After Reality with Courtney Robertson

Latest Episodes:

My Husband Got Served: Plea Deal Predictions in the Clayton Echard Case Jun 03, 2026

Show notes

In this episode of After Reality, I’m joined by my husband, Humberto Preciado, for a little summer life update and a deeper legal conversation. We talk about the chaos of parenting three young kids during summer break, from camp schedules to trying to make sweet memories while also feeling completely exhausted.

Humberto, a former prosecutor, also shares the surprising story of recently being served with legal documents at our home related to a years-old white-collar crime case. From there, we dive into the ongoing criminal case involving former Bachelor star Clayton Echard.

Humberto breaks down how plea deals work in Arizona, what might be motivating the defense, and why taking a deal could be a way to avoid the much bigger risks of going to trial. This episode blends real family life, marriage banter, and Humberto’s legal insight into one of the most high-profile Bachelor Nation legal battles.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Mackenzie Shirilla, Perfect Match Finale & Clayton vs. Laura Owens May 29, 2026

Show notes

I’m back with a quick summer update before diving into Netflix’s The Crash and the Mackenzie Shirilla case that has completely taken over my algorithm.

After watching multiple documentaries, I went down the TikTok rabbit hole of Shyann Topping — Mackenzie’s ex-girlfriend from prison — and her viral storytelling about what life is really like for women behind bars. Let’s just say, Kim Kardashian is not coming to save you.

Then I’m getting into the Perfect Match finale — the drama, the strategy, the couples, and who actually felt real by the end. I also play a clip from Nick Viall’s podcast that ties into the conversation.

I wrap with a few Bachelor Nation headlines, including the latest on Clayton Echard vs. Laura Owens — and whether she’s really going to accept a plea deal that could mean just two months in jail. A little true crime, a little reality TV chaos, and a lot to unpack.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Nothing Is Off Record: Juliet Harris on Crisis PR, Rachel Leviss & Taylor Frankie Paul May 20, 2026

Show notes

What happens when a celebrity scandal breaks, the internet is on fire, and everyone is waiting for the perfect statement? According to veteran publicist Juliet Harris, nothing is ever really “off record.”

This week on After Reality, I’m joined by the founder of IT Girl Productions for a behind-the-scenes look at crisis PR, celebrity scandals, and reputation management. Juliet has worked with major names including Nelly, The Backstreet Boys, La Toya Jackson, and Rachel Leviss, and she knows exactly what it takes to help a public figure survive a public storm. But what does accountability actually look like when the spotlight is on you — and is a statement ever enough?

Juliet shares how she went from studying criminology to managing high-profile reputations, and what really happens behind the scenes when a headline starts spiraling. We talk about how social media has changed the PR game, why accountability matters, and how publicists decide what to say — and what not to say — when the internet is watching.

We also get into the latest celebrity PR parallels, from Taylor Frankie Paul to Blake Lively, Spencer Pratt’s run for mayor, and how reality TV personas can collide with real-life consequences. Plus, Juliet shares her thoughts on The Bachelorette PR team, what they may be navigating behind the scenes, and how a franchise handles headlines when the story starts moving faster than the official messaging.

Juliet also opens up about balancing a demanding career with motherhood, staying organized under pressure, and why great PR is really a strategic chess game built on instinct, relationships, and knowing when to make the right move.

@itgirlpublicrelations

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Taylor Frankie Paul Drama, Spencer Pratt Running for LA Mayor & My Family Mystery May 12, 2026

Show notes

In this solo episode of After Reality, I’m coming off a very glamorous Mother’s Day — and by glamorous, I mean I did absolutely nothing. I sat in silence, recharged, binge-watched an intense Peacock crime drama, and then immediately needed to cleanse my nervous system with Farmer Wants a Wife. Honestly, my kind of holiday.

I’m also sharing more about the beautiful response to my Mother’s Day episode with my 98-year-old Grandma Angie, and why it made me want to open up about something much more personal: the disappearance of my Aunt Elaine Robertson, who went missing in Mount Rainier National Park in the 1970s.

Then we get into the mess. Taylor Frankie Paul’s never-ending battle continues, and I’m breaking down the latest back-and-forth with Mikayla Matthews, the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives fallout, the questions around loyalty, boundaries, and whether Taylor is unraveling in real time. And yes — will she go live again?

I’m also talking about what feels missing from ABC’s summer reality lineup, plus Kaitlyn Bristowe and Jenn Tran joining the new reality show Reality Retreat.

And because this episode somehow has even more range, I’m getting into Spencer Pratt’s mayoral debate moment. I used to run in the same circles as Spencer, and I’m sharing why I’m not surprised he showed up fired up, sharp, and ready to talk fire safety, law enforcement, homelessness, and the future of Los Angeles.

It’s Mother’s Day, family secrets, Mormon Wives drama, Bachelor Nation news, politics, and a little reality TV chaos — exactly how we like it.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Special Mother’s Day Episode: My 98-Year-Old Grandma Angie’s Wisdom May 08, 2026

Show notes

In this special Mother’s Day episode of After Reality, I’m sharing a heartwarming phone call with my 98-year-old grandmother, Angie.

We catch up on life, motherhood, my real estate career, the podcast, and the beautiful chaos of raising three young kids. Grandma Angie gives me a little window into her life now — enjoying the sunshine, playing blackjack, getting visits from her sons, and keeping everyone laughing with her honesty.

We also talk about the beautiful Hawaiian quilt she made me — a true labor of love — and she jokes about how she’s supposed to be teaching the ladies how to sew now, but honestly… she just doesn’t want to do it.

This conversation also carries a tender piece of our family story. Grandma Angie shares how much she still misses her daughter, Elaine Robertson, who went missing in May of 1979, and how she continues to hold out hope and pray for her after all these years.

At 98, Grandma Angie reminds me what really matters: family, faith, a positive attitude, and not taking life too seriously. This conversation is a sweet multi-generational reminder to slow down, stay grateful, and cherish the people who helped shape us.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Nick Pellecchia Reveals How He Won Million Dollar Secret May 06, 2026

Show notes

I’m joined by Nick Pellecchia, the winner of Netflix’s Million Dollar Secret, for a behind-the-scenes look at how he pulled off the win.

Nick opens up about his strategy, how he identified the secret millionaire, and what was going through his mind when he made the bold box swap in the finale that secured him the grand prize. We also talk about the casting process, his transition from finance into reality TV, and what it was really like trying to complete secret agendas while filming at the château.

Of course, we get into his flirtations on the show, his chemistry with Umeko Peterson, and what fans can expect from his upcoming appearance on Perfect Match Season 4. And yes — I ask the million-dollar questions: has he actually been paid yet, and what does he plan to do with the money?

Nick also shares how emotional intelligence, staying calm under pressure, and reading the room helped him navigate one of Netflix’s most fascinating social strategy games.

@nickypill

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Bonus Breaking News: Reality Steve on Taylor Frankie Paul, Dakota Mortensen & Jessi Draper Audio May 01, 2026

Show notes

Was Taylor Frankie Paul’s Bachelorette opportunity collateral damage in the fallout with Dakota Mortensen?

In this bonus breaking news episode of After Reality, I’m diving into the latest legal turmoil and personal drama surrounding Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen — from the leaked audio involving Jessi Draper to the outcome of yesterday’s court hearing.

I’m joined by Reality Steve to break down the latest court update, including the three-year mutual protective order issued to keep Taylor and Dakota separated. But the bigger question is: can these two actually quit each other — and what could all of this mean for Taylor’s future on reality TV?

Beyond the headlines, TikToks, leaked audio, and reality TV speculation, this conversation is really about what happens when a relationship becomes toxic — and why the safety and well-being of their young son has to come first.

@realitysteve

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Former Bachelor Producer Talks Bachelor Nation Secrets: “Gabby Never Liked Rachel” Apr 29, 2026

Show notes

In this episode, I’m catching up with former Bachelor producer Alanna Noel after she went completely radio silent for the last year.

She opens up about stepping away, what she was dealing with behind the scenes, and what it’s been like finding her way back.

Then we get straight into Bachelor Nation — where the franchise stands, what’s shifting behind the curtain, and the headlines surrounding Taylor Frankie Paul.

We also get into the dynamic between Gabby Windey and Rachel Recchia, and how much of what we saw was real versus situational.

I ask about former producer Julie LaPlaca’s upcoming book, The Love Producer: My Unscripted Journey from a Reality TV Career to My Own Happily Ever After, and what it actually takes to tell that story — NDAs, unspoken rules, and what may still be off limits.

We get into the realities of production — uncredited ideas, shaping storylines, and how much is mapped out before filming even begins. And yes… Alanna shuts down the rumor about producer bonuses.

It’s candid, direct, and full of the kind of behind-the-scenes insight Bachelor fans don’t usually hear.

@lannanoel

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Stefanie Parker’s She’s All Bach Solo Era, Bachelor Tea & Big Dreams Apr 22, 2026

Show notes

On this episode of After Reality, I sit down with Stefanie Parker, top-charting podcast host of She’s All Bach, for a fun catch-up between two close friends. We talk about her new solo era, what led to her professional split from her longtime co-host, and why this next chapter is rooted in growth, not drama.

We also get into some of the biggest Bachelor Nation headlines, from Nick Viall’s alleged treatment of guests to the fallout surrounding Taylor Frankie Paul’s canceled Bachelorette season. We share some gentle thoughts on the latest controversy and ask the question: is Dakota Mortensen actually capable of going off the grid?

We also talk about following your dreams, even with imposter syndrome, and I open up about shooting my shot for Dancing with the Stars.

Such a fun, honest conversation with plenty of tea and a little real-life encouragement mixed in.

@shesallbach

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Behind The Bachelor Casting Process: Chris Lancaster’s Untold Story Apr 16, 2026

Show notes

In this episode of After Reality, I sit down with Chris Lancaster to talk about his experience being in the running to become the next Bachelor. He opens up about the intense casting process—from background checks and psychological evaluations to even being asked by producers to cut his hair to fit the show’s aesthetic.

But just as things were gaining momentum, everything shifted. The network pivoted to The Bachelorette with Taylor Frankie Paul, and Chris shares how producers then encouraged him to join her season as a contestant instead.

He was told that going on her season could eventually lead to him becoming the Bachelor—but ultimately, he chose to walk away. For Chris, it came down to authenticity and wanting something real.

We talk about what that decision meant for him, how the experience pushed him to grow, and why it helped clarify what he’s truly looking for in a committed relationship—outside of reality TV.

He also shares advice for anyone considering the process, emphasizing the importance of staying grounded, trusting your instincts, and protecting your heart in an industry that can be incredibly high-pressure

@_chrislancaster_

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.