The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Mets Misery & Craig's Big Jets QB Question Aug 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle laugh at a caller's notion that the Mets have a brighter future than the Yankees -- and Craig says he's going to learn a big Geno Smith lesson at Jets camp.

Is Aaron Boone the AL Manager of the Year? Aug 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle talk about the job Aaron Boone has done at the helm of the Yankees this season, given their offensive success amid poor injury luck and struggles from their biggest stars.

The Yankees Will Be Favored In A Playoff Series Aug 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Yankees' postseason chances as they continue to bank on winning games "2-1," which might not be entirely sustainable in the postseason. Either way, the Bronx Bombers will likely be the chalk pick to win their first playoff series -- whoever it's against.

Can the Yankees Survive Without Aaron Judge? Aug 10, 2026

Show notes

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Monday's show by discussing the New York Yankees' offensive struggles -- and whether or not the strength of their pitching is enough to overcome their slump without Aaron Judge.

Best of the Giants on WFAN: Jaxson Dart concerns? Aug 09, 2026

Show notes

Willie Colon and Jerry Recco on what concerns they may have with Jaxson Dart this season. Plus: -Shaun Morash on what worries him about the Giants’ offense -Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle hear from a caller on whether John Harbaugh is right for Dart. -Tiki Barber revisits the takes around the Odell Beckham Jr. trade -Craig and C-Mac on whether or not the Giants should have pursued Stefon Diggs.

Best of the Mets on WFAN: Freddy Peralta's parting gift Aug 08, 2026

Show notes

Freddy Peralta orchestrated a sitdown with Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor to squash their beef, according to ESPN. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the stunning report, while Evan Roberts wonders if brokering peace between the team's two stars changes anything about Peralta's damaged legacy in Queens. Plus, the great Jefry Yan debate, as Jerry Recco and Willie Colon debate if the pitcher's animated celebrations are appropriate, while Shaun Morash predicts the celebrating will backfire in the most Mets way possible.

Best of the Yankees on WFAN: The Lombard era is here Aug 08, 2026

Show notes

George Lombard Jr. has made his Yankee introduction, and our hosts love what they see. Evan and Tiki rave about his defense at shortstop, and Ryan Ruocco of the YES Network calls in to the Morning Show to talk about Lombard's sparkling debut. Plus, Brian Cashman talks all things trade deadline with The Carton Show, and Evan Roberts is ready to declare the AL East race over.

Full Show: Yankees Panic as Red Sox Surge & The Great Oyster Wager Aug 07, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' current slump as the Boston Red Sox surge in the American League standings. They welcome Marcus from Cap Tree Clam Company to set a unique wager on the season's finish and discuss the Jets' quarterback future following the Hall of Fame Game. The conversation also covers radio history, the rise of cashless businesses, and a breakdown of John Travolta's film career.

(00:01:50) Yankees Panic Mode

(00:06:25) Yankees Versus Braves

(00:11:00) QB Dating Standards

(00:18:45) Wildcard Path Scenarios

(00:28:35) Mitch Garver Signing

(00:34:40) Radio History Lesson

(00:26:10) Cap Tree Clams

(00:31:32) Geno Smith Update

(00:36:45) Shaq Knicks Hatred

(00:46:45) The Porn Name

(00:23:55) Cashless Society Debate

(00:28:20) Tesla Valet Concerns

(00:34:20) Skin Flute Legend

(00:39:15) Syracuse Sports History

(00:46:40) Yankees September Schedule

(00:24:15) Spin The Wheel

(00:26:05) Yankees Weather Delay

Hour 1: Craig Taunts Big Mac as Red Sox Tie Yankees in the Loss Column Aug 07, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac discuss the intensifying rivalry between the Yankees and the Red Sox as the two teams become tied in the loss column. They also recap a high-scoring preseason football performance and debate the best strategic path for the Yankees in the upcoming playoffs.

(00:01:20) Yankees and Red Sox Panic

(00:04:47) Red Sox Incredible Run

(00:09:24) Football and QB Standards

(00:14:47) Yankees Braves Series Preview

(00:18:37) Wildcard Playoff Scenarios

(00:28:36) Listener Calls & Manager Debate

(00:35:53) Phillies Guest Play-by-Play

(00:40:06) History of AM Radio

Hour 2: Shaq Blasts "Lucky" Knicks and the Great Fenway Oyster Bet Aug 07, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac discuss a wager with the owner of Captree Clam Co. regarding the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry and the potential for a "Fenway Oyster." They critique Shaq's comments on the Knicks' championship run and dive into the Jets' offensive expectations. Discussions also cover the trend toward cashless businesses and the logistical challenges of owning a Tesla in the city.

(00:01:16) Captree Clam Bet

(00:06:44) Jets Quarterback Outlook

(00:12:43) Shaq Criticizes Knicks

(00:18:01) Jalen Brunson Surgery

(00:23:04) Cashless Society Debate

(00:29:15) Tesla And Waymo

(00:36:23) William Paterson University

(00:39:58) Big East Memories

(00:43:04) Yankees Playoff Math