Show notes
Chuck Todd surveys a dire geopolitical landscape where the Strait of Hormuz remains closed, fuel rationing has begun in many places around the globe, and the Trump administration is scrambling to extend a fragile ceasefire with Iran — sending JD Vance back to Pakistan for another round of talks, a move Chuck says signals genuine desperation to end a war that has become a generational foreign policy disaster. Heargues that Iran's control of the strait is now a greater deterrent than nuclear weapons ever were, that the Iranians know Trump is on the clock and that time is firmly on Tehran's side — meaning the best Trump can realistically hope for is a deal that looks remarkably like the Obama nuclear agreement he once shredded. Oil and stock markets appear divorced from reality while energy markets are in major distress, China's position has been strengthened enormously and Netanyahu has effectively suckered Trump into a mess that will define American foreign policy for a generation. He then unpacks a bombshell Atlantic report painting FBI Director Kash Patel as absent, unreliable, and allegedly drunk on the job — noting that just because it's a "hit piece" doesn't mean it's not true, that rank-and-file intelligence professionals don't trust the people leading their agencies, and that Patel himself believes he's about to be fired because Trump personally despises anecdotes about drinking. He closes with Virginia's redistricting referendum, which ends Tuesday and looks likely to pass, but he questions whether Democrats are making a smart investment — blowing enormous political capital and damaging Governor Abigail Spanberger's brand to pick up only two House seats, a tradeoff that may not be worth the cost.
Then, Sarah Isgur — legal commentator, former DOJ spokesperson, and author of Last Branch Standing — joins the Chuck Toddcast for a comprehensive deep dive into the Supreme Court that challenges virtually everything the public thinks it knows about how the institution actually works. Isgur argues that the court's politics don't map neatly onto the current left-right spectrum, and that the court isn't really 6-3 but rather 3-3-3 — with a bloc of doctrinaire conservatives, a liberal minority, and a pragmatic center that includes Kavanaugh and Chief Justice Roberts. She reveals that Elena Kagan plays a major behind-the-scenes role that the public rarely sees, and that over the past 20 years more than 90% of rulings have had a liberal justice in the majority (undermining the narrative of a runaway conservative court)
The conversation turns to deeper structural concerns about the judiciary that Isgur argues are undermining the rule of law itself. She notes that today's justices all have eerily uniform résumés — a problem created by a system that essentially identifies future Supreme Court candidates by the time they're 18 and forces them to lead incredibly sheltered lives for both career and safety reasons — making them detached from the real world in ways that earlier, more varied courts were not. She is sharply critical of Congress for making the court the arbiter of fundamental rights, which has turned every confirmation into an existential battle — the refusal to take on issues like Roe legislatively forced them to the court, and now there's no real dialogue between the branches. They close by debating a provocative proposal: the confirmation threshold for justices should be raised to 60 or even 75 votes to force presidents to nominate consensus candidates, breaking the cycle of partisan warfare that has made the Federalist Society effectively a prerequisite for any aspiring conservative judge and turned the nomination process into something that is actively bad for both the court and the rule of law.
Finally, Chuck hops into the ToddCast Time Machine to revisit America’s first war of choice: The Spanish American War. He also answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment.
Thank you Wildgrain for sponsoring. Visit http://wildgrain.com/TODDCAST and use the code "TODDCAST" at checkout to receive $30 off your first box PLUS free Croissants for life!
Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.
Link in bio or go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.
Timeline:
(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)
00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction
04:00 We’re in a precious position. Strait of Hormuz closed & fuel rationing is coming
05:00 Expect some sort of extension of the current ceasefire agreement
05:45 JD Vance headed back to Pakistan for another round of talks
06:30 Sending Vance shows they’re serious about trying to end war
07:15 Trump is desperate to get out of the war
08:00 Control of Strait of Hormuz is a greater deterrent than nukes
09:00 Oil & stock markets seem divorced from reality
09:45 Energy markets are is major distress
10:45 Trump’s approval has slipped, public knows the war is going badly
11:30 Trump is talking tough, but his actions are cautious
12:30 Iranians know Trump is desperate and Iranians have serious leverage
14:00 Iranians know Trump is on the clock, and they have time on their side
14:30 China’s position has been strengthened by Iran war
15:45 U.S. is stretched too thin currently to defend Taiwan
17:00 Energy shock increases demand for clean energy, where China leads
18:15 Bibi suckered Trump into a generational foreign policy disaster
19:15 We’re likely stuck without a resolution to the war for awhile
20:15 Best Trump can hope for is redoing the Obama nuclear deal
21:30 Time is running out on the 60 day war powers resolution deadline
22:45 Trump has 5 weeks to get a deal before congress is forced to step in
23:30 Atlantic publishes story about Kash Patel being MIA & drunk
24:30 Patel denied everything, hoping for White House backup
25:30 Just because it’s a “hit piece” doesn’t mean it’s not true
26:15 People working at the FBI don’t trust the guy leading it
28:00 Atlantic paints a portrait of an FBI leader that’s completely unreliable
29:00 Patel’s ineptitude creates a national security threat to the U.S.
30:30 Rank & file intel professionals don’t trust the people in charge
31:45 Trump hates anecdotes about drinking, Patel’s days are numbered
32:30 Patel believes he’s going to be fired
34:00 Balloting for Virginia redistricting ends on Tuesday, looks like it will pass
34:30 Democrats expending political capital to only pick up two house seats
35:30 Redistricting fight has been terrible politically for Abigail Spanberger
38:00 New map will trim two very blue districts and export voters to swing districts
40:30 Blowing all this political capital for two seats doesn’t seem worth it
42:15 Livestream on Tuesday evening breaking down the results from VA
48:30 Sarah Isgur (Last Branch Standing) joins the Chuck ToddCast
50:15 The Supreme Court’s politics don’t map neatly to current left/right
51:30 Bono called Chuck a “radical centrist”
52:15 Brett Kavanaugh’s biggest regret was not getting selfie with Bono
54:00 Songs that best comment on American political culture
57:00 Incrimentalism more important than liberal/conservative
58:00 Kavanaugh & Kagan most similar to Chuck in philosophy
59:30 Kagan plays a major role on the court behind the scenes
1:00:30 The reputation of the solicitor general has changed under Trump
1:01:15 Earlier justices didn’t have the uniform resume of the current justices
1:03:00 Current justices are detached from the real world
1:04:15 Alito likely retiring this summer or next as Dems senate chances increase
1:05:15 White House is eager to get a Supreme Court opening
1:06:00 Trump may have his hands tied, Alito will want to approve successor
1:08:00 Alito will want someone like him to replace him
1:08:30 Unlikely Ted Cruz or Mike Lee will be nominated for the court
1:09:30 We’ve narrowed down who can be justices by the time candidates are 18
1:10:15 Justices have to lead an incredibly sheltered life for safety
1:12:15 The court isn’t really 6-3, it’s 3-3-3
1:14:15 Which justices are the most overtly political for their side?
1:15:30 Gorsuch had best opinion of the year on Trump’s tariffs
1:16:15 Congress has abdicated their duty, forced the court to legislate
1:17:15 There’s no dialogue between congress & court. Court gets final word
1:18:30 Congress didn’t have the guts to take on Roe, forced it to the court
1:20:15 Court has become the arbiter of rights, making confirmations existential
1:21:45 Rights of criminal defendants are compromised by an elected judiciary
1:22:45 Elections for judges create perverse incentive structures
1:24:15 Jackson & Kavanaugh share view of their role on the court
1:25:15 In past 20 years, over 90% of rulings had a liberal in the majority
1:27:00 Justice Thomas has been remarkably consistent in his rulings
1:29:00 Gorsuch consistently relies on the text and applies it
1:29:45 Thomas is a hardcore originalist
1:31:30 Chief Justice Roberts has eschewed any type of label
1:33:30 Kagan tries to keep the court out of issues unless they must intervene
1:34:45 Justices are taking fewer cases and writing more opinions than ever
1:35:45 The court speaks in too many voices now
1:37:30 Justice Alito’s favorite movie is “Being There”
1:38:45 Breyer was a 2nd backup choice for the court
1:40:30 The value of moderation vs. abstention
1:42:15 Should the confirmation threshold for justices be raised to 60 or 75?
1:45:00 Requirement to join the Federalist Society if you want to be a judge
1:46:00 Proposal for how to fix the confirmation wars
1:48:30 Current nomination process is bad for the court & rule of law
1:53:30 Court is last branch standing for now, haven’t seen result of 50 vote confirmation
1:56:30 Thoughts on Sarah Isgur’s proposal on SCOTUS confirmations
1:57:30 ToddCast Time Machine April 20th, 1898 - Spanish American War
1:59:00 U.S.S. Maine exploded in Havana harbor, conclusion was Spain did it
1:59:30 The facts didn’t lead to the conclusion, the conclusion came first
2:00:15 Hearst & Pulitzer were locked in a publishing war, competing for readers
2:01:00 William McKinley didn’t want war, but pressure kept building
2:02:00 It was a War of Choice, and the press pushed leaders into war
2:02:30 Congress demanded that Spain leave Cuba
2:03:30 U.S. begins blockage of Cuba, basically kicking off the war
2:04:15 Congress backdated their declaration of war
2:05:00 Teddy Roosevelt’s rise scared establishment Republicans
2:05:30 The war produced Roosevelt’s presidency
2:06:30 It was a war of choice, until it felt like there was no other option
2:07:00 Wars of choice never end well
2:07:30 Ask Chuck
2:07:45 As Trump’s support erodes, any chance the 25th amendment gets invoked?
2:11:30 Does Federalist 10 still hold up? Is there a case for a constitutional convention?
2:18:00 A Top 5 list of races where you think the election projections are off?
2:24:30 Did I hear a dog in the background in your Wednesday episode?
2:26:45 Can you bring on a late night host like Colbert, Oliver or Maher?
2:29:30 What can and can’t be done with the huge fundraising hauls Dems are getting?
2:36:30 Thoughts on the NBA playoffs
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Our TOPPODCAST Picks 
Stay Connected
