The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Full Show: Bart Scott Joins Craig! The Mets Should Go After Ohtani, Bart Talks About Playing For John Harbaugh, The Giants Aren't Better Than The Jets, and More Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

My Man Pots N' Pans!! Craig is joined by Bart Scott, filling in for Chris McMonigle. They break down the Dodgers financial issues, why the Mets should go after Shohei Ohtani, debating who will be better this year, the Jets or Giants, and a whole lot more, tell ya friends!!

Hour 1: Bart Scott Joins the Show Today! The Mets Should Make a Move for Shohei Ohtani & Bart's Experience Playing for John Harbaugh Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Bart Scott is filling in for Big Mac today, my man pots n' pans! Bart breaks down John Harbaugh's coaching style, the Mets should make a play for Shohei Ohtani, and much more.

Hour 2: Bart Recalls What Went Wrong in the 2010 AFC Championship Game & Jaxson Dart in the Blue Tent Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Bart talks about the problem the Jets had in the 2010 AFC Championship, Jaxson Dart's possible injury concerns, and much more.

Hour 3: There's No Concrete Reason To Believe The Giants Will Be Better Than The Jets Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Hour 3: Craig and Bart Scott break down the Jets and Giants and why they believe there is no real reason why the Giants will be a clearly better team this year.

Hour 4: Bart Scott Teaches Us About Air Travel & Jaxson Dart is Not a Winner Quite Yet Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Bart Scott discuss travel stories and if they'll bring back the Concorde. Plus, you can't call Jaxson Dart a winner yet, Odell Beckham can still make an impact for the Giants and more.

Bart Scott on OBJ's Giants Potential and New Jets Stadium Rumors Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Bart Scott joins Craig to recount legendary Lawrence Taylor stories and discuss if the Giants should take a chance on Odell Beckham Jr. They also analyze the ongoing issues with the turf at MetLife Stadium and speculate on Woody Johnson potentially moving the Jets to a new stadium in Queens.

(00:01:00) Wild Lawrence Taylor Stories

(00:04:38) Odell Beckham Jr. Potential

(00:07:47) MetLife Stadium Turf Issues

(00:09:14) Jets Relocation To Queens

(00:13:35) NYC Parking And Tipping

Bart Scott Predicts a 6-11 Finish for the New York Giants Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton & Bart Scott analyzes the NFL's plans for a European division and the logistical hurdles of global expansion. He debates a caller regarding the New York Giants' quarterback situation before predicting a 6-11 record for the team. Finally, he shares stories from his extensive travels across Africa, including his experiences in Senegal and Nigeria.

(00:01:08) NFL International Expansion News

(00:08:44) Giants Offensive Confidence Debate

(00:13:11) Predicting the Giants Schedule

(00:16:26) Great Circle Flight Logistics

(00:20:30) Bart Scott's African Travels

Craig Recalls Wild 1995 Eagles Hotel Incident with Ray Rhodes Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Bart Scott discuss the social circles of professional athletes before Big Mac shares a wild story involving the 1995 Philadelphia Eagles. They transition into a heated debate comparing the New York Jets and New York Giants rosters, questioning which team has a better path to success this season.

(00:01:36) CeeDee Lamb Dating

(00:03:23) 1995 Eagles Scandal

(00:09:11) Jets Vs Giants Debate

(00:15:28) Analyzing Giants Offense

(00:23:52) Aaron Glenn Discussion

Alex Cora vs Carlos Beltran for Mets Manager & Giants QB Concerns Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Craig & Bart analyzes whether Alex Cora or Carlos Beltran is the better fit to manage the New York Mets while addressing potential clubhouse friction. The discussion moves to the New York Giants' quarterback situation and the high-pressure environment for their coaching staff. Additionally, the conversation evaluates the New York Jets' defensive depth and veteran leadership.

(00:01:00) Disney Cruise Discussion

(00:04:07) Mets Manager Debate

(00:06:11) Giants Quarterback Concerns

(00:12:28) Mets Win Discussion

(00:14:00) Jets Roster Analysis

Bart Scott: John Harbaugh Inherited the Ravens' Culture Aug 19, 2026

Show notes

Bart Scott joins the Carton Show, while Big Mac is away, to discuss the coaching philosophy of the Harbaugh family and the importance of established team culture. They analyze the leadership needs of the New York Giants and the roster construction strategies used by the New York Mets and New York Yankees. The discussion also covers the financial complexities of the Los Angeles Dodgers' recent contracts and the ownership hurdles within the NBA.

(00:01:00) Bart Scott Fills In

(00:02:04) Ravens and Harbaugh Culture

(00:07:25) NFL Roster Building Discussion

(00:10:35) Sports Ownership and Contracts

(00:18:46) Mets Management vs Yankees