The Interview Room

Latest Episodes:

Staged Scenes & Deceptive 911 Calls: A Homicide Expert Reveals All Oct 01, 2026

Show notes

When someone dials 911, we assume they want help. Retired NYPD Lt. Commander Vernon J. Geberth — author of Practical Homicide Investigation, the book detectives still call the bible of death investigation — says that is not always true.In this interview, Geberth explains how some callers stage the phone call itself to cover a crime: they report an accident, or an unknown intruder, when the death was a homicide. He walks through what investigators listen for in that first recording — the official first statement in the case — and how a staged call often lines up with a staged scene.This episode is for the public, not a how-to. It is about why first responders and detectives treat unattended deaths as possible homicides until the facts say otherwise, and why the 911 tape can make or break that investigation.

Nancy Guthrie Case — The Forensic Details You Need To Know Sep 28, 2026

Show notes

🚨 EXCLUSIVE PRESENTATION: NANCY GUTHRIE: WHAT DOES THE CRIME SCENE TELL US?What can a crime scene tell investigators about what happened—and what can it not?In this special edition of The Interview Room, we take a detailed look at the publicly known evidence surrounding the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie and examine the crime scene from a forensic and investigative perspective.Nancy Guthrie was last seen at her Tucson-area home on January 31, 2026. The FBI and Pima County Sheriff's Department have investigated the disappearance as a suspected abduction.🔴 Our merch is here! Check it out here: https://tirmerch.store/

Re-upload from 9/27/2026

Nancy Guthrie: The Timeline They Didn't Want You to See Sep 28, 2026

Show notes

Nancy Guthrie: The Timeline They Didn't Want You to See

Re-upload from 9/25/2026

Forensic Analysis: What Is Actually Happening Inside a Criminal's Mind? Sep 28, 2026

Show notes

Forensic Analysis: What Is Actually Happening Inside a Criminal's Mind?

Re-upload from 9/24/2026

Mica Miller: How Coercive Control Destroys Lives (And What to Look For) Sep 23, 2026

Show notes

Mica Miller - If something in a relationship feels off, that noticing matters. This LIVE session walks through an eight-stage intimate partner violence framework as a lens for earlier recognition—not a diagnosis, not a prediction, and not pressure to act before you are ready.CONTENT NOTEThis video discusses coercive control, stalking, escalation, and intimate partner violence warning signs. Pause, step away, or seek private support anytime. You do not need to disclose anything publicly.

Re-upload from 9/22/2026

Could You Solve This? Law Enforcement Reacts to Crime Scene Evidence Sep 23, 2026

Show notes

Could You Solve This? Law Enforcement Reacts to Crime Scene Evidence...

Nancy Guthrie Case - Why Bloodstain Analysis Isn't Definitive Proof Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Blood doesn’t just leave a stain—it can leave a story.In this episode of The Interview Room, Chris McDonough, Dr. Brucato, and Sgt. Lamb sit down with Karen Elliott of The Cold Case Foundation for an in-depth look at Bloodstain Pattern Analysis (BPA) and how investigators use blood evidence to reconstruct what may have happened inside a crime scene.Karen Elliott Bio: https://www.coldcasefoundation.org/karen-elliott.htmlHow can the shape, size, distribution, and location of bloodstains help investigators understand movement, impact, direction, and sequence of events?And just as importantly—what can bloodstain evidence NOT tell us?Karen breaks down the science behind bloodstain pattern analysis, common misconceptions, crime-scene reconstruction, and the importance of documenting and interpreting blood evidence properly.We’ll explore:• What bloodstain patterns can reveal• Impact patterns and projected blood• Directionality and angles of impact• Cast-off patterns and movement• Passive bloodstains and transfer patterns• How investigators document blood evidence• The role of photography and crime-scene reconstruction• Common mistakes and misconceptions• How blood evidence can support—or challenge—a theory of the case• The limitations of bloodstain pattern analysis• How this evidence can be used in cold-case investigationsThis is a fascinating look at one of the most misunderstood areas of forensic investigation.The Interview Room brings investigators, forensic experts, prosecutors, authors, and other professionals together to examine the evidence and ask the questions that matter.Join Chris McDonough and Karen Elliott for a deep dive into the science behind the stains.
Re-upload from 9/19/2026

The Mysterious Case of Nancy Guthrie: A Family's Secrets Sep 21, 2026

Show notes

Nancy Guthrie vanished from her Tucson home in the early hours of February 1, 2026. Blood on the porch. A masked figure on the doorbell camera. Ransom notes. A $1 million family reward. Months later, she is still missing.The Pima County Sheriff cleared Savannah Guthrie, her siblings, and their spouses. That did not end the questions. It changed them.This episode is not about accusing a family the police already cleared. It is about narrative control. Savannah Guthrie is a network anchor trained to decide when a story goes public. In 2026, the public mostly hears Nancy’s case through family videos, carefully timed statements, and silence in between.Nancy Guthrie was 84. She needed daily medication. She had a pacemaker. She lived a quieter life in Catalina Foothills. In this story, she has no voice of her own.We walk through:• Nancy’s last known hours after dinner with family• Nancy and her career• How a famous daughter’s media discipline shapes what the public is allowed to know• Why “family secrets” and “family cleared” can exist in the same caseIf you have information about Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, contact the FBI at 1-800-CALL-FBI or the Pima County Sheriff’s Department.

Re-upload from 9/20/2026

The Reality of Homicide Investigation: Vernon Geberth's Cold Case Secrets Sep 16, 2026

Show notes

THE GODFATHER OF HOMICIDE — COMMANDER VERNON GEBERTHIn this special episode of The Interview Room, Chris McDonough sits down with legendary NYPD homicide commander Vernon Geberth, one of the most respected names in homicide investigation and crime-scene analysis.Commander Geberth brings decades of experience investigating homicide cases and training detectives in the critical principles of death investigation, crime-scene examination, evidence preservation, and investigative strategy.In this fascinating conversation, we go inside the homicide investigation process and discuss what separates a good investigator from a great one.This is a rare opportunity to hear directly from one of the true legends of homicide investigation.Vernon Geberth has spent decades teaching investigators how to approach homicide investigations with discipline, experience, and attention to detail.Join Chris McDonough and Commander Vernon Geberth for an inside look at homicide investigation.0:00 A Legacy of Homicide Expertise3:40 From Narcotics to the Seventh Zone7:56 Baptism by Fire: Internal Affairs12:28 The Numbers Man Execution16:15 Thwarting a Targeted Hit23:43 Combat Homicide Investigation Tactics30:40 Staged Crime Scenes and 911 Analysis38:55 Quantico and the Birth of Profiling

The Nancy Guthrie Case: Why the Locked Door Doesn't Add Up Sep 14, 2026

Show notes

Nancy Guthrie remains missing. In this fact-focused briefing, we examine the reported condition of the Guthrie home, the overnight timeline, the locked-front-door claim, and the unanswered questions surrounding the case. No suspect is named, and we separate facts from claims and theory.

Re-upload from 9/13/2026

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected