WFAN Daily

Latest Episodes:

Darnold to the Super Bowl Would Be Peak Jets Pain | Evan & Tiki Jan 23, 2026

Show notes

A Jets fan dilemma: Sam Darnold is one win from the Super Bowl, and the fan base is split between rooting for a guy they still like and bracing for the avalanche of “LOL Jets” takes that would follow.

The guys revisit how the Jets handled Darnold, how the “seeing ghosts” moment became a career-defining label, and why moving on for Zach Wilson still feels like the franchise’s biggest sliding doors decision. They also debate how much credit Darnold deserves for Seattle’s success, why Jets fans fear two weeks of nonstop relitigating, and whether this would be more embarrassing than Giants fans watching Saquon win it all in Philly. Plus, the poll question that could start an all-out NY fan war.

Breaking Down The Championship Games | Boomer & Gio Jan 23, 2026

Show notes

Pats v Broncos, Rams v Seahawks. Offenses, defenses, QBs. Here it is.

Mets Trade For Freddy Peralta | WFAN Daily With Pete Hoffman Jan 23, 2026

Show notes

But what did the Mets have to give up? Some say too much. Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat have been sent packing. David Stearns gets his guy. Is the off-season complete? Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Pat Leonard: Leaks, Power Struggles & Why Joe Schoen Could Be DONE | The Carton Show Jan 22, 2026

Show notes

Pat Leonard joins Craig Carton and Big Mac to break down the real impact of John Harbaugh taking over the New York Giants. From cleaning up leaks inside the building to reshaping the front office, Harbaugh is already wielding serious power. The guys dive into whether Joe Schoen is officially on borrowed time, what scared ownership into making massive changes, and how broken the Giants organization truly was behind the scenes. Plus: Jaxson Dart’s future, staff shakeups, and why this finally feels different for Giants fans.

Craig Carton LOSES IT: Mets Fans Are Miserable Even After Landing Peralta | The Carton Show Jan 22, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton goes full Mr. Positive as the Mets finally make a splash, landing Freddy Peralta — and somehow fans are STILL complaining. Craig unloads on miserable Mets fans, fires shots at Evan Roberts’ negativity, defends trading prospects to win NOW, and declares the Mets a better team today than yesterday. Plus, a classic Carton rant on why fans can’t have it both ways. Passion, arguments, and laughs to kick off the Carton Show.

The Freddy Peralta Trade Has Evan Worried | Evan & Tiki Jan 22, 2026

Show notes

Evan makes one thing clear right away: he does not hate the move, but he is not celebrating either. The Mets are undeniably better after adding Freddy Peralta, and the rotation finally looks respectable. The problem is the price. Two top-100 prospects for a pitcher Evan believes is a one-year rental based on the track record of David Stearns.
That sparks a deeper conversation about what the Mets are actually building under Stearns and Steve Cohen. Is this a smart year-to-year strategy, or a risky way to live as a fan? Evan lays out why a rental only works if it leads to a World Series run, compares the move to past Mets rentals, and asks fans the real question: what result makes this trade worth it?
Plus, a hilarious and painfully real dad moment from Madison Square Garden, where Evan has to explain to his kids both Nets misery and why Jet Williams is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

UFC's Jon Anik previews UFC 324 & 325 | WFAN Daily With Pete Hoffman Jan 22, 2026

Show notes

The best play by play man in all sports, Jon Anik, stops by the WFAN studios and talks all things UFC, Boston Sports, New York Sports and a whole lot more with Pete Hoffman. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Mets Moves Make Us Smile | Boomer & Gio Jan 22, 2026

Show notes

With Freddy Peralta now coming to Citi Field, we're pretty up on the moves the Mets have made this off-season. We also toss some Yankees talk to mix it up a bit.

Yankees Win Big with Cody Bellinger as Mets Pivot to Luis Robert | The Carton Show Jan 21, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a huge day in New York sports as the Yankees officially bring back Cody Bellinger, shutting the door on the Mets, Blue Jays, and Dodgers. Craig explains why patience paid off for Brian Cashman and why this move was a must to avoid a disastrous offseason in the Bronx. The conversation turns fiery as the guys debate the Mets’ pivot from Kyle Tucker and Bellinger to Luis Robert Jr., questioning whether Mets fans should really be “crowing” over a defense-first, low-power lineup.

Mets Trade for Luis Robert Jr.: High Upside Move or Risky Painting? | Evan & Tiki Jan 21, 2026

Show notes

The Mets finally make the move everyone assumed would never happen, acquiring Luis Robert Jr. and forcing a hard look at what this roster is really becoming. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate why the trade makes sense defensively, why the upside is real despite two rough seasons, and why the only true risk might be financial.

The conversation turns into a deeper breakdown of David Stearns’ long term vision, the famous “painting” analogy, and whether this lineup is better, worse, or just wildly different after losing Pete Alonso and reshaping the middle of the field. They dive into Robert’s change of scenery potential, the Mets’ desperate need for a real center fielder, and how bad last year’s production truly was at that spot.

Plus, the ripple effect on the Cody Bellinger sweepstakes, why the Mets likely have a short term offer out, and why Yankees fans may feel more confident as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The big question remains: when you squint at this roster, is the picture starting to come together or does it still feel unfinished?

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected