Believing the Bizarre: Paranormal Podcast

Latest Episodes:

Terrified Together with Kaydra Brannan (Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast) Sep 16, 2025

Show notes

Our next Terrified Together is with friend of the podcast, Kaydra from Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast!

During this collab, we dive into two compelling listener submissions that took us from the Mississippi countryside to New Jersey suburbs.

Emma from Mississippi shared her incredible journey from being terrified of everything paranormal to becoming fascinated by it, starting with a dramatic UFO sighting in 2012 that had her mother calling both the police and their preacher.

Her story spans nearly a decade of encounters, including mysterious couch-climbing sounds and shadow figures that left us questioning what forces might be following her through different homes.

Our second story came from AI, who introduced us to "Hugh" - perhaps the most polite ghost we've ever encountered on the show.

This shadow figure with a hat and briefcase seemed content to coexist peacefully with the family until a skeptical friend made some unfortunate comments during a graduation party.

Check out Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast here: https://www.perplexitymysterypodcast.com/

Patreon⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The Black Eye Club Sep 09, 2025

Show notes

The Black Eye Club | Paranormal Podcast

This week, we dive deep into one of the internet's most intriguing conspiracy theories: the Black Eye Club.

We explore the curious pattern of celebrities, politicians, and influential figures appearing in public with prominent black eyes - particularly on the left side - and the theories surrounding what this might mean.

From George W. Bush and Jay Leno to Adam Sandler and Elon Musk, we examine the extensive list of public figures who've been photographed with these mysterious injuries, along with their often unusual explanations ranging from bicycle accidents to microphone mishaps.

We also discuss the potential symbolic roots of this phenomenon through ancient mythology, exploring connections to Odin's sacrifice of his eye for wisdom in Norse tales and the Eye of Horus from Egyptian lore.

Finally, we look at various theories about what these black eyes might represent - from initiation rituals into elite secret societies and humiliation punishments to more sinister explanations involving adrenochrome harvesting and even alien parasites entering through the eye.

Patreon⁠⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

🛸 Recommendation: If you like this episode, check out our episode on ⁠⁠the Montauk Project⁠⁠.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Episode Keywords: black eye club, conspiracy theory, secret society, illuminati, celebrities black eyes, political figures black eyes, adrenochrome, initiation ritual, humiliation ritual, odin mythology, eye of horus, egyptian mythology, norse mythology, reptilian aliens, elite society, occult symbolism, freemasons, all seeing eye, pattern recognition, confirmation bias, social media conspiracy, celebrity injuries, left eye symbolism, mk ultra, remote viewing, believing the bizarre podcast, conspiracy theories, ancient mythology, sacrifice for wisdom, parasitic aliens, body snatchers

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The Smurl Family Haunting Sep 02, 2025

Show notes

The Smurl Family Haunting | Paranormal Podcast

This week, we dive deep into one of the most documented cases of demonic oppression in modern history - the Smurl haunting.

We explore how a working-class Catholic family's dream of stability turned into a 14-year nightmare when they moved into a duplex in West Pittston, Pennsylvania in 1973. What started as subtle oddities like an impossible-to-clean carpet stain and a mysteriously exploding television quickly escalated into violent physical attacks, levitation, and encounters with shadowy figures that would test the family's faith to its breaking point.

We discuss the role of the infamous Ed and Lorraine Warren, who documented weeks of paranormal activity, including physical assaults, sexual encounters with demonic entities, and the presence of multiple spirits alongside a powerful demon.

Patreon⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

🛸 Recommendation: If you like this episode, check out our episode on ⁠⁠Pete the Poltergeist.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Episode Keywords: Smurl haunting, demonic possession, Ed and Lorraine Warren, West Pittston Pennsylvania, paranormal activity, haunted house, ghost stories, supernatural phenomena, poltergeist activity, Catholic exorcism, demonic oppression, paranormal investigation, true ghost stories, haunted duplex, demonic entities, spiritual warfare, paranormal podcast, horror stories, unexplained phenomena, paranormal encounters

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Terrified Together with Kassie (Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast) Aug 26, 2025

Show notes

Our next Terrified Together is with Kassie, the awesome host of the Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast.

