Sandy Tindale had a shootout with a crooked gambler. When the Lone Ranger brought him back to face the law, no one believed he'd go to jail. However, Banker Pottle, Sandy's rival for the love of his girl, Lenore, was on the jury and made sure Sandy was jailed for two years. Now Sandy has paid his debt and is due back on the next stage, along with $5,000 of Banker Pottle's money. When the stage arrives, there is no Sandy, and no money. Only a fancy silver spur that Sandy had won years ago in a rodeo. The Lone Ranger sets out to find Sandy, to either clear his name, or make him face justice.