The How To Podcast Series - Podcast Co-Hosts, Practical Podcasting Tips, and Podcast Community

Latest Episodes:

E528 - A New Challenge and Opportunity for Podcasters Starting Out to Get You Through Your First 10 Episodes Dec 26, 2025

Show notes

Episode 528 - A New Challenge and Opportunity for Podcasters Starting Out to Get You Through Your First 10 Episodes

This episode dives into a stark podcasting reality: most new shows stall before episode 10, but host Dave unveils a fresh 2026 program to change that. Drawing from Pod Match stats showing 93.99% of podcasters quit before 100 episodes and 11,740 fade daily after just 46 days on average, Dave spotlights the "single digits trap" where many abandon ship. Only 45% reach episode 8, dropping to 12% at 50 and 2.52% at 300, proving persistence separates survivors from the crowd.

Dave launches a free, limited-spot coaching initiative for 2026 starters, aiming to guide participants to double digits without the grind of 500+ solo episodes. The 12-week framework kicks off with 1-2 intensive sessions on Podcasting 101: artwork, naming, descriptions, and a 10-episode content calendar. Participants then commit to weekly releases (or bi-weekly for overachievers), figuring out voice, format (solo, co-host, interview), and cadence in real time. Dave provides hands-on support—no recording for you, but full guidance on tech, editing shortcuts, and mindset hurdles like imposter syndrome. Post-10, focus shifts to audience building, monetization, and engagement.

Central to the plan is a "soft launch" strategy, flipping guru hype on its head. Record a trailer and episodes 1-10, distribute quietly to all platforms (Apple, Spotify, etc.), then tweak privately: refine audio, artwork, and flow based on family/friend feedback. No big-bang promotion yet—just build confidence and a buffer. Official launch hits when ready (post-episode 2 or 10), timed for your audience with targeted tactics, ensuring sustainability over flashy one-offs. Dave compares it to his pre-COVID store opening: soft-open for testing, then ribbon-cutting with buzz.

He addresses listener pain points—no time for endless episodes?—by offering direct collaboration over pre-recorded courses. Everyone gets community access via free Meetups, but beta participants shape the future paid version (mid-2026) through feedback, even pricing it. A bonus Q&A covers content calendars: anchor with holidays/seasons (e.g., tax time for finance pods), layer mini-series (5-episode deep dives), batch-record reflections after interviews for double episodes in one sit, and fill gaps strategically.

Key takeaway: Beating the 10-episode hurdle demands structure, not solo struggle—pair commitment with guided soft launches and calendars to build momentum quietly, turning stats-defying persistence into a thriving show.

___

Helping Podcasters Everyday!

https://howtopodcast.ca/
We would love to hear from you - here is our listener survey!

https://forms.gle/GbrFv9DGszV8N4PW6

E527 - Merry Christmas Eve, A Christmas Story for Podcasters and Seasons Greetings Dec 24, 2025

Show notes

Episode 527 - Merry Christmas Eve, A Christmas Story for Podcasters and Seasons Greetings

A Christmas Eve Podcast Story

In the snug little town of Jinglejam Junction,

Livd Podcaster McPhee with a voice full of function.

Her booth was a bauble of blankets and foam,

Her microphone shimmering like fresh-chromed chrome.

On Christmas Eve night, with a peppermint grin,

She prepared for her episode: “Let the Yuletide Begin!”

She tapped on her soundboard - boop-bip! - just for flair,

While a garland of cables looped everywhere.

But just as she warmed up her holly-jolly flow,

Her laptop chirped warnings: “Update! Restart!” oh no.

“But not NOW!” she lamented with podcaster pain,

“For I just got my levels to sound less like a train!”

Still, she hit record anyway (as podcasters do),

For episodes must happen, tech tantrums or two.

She launched into stories with cinnamon zest,

About editing all night while refusing to rest.

She rhymed about listeners who email with glee,

Suggesting, politely, “More guests, less of thee.”

She joked that her intro still runs far too long,

And her outro has somehow become a whole song.

Then, CLATTER! CLONK! from the roof came a thunk.

“Is my neighbor again trying rooftop slam-dunk?”

But down through the vent with a grumbly sneeze,

Tumbled Santa himself, smelling faintly of cheese.

“I was checking my list on my Christmas Eve flight,

But your podcast popped up, ‘New Episode Tonight!’

I thought I could help! I’m a longtime fan too!

Though your mic needs a pop filter… maybe one, maybe two.”

He dusted off snowflakes and gave a quick wink,

Then adjusted her tripod, “It’s crooked, I think.”

He tightened her cables, he brightened her screen,

He even fixed hum that had haunted her since Spring.

Before she could speak, he whipped out a sack

And revealed a new gadget - a self-editing track!

“It auto-removes all your stutters and squeaks,

And those weird little gulps you record when you eat.”

She gasped at the gift - “It’s a podcaster’s dream!”

He nodded: “You bet - made by our North Pole Audio Team.”

Then they co-hosted together - what a magical sight,

A Christmas Eve special recorded in one flawless bite.

With a jolly “Ho-ho!” and a mic-drop for flair,

Santa zipped up the vent, disappearing in air.

And McPhee, full of wonder, hit Publish with joy,

A gift to her listeners, each girl and each boy.

Now every year since, on that festive Eve show,

There’s a faint jingle-jangle behind her audio.

Some say it’s a glitch. Some say it’s reverb.

But podcasters whisper, “It’s Santa… superb.”

And so if you’re editing late Christmas Eve,

And your software stops crashing - just suddenly leaves -

You might thank old Saint Nick for his podcaster cheer,

For he helps keep us all sounding crisp every year.

____

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E526 - The Cristina Santiago Podcast, With Guest CO-HOST - Cristina Santiago Dec 22, 2025

Show notes

Episode 526 - The Cristina Santiago Podcast, With Guest CO-HOST - Cristina Santiago

Cristina Santiago is the creator of "Stories by Dessi Kali," a unique AI-driven storytelling podcast that pulls original, imaginative fiction from the shadows, where reality and the supernatural collide. The host of "Stories by Dessi Kali" is an AI-powered podcast host by the name of Dessi Kali, in which, the virtual host broadcasts from her virtual show, "Red Room Radio," unraveling eerie tales pulled from the darkest corners of existence. With Cristina's creative direction and innovative use of artificial intelligence (AI), "Stories by Dessi Kali" stands out as a bold, imaginative, and truly, distinctive storytelling experience.

In this engaging guest interview, podcaster Cristina Santiago joins host Dave to share her vibrant journey through podcasting, from celebrity culture fangirl to true crime enthusiast. Cristina recounts launching her show during Taylor Swift's Reputation era, driven by a passion for defending her favorite artists amid backlash, and how that spark evolved into Red Room Radio—covering music, film, authors, and entertainment—before rebranding to The Cristina Santiago Podcast for a bold shift into true crime mysteries.

Cristina dives into what draws her to true crime: the chilling real-life horror, psychological what-ifs like catfishing best friends turning deadly, and the Scooby-Doo thrill of piecing together motives and clues. She traces her mic love back to mimicking Martin Lawrence as a kid, blending big imagination with lessons from other podcasts on intros, discussions, and flow. Pursuing a PhD in communication fuels her guest interviews, where she uncovers gems like connecting Dave to Niagara Falls via Prince's Vanity 6.

Practical podcast wisdom flows naturally: leverage PodMatch for community and guests, network at events from Drake tours to book fairs, engage in Facebook/Twitter groups even as an introvert, and use tools like SpeakPipe, Buy Me a Coffee, ChatGPT for covers, Eleven Labs for audio, and CapCut/Canva for promos. Monetization shines through Spotify, Patreon, Live365 radio mixes as DJ Roman4Door, and Twitter crypto communities. She prefers audio's traditional vibe but eyes video and YouTube Shorts for Gen Z/Alpha via fresh cases, Arkansas locals, and rising stars.

Top artists like Nicki Minaj, Rihanna, Beyoncé, Sabrina Carpenter, and Taylor Swift highlight her pop culture roots, while mood boards and travel keep inspiration alive. Editing remains a chore, but AI keeps it cost-effective. Future plans include guest breakdowns of cases, unique covers per episode, and Twitter Spaces for interaction.

Key takeaway for listeners
Embrace your passions, pivot boldly like Cristina from entertainment to true crime, network relentlessly in communities and events, and use free/affordable tools to stay inspired and consistent—your unique voice and genuine connections will build audience and open doors in podcasting.

https://storiesbydessikali.wordpress.com/

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/

Dave Throws Down the Podcast Gauntlet - A Bold 24 Hour Challenge Coming This February Dec 19, 2025

Show notes

Dave Throws Down the Podcast Gauntlet - A Bold 24 Hour Challenge Coming This February

In this Daily Dave bonus episode of The How-To Podcast Series, Dave shares an idea that came to him during an overnight shift and quickly refused to let go. Known for working nights and pushing creative limits, Dave wonders what would happen if he fully leaned into that rhythm and turned it into a podcasting experiment unlike anything he has done before.

The concept is simple and extreme at the same time. Dave is seriously considering recording, editing, and publishing 24 complete podcast episodes in 24 consecutive hours. The challenge would begin at 10 a.m. on Friday, February 13, and run straight through until 10 a.m. on Saturday, February 14, with a brand new episode released every single hour. No sleep, minimal breaks, lots of coffee, and total commitment to the process.

This episode is Dave thinking out loud, inviting listeners into the creative chaos as he works through the logistics. He talks about streaming the entire marathon live using Boomcaster, leaving the stream running so listeners can drop in at any hour to see how things are going. From clear-headed teaching moments early on to whatever happens after the twelve hour mark, Dave is open about the fact that it will likely get messy, silly, and very real.

Dave has already outlined 24 episode ideas, many focused on podcasting basics, while others may lean into experimentation and fun. He hints at possible visual elements, maybe even pulling out a guitar to create a custom intro during the marathon. Above all, this challenge is about creativity, endurance, and a genuine love of podcasting.

Listeners are encouraged to share feedback, ideas, name suggestions, and survival tips, or simply to tune in and witness the experiment unfold. Whether you join live or catch the episodes later, the result will be 24 new episodes ready to listen to on your own schedule.

Key Takeaway:
This episode is a reminder that growth in podcasting often comes from bold experiments. You do not need permission to try something ambitious. Sometimes the best ideas start as a wild thought on a night shift and turn into a challenge that pushes both your creativity and your limits.

___

Helping Podcasters Everyday!

https://howtopodcast.ca/
We would love to hear from you - here is our listener survey!

https://forms.gle/GbrFv9DGszV8N4PW6

E525 - The Five Questions Every Podcaster Should Ask Their Listeners Dec 19, 2025

Show notes

Episode 525 - The Five Questions Every Podcaster Should Ask Their Listeners

This episode of the How To Podcast Series finds Dave speaking directly to new and growing podcasters about one core idea: your listeners are your best teachers. From his studio in Ontario, Canada, Dave shares that after more than two thousand episodes across nine shows, one of the most valuable habits he has built is asking his audience a few simple but powerful questions. He introduces the concept of a listener survey and explains how he uses a free Google form connected to a spreadsheet so responses organize themselves and stay useful over time. The goal is not complexity, but clarity: learn who is listening, how they found the show, and what they actually want more or less of.

The heart of the episode is five key questions, inspired by Tom Webster’s book The Audience Is Listening, that every podcaster can ask. Dave walks through why “How did you discover my show?” is often the single most important question, because it reveals which platforms or appearances are truly working. If everyone discovered the show via YouTube or a guest spot on another podcast, that is a signal to double down on those efforts rather than blindly posting everywhere. He encourages podcasters to be present where their audience actually is, not where generic advice says they must be.

Dave then turns to questions about what other podcasts listeners enjoy, how long they think episodes should be, and who else in their life would love the show. These answers point toward adjacent audiences, potential collaborations, and opportunities to tighten or extend episode length so it better serves real listening habits. His final question imagines the show disappearing tomorrow and asks what, if anything, the listener would miss. That answer reveals the true connection point: is it the host’s companionship, specific topics, the tone, guests, or the routine of having the show in their week. Understanding that emotional anchor helps a podcaster know what must never be lost as the show evolves.

Throughout the episode, Dave models what he teaches. He invites listeners to complete his own survey, reassures them it is short and optional, and explains that their responses will help shape the future of the show. He also shares a bonus reflection on microphone confidence, reminding aspiring hosts that sounding natural is mostly a matter of repetitions, honest feedback, and continuing to show up rather than formal training. The episode closes with an open invitation for listeners to book a free call, purely to talk podcasting, their journey, and how the show can better serve them.

Key takeaway for listeners
The most effective way to grow and improve a podcast is to ask listeners a few focused questions, listen closely to their answers, and then align content, format, and promotion with what those real people actually value.

Link to The How To Podcast Series Show Survey

https://forms.gle/GbrFv9DGszV8N4PW6

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E524 - I Do What I Want in My Podcast, Authorship and Podcasting With CO-HOST - Hollis Jo McCollum Dec 17, 2025

Show notes

Episode 524 - I Do What I Want in My Podcast, Authorship and Podcasting With CO-HOST - Hollis Jo McCollum

Improv, presence, and the art of showing up
This episode centers on the joy of unfiltered conversation and the power of being present in the moment. Hollis Jo McCollum, host of I Do What I Want!, and her co-host Dave riff on the spontaneity and humor that come from live, unscripted dialogue. The conversation touches how improv mindset—saying yes and learning to adapt—fuels engaging interviews, teaches the value of authentic interaction, and keeps podcasts lively even when plans loosen their grip.

From hobby to vocation: creativity on display
Hollis reflects on her path as an author who embraced podcasting as a platform for connection and discovery. She recalls launching her show with a simple premise: to let conversations unfold rather than over-structuring them. The discussion sheds light on the practicalities of producing a podcast in real time—how she handles live recording, editing aversions, and the flexibility required to stay true to the “I Do What I Want” spirit. The value of sharing personal stories—especially about writing, reading, and the creative process—emerges as a key driver for building an audience.

Balancing craft and audience
The episode explores the balance between being a guest and a host, the dynamics of collaboration, and how to maintain a rhythm that honors listeners and guests alike. Hollis and Dave consider scheduling, consistency, and the realities of adult life that shape publishing cadence. The importance of audience feedback is highlighted as a catalyst for evolution—recognizing what resonates, and adapting formats while preserving personality and humor.

Cultural context and human connection
A recurring thread is how technology shapes everyday life and communication. The co-hosts share anecdotes about Gen Z interactions, the role of smartphones in shaping behavior, and how public spaces become stages for candid social moments. The conversation muses on the value of human-to-human conversations in a tech-saturated world and argues for deliberate presence as a practice—whether in cafes, classrooms, or on a podcast episode.

Key takeaway for listeners
Authenticity in conversation—embracing spontaneity, being present, and balancing structure with improvisation—creates compelling storytelling and meaningful connection with both guests and audiences. This episode champions showing up as you are, with curiosity, humor, and a willingness to go wherever the dialogue leads.

