True Crime

Til TRUTH Do US Part: An All Things Murky, Murderous & Mysterious Podcast

Til Truth Do Us Part is a true crime, unexplained mysteries & dark history podcast from Motive and Magnolia Productions, hosted by husband-and-wife team Shawna and David. Together, we explore cold cases, disappearances, suspicious deaths, criminal investigations, and solved murders that continue to raise questions and all things that make you go “HUH?” WALK THE PATH OF ALL THINGS THAT GO BUMP IN THE NIGHT WITH US!
Leave your message here:
https://www.speakpipe.com/Tiltruthdouspart

https://buymeacoffee.com/motiveandm3

Latest Episodes:

The Things That GO BUMP In The Middle Of The NIGHT! 🧡🎃 Oct 31, 2026

Show notes

A Halloween Special! !🎃🎃🎃🧡💜🧡💜🍬🍬🍭🍭

Til TRUTH Do Us Part — Where love, lies, and murder collide.

This Halloween, we're opening the doors to a different kind of counseling session!

Join Shawna and David for a special Halloween anthology packed with all things spooky, creepy, chilling, and spectacular! We're digging into the strange, the unsettling, the downright bizarre, and the stories that make you wonder what the hell is lurking in the dark.

From things that go bump in the night to tales that'll make you think twice before turning off the lights, we're bringing you a Halloween celebration with our signature blend of storytelling, twisted humor, and married-couple chaos.

So grab your favorite Halloween snacks, turn down the lights, and settle in. This session is going to get spooky!

AND WE'RE JUST GETTING STARTED!

Halloween is only the beginning of our HOLIDAY SESSIONS! Join us for the rest of our special holiday bonus episodes as we celebrate Thanksgiving, Black Friday, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, New Year's Eve, and New Year's Day.

Seven holidays. Seven special sessions. More stories, more laughs, and more reasons to spend the holidays with us!

Because around here, the holidays are anything but ordinary.

Til TRUTH Do Us Part

We're not doing True Crime the way everyone else does.

Forgotten Files: Lizzie Borden - The Girl Who Took An Axe Oct 31, 2026

Show notes

On a brutally hot morning - August 4th, 1892 - in Fall River, Massachusetts, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered with an axe in their own home. The only person home was Andrew's 32-year-old daughter, Lizzie.

No forced entry. No stolen money. Just a broken axe handle, a dress burned days later, and a nursery rhyme that would haunt America for over a century: " Lizzie Borden took an axe..."

In this Forgotten File, we reopen the house at 92 Second Street. We walk through the 90 minutes that left two people dead, the investigation that fixated on the youngest daughter from the start, and the 1893 trial that shocked the nation when an all-male jury found her not guilty in just 90 minutes.

We dig into the evidence they didn't want you to forget - the inquest testimony, the infamous handleless hatchet, and why Lizzie lived the rest of her life as Fall River's most infamous outcast.

Was Lizzie a cold-blooded killer who got away with murder, or was she the victim of a rush to judgment, small-town gossip, and Victorian-era sensationalism?

https://www.speakpipe.com/Tiltruthdouspart

https://buymeacoffee.com/motiveandm3

The Green Bay Horror: Taylor Schabusiness Oct 30, 2026

Show notes

CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains descriptions of murder, drug use, sexual violence, dismemberment, and graphic details. Listener discretion is strongly advised.

Sources For this Episode Are Law & Crime Network, The Washington Post, Reuters.com and Courttv.com

In February 2022, police in Green Bay, Wisconsin responded to a mother's worst nightmare. Inside her basement, they found the severed head and remains of her son, 25-year-old Shad Thyrion.

The last person seen with him was 24-year-old Taylor Schabusiness.

What started as a case involving meth and a casual encounter quickly became one of the most disturbing murder cases Wisconsin had ever seen. Investigators say Schabusiness strangled Thyrion during sex, then dismembered his body - and was found with evidence of the crime still on her.

In this episode we break down:

• Who were Shad Thyrion and Taylor Schabusiness? • What happened inside that house on Biemeret Street • The 911 call and discovery that led police to her • Her disturbing behavior in interrogation and in court • The competency battles - was she high, psychotic, or fully aware? • The trial, the verdict, and why a judge sentenced her to life without parole

This is not just a story about a brutal crime. It's about addiction, the mental health system, and how a small Midwestern community was left to make sense of something senseless.

What do you think - evil, insane, or both?

Discover The Amazing Sandy Marchant @

https://www.tiktok.com/@sandymarchant?_r=1&_t=ZP-9AxV5JJDXh8

https://www.facebook.com/share/1CrWqR8zHQ/

Leave us A Voicemail At

https://www.speakpipe.com/Tiltruthdousparthttps://www.speakpipe.com/Tiltruthdouspart

Help Support us To keep The True Crime Coming at

https://buymeacoffee.com/motiveandm3

TACKY TUESDAYS: HALLOWEEN EDITION - ALL THE FREAKS COME OUT DURING HALLOWEEN Oct 29, 2026

Show notes

Oh, it's TACKY. It's TUESDAY. It's HALLOWEEN. What could possibly go wrong?

Luckily, your favorite Delightfully Diabolical Storytelling Duo is here to walk you through this tackiness like two unlicensed tour guides through a haunted Spirit Halloween.

They'll be narrating the chaos, roasting the costumes, and explaining why Karen's DIY "sexy scarecrow" looks like she lost a fight with a hay bale.From tragic wigs to costumes held together by hot glue and bad decisions, no tacky choice will go un-noticed or un-judged.

Because remember: ALL THE FREAKS COME OUT DURING HALLOWEEN - and on Tacky Tuesdays, we give them a microphone.

Come tacky, leave famous.

https://buymeacoffee.com/motiveandm3

https://www.speakpipe.com/Tiltruthdouspart

Israel Keyes: The Murders of Samantha Koenig, Bill & Lorraine Currier — Evil Hiding in Plain Sight Oct 22, 2026

Show notes

WARNING: This episode discusses abduction and murder, and contains disturbing details about the murders of Samantha Koenig, Bill and Lorraine Currier. Listener discretion is advised.

He had no type. No pattern. No home base. And kill kits buried across America, waiting.

Tonight, Shawna and David take on one of the most terrifying serial killers in modern history — Israel Keyes.

But this isn't about him. This is about them.

【entity-Samantha Koenig — 18 years old, Anchorage, Alaska. Taken from the Common Grounds coffee stand where she worked, a kid just trying to get through her shift.

Bill and Lorraine Currier — Essex, Vermont. A married couple of 24 years. Taken from their own home in the middle of the night. The place that was supposed to be safe.

Three people who did nothing wrong. And one man who planned everything.

This case hit us different.

For the first time on Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna and David start getting personal. We talk honestly — as a married couple — about what it does to a marriage to hear how Bill and Lorraine were taken together, about how we would protect each other, about the fear of being that vulnerable in your own home, and about why we're focusing on the victims. There's more honest marital discussion in this episode than we've ever shared before.

This is our most personal episode yet. And also our darkest.

We walk through:

• What Keyes did and how he hid in plain sight for years

• How Samantha Koenig's case cracked Anchorage

• The night the Curriers were taken from their Vermont home

• The investigation that finally stopped a cross-country killer

• And the questions that still keep investigators up at night about how many more victims there are

Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction — and sometimes evil really does hide in plain sight.

If you have information about other potential victims of Israel Keyes, please contact the FBI.

Was this tragic, or terrifying? Tell us in the comments, Truth Seekers.

Til TRUTH Do Us Part — An All Things Murky, Murderous & Mysterious Podcast

Because True Crime is cheaper than marriage counseling!👀💜🎙💯

Visit Our Amazing Sandy Marchant Online !

https://www.tiktok.com/@sandymarchant?_r=1&_t=ZP-9AxV5JJDXh8

https://www.facebook.com/share/1CrWqR8zHQ/

New Episodes: Tacky Tuesdays every other Tuesday, Main Cases Thursdays, Forgotten Files every other Saturday

#IsraelKeyes #SamanthaKoenig #BillAndLorraineCurrier #TrueCrime #SerialKiller #Anchorage #Vermont #TilTruthDoUsPart

The Forgotten Files: 1916 Molokai Murder - The Disappearance of Wong Waiboud at Keawanui Bay Oct 17, 2026

Show notes

The Forgotten Files: The Man Who Vanished into Keawanui Bay

1916 Wong Waiboud Case: Murder Without a Body at Keawanui Bay, Molokai

A missing man. A fishpond dispute. Three murder convictions. And no body ever found.

In 1916, Wong Waiboud vanished on Molokaʻi, Hawaiʻi. Missing belongings, a heavy coral stone, and freshly cut rope became part of a case that ended with three men convicted of second-degree murder. But what did the evidence really prove — and what questions remain unanswered?

Join Shawna and David as they uncover this forgotten historical case and explore the fine line between suspicion, evidence, and the truth.

🎧 Listen now on Spotify! Follow the show, leave a rating and review, and share this episode with a fellow Truth Seeker.

Because every forgotten case has a story — and every victim deserves to be remembered.

💍 True crime… is… cheaper than marriage counseling.

#TheForgottenFiles #TilTruthDoUsPart #TrueCrimePodcast

Christa Pike: Timeline, Facts & The Death Penalty Question Oct 15, 2026

Show notes

Christa Pike: The Facts Behind the Case

Truth Seekers, this one is going to feel a little different.

The Christa Pike case sparks strong reactions and a lot of strong opinions. Because it's such a hot topic, we made a conscious decision to approach it differently this time - no hot takes, no banter, no personal opinions.

In this episode we focus on what can be established: the facts, the timeline, the court proceedings, and why this case became one of Tennessee's most talked-about death penalty cases. Christa Pike remains on death row, so we also break down where the case standsThat means you'll hear a little less of our usual commentary, and a lot more of the details speaking for themselves. We know the banter is part of why you love the show - and we promise, we haven't lost our personalities! We're just letting the truth do the talking on this one.

Listen closely, consider the facts, and draw your own conclusions.

Content Note: This episode discusses a violent crime involving teenagers and includes discussion of 911 calls. Please listen with care.

Til TRUTH Do Us Part — because true crime is cheaper than marriage counseling.

Visit Our Amazing Sandy Marchant Online

https://www.tiktok.com/@sandymarchant?_r=1&_t=ZP-9AxV5JJDXh8

https://www.facebook.com/share/1CrWqR8zHQ/

Tacky Tuesdays: 3 Ridiculous Arrests & Afroman's Lemon Pound Cake Free Speech Case Oct 13, 2026

Show notes

🚨 TACKY TUESDAYS: THE GRINCH, RONALD MCDONALD & THE LEMON POUND CAKE LAWSUIT! 🍋😂

💍 Emergency Session is IN!

Truth Seekers, some people wake up and choose chaos. Others put on a Grinch costume, get into trouble at Christmas events, or find themselves in a situation involving a Subway sandwich and a police officer! 🍔🚔

This week, Shawna and David are opening THREE ridiculous arrest files and ONE unbelievable legal battle that prove real life is sometimes stranger than fiction.

🎄 FILE #1: THE GRINCH GOT CAUGHT!

Apparently, someone decided to bring a little too much holiday mischief to Christmas events. But when the Grinch's antics land him in trouble with the law, even Whoville might need a lawyer!

🍟 FILE #2: RONALD MCDONALD'S BAD DAY!

Things get messy when an arrest story involves a Ronald McDonald costume and a Subway sandwich allegedly flying straight into a police officer's face. That's one fast-food feud nobody ordered!

🍋 FILE #3: THE LEMON POUND CAKE LAWSUIT!

Rapper Afroman turned a police raid at his home into music, videos, and a very public legal showdown. When several deputies sued him over his satirical content, the case became a major conversation about free speech. And the lemon pound cake? It became part of the story nobody could forget!

😂 Three outrageous arrests.

⚖️ One unbelievable case.

💜 Shawna's Marriage Survival Ratings.

🎙️ David's sarcasm and final verdict.

Join your favorite delightfully diabolical storytelling duo for another Tacky Tuesdays Emergency Session packed with ridiculous headlines, questionable decisions, and enough chaos to make anyone reconsider their life choices!

💍 Because TRUE CRIME IS CHEAPER THAN MARRIAGE COUNSELING!

🎧 Follow Til TRUTH Do Us Part on 【entity-Spotify¦canonical_name=Spotify】, share the episode, and join our Truth Seekers community!

💜 Where love, lies, and murder collide.

#TackyTuesdays #TilTruthDoUsPart #TrueCrimePodcast #WeirdCrime #TrueCrimeComedy #MarriageCounselingUniverse #Afroman #WeirdNews

Til Truth Do Us Part | I Am Jane Doe — Cornell University, Consent, and Accountability Oct 08, 2026

Show notes

JANE DOE: I AM JANE DOE

I AM JANE DOE

Seven hours. Seven men. One woman. One night.

And nearly two years later… she’s still fighting to be heard.

In this powerful episode of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, we examine the case of Cornell University student Jane Doe, who alleges that she was sexually assaulted by multiple men at a Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.

We take a deeper look at Jane Doe’s account, the investigation that followed, Cornell’s handling of the allegations, questions surrounding consent and intoxication, the civil lawsuit, and the controversy surrounding what Jane Doe was told about the status of the criminal investigation.

We also examine major developments in 2026, including the reopening of the criminal investigation, the appointment of New York Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor, and former U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates’ independent review of Cornell’s handling of sexual misconduct complaints.

And then we hear the words that became a rallying cry:

I AM JANE DOE.

This isn't about handing down a verdict.

It's about asking questions.

It's about accountability.

It's about what happens when someone says they weren't heard — and refuses to stop speaking.

Welcome to another session inside the Marriage Counseling Universe, where we examine the cases everyone is talking about from a different perspective.

Because True Crime… is… cheaper than marriage counseling.

⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: This episode discusses alleged sexual assault, intoxication, trauma, and violence. Listener discretion is advised.

SOURCES

Associated Press (AP)

CBS News

New York State Attorney General’s Office

Cornell University Student Assembly

ABC News

The Washington Post

Note: The allegations discussed in this episode are allegations and have not been proven in criminal court. The investigation and related legal proceedings remain ongoing.

Visit Our Amazing Sandy Marchant Online!

https://www.tiktok.com/@sandymarchant?_r=1&_t=ZP-9AxV5JJDXh8

https://www.facebook.com/share/1CrWqR8zHQ/

Forgotten Files: 1906 Grace Brown & Chester Gillette - Big Moose Lake Murder Oct 03, 2026

Show notes

THE FORGOTTEN FILES

1906 New York

Grace Brown's murder at Big Moose Lake, New York - killed by Chester Gillette in a case that shocked America and inspired Theodore Dreiser's An American Tragedy. One of the most infamous love triangle murders in history.

Some cases disappear into history. Others refuse to stay buried.

In today’s episode of The Forgotten Files, we travel back to a chilling murder case surrounding Big Moose Lake, where a quiet location became the setting for a crime that left investigators searching for answers.

Shawna takes David through the case as he hears the story unfold for the first time — from the discovery that changed everything to the evidence investigators uncovered along the way.

But as the facts begin to emerge, we’ll separate what is documented from what remains speculation, because sometimes the most fascinating part of an old case is what we still don’t know.

So grab a seat, Truth Seekers…

Let’s blow the dust off the files and begin.

Because some stories were never meant to be forgotten.

The Forgotten Files — a Til TRUTH Do Us Part mini-series.

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Til TRUTH Do US Part: An All Things Murky, Murderous & Mysterious Podcast

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected