Watch It or Read It

On Swift Horses (Shannon Pufahl) Jun 10, 2025

This was an unexpected one. The ladies had the rare opportunity to see a screener of On Swift Horses before it hit theaters AND were so moved, they immediately picked up the novel. What they found was a quietly powerful story about hidden desires, queerness, aching isolation, and the pursuit of freedom. They break down the breathtaking adaptation—moody, magnetic, and charged with longing and how it both mirrors and deepens Shannon Pufahl’s stunning prose. And if you stick around to the end, you’ll get to hear from Shannon herself. Yep—they got to interview her, and she was absolutely incredible. Thoughtful, generous, and just as brilliant as her writing. You don’t want to miss this one.

Outlander (Diana Gabaldon) Jun 03, 2025

Season Four is here! AND we’re starting with a swoon worthy BANG! Amanda and Dayelle are heading through the stones to 18th Century Scotland with the one and only Outlander, written by Diana Gabaldon. Let’s be real...this episode is 50% book talk, 50% Jamie Fraser thirst. The chemistry between Claire and Jamie? Off the charts. The adaptation? Practically perfect. The kilts? Always welcome. Whether you’re Team Book, Team Show, or just Team "Let’s Gush About Jamie," this is the episode to kick off your next obsession. AND of course should you Watch it or Read it? OR BOTH.

Long Bright River (Liz Moore) Apr 01, 2025

Amanda and Dayelle are diving into Long Bright River by Liz Moore. This one took us on a ride we weren’t expecting. A gripping mix of crime thriller, family drama, and emotional depth, this book had us hooked from page one. And just when we thought we had our opinions locked in, the new screen adaptation dropped on Peacock, shaking things up even more. Did it do the novel justice? Were the characters as compelling on screen as they were on the page? And most importantly should you watch it or read it?

Oh, and we were supposed to interview Liz Moore herself… but let’s just say, plans took an unexpected turn. We’ll spill all the details in the episode!

New Moon Mar 25, 2025

This week, Amanda and Dayelle are heading back to Forks, Washington, where the rain never stops, vampires sparkle, and werewolves have the best hair game in town. That’s right—they’re diving into The Twilight Saga: New Moon by Stephenie Meyer!

From Bella’s heartbreak and Edward’s dramatic exit to Jacob’s luscious locks. Amanda and Dayelle will compare the book to its movie adaptation, explore what worked (and what didn’t), and, of course, tackle the ultimate question: Should you watch it or read it?

So grab your Team Edward or Team Jacob merch, settle in with a cozy drink, and join Amanda and Dayelle as they revisit the world of New Moon!

Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. Mar 18, 2025

This week Amanda and Dayelle are throwing it back to their awkward tween years as they revisit Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret by Judy Blume.

From "Grow with Me" bras to figuring out who you are, they’re spilling all the tea on Margaret’s relatable journey through girlhood. Plus, they’ll dish on how the recent movie adaptation stacks up against the beloved book—what made them laugh, what made them cry and of course they’ll settle the big question: Should you Watch it or Read it?

Bridget Jones's Diary Mar 11, 2025

This week, Amanda and Dayelle are diving into the world of wine-soaked journals, awkward encounters, and every Pride & Prejudice easter egg. If you guessed Bridget Jones's Diary by Helen Fielding, you're spot on!

Join them as they break down the beloved book and its iconic movie adaptation. From Bridget’s judgy inner monologue to the unforgettable love triangle with Mark Darcy and Daniel Cleaver, Amanda and Dayelle chat about everything they loved—and what didn’t quite hit. And of course, they’ll tackle the age-old question: Should you watch it or read it?

Bonus: What We're Reading Mar 04, 2025

This week Amanda and Dayelle dive into what they are currently reading, what's on their TBR's and a whole lot of book gossip! Including a quick mention of a certain author, her book to movie adaptation thats been getting a lot of attention. Some Onyx Storm recapping (no spoilers don't worry) AND catch up on all things book related.

Daisy Jones & the Six Feb 25, 2025

Amanda and Dayelle dive into Taylor Jenkins Reid’s bestselling novel and its TV adaptation, Daisy Jones & The Six. Amanda had to put some pressure on Dayelle to read this one. AND after some major arm twisting (figuratively) Dayelle folded. So in the end did the show capture the magic of the book’s documentary-style storytelling? Is this now one of Dayelle's favorite all time reads? AND should YOU Watch it or Read it? “Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

A Little Princess Feb 18, 2025

Amanda and Dayelle revisit A Little Princess, the beloved childhood classic that made them believe in magic, resilience, and the power of kindness. Whether you grew up with Frances Hodgson Burnett’s timeless novel or the breathtaking 1995 film adaptation, this story is one that stays in your heart forever. Amanda and Dayelle discuss Sara Crewe’s journey from riches to rags and back again. Gushing over the stunning visuals of the movie, the way it captured the warmth and wonder of storytelling, and the iconic moment that had them both sobbing from the movie (you know the one). Grab some tissues and your inner child, because this one is going to hit you right in the feels AND in the end help you decide whether to Watch it or Read it…“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.

The Secret Garden Feb 11, 2025

Amanda and Dayelle unlock The Secret Garden (AND a lot of tears)—this timeless classic has had several screen adaptations...From a Hallmark love story to a visually magical remake in 2020 starring Colin Firth as little Mary's uncle, to the iconic 1993 adaptation. (Which is both Amanda and Dayelle's favorite) So Watch it or Read it...or BOTH.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Chronicles of Narnia Feb 04, 2025

Come with Amanda and Dayelle as they step through the wardrobe into the magical world of Narnia, with The Loin, The Witch and The Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis. Dayelle shares why she wasn’t super excited to revisit the book, while Amanda reveals why it might just be her all-time favorite. But both equally gush over the movie adaptation and their lust for Aslan. AND of course help YOU decide if you should Watch it or Read it...or both!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

New Year's Special Dec 31, 2024

Happy New Year! Amanda and Dayelle decided to give everyone a little taste of behind the scenes of Watch it or Read it. They dive into upcoming book releases, books slated to be adapted to scene and so much more! Let’s see how many times they bring up Henry Cavill…AND ACOTAR fan casting OR mainly Dayelle hating on the current fan castings.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Little Women Dec 24, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle are sharing their love for Louisa May Alcott's Little Women. From Katharine Hepburn’s iconic Jo to Greta Gerwig’s stunning adaptation, they’re diving into the book and its MANY versions. And are you: a Meg, a Jo, a Beth or an Amy? Whether you read the book now or in the middle of June should you Watch it or Read it? OR BOTH?

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Christmas in Evergreen Dec 17, 2024

Okay let’s set the scene…

A Small Town (Evengreen)
The Big-City Protagonist (A widowed doctor who has a daughter)
The Charming Local (Allie-a young, beautiful town vet)
The Conflict (Allie is leaving Evergreen, The doctor is passing through)
The Festive Event (The Christmas Festival)
Family and Friends (Mom & Dad-own the town diner)
A Sprinkle of Magic (A Magic Snow Globe)
The Montage (Sugar Cookie Decorating Party)
The Climax (Allie is falling for the doctor…her BF shows up)
The Happy Ending (Allie doesn’t move, the doctors stays in Evergreen)

Wrap that all up with a bow, You get a Hallmark Christmas Movie…OR in this case a book and a movie. That’s right Amanda and Dayelle fed their hunger for the perfect Christmas book, Christmas in Evergreen, written by Nancy Naigle. So did Hallmark deliver? Listen to find out if you should Watch it or Read it...OR BOTH.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Miracle on 34th St Dec 10, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle couldn't pass up the opportunity to talk about the timeless Christmas classic that makes you feel all kinds of warm and fuzzy inside, The book written by Valentine Davies, Miracle on 34th Street. Yupe its a book! The ladies are swooning over the heartfelt magic of the book, the nostalgic charm of the original film, and the cozy holiday vibes of the remake. Plus, don’t sleep on the radio special—it’s a hidden gem! So Watch it or Read it? (Not sure Amanda and Dayelle can pick for this one-they LOVE them all)

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

It's a Wonderful Life Dec 03, 2024

It’s beginning to look a lot like...The Greatest Gift! Amanda and Dayelle unwrap the story behind one of the most beloved Christmas movies of all time, It's a Wonderful Life. From George Bailey’s magical journey of hope and redemption to one of their favorite NAMED characters Clarence the Angel earning his wings. This might be the first book to screen adaptation where reading the book, watching the movie, listening to the book AND listening to the radio special is a...you'll have to listen to find out!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Season 3 Trailer Nov 26, 2024

Watch It or Read It Season three is almost here!

Amanda and Dayelle are back with brand new episodes coming out every Tuesday, beginning December 3rd.

Starting the season with your favorite holiday stories – It’s a Wonderful Life, Little Women, The Chronicles of Narnia, and more!

Join them as they dive deep into more classic books and their screen adaptations, helping you decide – Watch it or Read it? See you on December 3rd!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

A Discovery of Witches Oct 29, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle are wrapping up their Season of Witches AND Season Two with the captivating book, A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness! Amanda loved the book—it’s incredible—but felt the series adaptation fell short especially with the casting. *COUGH*Diana's lack of showing any emotions*COUGH* While Dayelle agrees the book was incredible, she watched the series first so it's hard for her to hate on the casting. So, in the end—Watch it or Read it OR BOTH?!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Escape to Witch Mountain Oct 22, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda continue their Season of Witches with a slight twist. This week it’s all about Escape to Witch Mountain by Alexander Key. So...no witches. BUT Tia and Tony do have powers and the word witch is in the title. Also Amanda couldn't talk about this book without talking about her favorite character, Winkie the black cat. Specifically the 1975 movie adaptation version of Winkie. (The ladies are pretty sure it's the same cat from Sabrina the Teenage Witch)

So, grab your hot cocoa (with a splash of bourbon cream for the adults) and join them as they revisit this Sci Fi classic and decide, Watch it or Read it...OR both.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Witches Oct 15, 2024

The witchy vibes continue on Watch it or Read it! In this episode, Amanda and Dayelle take a fun trip down memory lane as they revisit The Witches by Roald Dahl, a book both read in elementary school. "In fairy-tales, witches always wear silly black hats... but this is not a fairy-tale. This is about real witches." The original movie adaptation was downright terrifying especially as a kid watching it, while the remake starring Anne Hathaway was a fun twist. So should you watch it, read it, or maybe even both!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Practical Magic Oct 08, 2024

It's the season of Witches on Watch it or Read it! Join Amanda and Dayelle as they gush over the cult classic Practical Magic—an ode to the beginning of fall and all things magical. Yes, it's a book too! Was it worth the read, or should you stick to the screen? Should you watch it, read it, or maybe even both! And yes, they're making midnight margaritas!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

My Lady Jane Aug 27, 2024

"My Lady Jane" (2024) is a lesser-known historical fantasy romance series on Amazon Prime Video, based on the book by Jodi Meadows, Brodi Ashton, and Cynthia Hand. Starring Emily Bader as Lady Jane Grey, the show features an all-star cast including Edward Bluemel and Anna Chancellor. It's a satirical comedy set in an alternate 16th-century England, where Lady Jane Grey, pressured to marry Lord Guildford Dudley, navigates a world with shape-shifting Ethians and ordinary humans. Dayelle and Amanda discuss whether to watch it, read it, or both.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Gone Girl Aug 20, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle explore a genre they haven't tackled on the show before, thrillers. Kicking things off with a bang by discussing Gillian Flynn's gripping novel, Gone Girl. This book has been a hot topic since it hit shelves, and it's no wonder why. The story is a rollercoaster ride that keeps you guessing at every turn.

The intrigue doesn't stop at the page, as the story made its way to the silver screen in 2014 with a film adaptation starring Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike. Dayelle and Amanda found themselves completely engrossed by both mediums, unable to put the book down or peel their eyes away from the movie.

Throughout the episode, they discuss the edge-of-your-seat experience provided by Gone Girl and how it translates from the written word to visual storytelling. In the end, they weigh in on the ultimate question for their listeners: Should you Watch it or Read it? Or a thrilling combination of both!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

To All The Boys I've Loved Before Aug 13, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle dive into Jenny Han's romance novel "To All The Boys I've Loved Before." Fans might recognize Han from her other hit series turned Netflix show, "The Summer I Turned Pretty." Despite wondering if they were a bit too old for this teen romcom, both hosts couldn't help but fall for its charm. They were especially fond of the main character, Lara Jean, and the engaging style of Han's writing. So, should you watch the movies or read the book? Or maybe both? Find out what Amanda and Dayelle recommend.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Emma Aug 06, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle tackle Jane Austen's beloved novel, Emma! For Dayelle, it's her number one favorite, while for Amanda, it's a very close second. These Austen aficionados dive headfirst into the charming world of Emma Woodhouse, celebrating the wit, humor, and heart that make this novel a timeless classic.

Amanda and Dayelle explore the many adaptations of Emma, including the iconic '90s film Clueless, which cleverly spins the original storyline into a modern high school setting. They also gush over their favorite adaptation, the BBC's 2009 Emma mini-series, which brings Austen's characters to life with exquisite detail. And let's not forget the 2020 remake, a fun and colorful take on the classic story that adds a fresh twist to the familiar tale.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Bridge to Terabithia Jul 30, 2024

Join Amanda and Dayelle as they dive into the childhood classic, Bridge to Terabithia. Amanda, who first read this book because it was a school assignment, shares her enduring love for the story that has stayed with her ever since. Dayelle, experiencing the book for the first time in preparation for this episode, offers fresh insights into the beautifully crafted narrative and its poignant themes.

Prepare for an emotional journey as both hosts struggle to get through sentences without tears, reflecting on the heartfelt connections and the profound impact of this story. Whether you're revisiting this classic or discovering it for the first time, Amanda and Dayelle's discussion will deepen your appreciation for the magic and reality woven into Bridge to Terabithia. Be part of a conversation that celebrates the power of storytelling to touch our hearts and change our lives. And of course answer the question Watch it or Read it...OR Both.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

A Walk to Remember Jul 23, 2024

Join Amanda and Dayelle on a nostalgic journey as they revisit Nicholas Sparks' classic, A Walk to Remember. They discuss the beloved book and its heartfelt movie adaptation, sharing what they loved (and didn’t love) about both. AND answering the question Watch it or Read it or BOTH.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Me Before You Jul 16, 2024

Join Amanda and Dayelle as they chat about the beloved story of Me Before You by JoJo Moyes. This touching tale, brought to life on screen by the enchanting Emilia Clarke and the charismatic Sam Claflin, has left a lasting impression on both of them. They discuss the tender nuances of the book and the moving performances in the film. Amanda and Dayelle invite you to experience the magic of Me Before You with them. AND answer the question Watch it or Read it, or Both? Grab your tissues, settle in, and let them guide you through the emotional journey of this unforgettable story.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Tuck Everlasting Jul 09, 2024

Join Amanda and Dayelle as they gush over the beloved book "Tuck Everlasting" and its charming 2002 movie adaptation. Dayelle shares why this book holds a special place in her heart, while both hosts can't help but swoon over actor, Jonathan Jackson as Jesse Tuck in the movie. This beautiful coming-of-age story leaves them asking the question should you Watch it or Read it OR perhaps both?

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Idea of You Jul 02, 2024

We all love a good rom-com! Anne Hathaway and Nicholas Galitzine star in the 2024 Netflix adaptation of "The Idea of You" by Robinne Lee. This contemporary romance follows 39-year-old art gallery owner Solène Marchand as she unexpectedly falls for 20-year-old Hayes Campbell, a member of the world's hottest boy band. Their passionate romance, set against glamorous backdrops and public scrutiny, challenges Solène to juggle her private life, motherhood, and societal judgments. With themes of love, desire, fame, and sacrifice, the real question is: should you watch it or read it?

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Bridgerton Part 3 Jun 25, 2024

Dearest listeners,

It would seem that our gracious hosts, Amanda and Dayelle, have returned for a second season. The subject of today's discourse? The third season of Netflix's most watched series on record, Bridgerton!

This season draws its inspiration from Julia Quinn's 2002 novel, “Romancing Mister Bridgerton,” which delves into the romance of Colin and Penelope. The beloved character Penelope Featherington, portrayed by the enchanting Nicola Coughlan, graces us with her presence in an alluring carriage scene.

What, pray tell, are the significant deviations between the book series and this third season? Ah, dear listeners, you must continue your attentions to uncover these revelations.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Bridgerton Part 2 May 14, 2024

Dearest readers, it appears that two most delightful ladies, Amanda and Dayelle, have taken to the airwaves to discuss matters that we Bridgertonians hold dear to our hearts. Their topic of discourse? None other than the tumultuous, heart-fluttering, and scandalously delicious tale from "The Viscount Who Loved Me," the second book in the Bridgerton series, and its dazzling adaptation for television.

Prepare yourselves for an episode that is sure to keep you entertained, informed, and perhaps even longing for a ballroom dance of your own. Amanda and Dayelle have woven a delightful tapestry of commentary, wit, and, yes, a touch of scandal that will make you wish you had an invitation to the next grand Bridgerton ball. Do tune in, for this is one episode that promises to be the talk of the ton.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Bridgerton Part 1 May 07, 2024

Dearest readers, gather round, for I, Lady Whistledown, have quite the treat for you. In this most tantalizing episode of "Watch it or Read it," our hostesses, Amanda and Dayelle, take to the microphones to discuss that which has set all of London aflutter: the first book in the Bridgerton series, The Duke and I, and its illustrious Netflix adaptation. Oh, the scandal, the intrigue, the romance!

Fear not, gentle listeners, for these two will leave no stone unturned. With keen insight and no shortage of cheeky gossip, Amanda and Dayelle delve into the liberties the adaptation takes—dare I say, even more daring than Lady Featherington's wardrobe. They ponder the age-old question: Is it better to follow the book's storyline to the letter or to embellish for our viewing pleasure? The answer, like a well-played game of Pall Mall, is not as straightforward as it seems.

So, prepare your teacups and settle in for a most captivating discussion. Will Amanda and Dayelle find common ground on which version reigns supreme, or will their opinions clash like dueling Viscounts at dawn? You, dear reader, will have to listen to find out. But rest assured, wherever they lead, scandal is sure to follow. Yours truly, Lady Whistledown.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

One Day Apr 30, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle (tissue boxes in hand) travel to England on July 15th, 1988. They are introduced to Dex and Emma. A story unfolds on the same day for 20 years. If you haven't guessed it yet...They are talking about One Day written by David Nicholls. A story that isn't new to the film world, the first adaptation was released in 2011--starring Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess. But most recently Netflix took a swing at in.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Princess Diaries Apr 23, 2024

Amanda and Dayelle join Mia Thermopolis, a five-foot-nine, flat-chested freshman, who also happens to be flunking Algebra on the biggest adventure of her life. They also delve into some of the biggest differences between the book and movie adaptation.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Cinderella Apr 16, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda revisit the classic fairytale Cinderella by The Brothers Grimm. They gush over their favorite Cinderella adaptation, Ever After. The 1998 movie starring Drew Barrymore. To them it's the only retelling you need to see.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Damsel Apr 09, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda discuss the flaws in the "Damsel" film adaptation compared to the book, noting shallow characters and missed emotional depth while appreciating its world-building.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Jane Eyre Apr 02, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda analyze the timeless themes of love and resilience in "Jane Eyre," exploring character dynamics, mental health portrayals, and societal themes in the novel and its adaptations.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Percy Jackson and the Olympians Mar 26, 2024

Diving into Percy Jackson's world with Amanda and Dayelle, discussing mythology, millennial appeal, adaptations, and themes of identity and representation. Celebrating the timeless storytelling and magic of the series.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Hunger Games Mar 19, 2024

Dayelle and guest discuss "The Hunger Games," exploring characters, themes, adaptations, and emotional depth in books and movies. They analyze the series' enduring storytelling and intricate relationships.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

The Notebook Mar 12, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda compare "The Notebook" book to movie, analyzing character dynamics, relationships, and themes of sacrifice and enduring love. They discuss criticisms and the story's timeless appeal.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Peter Pan Mar 05, 2024

This week, Amanda and Dayelle set off towards the second star to the right, and straight on till morning. From the original book to the many film adaptations and interpretations, it's a look at the J.M. Barrie classic, Peter Pan.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Lessons in Chemistry Feb 27, 2024

This week, Amanda and Dayelle go back in time to the 1960s and get some lessons in chemistry with... Lessons In Chemistry.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Twilight Feb 19, 2024

Dayelle and Amanda head to Forks, Washington to meet Vampires, Werewolves, and Stephenie Meyer as they dive into The Twilight Saga. Is the movie good or so bad it's good? And, of course, should you Watch It or Read It?

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Pride & Prejudice Feb 12, 2024

On the premiere episode of Watch It Or Read It, Amanda and Dayelle dive into the Jane Austen classic and compare the book to the two most notable adaptations - the BBC mini-series and the 2005 film. What's your favorite parts and what was changed for the film?

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Season 1 Trailer Feb 05, 2024

Join Amanda and Dayelle as they dive into one of their favorite books turned movie or TV series while sipping on themed cocktails. They'll debate the age-old question: is it better to watch it, read it, or maybe even do both? Grab a drink, join the fun, and let the lively discussions begin!

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected