We’re Not All Like This

The Pitt Panthers Nov 21, 2024

Pitt Football has staked a claim to nine national championships and can point to ten alumni in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. The Panthers also have complicated relationships with two teams not in their conference, an NFL stadium that they call home, the number one volleyball team in the nation, and a whole host of anxieties. We discuss all of that with guests James Santelli, Jonny Gamble, and Obnoxious Pitt Girl (her name, not ours).
We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Texas A&M Aggies Nov 14, 2024

College football is a weird sport, and Texas A&M might be the weirdest school in it. We sat down with Kacie Rowlette, Jay Arnold, and the elusive String to talk about traditions, expectations, the meaning of the Texas rivalry, and what the world will look like only if the Aggies manage to avoid further stumbles this season.

We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The James Madison Dukes Nov 07, 2024

JMU Football made a big splash upon entering the FBS ranks in 2022, going 19-5 in their first two years (while not being allowed to play for the Sun Belt title). Then, head coach Curt Cignetti and several top players left for Indiana - where things have also gone pretty splendidly. So what does all this mean for fans of the Dukes? Amidst all this success, what have been the moments of JMU struggle? And which women's program gets the most attention at a school that had women's sports before men's? Listen as Jessica Black, Rob Abbott, and Stephen Hartzell walk us through the JMU experience.
We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The UCF Knights Oct 31, 2024

Like the USF cousin it doesn't really want to visit anymore, UCF is a young school and an even younger athletic department. We talked to Jeremy Taché, Eric Thompson and Christian Simmons to learn more about what the Knights want out of the Big 3 schools in Florida, the pros and cons of the move to the Big 12, what the 2017 season means today for the fanbase, and how softball is setting an interesting new standard.
We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 24, 2024

In the last fifty full seasons of Ohio State football, the Buckeyes have won nearly 80% of their games, and they've had 22 years where they either went undefeated in Big Ten play or only lost one game. But the life of an Ohio State fan is not stress free, and we have Ramzy Nasrallah, Ben Teaford, and Matt Brown explain the significance of the Michigan rivalry, what to make of the school's prominent costumed fans, and the Ohio-ness of being a Buckeye.
We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Virginia Tech Hokies Oct 17, 2024

Virginia Tech's fans have some good things going for them - a beautiful stadium that's always energetic, a women's basketball team that recently made a deep tournament run, an in-state rivalry that they dominate in football, and a legendary coach who's still a big part of the program. They also have some challenges to deal with, like the actual football results, the coach and two key players leaving the women's team, and the "what even is the ACC" thing. I talked to Pete Bertheaud, Mark Umansky, and Andy Bitter about the experience of rooting for the Hokies to find out more (and get some turkey leg tips).

We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Louisiana State Tigers Oct 10, 2024

Outstanding tailgates. Beleaguered football coaches. The whole thing with Nick Saban and Alabama. Success in baseball and plenty of other sports. Hurricane fights with Florida. The life of an LSU fan is full of twists and turns, all of which we discuss with Kennedi Landry, Warren Ables, and Zach Rau.
We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The South Florida Bulls Oct 03, 2024

On the geologic time scale of college athletics, USF is very young. Founded in 1956, the school didn't have any sports teams until 1965, and the Bulls didn't field a football team until 1997. But despite their youth, USF fans have experienced a lot of the same ups and downs as supporters of the old bluebloods: roller coaster seasons, a contentious rivalry, conference realignment, and the ever-constant battle over expectations.
Thanks to Nathan Bond, Anthony Vito, and Collin Sherwin for joining me on this episode. We're Not All Like this is produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Oklahoma State Cowboys Sep 26, 2024

We sit down with three Oklahoma State fans - Josh Crutchmer, Danny Gilliland, and Carson Cunningham - to learn more about the state of the Bedlam rivalry, the experience of being a Cowboy fan in a Sooner state, their happiest non-Oklahoma memories, which variant of the Pistol Pete logo is best, and more.
This episode was produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 19, 2024

Nebraska's sports teams have occupied several roles in the college sports landscape in the last forty years - dominant juggernauts, mismanaged boondoggles, beacons of hope, and representatives of both the past and future. Being a Huskers fan comes with a lot to juggle, so I talked to Erin Sorensen, Scott Johnson, and Andrew from the HuskGuys Twitter account to understand what fans want from the football team at this point, the love for Husker volleyball, and what the best and hardest parts have been about joining the Big Ten.
This episode was produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Florida State Seminoles Sep 12, 2024

The ACC's longest-standing (and loudest) football power goes under the magnifying glass in this week's episode of We're Not All Like This, as we examine the differences between the FSU-Miami and FSU-Florida rivalries, how FSU fans feel about their conference, what destination they'd pick if they could move the Seminoles anywhere they wanted, and more.

Thanks to Ernest Wilkins, Katie Shook, and Curt Weiler for appearing as guests on this episode, which was produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Georgia Bulldogs Sep 05, 2024

In the first episode of Season 3, we talk to three Dawg fans (one of whom used to play for the football team) about the previous anxiety of rooting for Georgia, which SEC rivalry is most important to maintain in a larger league, how much Hate there currently is in Clean, Old-Fashioned Hate, and whether Mark Richt is the coach most beloved by the fanbase of the school that fired him.

Thanks to Amanda Mull, Tony Waller, and George Foster for joining the show this week. This episode was produced by Michael Surber and sponsored by Homefield Apparel - use offer code LIKETHIS to get 20% off your first order at homefieldapparel.com

The Indiana Hoosiers Jun 03, 2024

For the Season 2 finale of We're Not All Like This, we talked to Galen Clavio, Kyle Robbins, and Homefield Apparel's own Connor Hitchcock about the importance of basketball in Indiana, the struggles of Hoosier football, the dominance of IU men's soccer, and what drives the hatred Indiana fans have for Kentucky.

Be sure to check out the special We're Not All Like This selections on Homefield Apparel and use code LIKETHIS to get 20% off any item in that group.

The Syracuse Orange May 28, 2024

Syracuse fans have seen a lot in the last 30 years: a national title in men's basketball with Carmelo Anthony, a string of championships in lacrosse followed by something of a drought, and Donovan McNabb high-fiving a mom after a victory. (We'll explain that one at the end.) We talked to Sean Keeley, Ryan McDonnell, and Jeff Parrotte about the ups and downs of the Jim Boeheim era, how Cuse fans feel about the move to the ACC, and whether the Orange really are New York City's College Team.

Be sure to check out the special We're Not All Like This selections on Homefield Apparel and use code LIKETHIS to get 20% off any item in that group.

The Kansas Jayhawks May 20, 2024

Mike Vernon, Sarah Kelly, and Alex Drude sit down with me to talk about what Kansas fans think about the post Texas/OU Big 12, the low point of Jayhawk football bottoming out, and the differences between the Kansas State and Mizzou rivalries.