Our first story comes from Mackie in Lubbock, Texas, who experienced a terrifying encounter that drained her and her boyfriend's energy for an entire week.

What started as unexplained fatigue and loss of motivation escalated into a haunting night where they both witnessed a seven-foot shadow figure prowling outside their bedroom window, followed by mysterious tapping sounds that sent them scrambling to check every lock in the house.

The second tale takes us to rural Ohio, where 13-year-old Calla and her friend Maddie decided to experiment with the Red Book game - a paranormal ritual involving a red hardcover book (they used a dictionary) and candles.

What began as innocent curiosity quickly turned sinister when the spirits they contacted through the book refused to let them leave the game. The aftermath brought sleep paralysis, mysterious scratches, encounters with shadow figures, and the terrifying appearance of the "old hag" - experiences that followed both girls to their separate homes until they performed cleansing rituals to break free from whatever had attached itself to them.

Check out Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast here: ⁠https://tellmeyourghoststorypodcast.podbean.com/⁠

⁠⁠Patreon⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The Creature that Wanted the Baby Aug 19, 2025

Show notes

The Creature that Wanted the Baby | Paranormal Podcast

Our first story comes from Baker in West Texas, who shares an incredible tale from 1985 about his newborn son's strange sleeping patterns and unexplained nocturnal visitors.

What started as puzzling midnight crying episodes soon revealed something far more extraordinary when family members began witnessing shadowy figures hovering over the baby's crib, and blankets mysteriously appearing to keep the infant warm during cold desert nights.

We then explore three unsettling encounters submitted by Dell from California's Sierra Nevada mountains, spanning from childhood to motherhood. Her experiences range from a terrifying figure spotted during a lightsaber battle when she was nine years old, to a disturbing bedroom intrusion involving a four-foot creature with glowing yellow eyes approaching her newborn daughter.

The final encounter involves phantom voices of her children calling out in the night from outside their remote home - but when Dell checks, both kids are safely asleep in their beds.

⁠Patreon⁠⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The North Canol Road Alien Abduction Aug 12, 2025

Show notes

The North Canol Road Alien Abduction | Paranormal Podcast

This week, we journey to the remote wilderness of Yukon, Canada, to explore the North Canal Road alien abduction case from 1987.

We follow Kevin, a seasoned outdoorsman who set out on what should have been a routine three-day moose hunting expedition on his motorcycle. What started as a simple trip through the desolate terrain quickly transformed into something far more extraordinary when Kevin encountered a mysterious cigar-shaped craft and two insectoid beings he described as "grasshopper people."

What makes this case particularly compelling is Kevin's 13-year silence and the physical evidence he discovered afterward - including unexplained scoop-like marks on his palms and memories that slowly resurfaced over time.

We explore the psychological impact of his experience, from the initial sighting to the missing hours and fragmented memories of what occurred during his alleged abduction.

🛸 Recommendation: If you like this episode, check out our episode on ⁠⁠the Allagash Alien Abduction.

⁠Patreon⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Haunted Schools: Part 1 Aug 05, 2025

Show notes

Haunted Schools | Paranormal Podcast

This week, we dive into the dark hallways and shadowy corners of America's most haunted schools just as students head back to class.

We explore two particularly eerie Schools: Pocatello High School in Idaho, where urban legends tell of a tragic suicide pact from the 1940s-50s that left one girl hanging from the top lockers (which were subsequently removed), and a ghostly wet child who supposedly drowned in the school's former pool. The campus is also known for phantom piano music echoing through an empty auditorium and unsettling sounds from the theater's changing rooms.

Then we discuss the much more historically documented El Paso High School in Texas, built in 1916 over underground tunnels that once served as a morgue during the Spanish flu epidemic. With alleged deaths on campus, sealed-off rooms discovered years later, and even a mysterious figure appearing in a 1985 school photograph, this institution has a deeply troubling past.

We also share two compelling anonymous stories from Reddit - one involving a Catholic preschool next to an 1800s cemetery where staff regularly encounter a spirit they call "Mary," and another from an Ohio behavioral school with such intense paranormal activity that it's now being demolished.

Patreon⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The Haunted Pool Mannequin Jul 29, 2025

Show notes

The Haunted Pool Mannequin | Paranormal Podcast

This week, we dive into two chilling listener submissions that will make you think twice about your next swim or house purchase.

Get 60% off the Magic Mind offer with our link https://magicmind.com/bizarremf or code BIZARRE60 upon checkout. #magicmind #mentalwealth #mentalperformance

Our first story comes from Baker in Nebraska, who experienced some truly terrifying encounters while working as a lifeguard at what can only be described as a haunted pool facility.

From feeling constantly watched while cleaning locker rooms to hearing mysterious conversations and footsteps when alone, Baker's experiences escalated dramatically after the staff started treating their CPR training mannequin, Fred, like a real person.

Our second story takes us on a decades-long journey with Tara and her family, spanning from 2001 to 2024 across multiple homes in Texas.

What began as a dream house purchase - complete with two acres and a backyard creek - quickly turned into a nightmare when neighbors warned them that "no one stays together in this house."

We explore the escalating paranormal activity that seemed to center around Tara's mother, from shadow figures and putrid smells to physical attacks and one of the most unsettling doppelganger encounters we've ever heard.

⁠Patreon⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Ed Larson | Last Podcast on the Left - Interview Jul 25, 2025

Show notes

Ed Larson Interview - Last Podcast on the Left

*Note - this episode is raw and uncut, with no censorship. Listener discretion advised*

We are thrilled to present this interview with Ed Larson, comedian and host of Last Podcast on the Left. Charlie truly could not contain his excitement!

Ed Larson discusses his journey from being the biggest baby born in Florida (nearly 15 pounds) to becoming a comedian, starting with sketch comedy group Murder Fist in Tallahassee and eventually joining Last Podcast on the Left.

He shares stories from his past including working as a cook for 16 years, dealing marijuana and getting arrested, and the infamous incident where he accidentally pulled an AK-47 on a pest control worker who entered his apartment.

He also discusses his love for animals and charity work, including benefits for dog rescues and the Last Prisoner Project which helps people incarcerated for marijuana offenses, as well as his passion for horror films and the killer whale SeaWorld episodes he led on the podcast.

Check out the Last Podcast on the Left here.

Learn more about the Last Prisoner Project.

Visit Ed's personal website here.

Patreon⁠⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Terrified Together with Drinking the Koolaid Jul 22, 2025

Show notes

Terrified Together with Drinking the Koolaid

We're thrilled to share our second official "Terrified Together," , where we welcomed Amanda and Cassidy from Drinking the Koolaid for some creepy listener submission stories.

Our first tale comes from Reagan, who experienced something truly unsettling during a seventh-grade school trip to the notoriously haunted Savannah, Georgia.

What started as an innocent exploration of a small cemetery near their log cabin accommodations took a dark turn.

Our second story transported us to rural Texas in 2020, where Sabrina's routine drive home from babysitting her nephew became anything but ordinary. Strange lights pursued her car at impossible speeds, followed by a mysterious loss of time and unexplained physical symptoms.

We wrapped up with Ben's lifelong encounters in Montana, beginning with childhood visits from what he called "The Stomp Dance girls" and escalating to shadow figures and mysterious dancing lights in his bedroom.

Patreon⁠⁠: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:

⁠⁠Shop Merch⁠⁠: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

Want to send BTB something? Ship it here: 3570 Executive Drive, Suite 218, Uniontown, Ohio 44685

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices