TopPodcast.com
Menu
  • Home
  • Top Charts
  • Top Networks
  • Top Apps
  • Top Independents
  • Top Podfluencers
  • Top Picks
    • Top Business Podcasts
    • Top True Crime Podcasts
    • Top Finance Podcasts
    • Top Comedy Podcasts
    • Top Music Podcasts
    • Top Womens Podcasts
    • Top Kids Podcasts
    • Top Sports Podcasts
    • Top News Podcasts
    • Top Tech Podcasts
    • Top Crypto Podcasts
    • Top Entrepreneurial Podcasts
    • Top Fantasy Sports Podcasts
    • Top Political Podcasts
    • Top Science Podcasts
    • Top Self Help Podcasts
    • Top Sports Betting Podcasts
    • Top Stocks Podcasts
  • Podcast News
  • About Us
  • Podcast Advertising
  • Contact
Not in our directory?
Add Show Here
Podcast Equipment
Center

toppodcastlogoOur TOPPODCAST Picks

  • Comedy
  • Crypto
  • Sports
  • News
  • Politics
  • True Crime
  • Business
  • Finance

Follow Us

toppodcastlogoStay Connected

    View Top 200 Chart
    Back to Rankings Page
    Film Reviews

    That Was Pretty Scary

    That Was Pretty Scary is a horror podcast hosted by Jon Lee Brody. From reviews and recaps of classic and contemporary horror to deep dive analysis and conversations with creators, JLB explores why scary movies stick with us and why they matter.

    NOTE TO LISTENERS:
    When That Was Pretty Scary first launched in 2023, it began as a joint venture between Jon Lee Brody and Freddie Prinze Jr. In 2025, after 102 episodes together, Freddie departed the show and JLB continued on as the solo host. New listeners can enjoy the full archive of early episodes and then seamlessly transition into the current era of the show. Enjoy and stay scary!

    Advertise
    • Apple Podcasts
    • Google Play
    • Spotify

    Latest Episodes:
    OBSESSION (2026) Explained: Why We’re So Obsessed with Curry Barker's Horror Hit | TWPS INVESTIGATES Nov 11, 2026
    Show notes

    Why can’t audiences stop talking about Curry Barker’s Obsession?

    JLB is joined by licensed clinical psychologist Dr. Andrea Letamendi as they investigate the psychology behind the 2026 horror phenomenon. Why are viewers so captivated by Nikki and Inde Navarrette? And how do fanaticism, hate-watching, male entitlement and the film’s $750,000 underdog story keep the conversation alive?

    Love it or hate it, Obsession has become more than a movie. It is a cultural argument and a psychological test.

    Spoiler warning: This episode discusses the complete plot and ending of Obsession.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    BUDDY (2026) with Writer/Director CASPER KELLY: Turning Childhood Nostalgia Into Psychological Horror Nov 04, 2026
    Show notes

    JLB is joined by CASPER KELLY, the writer/director of BUDDY, the horror movie that took audiences by surprise! Casper takes us behind the scenes of his twisted take on childhood nostalgia, revealing his approach to turning familiar children's television into psychological horror, the story behind the film's title and whether we can expect more movies set in the Buddy universe!

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    TUSK (2014): Kevin Smith's Horror Movie Was Ahead of the Curve and Predicted the Future | TWPS LISTENER PICK Oct 28, 2026
    Show notes

    In 2014, Kevin Smith took some big swings with his (now prophetic) horror movie 'Tusk' that may not have made complete sense at the time but looking back we realize how ahead of the curve he was. And he also predicted that podcasting would be the mainstream thing.

    Today's listener pick is courtesy of Kai!

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    GHOSTWATCH (1992): The Made for TV Movie that Fooled Audiences Years Before BLAIR WITCH Did | TWPS LISTENER PICK Oct 21, 2026
    Show notes

    Before Blair Witch was fooling audiences with found footage, the BBC did it in 1992 with Ghostwatch. This British gem is one that you may have missed and one you definitely need to check out.
    This weeks movie was selected by TWPS listener Kim the Horror Fanatic (who is the reason we have the name 'Scaries' for our TWPS community).

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    THE MONSTER SQUAD (1987) with Special Guest Host SARAH NICKLIN | TWPS LISTENER PICK Oct 14, 2026
    Show notes

    JLB is joined by SARAH NICKLIN and going back to the year 1987 with The Monster Squad! Today's TWPS Listener Pick was chosen by Brook4tini4real.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    SCREAM 3 (2000): A Very Worthy and Underrated Threequel That Gives Important Commentary on Hollywood | TWPS LISTENER PICK Oct 07, 2026
    Show notes

    Today's listener pick is courtesy of Ellie Quinn and Laura Daly. Thanks to them we head back to Woodsboro by way of Hollywood and compare the reception of Scream 3 back in 2000 vs now. JLB also unwraps all of the messages that are present in this underrated threequel.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS (1991): The OSCAR WINNING Slasher Movie Sep 30, 2026
    Show notes

    JLB revisits the Oscar winning movie The Silence of the Lambs; he unwraps all of themes and talks about how the movie really is a slasher wearing the skin of a prestige crime thriller.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    THOMAS RONDINELLA & WILLIAM PACE: Writing BLADES in 9 Days, Parodying JAWS & Plans for BLADES 2 | TWPS SCARY TALK Sep 23, 2026
    Show notes

    JLB gets more insight into the once forgotten gem from 1989 BLADES when he speaks to THOMAS RONDINELLA (writer/director/producer) and co-writer/producer WILLIAM PACE. The two talk about writing the script in 9 days, all of the challenges with production and the renaissance it has gotten recently.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    BATMAN THE ANIMATED SERIES "NOTHING TO FEAR" with writer HENRY GILROY! Sep 19, 2026
    Show notes

    It's BATMAN DAY! And to celebrate this, JLB sits down with writer HENRY GILROY who wrote the Batman Animated Series episode 'Nothing to Fear' famous for debuting The Scarecrow and containing the ultimate Batman mic drop of "I am vengeance. I am the night. I am Batman'. Henry shares behind the scenes info on crafting this story and shares his thoughts on Batman belonging in the category of horror!

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    TWPS Scary Talk with ARKIRA CHANTARATANANOND (The Last Kiss) Sep 18, 2026
    Show notes

    JLB sits with ARKIRA CHANTARTANANOND who stars in Blumhouse's latest horror romance movie 'The Last Kiss'. She talks about bringing life to her character, her background in computer science and what Asian American representation means to her.

    Follow That Was Pretty Scary on Instagram and TikTok

    Follow Jon Lee Brody on Instagram


    Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.


    1 2 3 20 Next

    Related Podcasts

    Watch What Crappens – Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam

    1

    Watch What Crappens – Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam Arts
    Mad About Movies

    2

    Mad About Movies Film Reviews
    Pop Culture Happy Hour

    3

    Pop Culture Happy Hour Film Reviews
    Filmspotting

    4

    Filmspotting Film History
    Cinephile with Adnan Virk

    5

    Cinephile with Adnan Virk Film Reviews
    Mad About Movies

    6

    Mad About Movies Film Reviews
    footer-logo

    Contact Us

    Toll Free: 844-670-7747

    Links

    • Home
    • Top Charts
    • Networks
    • Apps
    • Independents Podcasts
    • Podcast Advertising
    • Podcast News
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Analytics & Insights

    Stay Connected

      Privacy, Terms of Use & Our Code of Ethics Protecting Content Creators Copyrights