The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Latest Episodes:

Big Mac: Aaron Judge Injury Ends the Yankees' Division Chase Sep 16, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac reacts to a devastating extra-innings loss to the Minnesota Twins and the news of Aaron Judge leaving the game with a lower-body injury. He critiques the organization's decision to rehab the captain at the major league level and discusses the impact on the pursuit of the AL East.

(00:01:07) Heartbreaking Loss to Twins

(00:03:27) Aaron Judge Injury Update

(00:09:34) Questioning Judge's Rehab Process

The War Between Mets Fans | 'WFAN Daily with Pete Hoffman' Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Pete Alonso has returned to cause Mets fans to explode on one another. Who is the embarrassing Mets fan? Let's find out. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Full Show: Craig & C-Mac: The Truth Behind Pete Alonso's Exit From Queens Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Craig and C-Mac dive into the heated debate surrounding the New York Yankees' locker room celebration after clinching a postseason berth. They also provide an inside look at the contract negotiations between Pete Alonso and Steve Cohen, debunking narratives about how the slugger ended up in Baltimore.

(00:01:50) Yankees Postseason Celebration

(00:11:00) Coughlin Push-Up Challenge

(00:17:30) Hyrox World Champion Mishap

(00:26:00) Craig's Bathroom Emergency

(00:34:20) NFL Week 2 Preview

(00:38:15) Pete Alonso Negotiation Truths

(00:53:40) Ringo Starr Debate

Hour 1: Craig Carton Defends Yankees Celebration After Clinching Postseason Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

On the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Big Mac celebrate the New York Yankees clinching a playoff spot and address critics who believe the team shouldn't celebrate before winning a championship. They also dive into a studio push-up challenge inspired by Tom Coughlin and evaluate Aaron Judge’s impact as the playoffs approach.

(00:01:20) Yankees Clinch Postseason

(00:02:49) Defending Champagne Celebrations

(00:06:46) Postseason Goals Strategy

(00:10:05) Coughlin Push-Up Challenge

(00:15:15) Early Celebration Debate

(00:21:44) Judge Leads Rally

Hour 2: Craigie Reveals the Truth About Pete Alonso's $158 Million Met Offer Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

They analyze a viral Hyrox race incident involving an athlete's grit and a significant biohazard. Craig recounts an embarrassing personal story before delving into the New York Mets' roster drama. The conversation uncovers the alleged details of Pete Alonso's rejected $158 million contract and the impact of agent Scott Boras on the negotiations.

(00:01:40) Taylor Swift At Game

(00:04:45) Hyrox Race Incident

(00:08:33) Craig’s Personal Story

(00:13:50) Yankee Celebration Debate

(00:21:10) NFL Betting Results

(00:24:30) Mets Fans Boo Stearns

(00:33:10) Pete Alonso Contract Truths

(00:39:30) Business Of Baseball

(00:46:30) Evaluating David Stearns

Hour 3: C-Max Shares Chilling Story of Rescuing His Son From Drowning Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

After analyzing the betting odds for the Giants and Jets' upcoming games, they debate the merits of wild card celebrations in Major League Baseball. C-Max recounts a harrowing experience where he had to save his son from drowning during a family outing, leading to a broader discussion about emergency preparedness and restaurant etiquette.

(00:01:20) NFL Week 2 Outlook

(00:05:41) Yankees Postseason Celebration Debate

(00:10:12) Steakhouse Etiquette And Judge

(00:15:14) Mariah Carey Hall Snub

(00:20:35) Rock Hall Induction Snubs

(00:23:47) C-Max Heroic Rescue Story

Hour 4: Yankees' Playoff Pitching Strategy and Craig's Beef With Houston Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Craig and Big Mac evaluate the Yankees' pitching rotation for the upcoming Wild Card series and the decision to rest Aaron Judge. They analyze major NFL storylines following Week 1, including the Chiefs' dominance and the Giants' victory over the Cowboys. The conversation also detours into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Craig’s refusal to return to the city of Houston.

(00:01:20) Yankees Rotation Strategy

(00:05:15) Wild Card Race Prep

(00:10:30) Craig Sounds Like Mel Brooks

(00:14:15) Rock Hall Of Fame

(00:17:45) NFL Week 1 Recap

(00:23:40) Division Storyline Rankings

(00:26:50) Host NFL Betting Records

Hour 5: Mets Fans Protest David Stearns as Pete Alonso Returns to Queens Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Chris McMonigle reviews the emotional return of Pete Alonso to Citi Field and why fans turned their frustration toward David Stearns. They discuss the disconnect between ownership and the fan base following a disappointing season for the New York Mets. The segment also covers Yankees playoff rotation concerns and lighthearted trivia regarding Ringo Starr.

(00:01:20) Giants Post-Game Atmosphere

(00:04:27) Mets Fans Confront Stearns

(00:08:52) Cohen and Management Impact

(00:12:36) Pete Alonso Contract Logic

(00:16:43) Ringo Starr Trivia Segment

(00:22:05) Look Who's Talking Soundtrack

(00:25:44) Abe Vigoda Movie History

(00:28:45) Yankees Postseason Pitching Choices

Big Mac Recalls Saving His Son From Drowning on a Boat Trip Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

Big Mac recounts a terrifying real-life experience where he had to save his young son from drowning during a boating trip. They also discuss Mel Brooks' legacy in comedy and a hypothetical scenario about jumping overboard during a Disney cruise. Additionally, the conversation touches on physical fitness and the challenge of completing a single pull-up.

(00:01:01) Comedy Legends And Movies

(00:05:43) Yankees Nation TV Appearances

(00:06:43) Big Mac Pull-up Challenge

(00:09:15) Cruise Overboard Hypotheticals

C-Mac Defends the Yankees' Playoff Clinching Celebration Sep 15, 2026

Show notes

C-Mac & Craig debate whether Mariah Carey belongs in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and reviews Barry Manilow's catalog of hits. He also pushes back against fans criticizing the Yankees for celebrating their postseason clinch, highlighting the many injuries the team overcame to reach the tournament.

(00:01:12) Mariah Carey HOF Snub

(00:03:34) Barry Manilow's Career Hits

(00:07:06) Yankees Playoff Celebration Debate

(00:11:06) Silvox Outdoor TV

Our TOPPODCAST Picks

Follow Us

Stay Connected

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Related Podcasts

Links

Stay Connected