like. They understood what it took to lead Marie was, was one of those leaders.I felt like at least that organization had a good head on his shoulders and it seemed to be pulling many of them, brighter folks and the IBM organization into it. I just think that the issue, and this is kind of IBM’s broader issue, has been this focus on immediate revenue growth over-investing in research and development. In any emerging technology blockchain, in particular, there’s going to be a pretty significant lag between capital you invest now in understanding and developing a sort of a new domain and the revenue that’s going to materialize from that investment down the path and IBM, particularly under the leadership of Ginni Rometty, was so focused on quarterly revenue growth that there wasn’t a lot of tolerance or patience for sort of longer-term investment.That’s the concern I had at the time, and the concern I’ve continued to have over the last couple of years, there’s not significant, being measured in hundreds of millions or billions of dollars, investment from third party companies into private blockchain space. Yet, like there’s investment/ interest, but this is not the next Watson at this point in time, and it’s going to take time for that to materialize. The question I have is there patience or the ability to sort of wait out that timeframe? I’m not sure. I’m not sure how that’s played out internally, but that’s been my observation and my consideration.Samuel: Well, I think you called IBM a marketing machine primarily in one of your previous interviews, and you know, they have to keep rolling out technologies to sell to their clients to drive revenues. I think it doesn’t meet the necessity of why you would ever need a blockchain. Right, I’m in the camp of probably 99% of people don’t need a blockchain or companies; it just doesn’t do anything for them. It adds complexity to the typical business operations that they would do and makes it more difficult for them to grow as a company.Because you’re locking yourself into this one specific network structure that has very conservative growth patterns and is not something that can be adapted to your own personal company’s needs very readily. If you do move on to using a blockchain, going halfway just doesn’t do it. You have to jump all the way into using Ethereum or something else which would then allow you to develop specifically for the traits that are inherent to those blockchains itself. I work for a company that issues securities. I think we’re actually the only company that has a tradable security token on Ethereum right now.The amount of legal that goes into every decision that we make is the majority of the problems that we have. I can see this exponentially magnified for a company like IBM or any other major corporation, which does not want to get in the sights of the SEC or any other regulatory body when they’re trying to roll out this new technology to their clients because it’s the last thing that they would want to end up on was something like huge liabilities from breaking securities regulations, but there are only a few benefits that are really specific, and if you don’t offer those benefits, then there’s almost no point. But if you can figure them out, which I think we have, then you know there is a benefit to using a public blockchain, but I don’t know about a private one.Jesse: I think you’re exactly right. You think about, in my eyes, like some of the most clickable use cases outside of financial transactions, like the one that always comes to mind for me is property titles and property deeds, and so here is an existing legacy process and involves a bunch of physical paperwork. It’s shuffled around from signing partner to the escrow agents to being recorded with each individual city. It’s an old bureaucratic, broken process and it’s expensive, and it’s painful. That is a use case where you’ve got a bunch of parties that don’t necessarily trust each other, where you want to a history that is immutable. It’s a perfect use case, but then you think through the regulatory landscape of what it would take to change how that process works, and it’s just immense. The challenge I think that IBM has with going down that private blockchain road is that most of the use cases that really do make sense and where a private blockchain or even a public blockchain would be applicable are touched by so many historical actors and would require so much agreement across so many different parties to make that transition. The bureaucratic headwinds themselves feel almost impossible to overcome. So that’s the challenge. You end up with sort of these pilot projects that are amongst small groups of trusted parties to try to prove that the technology works, and it just doesn’t, the benefits I don’t think, outweigh the effort.Samuel: Yeah, exactly. I’m excited to see what comes out of IBM because I know there’s a lot of smart people working there, especially in Hyperledger, and it adds back into the system of all the other different networks of what they’re developing. Right? It’s a win-win for everybody else, but at the same time, I don’t see how it directly affects their business bottom line, the business revenues in the short term. I mean, maybe in the longer term they can figure it out.Jesse: The powerful pieces that IBM truly is a marketing machine. Like I’ve always been impressed with their marketing organization and for the broader blockchain industry as a whole. IBM has the ability to inform and educate such a broader audience with the marketing budget that they have than any individual company could do on their own. That’s a really powerful benefit to having IBM in this industry. Right? I remember sort of the end of 17/beginning of 18, you would see these IBM ads in the airport talking about blockchain technology, and at least it starts a question for folks. The answer may not be particularly clear, but if IBM can get people interested in the space and can get people starting to do their own research and learning more about what’s involved here, that’s a net win. Whether or not you’re exactly right, whether or not that has a financial benefit for the company as a whole is it’s a different question. But from an industry promotion perspective, I think they’ve done a great service.Samuel: Well, here’s the thing is that I’m of the opinion that even in 2020, even with the release of CME futures and the development of grayscale trust and all the different products that have been released in the past couple of years, I still see these platforms, these networks as retail predominantly driven networks, right? Where the individual users that makeup of it are the ones who are driving price and who may not have that level of sophistication which would be equivalent to a Goldman or a top-level, top tier hedge fund that’s managing hundreds of billions of dollars where they have specific outcomes they want to affect onto the market by entering it. I think we’re inching closer towards that. There’s a lot of issues, and in getting these types of entities on board, there are regulatory and custodial and all these things which are being solved at the moment, but when you look at the actual users of the products themselves, once you get away from Bitcoin, like Ethereum, primary users of these applications are our retail clients. Even if they have $50 million dollars, you could still probably consider them a retail user just in the way that they’re using it and the way that they are structuring their trade setups or even their general use cases for interacting with these blockchains. If that’s the case, then if you are designing new products, right? At RealT, we’ve designed a product which is geared towards the retail client. The reason we do this is because public blockchains solve three/four things.The first one is, of course, transparency and accounting, right? So, you know, if you issue a token or anything on a blockchain, you can see it everywhere. It’s completely public and completely transparent. The second thing, which…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    On-chain Insurance - Hugh Karp - Nexus Mutual May 08, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeHugh Karp joins this episode to discuss onchain insurance, protecting Defi against hacks and what it means for the insurance companies of the future. Hugh Karp is the Founder of Nexus Mutual, an automated discretionary mutual running on Ethereum. He is an insurance professional and actuary with over 15 years of experience in the insurance industry. He has held a variety of roles in both primary and reinsurance companies including as CFO for a global reinsurers’ Life operations in the UK.Hugh's LinksLinkedin | Twitter | MediumNexus MutualWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy insurance is one of the massive verticals in the real-world financial economy and why it is now being built on-chain in the DeFi economy.Why insurance came about as a community method of sharing risk between people.How their decentralized protocol prices risk on-chain and how they developed their crypto risk pricing framework.What the recent bZx hack and Black Thursday taught Nexus about their smart contract cover and why they need to look at creating complete coverage to meet the needs of the evolving DeFi space.Why Nexus can provide any insurance product on-chain so long as its members vote on it and the staking around the risks being covered.Why Hugh thinks their risk pricing framework could be applied to exotic products like digital art or tokenized assets in the future.As a huge privacy proponent, Hugh is worried about going too far too fast in the pursuit of privacy in DeFi and the perceived political risk to the ecosystem from regulatory/political clampdown as a result.Why Hugh loves experimentation, but maybe we should do this without putting massive amounts of funds at risk.Why sometimes we are running before we can walk in DeFi.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show TranscriptionHello and welcome to the end of the chain. I am your host Samuel McCulloch in this episode. I’m joined by Hugh Karp from Nexus Mutual. We jump right into discussing the interactions of on-chain insurance and also the evolution of how the industry has been growing, especially after the multitude of hacks that have happened over the past few months. If you haven’t already, make sure to subscribe to this podcast wherever you listen to it and to follow me on twitter, so that wraps everything up, let’s hop into the episode now:Samuel: [00:00:45] Hugh, welcome, you are the founder of Nexus Mutual, an on-chain insurance protocol for Ethereum, which I think people took less seriously a couple of months ago before the bZx hacks and before the attack on Maker How would you say that insurance has changed in the Ethereum landscape in late 2019/2020?Hugh: [00:01:15] Yeah. I think insurance is one of these massive verticals of the financial ecosystem that kind of needs to be built. I think if we’re building a parallel financial ecosystem or just a parallel economy on Ethereum, then it needs to happen. I guess it’s also a lot more complex to build than some other financial products, so it does make sense that it comes a bit later than some of the other stuff. We were the kind of one of the first main ones to get out there, covering crypto-native risks if you want to call it that. There’ve been a few other kinds of alternative approaches coming out more recently. We are definitely still at the experimental stage, but, everyone’s got to start somewhere and, you know, we’re starting small, and I guess hoping to grow and hoping to protect people getting involved in this new economy.Samuel: [00:02:09] But why does it need to be on-chain? I mean, what are the reasons for it needing to be trustless and decentralized when most insurance has underwriters, and it’s done through a per-claim basis?Hugh: [00:02:22] Yeah, the main benefits of actually doing this on-chain, they kind of come back to why you actually regulate insurance companies in the first place. I mean, the crux of why you regulate insurance companies is because in essence, they’re looking after customers’ money on their behalf, and then at some point, they will pay it back as claims. They take fees along the way to, you know, to pay expenses and profit, etc. but essentially they have to do the right things by that money and protect it. Invest that appropriately, you know, make sure it’s there to meet those potential liabilities. So you have all of these controls, laws and regulations around why and how you should do that.The other main reason why you’d want to regulate insurance companies is to ensure this kind of asymmetry of information between the customer and the insurance company. That’s kind of basically done through reporting, financial accounts and that type of stuff. This means you can be confident that they hold the money and are well-capitalized. Those two things are actually done really well on-chain. If you can specify the rules about how the money can be used and it can only be used in these circumstances, then you’ve effectively taken away that agency risk that is the primary reason for regulating. Then the second reason is about transparency, about how much money is there. That it is all there and open which is by definition on Ethereum, that is the reason for the regulation; it’s just dealing with it in a different way.[00:03:50]That means it can all flow back to benefit the people who were buying, cover insurance and they can benefit from it. When it comes down to it, the insurance came from community-based methods where people got together and shared risk together. Then it morphed into shareholder-based companies because, that was a more effective way of getting capital to the customers, connecting the capital to the risk that people wanted. Butt now we can cut out that entire value chain and connect the people and the capital together in a one really easy way. In theory, this allows us to do non-custodial ways of holding funds and defining those particular rules. To me, it fits very naturally with a decentralized framework, and it can strip out massive costs compared to the regular insurance industry, and it can hand those kinds of benefits back to the people involved in the protocol.[00:04:47]Obviously we’re really small and all the rest of it. The insurance vertical in the regular financial world is huge, but we have to start somewhere and, I think it’s a really natural fit for a decentralized network.Samuel: [00:05:00] What was the name of a group of people that would get together and implement insurance for retirement? A tontine.Hugh: [00:05:15] A Tontine, it is like a type of life insurance or the opposite of life insurance in some ways. Basically, in the extreme version of the tontine, which you’ve may have seen on the Simpsons where the last surviving person receives the whole pot of money. Everyone puts in an equal amount of money, and then the last person gets it. Apart from the obvious social issues about incentivizing murder or something like that, if you can actually work around those things, this is actually a very useful financial construct. I think they abandoned it in a few places, but they’re actually useful in particular for managing longevity risk or paying pension liabilities and those types of things, even though they’re not widely used anymore.Samuel: [00:05:59] How do you do pricing for these on-chain assets? The risk of a certain event happening is typically decided by underwriters, by insurance companies. How does it actually get done with a decentralized protocol or through Nexus Mutual?Hugh: [00:06:21] The way underwriting and pricing work in the regular financial world is you have a combination of these underwriters with specific risk knowledge, and also actuarial tables based on historical data and those types of things. Right now, especially with the crypto risks where I’m covering the risk of smart contracts failing as an example, then you don’t necessarily have enough data to construct that. The way we’ve got around that problem is constructing a staking mechanism, and it works in a similar fashion to a prediction market where the more you stake on a particular risk, the lower the price. Ours is more structured than a prediction market as it has some other factors and frameworks in it as well, but essentially it is like a prediction with built-in staking on the risk to lower the price.Samuel: [00:07:03] How has the response been to some of the bigger events that have happened? I guess the two that I mentioned before the bZx attack. It was not really even a hack, there was just too much congestion within the market at that moment, and people couldn’t get their transactions through. Somebody took advantage of that and made little bits for these liquidated CDPs.Hugh: [00:07:44] Our product that Nexus offers right now is called smart contract cover. It covers the risk of smart contracts failing. It came from events like DAO hack or the Parody multisig quality issues which we observed actually happening. This is a risk, but in theory, it needs to be dealt with if it’s going to be successful.I think the first BCX hack is actually a good example because it was a complicated transaction with a flash loan and a whole bunch of different protocols. Quite a lot going on. It took a while for people to realize that. The initial reaction was that it was an oracle manipulation that you change the price on UniSwap, and then you take money out, et cetera. That’s what we initially thought it was kind of a large part of what the transaction is doing, but it also turned out that there was a check in the bZx smart contracts that were intended to be triggered that would prevent an under-collateralized position, but it was bypassed and as part of that the flash loan transaction. Our community members and people voted on the claims, and we agreed to pay out the claims related to bZx hack.That was a really good test to have a system. It proved it pays claims. It was really quite an important moment for us then I guess. A few weeks ago with the black Thursday events with Maker as you described that that was more outside of the smart contracts cover with congestion and a few other bits and pieces kind of coming together which meant that some people got fully liquidated, even though the smart contracts did operate as designed and intended.I think there was quite a lot of discussion on discord because claims got submitted to Nexus. They were all declined because it didn’t meet the definition of what we were doing. I think we’ve got some good learnings from that, to be honest. We started with a narrow product because it was our first attempt at things. My opinion is that the claims should have been declined because they were outside the terms; however, it’s not necessarily where we want to get to. There are a lot of risk people are taking on interacting with DeFi. We want to provide complete coverage so they can feel safe with that type of thing. We’re definitely looking at ways to expand the coverage and change the terms so a wider variety of things can be covered in the future. It’s a bit more tricky, but we’re definitely looking at doing that.Samuel: [00:10:11] Especially with all of these, DeFi is nascent, right? It’s only four years old now with 65 projects came out in 2016, found establishment in 2019 with the launch of most of the interest-bearing contracts. I think is what got most of the interest, but there’s a bunch of other projects which have released over the past 18 months, a lot of those contracts (I mean this is what Nexus is designed for) may have critical issues which could cost a growing amount of money that the amount of money locked in DeFi is recovering, but at the same time, there are still risks. I remember even before the BZX hack, they had come out and talked about the emergency shutdown with Major, where someone with enough of MKR could come along and trigger an emergency shutdown and drain the Ether that was in or was being used as collateral for the major contract. Do these problems ever go away, do you think? Or is it just the longevity of the contracts that play out and then in addition to that you have insurance protocols like Nexus that support any losses?Hugh: [00:11:40] I mean that’s the way I view it. These are new systems, but also they’re also complicated systems. They are system with many moving parts, and, you know, we were getting better at coding more securely, but we still have issues, so several years in after tooling has improved massively. Now we’re looking at economic attacks and, you know, flash loans didn’t actually change the potential attacks, it just made some of them a lot easier to access. We have a lot of people working on governance type stuff, so there will be covenant attacks and network congestion that no one ever really thought about. It’s kind of like when things go bad, multiple things tend to go bad at the same time, and it’s really hard to think about all those potential scenarios when you’re designing a system, and you only get to learn about them through experience.When it comes down to it, there’s kind of marginal benefit of testing and analyzing absolutely every combination of everything you can think of, and you may even miss stuff cause you just don’t know what it is, and that’s kind of where insurance comes in. It helps when the marginal benefit is just not worth it and, to me, if there’s always going to be some use for it, just like there is in the regular world. I mean, you don’t really do anything in the regular world without insurance, even for example airline safety, right? It’s one of the most secure things that a lot of people are looking at it and all the rest of it, and everyone does what they can, but, you know, planes still do have issues. I kind of consider it to be a similar situation to that.Samuel: [00:13:13] insurance, it varies by industry and by the ability of the insurance companies to create a cartel essentially to control prices for the insurance. Do you think that can happen on Ethereum where a group of insurance providers could dictate or create a monopoly on providing insurance? I know that any smart contract can be replicated and that the idea of providing insurance could also be replicated, but if there’s enough liquidity that’s funnelled into certain companies such as yours, right? Let’s say that you gain significant market share and really could dictate prices at that point. Is there a potential threat of monopolization cartelization that we should be looking out for?Hugh: [00:14:08] Potentially, I mean, I’m not quite sure actually how much that happens in the regular insurance world. In any big enough market, we’ll have a few big players that you’re going to get some competitiveness, and you know the same thing’s going to happen here. I think one of the benefits with what we’re doing is that everything is completely out in the open and transparent. Any behaviour like that will become quite obvious rather than hidden away for a while, and people can’t necessarily connect the dots.Samuel: [00:14:42] I guess the answer would be that in a non-regulated industry, right, because you guys are not regulated.Hugh: [00:14:51] Yeah, that’s correct. We not regulate.Samuel: [00:14:53] Okay. Exactly so in a non-regulated industry, there are no barriers to competition for other people entering the market, so for health insurance, for example, it’s a highly regulated noncompetitive market where you have a bunch of big players who are able to use their size and ability to navigate the legal s…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Communication is Value Transfer - Corey Petty - Status May 02, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeWhat does it mean to have communication privacy? Who is responsible for free speech? Dr. Corey Petty, Chief Security Officer of Status joins the podcast to discuss his role at the company, how he is securing the rights of others and the role of messaging networks in the 21st century. Dr. Corey Petty is the Chief Security Officer of Status and started his blockchain focused research around 2012 as a personal hobby while doing his PhD candidacy at Texas Tech University in Computational Chemical Physics. He then went on to co-found The Bitcoin Podcast Network and still serves as a host on the flagship The Bitcoin Podcast and a more technical show Hashing It Out. Corey left academia and entered the data science/blockchain security industry for a few years attempting to fix vulnerabilities in ICS/SCADA networks before finding his fit as the head of security at Status.im where he remains today.Corey's LinksLinkedin | TwitterStatus' HomepageWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhat interested Corey about working at Status and how he ended up there after academia.Would Satoshi have created Bitcoin differently today to build privacy into the network given what we know now?How Status built privacy and security into their messaging protocol app.How Web 3.0 companies can compete against big tech whose goal is to monitor and surveillance users to make money.Why there are a plethora of new ways to capture what users want without compromising their privacy or security through careful protocol building.Why Bitcoin technology will get better (it’s not there yet) and why eventually data on the network will be obfuscated.Why Status is decentralised by design and will work regardless of whether or not Status exists as a company.Why our society needs to have more situational awareness on the internet when interacting online and make users responsible for their conduct, not companies.Why Sam thinks we need more freedom, not less.Why Status has a responsibility to build good software that people can use it in the way they want to; but the responsibility for conduct should lie with the end-user, not a central control structure like Facebook.How Status fits with the three-part purpose of the Ethereum network and achieves its goal of on-chain messaging.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show NotesDr Corey Petty, the Chief Security Officer at Status.im, he is more than just a security officer. He is also the co-founder and co-host of the Bitcoin podcast. He has some really interesting views on communications and what it actually means to be building out a network like Bitcoin or some of the other networks that have been created afterwards, such as Ethereum or Status that focus more on the communications aspect and how that propagation of Data allows for greater freedoms and evolving society in this ever more surveillance age.What is it about working at Status and how you ended up there? You have only been there for the last two years and they have done some amazing stuff in that time. It has been serendipitous. I left academia after finishing my PhD and doing some work in computational chemistry to pursue a blockchain career to leverage the skills I had gained during my PhD which was very data-sciencey. I have always been fascinated and heavily involved in computers from a technical perspective my whole life. When I left, I found a couple jobs in the government consulting area basically leveraging blockchain and making sure people knew what they were talking about and technical education. My goal was to make sure that governments and regulators were looking into these things. And they didn’t have a lot of good quality resources to make good decisions about these things. My goal was to help them with this process. The bureaucracy and how organisations work was not quite my level. I had built some hobby projects doing analysis of very large projects in the space in Ethereum; how tokens were distributed in some of the really large early ICOs and one of these was Status and I talked with Jared Carl and became friends. One day I was talking with Jared on a very different community-based project. He asked what I did and I applied for the job and got it. It has been a wonderful trip working with Status. It is exactly where I wanted to be when I left academia. I have been very fortunate in my experience.I was never cleared or went through any of the security clearance interviews. I did not want to go through the process or be beholden by the promises you make doing those things. It is great for job security but I wanted to maintain my freedom in pursuing whatever I wanted to pursue and being able to say what I wanted to say it in a timely fashion. I am pretty happy I did not go through the process.In the military it is a whole different life. It took me two years. I’ve been out since 2008 and I lost my clearance. I was amazed by the job security it gives you. You will basically have a high paying job for the rest of your life if you want it. The second thing is the growth of these consulting/contracting companies out of Hamilton that have a huge responsibility outside the beltway. I learned a lot about security but working in such an organisation was not my bag. I have been out of DC for five years.It is really interesting to see the growth of these consulting companies and how much the government relies on them. The fact that Bose Allen has a senior blockchain specialist was that a position you carved out for yourself or were they just wanting someone who could call themselves blockchain developers? My opinion is partly my own perspective and partly my experiences of working there. I know that a lot of contracts were looking for bitcoin expertise. When I did educational things I was doing broad scope educational initiatives and then when I moved to Bose Allen was specially carved out around me and my team. We need to say we have some skin in the game. We were incredibly efficient in getting things done.I just spoke with Alexander from Beam, he talked about the privacy functions embedded in Bitcoin. He said that if Satoshi had been building something today he would have built something closer to Monero, ZCash or one of the protocols that has privacy built into it. The open database that Bitcoin gives you is too much of a honeypot for intelligence agencies or any other foreign government agency that wants to track all on-chain transactions and be able to identify money flows across the network.Where do you stand on this privacy issue? I agree with Alexander in a sense and if I had to prognosticate about what Satoshi would do today; he would be incorporating a lot of the technology that has been developed and funded directly because of what he built. He build something that solved a computational consensus problem and then as it grew, it became a data mine for financial information because everything is public and included. As a response to that publicicty and lack of privacy, we have been able to fund a lot of the cryptography that wasn’t quite getting the focus that it needed to fix these problems. In many ways he has enabled a lot of that research and development of that cryptography that we have today. As it stands today there are solutions in the pipeline that help address these privacy concerns for Bitcoin and Ethereum, that obliviates some of the information. But if you want real privacy in my opinion, then there are things like zero knowledge proofs. In applications like Status, the most un-private thing we have is when people interact with the blockchain and that is not a reflection on us but rather just the way the technology works at this point.How do you bake that into a product like Status? How do you identify those privacy concerns and address these in a private messaging app that is both private and secure? That is the million-dollar question. It starts in my opinion with using the available technology appropriately and setting appropriate defaults that lean toward the side of privacy and security for the user. Then you provide users with options of changing those available levers so they can change these; but in an informed manner, they can make the decisions affecting their privacy and protects their data. The only way to really build products that allow users to maintain their privacy and security is to give them all the options you possibly can and defaulting towards private and secure and then allowing them to change it but in an informed way. The business model of What’s App, in theory, it should exist outside of Facebook. Facebook bought What’s App for $2 billion dollars a decade ago. The original founder left because of Facebook’s plans. They wanted to better understand user behaviour and linguistics. That intrusion into user privacy and messaging has allowed them to grow to billions of dollars. This is the same as any other major tech company today.When we talk about Web 3.0, we are talking about companies that are trying to buck the trend of using people’s data and taking their privacy to sell this information to third party companies—using the information from their user base to generate more revenue. How does a company like Status compete against a company whose goal is to monitor and survey their customers? Our goal is to give people the option if they want it. I think it would be useful for everyone. I am not sure what it is going to be until we have reached the level of convenience. They are able to do what they do because they have all the information. How does a more decentralised product (that is not spying on its users to use that data to increase their revenues) how can they compete with the FAANGS? I am not sure. My intuition tells me that we have a vast unexplored space of what a social network looks like. If we look at what information is provided in any blockchain network, it represents a value transfer. We do not see that 80 or 90 per cent is communication. If we can capture that value, there are a plethora of new ways to capture what users want and what they want to do without compromising their privacy or security by participating in that network. I think this is my personal vision if we are able to push forward this idealised view of Web 3.0, but it is still early days. Bitcoin is the beginning, and it is only a decade old.Sam thinks think the shift will happen slowly and then all of a sudden. Bitcoin is boring, and there is not much to develop on. A lot of people have set its past present and future. It is just a not if but when. Corey thinks there is still hope for Bitcoin to develop other use cases. Bitcoin does some things well, but other networks like Ethereum do it better. Some of the potential technologies that could find its way into the base layer drastically expand what you can do with it, and for the time being, Corey does want to spend his time there.Ethereum is the best place as it stands today to be building. What you can do with this technology and what you can build on top of it is very interesting. Because this technology is so early, I am not comfortable naming what is going to be useful in five years or what we are going to call Web 3.0 or blockchain. There is so much room for expansion because we have to be able to start thinking about what we can do with it or build with it. We are starting to think about how to build stuff this way.The Big 4 versus Web 3.0 issue is something Sam thinks about quite a lot. We have been trained to be desensitised to how much data we give up every day. I worked with systems that were at the NSA and the hoard of metadata that this creates. You can build a near-perfect picture of everything with metadata. I talked to a police officer – once they are on the Bitcoin, everything is visible because there is this perfect data trail that can be used by law enforcement. When Sam came to Bitcoin what interested him was the metadata to be exploited by companies. The technology will get better, but it’s not there yet. Eventually, everything will be obfuscated.How does that apply to Status? What sort of data do your users give up? Status is completely open about what we do. It is very hard to see what anyone is sharing or unless you have broken encryption. We use signals whispers encryption to make things very secure. Even if Status dies, the technology stays and remains open. You don’t need any personally identifiable information to set up an account. If you use the Blockchain, you are going to disclose information about yourself and leave a trail behind you. We inform you when you use ENS username then you secure a sub-domain ENS record. You are staking this, and this makes your account public and the wallet attached to it. OR make another account that is not public. You become discoverable you need to put something out there.Sam is a heavy Telegram user. They have built an interesting product. But because of its origins and the code itself, there are a lot of questions he has about its privacy and security. There is still this veil of obtusification around Telegram as to whether they are private and secure with user information. Even when Sam is trying to have private conversations, he is looking forward to the release of Status. Can it be a good replacement for Telegram? That is what Sam wants to know. How can you trust Telegram when you cannot see the code or know how their privacy and security work?The ultimate goal, if we do things correctly, is that you won’t need Status. The network will work regardless of our existence, but the question is, how do we build network value while still having a job? Since 2016, we have seen the growth of disinformation across social media and social networks in the hopes of converting peoples opinions or changing the hearts and minds of people using content.Do you think that these decentralised systems are more open to exploitation or there are other ways that Status can address these issues? In a more general system that is less controlled or constrained is more susceptible to people saying to things that are true because that control does not exist. There are things that we as a company we can do and things we can do as a society. In my option, these are necessary for the future. At Status, as a company, we can build tools that give you more situational awareness; so you know who is saying what and how much we know about that person in terms of trusting their content. Like ENS Usernames – if you have gone through trusting to someone you are talking to that it cannot be faked. It is hard to fake an ENS Username. These are very strong fundamental guarantees that the person who owns the private keys is the person you are talking to. We need to allow people to attest to who they are and attach it to private keys so you can be more confident that you are talking to who you think you – so you cannot be manipulated and/or phished.As a society, it is about how we conduct ourselves on the internet and having more situational awareness. Thinking about whether or not you are talking to the person who you think you are talking to. That is a terrible way to run a society or the internet that you give over responsibility to people whose whole goal is to make money off you through their system. We need a social shift to ask is this the person I am talking to? We need an attestation – or an identification system. Identifying core contributors on Status – this might be a way to go. We want to build it in a way that we…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Defi's Infrastructure Stack - Mona El Isa - Melonport Apr 22, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeAs one of the first Defi projects, Melonport set the stage for what was to come in 2019 and beyond. Founder Mona El Isa speaks in this episode about Defi's rapid growth, rebuilding Melon, and the future of Web 3.0.Mona's LinksLinkedin | TwitterMelon ProtocolWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy Melon foresaw aspects of DeFi’s rapid growth in composability, but not the speed of its development into a new financial stack.Why Melon now has a three-year flexible roadmap for their protocol’s development, and how they learned lessons from their first fixed ‘roadmap’ about delivery versus the ability to innovate.Why Melon rebuilt their user interface to deliver a better user experience and grow their community network in 2019.Why asset infrastructure is a chicken & egg thing: you build it to see if they will come, without knowing what kind of assets will be integrated in the future.Why the future is tokenised asset classes, but it may take five, ten or twenty years to get there given the current state of US securities law which is not fit-for-purpose.Why Mona set up MAMA, the Multi-chain Asset Managers Association, to coordinate action between DeFi projects to lobby Regulators and US lawmakers to change the existing securities laws to be fit for Blockchain.How DeFi’s creation of Web 3.0 native asset classes makes it much less dependent on security tokens for success.Why maybe it is time for extreme measures like debt-jubilee in responding to the aftermath of Coronavirus.How, with bond rates going to zero, the landscape of investing and asset management will change, because bonds will become cash and that has never happened before.Why both Sam and Mona never foresaw the demand for Stablecoins like Tether and USDC, and why this is one of the most commercially useful innovations in DeFi today.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show NotesI heard you speak at a conference in Zug in 2018 and I have been super excited to have you on the podcast. I was impressed with Melon. Melon protocol is live now in 2020, and the transition to the foundation has taken place. I have been following you since 2018. It is cool though to see the growth.How would you describe the implementation and where you are now? Are you happy with the development so far in the Ethereum Ecosystem? The first time we hit the main net was in February 2019 with Version 1. At the same time, we gave up control of the main net at the same time as we launched it. We were the first protocol in history to do that. It was quite a strange feeling to do that and quite experimental as well. I think we have a very well thought out governance process combined with an attractive token model which aligns the stakeholders in our ecosystem, so it is a well thought out process. In practice, it is a little bit different than the theory, but it has been an interesting first year. To see Melon run and be governed by a DAO. The V1 implementation, we were happy with that and we over delivered on our road map. Having a fixed roadmap in this space is maybe not the most sensible thing to have in this space, to be honest. This space is so fast-moving. When we set out in 2017 and conducted our token sale, to deliver that roadmap – there were only three DeFi projects out there then.We have had to adapt since them because of the developments in the space. We integrated exchanges, including Kyber Network, that we had not planned on integrating due to developments in the space like lending, credit, derivatives, etc. The space underneath us moved so fast and so much – that having a fixed roadmap was not a good thing. This time the roadmap is not set in stone; we learned from our mistakes, and we decided that we wanted to put forward a three-year road map. We are not one of four projects building on Melon, but we are the lead developer building on Melon. We have also re-architectured the protocol in a large way. Our first UX/UI we delivered last year was not one that we were particularly proud of; it definitely hindered user growth. One of the first things we did in October last year was to rebuild the interface from scratch and so anyone using it today will see a massive improvement in user experience. It still could be better, but it is night/day in comparison to the last version. I tried to show both sides of what we delivered.You have been building Melon since 2016. You mentioned some of the huge shifts since then. There was no lending platforms then or DeFi platforms. There has been an explosion in DeFi platforms since them. Did you foresee this coming or the rapid growth of composability in the DeFi space? Yes, to some degree, I definitely saw the composability. I didn’t expect there to be only on DEX for the rest of our lives. I also saw the tokenised assets would explode but not in the way I envisioned it would. I think yes and no is the answer. We set out building asset management infrastructure we were building this from Day 1. However, when you are building asset management infrastructure, the products that will be integrate-able into that infrastructure will also be built. The infrastructure play is a chicken and egg thing: you build it to see if they will come to use the asset management platform, without knowing what kind of assets will be integrated in the future. I guess you can take some examples from existing financial products/systems. It is risky to be so far ahead in infrastructure when the rest of the space catches up in having to use it.One of the assumptions we made was the future would be tokenised asset classes. We envisioned that everything you may wish to purchase or sell would have a tokenised asset classes just like everything does today. This was the main underlying assumption we made from the beginning. The future is tokenised whether it takes 5, 10, or 20 years to get there. What we have seen is that we have to make developments to the protocols, and we would have to integrate these as we go along regardless of our assumptions. There are new decentralised assets that we did not see before, such as Cryptokitties, collectables, DAI etc.As someone working with securities on Blockchain now, it is interesting to see how everything integrates with existing regulatory structures. Working at Realt.co, we are the primary insurer of securities. If we want to go to an exchange currently on Ethereum, they all want transfer agents like Securitise, when we do a lot of that work ourselves. What I am finding is that there is a walled garden where we can build securities that exist and operate in DeFi really well, through for example using UniSwap and build into Melon if we whitelisted contracts. There are other platforms we know we could integrate into as well; but, when we want to go back to more regulated financial structures, like regulated securities exchanges on Ethereum, it gets much more difficult.How does this get bridged? This is a good question. I don’t know. Anyone who has looked into securities law and tried to apply it to any Blockchain securities will know that existing US securities law is just not fit for purpose. It doesn’t make any sense at all, and it hinders innovation in that space, which is a real shame. It is also why we haven’t seen more development in tokenised securities because Blockchain offers a ton of advantages that the regulator wants and likes, but often these advantages are overseen. They just get caught up in the narratives of Blockchain and their fear of it.It results in very inefficient processes, or people giving up on what they were trying to create. What my view is that this is going to have to change, and it is going to require coordinated action from DeFi projects. In 2017, I helped set up MAMA, the Multi-chain Asset Managers Association, which was built exactly for this purpose and to respond to any Blockchain-related papers to governments, regulators, and lawmakers. We are always lobbying for this kind of thing and trying to encourage regulators to be aware that this is detrimental to innovation. We have approached this by coordinating the industry, but this is a longer-term game.In the meantime, what has been really impressive is that the DeFi space has become less dependent on security tokens as a means of success. Because there are so many Web 3.0 native asset classes now, it doesn’t even matter if it takes five or ten years for security tokens to become a reality. In the meantime, you have interest-bearing tokens, and you can stake against a project or via insurance protocols and earn interest on that. There are on-chain derivatives, etc. being built and the whole collectables market. These all are very interesting investable asset classes that are not securities, and so that is an interesting evolvement. If you had asked me three years ago if the success of DeFi would have been based on security tokens becoming a thing, I would have said yes. I was wrong about that. There are enough native Web 3.0 instruments to make DeFi a stand-alone industry on its own without security tokens. Security tokens will become a thing, and then it will be explosive. We just need the regulatory and security law to catch up to DeFi in order to integrate security tokens into the DeFi space. The problem is that these Web 3.0 Instruments are highly correlated to Bitcoin and Ethereum. It creates too much inherent risk in the portfolios themselves.We are excited about synthetic tokens and what you guys are doing in the real estate space. Medium to long term, we are convinced protocols like Melon can be used to create trust between investors and fund managers for any kind of tokenised asset.The point I am trying to make is that if you had asked me in 2016 if we were dependent on security tokens to drive usage, I would have said yes back then. But that is because I did not foresee these native Web 3.0 instruments coming. The longer I am in the space; I have to wrap my head around what kind of assets would I want in my portfolio for a longer period of time? It is a very difficult question. With the inherent volatility in the space, it is hard to do that once you get past the first few native assets. DeFi was when Ethereum people realised they could put interest rates on the Blockchain. Once you have an easier way to integrate with interest rates, it makes the space much more accessible.Mona sees it differently. What you see now is a new financial stack being built. Like any stack, the stack is made of many layers. The baseline is the Blockchain we are building on: Ethereum. The layer on top of that is the issuance of native Ethereum-based assets, whatever they may be, starting with Ether ranging from RapBTC to all the ERC-20 tokens we know including on-chain derivatives and interest-bearing tokens. This is the asset issuance stack.On top of that, I see the infrastructure stack (or maybe that is even below, I am not sure); the infrastructure stack is the protocols that are being built that establish trust between various different players. Ethereum does that for token transfer, so the first layer of the stack. Melon does that between investors and fund managers without the need for intermediaries. ZeroX establishes trust between buyers and sellers without intermediaries. Compound establishes trust between borrowers and lenders without the need for intermediaries. That is what I consider the infrastructure layer. On top of that, you have the application layers and interface layers where people build products on top of the infrastructure layer.My colleague David writes a lot about Ether is Money, and everything is built on top of ETH and which is creating a new monetary system. Even now in 2020, my original idea of Bitcoin was as separate from fiat money structures. The USA has draconian measures for how people can use its money. This causes stress in countries where people cannot get dollars freely, like in Russia and Iran. An asset-backed stablecoin connected to the dollar or synthetic dollars is what people want to keep the value of their money stable in places where inflation is out of control in their home currency. That is hugely compelling and a big selling point that gets missed.Mona thinks we are still very early the lifecycle of DeFi and Crypto as an asset class and so because of that, everything tends to be very highly correlated though she understands the idea that Bitcoin is a way to hedge against your local currency or against high inflation. They all appear to be very highly correlated in today’s highly volatile environment. These tokens and networks that have been launched are still in their infancy. What gives a token value is a non-security token is linked to the success of the network. We are so early on that curve. Mona thinks it will be a year or two before we see this curve inflect. We won’t really see this value until users start to depend on these protocols, and then you have something that looks like an investable market instead of a speculative market. In that case, your alternative then is not to hedge your Venezuelan currency with Bitcoin, but to invest, for example, in a Melon Fund that diversifies across a range of crypto funds or a basket of crypto assets and/or stablecoins. It could be a fund that arbitrages between DEXs without risk. There could also be a fund that stakes its funds against protocols that they have audited like Nexus Protocol. There will be some very interesting alternative investments that give you all the same things that Bitcoin gives you. It is hard to see that right now.This goes back to the questions Same asked earlier when Mona launched in 2016 about what Melon did not see coming; what Sam didn’t foresee is the growth of the stablecoin market and especially Tether and the growth of USDC through Circle. These are even more important than the market for Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency because they allow for commerce to happen on-chain and that is something people talk about happening on Bitcoin or with ETH, but Sam does not think it will. One of Sam’s belief is that Crypto does not become less volatile. It is an inherent characteristic of both protocols. Maybe Ethereum gets over it, but Bitcoin will always be volatile because it has a fixed supply. You can issue synthetic dollars as a means of exchange – using it for commerce and cross-border transactions. There is high demand in Russia for Tether to send money to China on a daily basis back and forth from Chinese traders who sell their products for rubbles and send them back in the form of Tether to China.It comes down to expectations. There is this idea that there is one asset that you can use for every kind of economic activity. It doesn’t exist. Stability is key for commerce and businesses. You have worked on the institutional side. Sam sees Crypto as a retail product. How can these assets affect the institutional side, which deals in a very different way to the retail side? The traditional side will be steered by its clients. If clients demand certain products, they will go where they can access these asset products. Maybe they will move to CoinDesk etc. to service people in those fields. I am seeing institutional people who are now asking about Bitcoin who I would have never thought would be interested. There is an increasing need for uncorrelated assets given everything going on. Mona was disappointed that Bitcoin was in fact correlated to the markets with Coronavirus. It will be really interesting if Bitcoin stays…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Data-Driven Crypto Economic Modelling - Philip Gradwell - Chainalysis Apr 15, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodeLearn how to say "Chainalysis" from Philip Gradwell, the company's chief economist and data driven analytic. He chats with host Samuel McCulloch about what on-chain economics is and their use in day to day operations and analysis. Philip Gradwell is Chief Economist at Chainalysis, the blockchain analysis company. He analyses on-chain data to understand cryptocurrency markets. This includes identifying economic fundamentals, how cryptocurrency moves on-chain between exchanges and across borders, and the nature of crypto crime, amongst other topics. Prior to joining Chainalysis, Philip led a team of economic consultants working globally on energy system analysis and climate change economics.Philip's LinksLinkedin | Medium | TwitterChainalysis' WebsiteWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy blockchain has much less data precision than people think and why the datasets are noisy.Why Chainalsysis’ core work is really about mapping datasets of entities and their relationships to one another.Why the interpretation of the data in the Crypto-economy is so much more complex than in Fiat economic systems.What the biggest challenges facing on-chain economic studies are and what Philip will be working towards solving in 2020.Why the creation of Stablecoins is about the demand for a dollar-denominated product which is regulated in a different sphere of jurisdiction from the one the underlying asset originated from: the USA.Why Tether was essentially filling a gap in the market for a stable fiat on-ramp and meeting the demand for a privately issued tokenised dollar in 2018.Why Chainalysis’ on-chain metrics during the Bitmex implosion provided data-driven insights into the market structures and the price movements of Bitcoin.How daily inflows and outflows of cryptocurrencies from exchanges correlate to price movements due to the illiquid nature of Bitcoin and cryptocurrency markets.Why Philip believes the fundamentals of Bitcoin are stronger than any other Cryptocurrency but that DeFi still has many maturity cycles to go through.Why we will be exploring a new paradigm in terms of monetary and fiscal policy in the fiat world after the Coronavirus induced recession.Why Philip worries as an economist that we had not gone far enough into the ‘future’ to see the consequences of the last ten years’ expansionary monetary policies after the 2008 crisis, but we have just doubled down with the economic responses to the Coronavirus in 2020.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.Show NotesChainalysis analyse chain data for regulatory analysis and for clients that need to trace transactions on the blockchain and how they are tied into the real world.What does a Chief Economist do? Chief Economist is one of the stranger roles in an organisation like Chainalysis. Because the core of the business is about understanding transactions on the blockchain and how they link to the real-world entities, this is mostly used by law enforcement agencies and for compliance purposes. If you look at a blockchain it is a complete economy, so its individuals sending money between themselves in exchange for services. I am here at Chainalsysis to try to understand the crypto economy from that perspective and to take the macro view and describe the trends we see in usage patterns in Bitcoin, Ethereum and all the cryptocurrencies we cover.Chainalysis covers a lot; they work with some of the largest exchanges in Crypto. They also are providing services for a lot of people. Compliance is an integral part of every real-world businesses’ operations. Employing a company like Chainalysis is important to make sure no company taking funds is connected to criminal or terrorist financing. I have always been interested in Chainalysis because I come from an intelligence background. The gobs of metadata that exist and can be connected with Bitcoin is both extremely interesting, and it also scares me. It scares me in one respect. If you think about the level of data collection, and you can pair the analytics you have with the data, a government might have in their own scale intelligence-gathering operations, it becomes a whole different picture. On the private side, when you are only providing compliance, then maybe it is a bit different.Blockchains are databases. At the heart, they are database that says this address transacts with this address and actually the core thing we do is we map core sets of addresses to entities because any individual or business can have as many addresses as they want. Entities are individuals and businesses are things like exchanges. This entity looks like a business, and this one looks like an individual. This allows our clients to follow the funds in from these addresses for their services. This is basically the core of what we do. Then you mentioned the metadata which is on the blockchain, but it is quite limited in nature actually. There is also the peer-to-peer network in which transactions are broadcast, but the way in which transactions are broadcast makes it less useful than you might think. The core data set is this mapping from entities to businesses as a real-world thing.The choke point is really the service where criminal activity can be stopped. This is where governments focus most of their work. The only powers that can be used are at the exchange level.If I am a business and I am going most of my business on the blockchain, it is publically verifiable transactions that people could use these data flows against a company. I do think Bitcoin is too transparent. People can see what I have – either we see greater privacy options in cryptocurrency or we will get more comfortable with this level of transparency. One example of this is crypto reserves and exchanges showing clearly their cryptocurrency reserves to prove they have not run off with my Bitcoin. I think the exchanges have many reasons why they don’t want to do this. But their nervousness about revealing how big their business is. I don’t like the proof of reserves as it is disingenuous. For a business, as soon as you make a deposit and then lend out based on this deposit; you have created more money, in essence, and you don’t know what their loan book looks like. I think it can give you some help in terms of ratios.People think blockchain has much more precision than it actually has to be honest. I spent two years at Chainalysis doing fundamental research to make sure that when we say something, we can say it with certainty because we know why we may be wrong, why it may be a high or low bound. The data sets are noisier than people think. It’s not quite this God view of the crypto-economy. It takes a lot of work even to get to this point. Every day I ask myself the same question, how do I know I’m wrong? Because most of the time, you are. Again it mostly comes back to the service providers. With zero transparency into what was happening on these exchanges, there were attempts to show liquidity via volumes of trading.Do you like that all this data is public? The data is fascinating from an economics perspective. The thing that is really interesting from the crypto-economics side; you mentioned earlier you’ve got the address data set and then you have to do all this work to link these to entities. So you get to look at a complete economy, but it is like you have blurry vision; because you are never sure if these addresses look like they should belong to this entity or if they actually belong to another entity.I had a whiteboard my first week at Chainalysis listing on the metrics we wanted to do, and it has only taken eighteen months later to do all our research, which means we can finally do all these metric charts. The interpretation of the data is so much more complex than economics in the fiat system. The entities are very clear cut in the fiat system.What are the biggest challenges facing on-chain economic studies that are yet to be solved or that you are working on in 2020? It is an interesting time for Crypto as we are recording this during the coronavirus lockdown and the really significant price changes we are seeing and whether crypto winter is coming or if Crypto can survive even. I think there is the broader narrative of what is Crypto, is it heading into Winter? Is it even going to survive? Are the people who were holding Bitcoin are they even bothered about the price move and did they move into exchanges? These are all tactical questions that get asked the most. Then there are bigger questions, such as what is the interest rate of Bitcoin? What’s the equivalent metric of GDP growth rate in Crypto? We still don’t have a framework to explain this asset and why it is useful. It will often come down to some high blown narrative trying to convince people to get involved in the tech stock gamble. But I want to give more data on actual use cases and real valuation methods, both on the theoretical side and also bring the data to it. That is the bigger challenge.Where do you stand on the long term valuation and worth of Bitcoin? Yes, I am not a maximalist. Of the Economists who are in this space, I am not the typical economist; I see cryptocurrencies a really interesting alternative asset that has characteristics that others don’t. If it is a store of value, it can be used as means of exchange; unlike your bar of gold in the apocalypse. Bitcoin is, in many ways, a basket of very interesting properties that get fitted together. I think the world is short of assets that are not correlated to what is going on in a certain country, that have a fixed ownership policy but can be stored in very large amounts safely and securely.Stablecoins, like Tether, removed the volatility from the Bitcoin model makes sense. The tokenisation of the dollar might change some of how the financial plumbing will be done. We need to see how large the world’s demand for Bitcoin is in the long term. The best example of why people love Tether – People in Russia would send their money back to China using Tether instead of Bitcoin. This asset was dollar-denominated, which makes sense.Sam thinks there is huge demand for Stablecoins and what came out of 2018 is the demand for a dollar-denominated (less regulated) product that moves freely between countries that do not have the best relationship with the USA. Philip would put it differently: they are regulated in a different sphere of jurisdiction from the one underlying asset originated from. Dollars are regulated by the USA, but the usage of these is happening in China and Russia, which are outside that sphere of jurisdiction to some extent.Do you look at Tether flows? Yes, we do. One of the most interesting things for me in 2018, was when these Chinese mainland exchanges were shut down, a lot of this bitcoin was exchanged for Tether, and then this Tether moved off the mainland. This is why Tether is quite sticky as there was a lot of wealth transferred into during this period, and that formed the basis for that ecosystem.Sam goes back and forth on Tether. You have to ask on the day. It does not have the best foundation and exists in an arbitrage structure because it exists outside of normal regulatory properties. This is what creates the demand for Tether and why it is in demand in emerging markets.Looking at Tether as an economist, what do you see? Philip sees essentially a gap in the market being filled. The reason Tether has been so popular is there was latent demand on two major fronts: (1) to have a stable pair in a trade (you don’t want to always be trading pairs that are correlated to each other), so there was a need for that, but (2) there was a restriction on Fiat getting into exchanges, and there was also a benefit for exchanges to remain Crypto to Crypto. Tether definitely filled that need for a stable fiat on-ramp and fulfilled that leg of the trade, and also there was latent demand for a dollar-like instrument in jurisdictions where people did not want to use the dollar all the time. That is where we see the demand for Tether coming from. What I do think the fascinating thing about Tether is in its issuance and its monetary policy. I find it amazing that people are happy to abstract away from that and just say this is really useful. For me, this is a sign that there is the potential for even greater growth in Stablecoins because if people are willing to value it on par or sometimes worth more than a USD with the caveats that people have. Then there must be a whole bunch of people who would be willing to use a stablecoin that has slightly better properties. Sam completely agrees.Tether proves that there is demand for a privately issued tokenised dollar that does not exist in an account in a bank somewhere. I think this is what has driven Circle and other stablecoin operators and ramped up their operations. There has been incredible growth in USDC in the past year.In Sam’s head, the benefit of the company that is issuing the stablecoin, let’s use USDC, is that the underlying asset is a derivative of the cash balances that sit in their account. When you send money to Circle, they reinvest into bills or bonds so they can earn a yield on it. When you can be an asset gatherer, and you can earn 1-2% on that a year in relation to the stablecoin that you have issued, that’s a great business revenue model. But what happens if interest rates continue to go negative? It becomes harder for Circle to find the yield it needs to continue to issue stablecoins. There are huge questions there. Circle has come out with statements saying they will be okay, but that is just a statement.It would be amazing if the best use case for Crypto was destroyed by expansionary monetary policy and negative interest rates. They would have to run their fiat investments with some risk to earn yield. I don’t think you could treat it like money market funds because they would not make enough money to fund their business, especially with being regulated in the USA. Let’s say they can go to 30-year bonds which are doing 0.5% at the minute. If the 30-year bond collapses any further, it destroys Circle’s business model. I am sure they will say they can continue, but it will see what happens in the future. You can barely get yield for your dollars in the real world, but if you move into the crypto-sphere, you can get a much higher yield.Do you think they could get to the point where you have to pay more to get a stablecoin from Circle, like $1.02 or above par further? Maybe. The thing that is so interesting for us is that we can move between our bank account and stablecoins on a one to one par. The one thing I worry about with DAI is almost statistically there will be DeFi implosion because we are too early in the lifecycle to have all the kinks ironed out. We can definitely see the DeFi contracts are sending DAI to each other and are making loans on borrowed DAI. There is counterparty risk and leveraging going on in DeFi. Could we create those counterparty risk models? Who knows.Are you doing analytical research into what is happening in DeFi at the moment? Not really. We work on a very large scale – Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP – but in terms of commercial focus, it is not on our radar yet.Is DeFi derivative leveraging? There was a price collapse, and the volatility of Ethereum pushed the GAS price so hard that someone was able to take ETHER thanks to working contracts to take money from the CDP.What were you looking at in Chainalysis a couple of weeks ag…

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Transactional Privacy for All - Alexander Zaidelson - Beam Apr 09, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episode

    A deep dive into privacy with Alexander Zaidelson, founder of Beam with host Samuel McCulloch in this episode of End of the Chain.

    Alexander's Links

    Linkedin | Crunchbase | Twitter

    Beam Website

    Where to find the show

    iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS Feed

    What to listen for

    • Why Bitcoin and the overall privacy structure of any open ledger platform is a treasure trove for analysts.
    • Why we still haven’t figured out what the most acceptable level of privacy is in terms of cryptocurrencies.
    • Why we need to make transactions private by default, but there needs to a compromise to enable reporting.
    • How the state of privacy, in general, is not good, and it is getting worse all the time in the world, especially given COVID-19.
    • How privacy coins are addressing different shades of encryption methods and cryptography, but everyone has the same goal to fight the same war together, to achieve true privacy.
    • Why encryption is an extension of people’s free speech, and this right needs to be fought for.
    • What BEAM’s plans are for the rest of 2020 and why their goal is to create a DEFI ecosystem built on top of BEAM with bridges to other blockchains.

    SUPPORT THE SHOW

    If you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:

    • Help keep this show going by sending us $5
    • Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.

    Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSE

    Ethereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644

    • Leave a Review on iTunes
    • Share an episode with family and friends
    • Follow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.

    Show Notes

    Sam is a big privacy advocate because he used to work as a signals analyst for the NSA. When I came across Bitcoin and its permissionless nature of transfers, having looked at metadata and how you can link this back to people involved, everything comes back to privacy. Anyone smart enough can put together an identity map of the bitcoin network. I think that is almost a loss since real privacy does not exist in the network.

    How do you see the overall privacy structure in Crypto? It is really interesting that you worked for the NSA and you understand that Bitcoin that any other open ledger platform is a treasure trove for analysts. And a lot of people are building nice businesses around this. For me that Bitcoin is not private is a fundamental bug in the design. This bug hinders the realisation of this dream of using Bitcoin has money, the original goal of Satoshi, to create digital cash that businesses could use online blah blah. Without privacy, it is blatantly NOT possible. No private person wants to share their financials with anyone, not how much they are making, what they are spending, where and when. Especially not businesses – as this is a huge disadvantage as your competitors can see everything you are buying, employee payroll etc. etc. This absence of privacy is a huge obstacle to Cryptocurrency becoming a replacement for money.

    There are different levels of privacy. There is general transaction privacy; wanting to shield transactions, for example, at a company you want to use Cryptocurrency to do your payroll, if you are paying them out from one wallet, everyone can see the salaries of everyone else. This is a very basic transaction. Of course, businesses want to shield these transactions from others. With Bitcoin, everything is completely open. There is the tracking of individual accounts and businesses on centralised exchanges. It absolutely does open up companies to audibility and to tracking by surveillance companies.

    Is only transaction privacy needed? Third-party companies use this data to enhance the idea of who their customer is to sell ads/services or change opinions. This is very scary. My big question is, how does this circle get broken? Bitcoin doesn’t do that.

    How do we get to this level of user privacy? Technology-wise there are several answers: Monero, ZCash, Mimblewimble – this is probably the best and most recent development. The only thing that is important in the cryptocurrency network is that you don’t change the supply function. Everything is fully opaque, which is what you want for a financial system. I don’t want you to know how much money I have, I don’t need to know what you have, and no one should be able to know how much we have transacted between us. Beam offers all three: transactional, amount and system level.

    I can choose what to share and what not to share. This is what happens today with the banking system; governments can seize my bank account and see all my transactions. The emergence of cryptocurrencies was not just a response to a global crisis, but it was also a response to people outside of the USA wanting dollars. They want to get around the USA’s obtuse regulatory system. I think it is more about freedom and sovereignty over your own money. Ricard puts it very well in his book. Once the government freezes your assets, those are gone. It could happen right now, and it has happened during the world wars. Cryptocurrencies make this taking of assets much more difficult.

    A cryptocurrency like BEAM means that no one can take assets easily from people. Once you have full confidentiality and privacy, you lose full legal recourse by governments to try and track assets or transactions. Bitcoin’s success is not because it is transparent; it is because governments did not want to forbid it. Cash is not traceable, so governments want to forbid this or reduce it. I think transparency is more of a bug with Bitcoin – it is a reason for less government pushback.

    Has there been any pushback against BEAM by countries? Only in Japan – and this was because of an exchange hack using Monero. We don’t want exchanges to keep confidential currencies because we won’t be able to help people get their money back. It can be dangerous if someone steals those funds. I would think there are ways to track Monero. There are some attempts. These are not as good as Bitcoin. BEAM is in a better position in that regard.

    There are atomic swaps where you don’t need a third party or an exchange to having these transactions. You cannot forbid BEAM realistically. I think we still haven’t figured out what the most acceptable level of privacy is in terms of cryptocurrencies. Monero is coming up to 10 years soon. No one has really settled on where the happy medium is.

    You need acceptance from governmental structures to grow. There needs to be a compromise. ZCash is a compromise – 95% of transactions are not shielded in ZCash. They have those two modes: that is why they present to the governments, and there is a way to be not shielded. Their approach was to create two separate kinds of transactions. We make transactions private by default, and they can choose to make their transactions visible to the government. It is their choice to reveal this or not. There is a lot of technology around this. You then report this to the government. Governments are trying to make cash obsolete. The biggest success they have had is in Sweden. I don’t think Germans are going to keep their cash and Americans will not give up the Greenbacks. People at the bottom are most affected by a cashless society. It is about them and people who are distrustful of their system and who value privacy. They don’t want to pay any fees to banks or credit card companies. It makes sense, but I would like to see a mixture. Transactional privacy is for me the most important thing. This information is dangerous. They can ask very embarrassing questions.

    If all these third party companies are taking your data to put into algorithms, they can track your behaviour online. Snowden’s book addresses how you can rank them and where they go etc. The Chinese use the data collection in a more public way; the USA cannot use them in a negative way against a person because the law prohibits it unless they are involved in illicit activities. I am sure governments have all this data they are collecting about their citizens, but they are bound by law to not use this data from their citizens. Having this capability it very scary; I left ten years ago, and there were no iPhones then. With the amount of machine learning, companies and government have huge amounts of data collection now. The state of privacy, in general, in the world, is not good, and it is getting worse all the time.

    Crypto, when it emerged, seemed to counter this movement; but Bitcoin it turns out does not solve the problem but makes it worse. Here at BEAM, we are here to solve the privacy question for Crypto while keeping all the best things. Our vision is not to do something subversive, or for anarchy, it is more like saying you cannot stop it, so privacy coins are here to stay. We give people a way to report to governments. We are trying to find a compromise for everyone.

    With the ability of BEAM, with these auditable accounts, that is something that is not out there at the minute. You can nominate an auditor and this way you can be transparent to who you want to be. Maybe that is the best way forward, and a way for regulators to catch up and see the possibilities. We will see how long it takes. It is about doing the groundwork and building a solid user base for your product. You have been launched for a year.

    What have you learned in that year? Most of all, being open and hardworking pays off. It is about 50k to 60k people, our community. This way, we gathered a community that really cares about what we are doing. The Crypto world is not like things are getting better all the time; we are ready for the bad times. We learned so much about technology and working with other projects (like GRIN) pays off. We are talking to Lightcoin. My learning is that it is important to be open to other projects. I think privacy coins are addressing different shades of grey – these different shade of encryption methods and the complexity of the underlying cryptography means that it takes a certain type of person to work in this area – everyone has the same goal to fight the same war together, to achieve true privacy for everyone.

    Are you worried about the general dissatisfaction of governments with encryption, especially in the USA? Overall it is a movement against businesses and individuals who want to use encryption. There are several attempts by the US government, but this was deemed to be illegal. This will not happen in the States; where people do not want to live in a police state. There are always parts of the government who want to limit privacy and encryption, but it is our job as citizens to monitor that and not to let it happen. More and more people understand the importance of privacy, and I hope they will vote and fight accordingly. Things are being taken away, but people are fighting against that. I don’t want to see any erosion of encryption/free speech. Encryption is an extension of people’s free speech, and this right needs to be fought more.

    What is BEAM working on for the next few quarters? We are building BEAM as a privacy coin and first-layer protocol. Back in November, we released our atomic swap ability (being able to exchange BEAM for Bitcoin) in a totally decentralised step and our first step toward DeFi. This year our roadmap is to build a fully confidential DeFi ecosystem built on BEAM, and that includes bridges to other blockchains to be able to trade ERC 20 tokens on top of BEAM, eventually, with the ability to build lending and credit applications on BEAM and take privacy to the next level to the transactional privacy we have delivered to distributed privacy features. This is opening up the BEAM ecosystem to more kinds of value, interfaces to other blockchains and eventually DeFi applications on top of BEAM. This is responding to what people want; Ethereum has very interesting applications, but the state of Privacy in Ethereum is even worse than Bitcoin. You can see everything on Ethereum. It is kind of crazy. How long will it take to roll out? We hope we will have some things out this year according to our roadmap and it is hard to put shipping dates on software development.


    Opening Founders' Doors - Chuck Pettid - Republic Apr 02, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episode

    Learn everything you need to know about crowdfunding with Chuck Pettid, Principal at Republic.co. We dive into the potential effects of Covid-19 on retail crowdfunding, the coming changes to Reg CF and A+ that will affect non-accredited investors and the benefits Republic provides to its investors and portfolio companies.

    Chuck is Senior Partner | CEO, Republic Crowdfunding Portal, a leading equity crowdfunding site, and co-producer of the international television show Meet the Drapers. He is also GP of micro VC fund RainmakeMe and sits on the board of Ruby Love (aka PantyProp), RidersShare and CrowdSmart. Chuck has an MBA from Fordham Gabelli School of Business and a BS from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln.

    Chuck's Links

    Twitter | Crunchbase | Linkedin | Republic

    Republic's Homepage

    Where to find the show

    iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS Feed

    What to listen for

    • Why the fire in the forest clears the undergrowth for new plants to grow afterwards, and this is what is happening now in the current crisis.
    • How Republic creates a network effect for founders which propels their business forward.
    • How this 'word of mouth' network support is hard to measure effectively through Republic.
    • Why most portfolio investors in Republic are looking for returns on their investment, usually through equity but also because they believe in the product or the founder's vision.
    • How Republic has lobbied the SEC for Reg CF and Series A harmonisation which will come into effect in September 2020 which will benefit start-ups by raising the limit to $5 million and investors through removing the $107,000 annual investment limit in crowdfunding.
    • Why this is great for investor protection in crowdfunding going forward.
    • Why Republic Crypto brings in deal flow to the business and how they came into this space through consulting in 2018.
    • How Republic's regulatory work has brought companies and businesses to their door because of their history and work in this area with the SEC.
    • How Republic educates companies on crowdfunding campaigns and on-boards them through systems they have built.
    • Why due diligence and partnership matter most to Republic in their choice of companies.
    • How Republic does not geographically concentrated in Silicon Valley or New York, but looks at start-ups from across America and why this benefits everyone.
    • How this current crisis will make people more focused and professional in their dealings, and this will create better companies in the long run.

    SUPPORT THE SHOW

    If you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:

    • Help keep this show going by sending us $5
    • Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.

    Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSE

    Ethereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644

    • Leave a Review on iTunes
    • Share an episode with family and friends
    • Follow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.

    The Bitmex Blowup - Patrick Dugan Mar 31, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episodePatrick comes back for another great episode with host Samuel McCulloch and discusses the recent price collapse, Bitmex conspiracies and the soon-to-be-launched Tradelayer. Patrick's LinksTradeLayer: tradelayer.orgTwitter: https://twitter.com/duganistWhere to find the showiTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS FeedWhat to listen forWhy interest rate arbitrage is all about the basis point, and this is its day to day liquidity mechanism.How Bitmex is the solar system of these trades and flipped the switch when the market seized up completely.Why when Bitcoin is not correlated to the stock market and is left to its own devices, God help us all.Why the Asian open hour is always a good indicator of flows and market structure.Why the conventional markets are correlated to bitcoin when there are liquidity demand spikes.Why when they flash crash Bitcoin, the loss is so great systemically that it crashes the market and this is what happened with Bitmex.How Tradelayer would create trade channels to execute trades and create liquidity with oracles and without an order book dependent on co-located market makers.Why the dollar will be the trade of this decade and how its strength will cause problems across the world.SUPPORT THE SHOWIf you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:Help keep this show going by sending us $5Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSEEthereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644Leave a Review on iTunesShare an episode with family and friendsFollow me on Twitter | YoutubeIf you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.SHOW NOTESPatrick was one of the first guests I had on the show that talked about interest rates, and this was almost a premonition of what was to come in DeFi and the year that came after. I want your thoughts on what happened in the markets over the last few weeks and today is 20th March. Bitcoin has ripped back up to 6600. I guess there is a conspiracy put forward by Sam at FTX (bank man), it seems that the overarching theory is: On 11th March there was a catastrophic market push of 287,000 Bitcoin that was sold off by professional traders where the price as 9000 and after this, it took the price on 13th March to 3500. If you can move the market with 1/3 even of spot quantities, then you are actually a derivatives position. The pricing on Bitmex has no correlation to the spot market. If the spread is blown out, then you have to pay the rate (pushing the rate negative). This incentivised short spots on the market, and this got so dislocated from the rest of the futures market it was ridiculous. Around sub 6000 things started really dislocating. The spreads started getting wider and wider; it started getting destroyed and a rolling margin call. There was no liquidity; nobody was bidding. The total combined interest in Bitmex in total are many be 3-5 million. A lot of those future positions are people who are shorting it and then buying the swap. Those guys are working a few percentage points on their accounts. Therefore, it is not supposed to go negative 6. Interest rate arbitrage is all about basis point. That is the day to day liquidity. People are taking advantage of these movements. Bitmex is still the solar system of these trades.On 12th March, as soon as we passed under the 5000, we had the first dump in the morning. This can be a full episode for the twilight zone.I was fully hedged and short perps. It is the most popular world religion. As we had a clean break under 9000, Deribits tend to stay at zero. This was a normal break. There was a 1.2 million volume. That is a lot of money. The other thing we have to factor in here is that a black swan event, Tether is a swap market also it just doesn’t have an interest rate, so it is a perpetual future they have written themselves. There are some fractional reserves in it, but it is not fully collateralised.Re: the Bitmex scandal. I got liquidated both sides, and the slippage was worse than the liquidation fees. It was a curved position which was working for me. There was a little delta slippage. The climax of this story is that I took advantage of the Apex of this story, and we had a strong reversal, 3.6 sigma rally. Do you think these people could have pushed Bitmex to $1? Phase 1 happened when it broke 9000, 7th March. It was pretty clean from there. If we had a better market structure, that might have been, it has more to say about when Bitcoin is not correlated to the stock market and is left to its own devices. God help us all.The Asian open hour as I like to call it is often good for short term positions and trades as you will see one or two hours where there is a move up or down and flows in futures, Tether, derivatives etc. My time it would have been 4 am-5 am in the morning, that is when we had the big dip down. Do you have a chart of S&P/Bitcoin price comparison?Now we are at 2740, and we are on the low end of the range where we have been early February. It is what it is. This is a decent range until we get to a net inflow. Do not lose your coin trying to leverage it. This is the ratio between Bitcoin/SPY.The real fun started with Bitcoin when it broke down past 4000. We have a one-hour candle. Some of this stuff happens in one minute. The relocations started to happen at 6 pm New York time, and there were these giant margin calls. It was a little bit more orderly than it could have been. It really started to get disconnected at this point – from the micro-structural viewpoint. We completely exhausted all the bids. What we had in the evening is a lot of spot buying and retracing. In a sense there was a functioning market, I was buying/selling and quoting in September. There were $200 spreads in the order book. Bitmex is still fine at this point in the story. The evening session it just got destroyed in a 5-minute candle. The conventional markets are correlated to bitcoin when there is liquidity demand due to events. This structural volatility limit collided with the structural volatility limit; in theory, you could have a perpetual swap that goes as wide as the market takes it. It is kind of crazy to think about it. If a guy is 100x leveraged in this, they make the max funding event so big that he will not get liquidated. If you were thinking about this as a short, we would have spot inflows hedging it is the spots pay. Negative rates don’t matter that much.The spreads blow out between BitMex and CoinBase and all the other exchanges. Things just go haywire for roughly about two hours. There is a massive sell-off – liquidation wall in Bitmex, and it seems unstoppable. There was a point where it just went over the edge. That is when things got extremely dicey. I was repositioning seeing the flow, and I was booking some bitcoin as profit. It was a quick, quick move. When the market spreads like this, at the extremes it is, it is really shitty for market makers. They are not able to provide liquidity into the markets at these times. They are supposed to keep the spreads tight and when they get fucked like this, completely run out. Liquidity dropped to zero. But what happens if they can drive it down and it disconnects from the spot market, and push it down for just a few seconds. That is all it takes. In that scenario, when they flash crash Bitcoin, they would be in a situation that the loss is so great systemically that it crashes the market. Only so much volume is going to execute at that level. I did not hold the leverage; I do not have enough pirate in me to say that leveraged. Whatever the scale is, the pattern is the same. It is like a wave five down. It was one of those. We got the deviations, and I saw the push above 4500. I was saying to a friend of mine, relax this is looking like a bottoming move. The way bottoming move get moving is that they get this pump and then it is like over the next forty minutes it moves up very quickly to another support. Do you think Bitmex pulled the plug at 3500? Of course, so I can’t say that, and I can’t quit. Bitmex has a lot of responsibility for other people’s money and assets. They are calling it a DDoS attack on Bitmex on the queue to the book. Instead of doing rollbacks later, they may have just turned off their system for a minute. Maybe they did; maybe they didn’t. Let’s look at the counter-argument, and I will plug my thing. With Tradelayer, instead of having all the liquidity makers co-located in one hard location, the stack is processing things in packets, there is latency there. Then there is the sequence flow through. EMX and Deribit had a freeze up in this time too. Everybody kind of went down in this half an hour of extreme volatility and joy on my part. My plug is let’s run our own Bitcoin derivatives on Tradelayer and build our own clients, run the transactions on the blockchain, run this on our own computers (get more RAM) and control our own assets in cold storage to process trades between each other using hotkeys. We can create bilateral liquidity channels where we are high-frequency trading with each other using the underlying signature feature of Bitcoin. I am just adding logic to things in the channel and in the trade logic layer. There is no order book. This is ten times worse for Bitcoin. On-chain order books are screwed for this – a trade channel would just put a higher block height expiration for its unsigned trades. I am working on open source javascript and trade channels are very good for this. It doesn’t propagate to Mars. Bitcoin Mars is going to be big – Elon Musk will be the CEO. There is always going to be latency. C++ logic will become relevant to trading algorithms. We can play this like it is an option. You can keep trading during this time regardless of volatility. We might be paying a big spread or a large miner fee, but this is life. This is my humble marketing structure to Bitcoin. We will have insurance funds of USDC in TradeLayer in order to make sure that we have liquidity regardless of what happens. Bitmex takes everything instead of Fees, allegedly. Deribit had to chip in BTC during this event. We have black swan events across DeFi, and this won’t be the last one. DeFi has just exploded since we last talked. The ETH guys made a retail investor version of what you are talking about. By creating a retail version, you can create something in a couple of clicks that has driven people to build in DeFi. Yes, it is something that Bitcoin does need to catch up here. Synthetics is a Ponzi scheme. I am Pat Dugan, and I am doing a decentralised derivatives structure without a banking system. Can you create dollars through TradeLayer? Yes, this is simple with an Oracle to create USDC. You will create a dollars with enough Bitcoin to create meta coin, what I would call DUDs, not Dugan dollars, but Digital US Dollars. We are trying to get some dollar issuers on TradeLayer. I want to talk about a company, Valiu – in Colombia, and they are going to have a dollar savings wallet where people in Latin America/South America can use. There will be no interest rates at first. I heard of this company, but they are doing it with Bitcoin. They are dollarizing it for transfer and then selling the hedge. The customer does not know that they are using Bitcoin. Brave New Coin has an ETP tradeable on ETH and KYC – a proper investment product. They take your money, and they buy a basket of DeFi things, they buy this coin and hedge it so they get yield there. They are dealing with operational risk through their blockchain and staking yield. It is a different kind of collateral. There is a very liquid derivatives market while you are in this bull market. When there is Deribit decentralised, I would like to get them on TradeLayer. Are you going to release TradeLayer soon? We raised some money, we got the KYC logic ready, and we have been working on this for two and half years, but we are hopeful of releasing oracles first and then a test net release to get some people trading on it. We will be starting on LightCoin and then moving to BitCoin next. Then we would like to do an options version too. Everything is done in trade channels OTC. These are going to be European style, and the ROI is a real thing in DeFi. Cash settled European is fine. I have made several design choices to make this as simple as possible. The ultimate exchange trading product: short negative bond rates buy an interest rate floor, and you hedged the short principal. You take the proceeds and buy bitcoin and sell that with a derivative for positive yield. You make an index between two indexes. Aren’t you scared by what has been happening in the RePo market of late? Giving them a business model to get their yield on these bonds?What Hitler did, he went full MMT for Germany. That is why everyone loved him. What this means that they will never let the banks go bust. I am reticent that they are going to be able to keep it under control. I think the Fed has underwritten banks in America. The Euro-Dollar market is already getting weird. What happens if we get a 20% increase in the dollar to the Euro? I see that bailing out people in Europe. Now people are going to have to cover their dollar holdings with currencies that are getting killed. You would think Gold and Silver should be going up, but they are being sold out… all commodities, platinum, gold, silver, oil, palladium, etc. Look at some of the currencies – they have all fallen apart in relation to the dollar. This is a global dollar increase, and this is a dollar shortage. They are just running the same playbook again and again. If the trade of this decade is the dollar, the dollar index will top out in the near term. And it is also the least bad place to put your money. If we are going to see an additional 20% in the dollar over the next two to three years, there is going to be a huge movement of money into dollar-based assets. The Fed and Trump will issue as much longer-dated debt as possible. You will see credit risk, but it will be less than it is today. Patrick is not a big fan of DAI. I have not launched yet and failed systemically considering I have not launched TradeLayer yet, so we will see what happens. The point is that everyone needs to do their due diligence and be safe; only invest what you can afford to lose. It is possible that these stimulus checks could end up in BTC. If 5% of Americans hold Bitcoin, they take $250 out of their $1,000 cheques which equates to $3.75 billion, and they invest this into BTC that could be more people in the market as a result.

    Full show notes at the publisher

    Superfluidity in 2020 - Dan Elitzer Mar 27, 2020
    Show notes

    About this episode

    In this Episode Dan Elitzer joins host Samuel McCulloch to discuss the growth of Ethereum & Defi, different approaches to coding languages, liquidity and modern business systems.

    Dan's Links

    Twitter | Linkedin | Medium

    Where to find the show

    iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | Youtube | RSS Feed

    What to listen for

    • Whether building on each other in DeFi creates fluidity between apps when it comes to Ethereum, or does it increase the fragility of the whole ecosystem?
    • Why how we approach building smart contracts needs to be different from software coding, and more akin to hardware design.
    • Why formally verified smart contract languages need to happen.
    • Why we are moving from an infrastructure phase to an application phase right now in Ethereum, and this requires cross-chain protocols that work.
    • Why liquidity is more important than long-term price stability, and this is liquidity maximalism in action.
    • Why greater control over our data is going to take more ‘moon math’ to make this happen.
    • Why we help our portfolio companies focus on their user experience and design first.
    • Why DeFi projects need robust go-to-market strategies, not just traction through creativity and technology execution.
    • How East Coast/West Coast viewpoints within Crypto differ depending on the narrative arc and why San Francisco is still the centre of innovation in the US despite its regressive land-use policies.

    SUPPORT THE SHOW

    If you like End of the Chain you can help support the show by doing one of the following:

    • Help keep this show going by sending us $5
    • Make a Tip - Send me an email after so I can mention you on the show.

    Bitcoin: USE THIS LINK FOR ADDRESS REUSE

    Ethereum: 0xDAb148614f22dDa800cF006Be7932eeEB75AC644

    • Leave a Review on iTunes
    • Share an episode with family and friends
    • Follow me on Twitter | Youtube

    If you are interested in sponsoring the show please send me an email.

    Show Notes
    I wanted to address something that we have seen with the evolution of DeFi: platforms and apps being built on each other. You have Maker which is used in Compound, which is used in bZx which is then used in a whole host of other programmes. You begin to see multiple derivatives of single products being built out. The safety and the security of those products are tied to the underlying products and programmes they are using.

    One of the things I have been wondering is this fluidity between apps when it comes to Ethereum, or is it just an increase in the fragility of the whole ecosystem? In some ways, it is both. A year ago, I wrote a piece about superfluid collateral where I wrote about how we were going to see a lot more interaction between these protocols and the apps, with assets flowing through multiple protocols and the idea of C token before they were created. We have seen these play out and this what we refer to as these money Legos but at the same time, it is a weakness. There are a lot of dependencies, and these can be scary when pretty much every major smart contract has had some flaw in it. Security researchers have been crushing contract after contract; do I think these things are safe yet for the general public? Most of them probably not. Certainly, once you start compounding this risk together, I think we come to a place where we have to start hardening this.

    We really need to think about Nick Szabo, who wrote a great piece about the fiduciary code. The approach to how we are building these contracts needs to be different from normal software. It needs to be akin to designing something like hardware; the difficulty of modifying it after it is set in stone, thinking through how this is running and so many tasks through situations. This is not just people’s money; if we are successful, this is about the whole financial system. If you are trying to build a whole new financial system, and you are building a critical piece of hardware for the structure, then a failure in your code or a piece of it could bring down the whole system, so we really need to be applying a very high bar to how we are auditing these things and what we are doing before launch.

    Is it a weakness in the coding language when you are not using formally verified languages? Tezos is very focused on this. There have been attempts to formally verify on Ethereum. It is a step in the right direction. People should be looking for some kind of formal verification on the contracts when we get to a certain size. Couldn’t that be added into Ethereum in some way?

    Yes, people are working on this in Ethereum to see how this issue is addressed. We are moving towards superfluid protocols, and Bitcoin is coming to Ethereum this year. Is this an argument or a good multi-chain environment? Or is this a monopolistic play where Ethereum will suck liquidity from other chains?

    I think we are moving from an infrastructure phase to an application phase right now. We need cross-chain protocols that work. There are lots of interesting things happening in Cosmos to be able to move across chains. I think when one Chain like Ethereum becomes dominant, we should see consolidation onto Ethereum, which will make cross-chain platforms less appealing. Bitcoin is a separate thing as it is meant to be just money.

    Why is there a sub-case for Bitcoin? If there is no other use for these other coins as ‘money’ or as a user application layer? I think because those things are out there and they are saying use our platform to build out your applications, and value will accrue there. This means that there is value that will follow, or that is the assumption.

    Bitcoin started off with historic value approach, and it is different in that the power of money is people’s belief in it. You can fork Bitcoin, but it is about people’s belief in the social contract around that asset, and that is hard to overcome. Bitcoin is the ultimate thin protocol, which is a differentiator. Globally, Bitcoin is leaps and bounds ahead of Ethereum. I am hopeful we can build useful applications on Ethereum. Ethereum was the first to create dollars out of other things; this is much more powerful than a store of value. I am more of a dollar maximalist.

    The ability to have a stable asset like a stable coin is so much better than any regular cryptocurrency. I find much more interest in these trustless stable assets rather than Layer 1 solutions themselves. There are more use cases for these assets; however, it also layers on additional risk on top of these protocols by building on them. Do you want all the logic handled on-chain or do you want to keep this off-chain instead?

    Liquidity, in some cases, may actually be more important than long-term price stability when you are talking about flows of money. This is my liquidity maximalism in action. Yes, I would also classify myself as a liquidity maximalist; we need to get more activity happening in Crypto rather than on legacy rails and we are all going to win if we can move more stuff into the system.

    Micro-payment options are useless without being able to move into dollars. Any payment system only shines when you get people in there and keep them there. I came into Bitcoin as an open-source payment rail; rather than its anti-government anarchy thread. I am really concerned about our monetary policy and at what point we hit hyper-inflation?

    There is a clear path to accepting cryptocurrencies without getting involved in the cyberpunk/libertarian religions surrounding Bitcoin et al. There are still a lot of open questions. I have worked as a signals intelligence analyst in the marines. We worked with the NSA to work through metadata to find people and send special forces to hunt them down. I can see the use cases when applying them to Crypto.

    We really need much stronger privacy solutions within Crypto going forward to address how we make financial transactions private. My question for Crypto in the 2020s is, can we break the business models of surveillance capitalism by the FAANGS? I think there are benefits of ad-based businesses. Google takes all your communications and processes them through algorithms, to come up with new ways to sell you stuff, and they extract value from you.

    What do individuals care about and what Google the company cares about? I don’t think they are about extracting value from you to sell to other people. If they are not providing value to you and me, for our information, we are not going to give it to them. I am not sure if the way the value is accruing is fair, I don’t know. I am not convinced the model of giving users things without paying for them in exchange for their data is broken. Having the cost of delivering those services being subsidised by advertising revenue is not necessarily a bad thing. I think you can strip out the surveillance aspects of this system by giving them ownership of their data. If you have greater control over what is given out, that is going to take more moon math to make this happen.

    I will store this data locally and then get an app to verify that they are not extracting a copy of that data. Google/Facebook should be data guardians and not show it to anyone else. They should act as a shield between all those advertisers who want our data and us.

    Do you think it is time to democratise them? Should there be an oversight panel that is elected and oversees them? I find this idea uncomfortable, and we do need to fix things we see in big tech companies. I think this is not somewhere Crypto should be heading in the next few years. If we can’t get digital money, assets that are not centralised, then we don’t have a chance on any of these Web 3.0 issues. I think the bigger questions are about implementation and how you are going to go to market. There seems to be this mindset in teams across the space that they get lost in the technical and philosophical questions of their project rather than actually talking to users and who they are trying to serve and getting their feedback. There seems to be this assumption in Crypto that if you build it, they will come, but we know this is not true. You really need a go-to-market strategy.

    I guess this also ties into what you are doing as a portfolio company, and how do you position yourself with the companies you are working with? What kind of operational support are you giving them on a day to day basis? We are trying to make sure our portfolio companies stay focused on their users and that they are interacting with them on a daily basis. In some cases, we are very hands-on with some projects to help them at the user level, and with others, we are pointing them in the right direction. Our help can take many different forms. Just technical creativity and execution is not enough, and it hasn’t been enough for years. What we need now is that folks are thinking from the beginning, how are we going to get users using our project. There is a lot of liquidity hacking stuff that we are going to start seeing that will let these DeFi projects get that initial traction and their go-to-market strategy.

    You need to get over an initial liquidity threshold to make these protocols really useful for a large number of people and in order for them to be successful, this threshold is necessary. One of the projects you are working with Handshake has just launched. They have a really interesting token distribution model – including 80% token distribution in the form of token developer grants. It needs to be in the hands of developers and users. We need to give it to the people who are going to use and develop it. They are optimising for adoption. Did you have any hand in helping them structure their token? We helped them design their logo, front end and onboarding. We helped them with some technical issues too. Their token structure was already their idea.

    What is the process of finding new companies to add to your portfolio? It is not a one size fit all kind of process. Our funnel is based on myself and other team members knowing builders in the space. We are based in San Francisco and the beauty of the space being distributed around tech and Crypto. Our process for vetting companies is focused on DeFi and other aspects of Web 3.0. We all bring different backgrounds to the table. The design has always been a part of the conversation rather than just the technology itself. Our team has been working together for the last five years. We have developed our expertise together. We haven’t gone out and added people to the team at this stage.

    Do you see differences between what is being built East versus West here in the USA? Yes, I think this is accurate. There is an East Coast/West coast view of Crypto. The East Coast is more bitcoin oriented, and the West Coast is more Ethereum focused.


    Previous 1 2 3 4 5 7 Next

    Related Podcasts

    Reply All

    1

    Reply All Games & Hobbies
    Inside VR & AR

    2

    Inside VR & AR Gadgets
    Note to Self

    3

    Note to Self News
    BrainStuff

    4

    BrainStuff Natural Sciences
    This Week in Tech (Audio)

    5

    This Week in Tech (Audio) News
    Hands-On Tech (Audio)

    6

    Hands-On Tech (Audio) Technology
    footer-logo

    Contact Us

    Toll Free: 844-670-7747

    Links

    • Home
    • Top Charts
    • Networks
    • Apps
    • Independents Podcasts
    • Podcast Advertising
    • Podcast News
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Analytics & Insights

    Stay Connected

      Privacy, Terms of Use & Our Code of Ethics Protecting Content Creators Copyrights