Notes on style and connective threads

The show’s vibe is conversational, improvisational, and warmly informal, reflecting Hollis’s personality and the “I Do What I Want!” ethos.
Personal anecdotes about writing, voice work, and the creative process illuminate a behind-the-scenes look at podcasting for authors.
The hosts’ emphasis on listening, presence, and playful exploration provides a blueprint for listeners who want to cultivate their own creative projects and maintain authentic communication.

Endnote
Listeners are encouraged to engage with Hollis’s work across platforms (YouTube, Spotify, and other hosts) and to consider how a flexible, people-first approach to conversations can enrich both creative endeavors and everyday interactions.

https://pod.link/aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuc3ByZWFrZXIuY29tL3Nob3cvNTUyNDExOS9lcGlzb2Rlcy9mZWVkhttps://www.hollisjomccollumauthor.com/

____

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E523 - Please STOP Listening to My Podcast - Inaction is getting in your way, Sart Your Podcast Dec 15, 2025

Show notes

Episode 523 - Please STOP Listening to My Podcast - Inaction is getting in your way, Sart Your Podcast!

Starting Your Podcast: Just Take the First Step

Starting a podcast can be a daunting task, especially if you're new to the world of podcasting. Many aspiring podcasters often find themselves overwhelmed by the numerous steps and decisions that go into launching their show. But the truth is, getting started is easier than you might think. It's all about taking that crucial first step.

Do Anything: That's the mantra for all new podcasters. Perhaps you've already made some initial progress – you've acquired a decent microphone, selected your co-hosts, or even considered album art. Or maybe you're sitting there with a blank slate, unsure of where to begin. Both situations are perfectly fine because the most important thing is to start making your podcast.

In this article, we aim to provide guidance and encouragement to new podcasters who are struggling to make that first move. While we'll touch on various podcast-related aspects we've learned from our years in the industry, the key takeaway is to avoid getting bogged down by endless deliberation and overthinking.

Action Over Perfection: It's common for new podcasters to fixate on making everything perfect before they even hit the record button. They might spend endless hours setting up a professional-grade recording studio, refining their ideas, or crafting a flawless marketing plan. However, waiting for perfection can be paralyzing.

Experience is the best teacher. So, if you feel stuck, unable to take that first step, we have an exercise for you that you can do right now.

The Simple Exercise: Grab your phone, open a voice recording app (most operating systems come with one), or use any device with a built-in microphone. Press record and start talking. Don't overthink it; talk about whatever comes to mind. What's your passion? What stories do you want to share? What keeps you up at night? Once you've said your piece, press stop.

Congratulations, you've just recorded an episode of your podcast! Don't let technicalities or self-doubt hold you back. Making the recording is the baseline, the essential step you must take to get started.

Continuous Improvement: Podcasting, like any creative endeavor, is a learning process. Don't expect to master it on your first try. Instead, focus on getting better with each recording. Try different approaches, experiment with music, or work on your pacing.

Remember, podcasting is easy in terms of its technical simplicity. Just click record, talk, and click stop. However, creating content that resonates with your audience and satisfies your creative aspirations can be as challenging and time-consuming as you choose to make it.

So, here's the key takeaway: take that first step. Start recording, and then work on improving with each episode. Learn from your experiences and keep refining your craft. This is not only how we become proficient podcasters; it's how anyone becomes proficient in anything.

The journey begins with that first recording, and it's time to embark on your podcasting adventure. Don't hesitate, just record something, and you'll find yourself on a path of constant growth and improvement. Happy podcasting!

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E522 - Boundaries and Bonds - Navigating Parasocial Relationships in Podcasting Dec 12, 2025

Show notes

Episode 522 - Boundaries and Bonds - Navigating Parasocial Relationships in Podcasting

Dave dives into the intriguing concept of parasocial relationships in podcasting, sparked by the sudden passing of Todd Cochrane, the influential host of The New Media Show and Geek News Central, and champion of independent podcasters through his Blueberry hosting platform.

Though Dave never met Todd personally - no emails exchanged, no direct interactions - years of listening created a deep one-sided bond. Listeners like Dave feel intimately connected to hosts, knowing their voices, opinions, and lives intimately, while hosts remain unaware of individual fans beyond download stats.

This dynamic makes podcasting profoundly intimate, like inviting listeners into your living room for ongoing conversations they weave into their routines.

Hosts hold significant influence: listeners trust endorsements, remember details from early episodes long after hosts forget, and may share vulnerable stories, treating podcasters as confidants.

Dave stresses the ethical weight this carries—avoid manipulation through sponsorships, set clear boundaries on personal sharing like family details or contact info, and always prioritize listener welfare, consent, and autonomy.

Practical advice flows throughout: be transparent about paid promotions to maintain trust, moderate communities to protect vulnerable members, get opt-in for using listener content, and regularly self-reflect on boundaries.

Hosts must recognize signals of strong bonds, like persistent outreach, and respond with care without exploiting the power imbalance. Dave shares his commitment to monthly listener chats via a calendar on howtopodcast.com, inviting five fans to connect genuinely.

The episode closes with a bonus Q&A on launching: technically, one episode suffices, but bank a short trailer (1-2 minutes) plus 1-3 episodes for momentum without overcommitting like pre-making a year's worth.

Key takeaway: Parasocial bonds are a beautiful privilege—treat your audience as a cherished community, not a commodity. Honor their trust with integrity, boundaries, and genuine care; your microphone wields real power, so wield it responsibly to build lasting relationships.

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E521 - Are You a Confident Podcaster or an Arrogant Podcaster - How To Tell What Path You Are On as a Content Creator Dec 10, 2025

Show notes

Episode 521 - Are You a Confident Podcaster or an Arrogant Podcaster - How To Tell What Path You Are On as a Content Creator

Confidence vs. Arrogance for Podcasters

A simple way to put it for podcasters: confidence is “I have valuable insights and the skills to share them,” while arrogance is “My voice and knowledge are more valuable and better than everyone else’s.” Listeners and collaborators feel encouraged and engaged around confidence, but shut down or distant around arrogance.Clear Definitions for Podcasters

Confidence: A grounded belief in your abilities as a host and creator, with a realistic sense of your strengths and areas to grow, and a willingness to learn from feedback and collaboration.

Arrogance: An inflated view of your importance as a podcaster, exaggerating your expertise, needing to be right at all times, and dismissing others’ ideas or contributions to feel dominant.How Confidence and Arrogance Impact Your Podcast

A confident podcaster listens actively to guests and audience feedback, makes thoughtful editorial choices, owns mistakes, and maintains respect and warmth that creates a welcoming and collaborative community.
An arrogant podcaster dismisses contradictory opinions, talks over guests or ignores listener input, blames others for problems, or mocks opposing views, which creates tension and causes people to tune out or disengage.

Quick Self-Check Questions for Podcasters

Before recording or sharing content, ask yourself:

“Am I trying to serve my audience or prove how smart I am?” Confidence serves listeners; arrogance tries to prove superiority.
“Can I still respect someone who disagrees with me or points out my flaws?” Confidence welcomes constructive disagreement; arrogance cannot handle critique.

Everyday Podcasting Examples

When interacting with guests or collaborators, a confident podcaster says, “I trust my skills but want to genuinely hear your perspective.” An arrogant podcaster implies or states, “I’m the host, so my way is the only way.”
In responding to listener feedback, a confident podcaster listens and adapts when needed. An arrogant podcaster doubles down on their opinions, ignores feedback, or refuses to acknowledge mistakes.
When promoting the podcast, a confident podcaster celebrates team efforts and takes responsibility for setbacks; an arrogant podcaster takes all credit and blames others for failures.

How to Grow Confident, Not Arrogant, as a Podcaster

Ground your identity: Recognize that your worth as a content creator isn’t tied only to downloads, likes, or reviews; it’s deeper than performance metrics.
Practice humility: Regularly admit when you don’t know something or made a mistake—this builds trust with listeners and collaborators, and actually enhances your credibility.
Use your strengths to lift others: Whenever you feel powerful—whether in knowledge, skills, or platform—ask, “How can I use this to support and amplify others, rather than dominate the conversation?”

This approach helps podcasters cultivate authentic confidence for building a loyal audience and strong collaborations while avoiding the alienating effects of arrogance in content creation.

https://www.threads.com/@howtopodcast.ca____

https://howtopodcast.ca/

E520 - Comparing Your Show To A Top Podcast is Not Fair to You or to Your Audience - Please Stop Dec 08, 2025

Show notes

Episode 520 - Comparing Your Show To A Top Podcast is Not Fair to You or to Your Audience - Please Stop

This episode takes aim at a trap many new podcasters fall into: building their shows by comparing themselves to celebrity podcasts. Dave Campbell shares candidly from his experience in Ontario, Canada, hosting nine podcasts and talking daily with new creators who arrive with “stars in their eyes,” wanting a show that looks and sounds like Mel Robbins, Joe Rogan, Diary of a CEO or other top names. The core issue, he explains, is that famous hosts start at a completely different line: they already have audiences, money, teams, relationships with big guests, and promotional power. Expecting the same results when you are starting from zero is not only unrealistic, it is deeply unfair to you and to your listeners.

Throughout the episode, Dave breaks down how this unfair comparison shows up. New podcasters often believe landing big-name guests will make them famous, forgetting that well-known guests usually want big platforms, not shows with ten or twenty downloads. Celebrity hosts are often talking to people they already know, while most beginners have neither those relationships nor the reach to attract similar guests. Chasing that model leads to frustration, rejection, and the false belief that their podcast is failing, when the real problem is a mismatched expectation.

He also highlights the danger of trying to match celebrity-level production on a zero budget. Big shows rely on large teams, professional studios, multiple cameras, editors, marketers, and ad revenue that fuels everything. In contrast, many new podcasters are sitting at home in pajama pants with free software and no money coming in. Trying to jump straight into animated video, elaborate visuals, and complicated production without resources just piles on pressure and disappointment. Instead of copying the outcome of those shows, Dave urges creators to focus on what they can actually control: a clear value proposition, a consistent format, audience-led content, and smart, simple production that fits their reality.

Platform visibility is another unfair comparison he tackles. Apps and algorithms promote big-name podcasts because that’s where the money is, leaving new shows with five downloads nowhere near the “Top 100” charts. Measuring yourself against that level of exposure makes small podcasters feel invisible and discouraged. Dave argues that indie creators actually have an advantage the big shows don’t: the ability to personally connect with listeners, invite them for virtual coffees, respond to messages, and build genuine relationships that are impossible at scale. The real power of a small show lies in depth, authenticity, and trust, not in inflated numbers.

Dave closes by calling out one more subtle danger: obsessing over stats and comparing numbers with other shows. Staring at early download counts is like watching seeds you just planted, waiting for them to sprout. It doesn’t help them grow and only fuels anxiety. He recommends ignoring stats at the very beginning, focusing instead on getting good at podcasting, refining the message, and serving listeners well. The only comparison that matters, he says, is between your last episode and your next one. As a final invitation, he opens his calendar to listeners, modeling the kind of one-to-one connection that truly sets smaller podcasters apart.

Key takeaway for listeners: Comparing your new podcast to top celebrity shows is not a fair or useful benchmark. You don’t share their fame, budget, team, or platform support, and trying to copy their model will only erode your confidence and shortchange your audience. Instead, measure your progress against your own past work, build slowly and authentically, and lean into the unique advantage you have as a smaller creator: the ability to truly know, serve, and connect with your listeners one person at a time.

____

https://howtopodcast.ca/

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The How To Podcast Series – Podcast Co-Hosts, Practical Podcasting Tips, and Podcast Community

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected